Ex-Cop On Trial For Killing Pregnant Woman

Prosecutor Says Bobby Cutts Murdered Pregnant Girlfriend; Defense Says There's No Evidence

(CBS/AP)  Prosecutors on Monday accused a former police officer of strangling a woman who was pregnant with his child, dumping her body, then lying to investigators as thousands searched for her last summer in a case that received national attention.

Bobby Cutts Jr. was feeling the pressure of his crumbling marriage, financial debt and supporting several children, Stark County assistant prosecutor Chryssa Hartnett said in her opening statement at Cutts' trial.

"We are here because of physical pressure - the physical pressure he exerted around the neck of Jessie Davis for the several minutes it took for him to snuff the life out of her and her unborn child," she said.

Cutts' attorney, Fernando Mack, told jurors that they wouldn't like the fact that Cutts knew where the body was and left his 2½-year-old son Blake alone for 26 hours, referring to charges of gross abuse of a corpse and child endangering.

But he said that prosecutors did not have the evidence that he killed Davis and only hoped to enrage them enough to convict him of a murder charge.

"They hope that you'll lose your way," Mack said.

Cutts, 30, a former Canton patrolman, has pleaded not guilty to aggravated murder, aggravated burglary and other charges in the death of Davis and her female fetus. He faces the death penalty if convicted.

Cutts was supposed to pick up his son on June 13, Jessie Davis' mother Patricia Porter testified.

After Porter couldn't reach her daughter on June 14, she went to Davis' house the next morning and found Blake alone.

"He's soaked in feces and urine," Hartnett said.

Porter testified that the 2½-year-old told her: "Mommy's crying. Mommy broke the table. Mommy's in the rug."

"I started screaming, 'Where's my daughter?"' Porter testified.

The toddler's statements have been ruled admissible at trial, despite strenuous objection from the defense.

Hartnett told jurors that Cutts, who sat with his hand on his chin throughout her opening statement, removed Davis' body from her house.

"He rolled Jessie up in the comforter from her bed and put her in the back of his truck," said Hartnett, adding that her feet hung out of the comforter.

Cutts then headed to the home of friend Myisha Ferrell, a high school classmate, and told her that he used his arm to strangle Davis, Hartnett said.

He told her to say that he had arranged for her to baby-sit for Blake - part of his plan to cover up his involvement in the crime, Hartnett said.

"She does it. She lies for him," Hartnett said.

Prosecutors say Ferrell later told police of Cutts' admission. She then pleaded guilty to obstructing justice for lying to authorities and complicity to gross abuse of a corpse. She was sentenced to two years in prison.

Mack told the jury not to allow testimony portraying Cutts as a womanizer or horrific photos of Davis' corpse to anger them into a conviction. Her body was found in a park on June 23 about 20 miles from her home and was badly decomposed.

"They will not tell you the facts and circumstances that led to her death," Mack said.

Hartnett told the jury not to expect a lot of forensic evidence.

"It's not a CSI episode," she said. "DNA will not determine this case, common sense will."

Mack pointed out that the Summit County medical examiner was unable to determine how Davis was killed, listing the cause as "unspecified homicidal violence."

"They don't have a cause of death, rather they have hypotheticals," he said.

The trial is expected to last at least two weeks. An all-white jury is considering the case against Cutts, who is black. The only black juror is a female alternate.

Cutts' attorneys have objected to the panel's lack of racial diversity.

[realtalk5950]

"An all-white jury is considering the case against Cutts, who is black."

Stick a fork in him boys, he''s done.

[lisann326]

Women stay away from married men. It is not to your benefit to get involved with a married man. Some women actually brag about taking a man away from his wife, but the triangle is showing your emotional deficits and personality quirks.

[keithle1]

It takes two to tango of course. If the boyfriend/one night stand/man du jour won''t use a condom then why don''t women protect themselves? I don''t understand that. Are you a barefoot hillbilly with half a brain cell living in the mountains? How stupid do you have to be not to use birth control?

[stephs2625]

That man''s already convicted. It doesn''t matter if he''s white or not. That story received national attention, so race has absolutely nothing to do with it. Maybe next time he decides to commit a crime like this, he''ll have a little better trustworthy people.

[Krazcarl]

Just read on Yahoo news that the woman in prison where he brought the body will testify against him and that he admitted stanguling her with his arm. She is the mother of one of his children only got 2 years no big motive to lie.

[leslie7088]

Blacks are not by any means the ONLY ones that need a class about putting on a CONDOM Keithle1. I propose that people need licences to have kids. There are too many giving birth and REALLY don''t want them. These are the ones that need the class!!!! It does not matter whether they are black, white, yellow, green or BLUE!!!!!! Anyone that kills without a care NEEDS to be dealt with no matter what RACE/COLOR you are!!!! We need to love each other and stop the hate!!

[mercyme884]

And another case showing the sorry state that the Criminal justice system of this country is in. There needs to be changes made and sooner good people. There are too many cruel, evil criminals loose out there preying on innocent women and children and elderly people.

[shammy0202]

Downright sickening, DEATH PENALTY!!

[keithle1]

Can you say C-O-N-D-O-M? Why are so many black men so resistant to using a condom? Black men are their own worst enemy. Why didn''t he use a condom? Do they cost too much or are too difficult to find?

Got to be the cool ladies man/playa. That takes precedence over anything else. "Look at me, I''m Super Stud! I''m so cool. God''s gift to women."

[incog-nito]

Bleem3: I''m sure he will be found guilty, but in a court of LAW. Before that happens he is constitutionally entitled to legal representation. Otherwise the U.S. would be no different that a third-world dictatorship. You don''t have a problem with the Constitution, do you?