States Take Aim At Abusive Teachers

Legislation Proposals Seek To Better Protect Students From Sexual Misconduct

(AP)  Heeding a steady drumbeat of sexual misconduct cases involving teachers, at least 15 states are now considering stronger oversight and tougher punishment for educators who take advantage of their students.

Lawmakers say they are concerned about an increasingly well-documented phenomenon: While the vast majority of America's teachers are committed professionals, there also is a persistent problem with sexual misconduct in U.S. schools. When abuse happens, administrators too often fail to let others know about it, and too many legal loopholes let offenders stay in the classroom.

Advocates include governors, education superintendents and legislative leaders.

"We've got to be on a bully pulpit with our school districts," said Missouri state Rep. Jane Cunningham. The Republican's legislation would eliminate statutes of limitation for sexual misconduct, allowing victims to come forward and bring charges against abusers no matter how many years had passed since the crime.

The ideas emerging in state capitals come at a time when U.S. media have been reporting steadily on individual cases, along with more in-depth examinations of the problem.

A nationwide Associated Press investigation published in October found 2,570 educators whose teaching credentials were revoked, denied, surrendered or sanctioned from 2001 through 2005 following allegations of sexual misconduct. Experts who track sexual abuse say those cases are representative of a much deeper problem because of underreporting.

There are roughly 3 million public school teachers nationwide.

In eight states, leaders pushing changes said the AP investigation had inspired their proposals. Others said they had grown concerned from individual cases of abuse in their states, or other news reports that looked at the problem locally or in their state.

In New York, Gov. Eliot Spitzer supports automatic suspension of teachers convicted of sex crimes, which now requires lengthy hearings. In Maine, Gov. John Baldacci hopes to share the names of abusive teachers with other states, which a 1913 confidentiality law there prohibits. In Florida, Gov. Charlie Crist endorsed federal legislation proposed by U.S. Rep. Adam Putnam, a Florida Republican, to create a national databank of abusive teachers, a hot line for complaints and federal funds for state investigators.

Some states are looking to increase penalties, expand background checks or broaden their ability to police charter schools for abuse, like Indiana, Massachusetts and Utah. Kentucky and South Carolina are considering making it illegal for teachers to have sex with older students.

Several states are tackling a major problem - the loopholes that allow problem teachers to move from one school district to another, or from one state to another. The AP investigation found that what education officials commonly call "passing the trash" happens when districts allow a teacher to quietly leave a school, or fail to report problems to state authorities, or fail to check with state authorities before hiring a teacher, among other glitches.

In eight states, legislators are pursuing changes to close those gaps, including California, Colorado, Florida, Minnesota, Missouri, Virginia, Washington state and West Virginia.

"Despite acts of misconduct that were threatening and dangerous in schools, there is a track record of people going on to another school district and finding employment," said Missouri state Senate President Pro Tem Michael Gibbons. "The new school district may get the truth, but they don't get the whole truth about this person's background. They may find out the dates of service, they may find out this person was dismissed, but there really is no other information forthcoming."

His legislation aims to get school employees and districts to share all information about job-hunting teachers, including whether those educators sexually abused their students, by granting administrators civil immunity from lawsuits.

Other states approach the same problem differently. A Colorado measure being drafted would penalize school districts and state officials that fail to report problem teachers, while a West Virginia proposal would open school officials themselves to punishment. Florida would bar any confidentiality agreement between districts and teachers, and require districts to report every firing to the state.

In California, one proposal would close a loophole that bars the teacher credentialing commission from revealing the reason teachers lose their licenses if they plead no contest to an offense.

Under no contest pleas, defendants are punished as if they pleaded guilty, but retain the right to challenge the charges against them in lawsuits and other proceedings. Such deals have meant public records were unclear about why educator licenses were sanctioned in dozens of cases, the AP found.

"You should not be able to plead no contest to a sex offense just so you can continue teaching," said state Sen. Bob Margett. The measure means teachers who plead no contest would immediately lose their license, and the reason for the revocation would be public record.

Some say the latest legislation is just the beginning.

South Carolina has created a new committee of parents, teachers, social workers and prosecutors to study the problem and come back with new ideas.

Though small statistically, the number of abusive teachers is too high, South Carolina Education Superintendent Jim Rex wrote after reading the AP report.

"I am nonetheless outraged by any incident in which an adult entrusted with the care of one of South Carolina's students violates that student. The ramifications for that student, his or her family, and the community as a whole are painful and long lasting," he wrote.

In Utah, the numbers of abuses flat-out shocked state Rep. Carl Wimmer. "These things happen a lot more often than parents would think," he said. "It seems we do have an unacceptable high amount of children who get violated in the classroom. One is too many."

[Con Mohrat]

"I am nonetheless outraged by any incident in which an adult entrusted with the care of one of South Carolina''s students violates that student. The ramifications for that student, his or her family, and the community as a whole are painful and long lasting," he wrote.
===========

Hog tie them to a telephone pole naked and give them a public flogging. Then let us all spit on them for a week. That should do it. They don''t need courts or jail.

[mcv57]

Hog tie them to a telephone pole naked and give them a public flogging. Then let us all spit on them for a week. That should do it. They don''''t need courts or jail.

Posted by Vet1971

They need both, public educators are the worst type of government tyrants. They also have a union that protects their crimes.

[dowjones20k]

Boy this sure sounds like a familiar crime ...

Reminds of the Catholic Church and how they hid all the pedophilia priests committed ... now we have the NEA and the Teaching elite trying to circumvent laws and keep these so called teachers from being exposed ...

What a sad course we have taken in this country ..

You gotta love the NEA and ACLU !!!

NOT!!!

[fiteit1]

I am all for protecting the kids, I have two still in school and anyone touching them would have more than the prosecutor to deal with. My fears with this new, round them all up and shoot them. attitude is the teacher that is disliked by a resourceful and revengeful student. In my daughters class a fellow classmate had a beef with the teacher. This teacher was liked by administration and all the students, he was successful, likeable and approachable, the perfect teacher. When this disgruntled student claimed he touched her inappropriately, he was suspended for over a month, the administration turned their backs on him, and the teachers union turned their backs on him. It cost him financially to defend the false accusations, his wife left him and he couldn''t see his 3 kids. When it was found the girl lied the teacher was told he could come back but the student that made the claim would still be in his class. He decided to stop teaching because the risk of losing his freedom because of another pissed off student in the future was not worth it. This happens all the time even with kids falsely accusing parents because they aren%u2019t happy with rules. I think there should be statue of limitations. How reasonable is it for a teacher to defend himself or herself 10-15 years down the road? The student can make up anything they want with no proof and the teacher is screwed. Just another way for someone to make money on a civil suite $$$

[fiteit1]

Make the penalty apply to the accuser, anyone falsely accusing someone gets the same sentence as the person accused would get. If it%u2019s not worth the risk of accusing, don%u2019t accuse or prosecute.

[excoachken]

I taught for 40 years and, although they are few and far between, a few are too many perverts in positions of trust, and as a result they have damage the potential support that teachers really want to offer kids who are not getting positive feedback at home. it would be nice to "clean it up" but, please do it with care because most teachers who make important progress with a student need to have a close personal relationship to have the child overcome damage that they acquire at home and bring to the school.

[Deadguylurking]

What about mandating punishment for false accusations?
I was talking to an ex-high school teacher, explaining my son was in college to be a high school teacher. She told me "Good, we need more male teachers." When I showed her his picture, she replied "Oh he''s handsome. Thats'' too bad. He won''t make it three years before some girl he''s failed accuses him of offering to trade grades for ***. The nice ones never make it."

[runningralph]

If a man wants to be a school teacher and he is attracted to the girls he must squelch his desires or be discredited and/or imprisoned. But if the girl falsely accuses him she will be dealt with severely. But that same threat of severe treatment will frighten some girls who have true accusations. Then the perpetrator will get away. Or the innocent teacher will be prosecuted. Either way it''s a mess. I propose that schools should be sexually segregated and the male teachers teach only male students, females teach girls. Due to the large majority of teachers being female, many of the boys will have to have female teachers.

[Krazcarl]

There was a couple of cases of this back when I was in school one that started whed the fellow was in grade 8 they ended up married they left town and were still married last I knew but that was many years ago.I don''t believe stiffer penaties will help it will just make an illicet afair more illicet to those involved.. Without photos hard to prove hes says I say is all you really have no real evidence.

[trillion1]

This is a joke. The union in NY protects teachers that use their position to have *** .

[annamarie47]

As a teacher, I do not support eliminating the statute of limitations. It is simply much too easy for a vindictive student to make a false accusation, and even if the teacher isn''t convicted, the person has been put through much trouble.

I recently gave a student of mine a high five and handshake. Another student who doesn''t like me (or any of his teachers for that matter) asked if I was a child molester! I referred him to his counselor and he came up afterwards and said he hadn''t called me that. However, everyone heard it, and I rebuked him at the time.

In my school, we also have a male teacher who is married with three small children. The girls always say he''s too much interested in them. But he''s also a very hard teacher academically. None of his boy students make the accusations and in fact refute what the girls are saying.

If the abuse is going on, let the administrator deal with it properly, but do not allow vindictive and retributive students to file false charges.

[michellem99-2009]

Sorry Teacher yer peers do hurt pupils.. And yes I had lazy teachers years ago..The rule is teachers are predators..Theere is good ones. The kid lied that is wrong and really who teaches the pupil to lie. The parents.. I was never scared of my teachers years ago.. But they pissed me off in the fact they would not teach me..I was the only blind pupil in the school system..There is no since for the lies..I was not a boy. Back them they favoured boys.

[akakjb]

Its always the ***, ***, ***. Fact is, I had a teacher who HATED me in the 5th grade. So much so, in fact, that she kept a bottle of booze looked up in the lower desk drawer (I''m pretty sure it was Gin and it got used mostly because of me). She PAID rougher kids on the playground to wail on me, possibly so that the only words I could then use in class were "owwwwwww", "can I go see the Nurse about my high rate of blood loss" and my personal favourite, "I''m off to see a movie but I should be back before the buses arrive''.

[tomtomasters]

And the President of the United States and his goons get away with murdering thousands of Iraqi Kids with bombs, and bullets, and DU poisoning. I know what he means now, when he says "leave no child behind." American priorities are wrong. Send people to jail for ***, but give others guns and keep them out of Prison for murder and torture at the highest levels of leadership in Government.

[jennmarie620]

Teachers are in a position of authority over children, and as such are targets for the malicious retaliation of a student who feels he or she is being treated differently or graded harshly. That being said, there are many teachers who abuse their position of authority and because of these adults, all teachers are now under harsh scrutiny.

But to think that this is a recent phenomenon is asinine! Teachers have been seducing their students for decades - it doesn''t make it right, but to focus on today''s teachers and say there is something wrong with THEM is laughable. People are no different today than fifty years ago - people just talk about it more, so it seems like some new increase in crime.

Teachers should be held to high standards, though, as they spend 7-9 hours a day with our children for five days a week. If a teacher has acted unprofessionally or has been investigated for a crime, then that person should NOT be allowed to just switch school districts or states to hide from it. If they are innocent, that will come out and be proven - and if they are guilty, they should be punished.

Our children learn from their authority figures.

[vet_sk]

It is just more fear mongering.
There is a very, very small amount of this behavior but they have people believing there is a lot more.

Just a way to throw more people in jail and be the all for "Law and Order." The real crime in our war crimes and how how No Child Left Behind (Awake) takes away any control of the curriculum from good teachers. Critical Thinking - why would the government want that in public schools: That is for the realm of private schools where the new generation of leaders will come from.

[excoachken]

to runningralph: Don''t assume it is only men teachers who are perps of this awful crime. But, just like in divorce court, female perverts are always "cut a break" by male judges, who just don''t see the damage done to a young boy.

[tomanyt]

Oh great, just what we need a knee-jerk reaction to a perceived problem.

[snapdorris]

While it''s encouraging to seek lawmakers working to protect kids, they''re missing the mark.

We don''t necessarily need special new laws dealing with teachers who molest. We do, however, need to reform the archaic, predator-friendly statutes of limitations that protect all predators from being exposed in court.

Victims of horrific child sexual abuse need time to cope with and recover from their trauma, then time to pursue justice through the time-tested US court system, and thereby warn parents about predators.

Eliminating the statute of limitations is the quickest, safest, and most reasonable way to safeguard kids from child predators.
Barbara Dorris Outreach Director for SNAP
Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests

[runningralph]

excoachken,
You are quite correct. Females can and do instigate sexual episodes with their students. And sometimes female students entice a male teacher intentionally. But the majority of these problems happen when a male teacher goes after a female student. So I think my proposal of segregating the girls and boys and keeping the male teachers away from the girls would cut way down on the number of incidents.

[navyvet77]

Why am I so not surprised by the responses posted here? Substitute the words teacher and school with priest and church and I am sure that the opinions would be very different. The double standards are both laughable and predictable. And for the record, I am not a Catholic. But then again, I don%u2019t need to be a farmer to recognize bull *** when I see it.

[nlm2383]

They should also have harsher punishment for the students as well. Any student who actually agrees to a $exual relationship with a teacher is at fault as much as the teacher is. If it is assault or harassament, that is different, but some of these relationships go on for months or years. The teachers and students should both have a strict dress code. I think this would get rid of some of the $exual tension.

[psk123-2009]

More than time limits, I think the biggest problem in this area is the "keeping of the secret" mentality. If there is a problem with a teacher being inappropriate with students then their record should be public, to be seen by any other school system anywhere in the country.

But teachers/schools like doctors/hospitals protect their own and never shall the general public know there has been a problem...

[michellem99-2009]

I ''member years ago.. Teachers did have a dress code..IT was different from the pupils'' dress code.. Teachers had to wear their hair,dress as an adult that thay are.BE A TEACHER NOT THE PUPILS'' FRIEND..Parents who had their child in the class as a a pupil,it was Mrs/Mr. and their surname at school..aT HOME mum/dad. There was clothes we pupils could no wear to lessons in shcool. That was years ago. I were a public school/sp,ed.

[kansas1946]

The key to solving a lot of this problem is kids need to be informed and trained (from a VERY young age) on how to handle sexual advances. If a child does not know there is such a thing, they they are completely vulnerable. Unless they are just flat bodily kidnapped, there is a lot children, even kindergarteners can do to protect themselves. It just takes early education from their parents.