Jan. 26, 2008
Analysis: Bill Clinton's Lost Legacy
CBSNews.com's Vaughn Ververs: Inflammatory Remarks Tarnish Ex-President's Reputation
-
Play CBS Video
Video
Bill Clinton's Impact On S.C.
Former President Bill Clinton has played a big role in his wife's campaign. But after Hillary's significant loss in the South Carolina primary, things may in fact change. Jim Axelrod reports.
-
Video
Bill Clinton Lashes Out
"CBS News RAW": Former President Bill Clinton became visibly upset when asked about accusations that his comments on the campaign trail made appeals to voters based on race and gender.
-
Video
Does Hillary's Husband Help?
Former President Bill Clinton has been a fierce contributor to his wife's campaign. But, as Jim Axelrod reports, some say that this might not be the best thing for Hillary in South Carolina.
-
Photo
Former President Bill Clinton campaigns for his wife, Democratic presidential hopeful, Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton, D-N.Y., in Independence, Mo. Saturday, Jan. 26, 2008. (AP)
-
Photo Essay
Hillary Clinton
A look at a life and career full of firsts.
-
Photo Essay
Barack Obama
A look at the life and meteoric rise of the president-elect.
The man crowned as America's first black president for his unprecedented personal connection to the African-American community has abdicated the throne.
By injecting himself into the Democratic primary campaign with a series of inflammatory and negative statements, Bill Clinton may have helped his wife's presidential hopes in the long term but at the cost of his reputation with a group of voters that have long been one of his strongest bases of political support.
Illinois Senator Barack Obama won an overwhelming victory in South Carolina with the support of African American voters who made up 53 percent of the vote, according to CBS News exit polls. Eighty percent of those voters chose Obama.
The rout came after weeks of racial polarization, much of it involving the former president, who thrust himself into the fray in a manner more reminiscent of backwoods Arkansas politicking than conduct befitting a former commander in chief.
Bill Clinton was once seen as a big asset for his wife's campaign, especially among Democrats. After the thrashing Hillary Clinton took in South Carolina, the former president may find himself in the doghouse, if not the bullpen.
It was one phrase that began the racial ball rolling. When Bill Clinton referred to Obama's claims of consistent opposition to the war in Iraq as "the biggest fairy tale that I have ever seen," many blacks heard more than policy criticism. They heard a dismissive attack on the first black with a real chance of winning the White House. They heard echoes of racial battles of the past. And they heard it from someone who was supposed to be on their side.
Bill Clinton has not been the only campaign surrogate to stoke the racial fires. References by at least two Clinton supporters about Obama's past drug use, including a comment from one of the wealthiest African-American businessmen in the country.
E-mails have surfaced, some traced to Clinton campaign volunteers in Iowa, claiming that Obama is a Muslim. Former Senator Bob Kerrey, on the day he announced his support for Clinton, made sure to make a point about how wonderful he thought it was that Obama's middle name is Hussein. A radio ad in South Carolina sought to portray Obama as a fan of Republican policies in the 1990s.
The candidate herself contributed to the furor when she intimated that while Martin Luther King Jr. was a wonderful leader, it took President Johnson to make the Civil Rights Act a reality.
But it has been Bill Clinton who carried the campaign's attacks in the wake of his wife's Iowa loss. The "fairy tale" comment was followed by the claim that he had personally witnessed attempts at suppressing votes (a topic that touches blacks on a personal level) in Nevada by Obama supporters. It was Bill Clinton left to carry the ball in South Carolina for most of last week, while the candidate was in Super Tuesday battlegrounds like California.
When confronted with the rhetoric, Clinton lashed out at the media - and his wife's opponents. "I never heard a word of public complaint when Mr. Obama said Hillary is not truthful about character," he told reporters last week. "When he put out a hit job on me at the same time he called Hillary the senator from Punjab. I never said a word."
South Carolina Rep. Jim Clyburn, the highest ranking African American in Congress, publicly told Bill Clinton to "chill a little bit." Atlanta Mayor Shirley Franklin, speaking with the former president just feet away, rebuked his language, insisting, "this is reality, not fantasy or fairy tales." The shots came from all corners. Writing on his own blog, Clinton's former Labor Secretary, Robert Reich accused Clinton of spearheading a "smear campaign against Obama."
South Carolina voters apparently agreed. The numbers are jarring: Fifty-eight percent said Bill Clinton's involvement was important to their decision and most of them voted for Obama. Seventy percent believed Hillary Clinton had unfairly attacked Obama. As a warning to Clinton, just 77 percent said they would be satisfied with her as the nominee.
"Not presidential" is how former Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle described Bill Clinton's behavior on the campaign trail of late. All the same, it may be effective. Clinton's campaign is aimed at capturing voters who make up a huge part of the Democratic demographic: Middle class, white, female, older. Those are the voters who may shy away from backing a "black" candidate, as they have in earlier contests in this race. Despite his huge margin of victory, Obama captured just a quarter of white voters.
And the nasty tactics had another purpose - to knock the candidate of "hope" off the mountaintop and down into the gutters of hardball politics. Forcing the man who has sought to connect himself to the legacy of inspirational leaders of the nation's past (he announced his candidacy in the shadow of Abraham Lincoln) to trade blows and accusations with Bill Clinton on the divisive issue of race only serves to muddy both. And there's some evidence that it worked. Fifty-eight percent of South Carolina voters said they felt Obama unfairly attacked Clinton during the campaign.
Should Clinton win the nomination by marginalizing Obama as a black candidate, she may well end up in the White House. The sign outside should read: Still wanted, the first black president.
© MMVIII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Video



- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
...
- 13
- next
See all 643 Comments340 days & counting....
I''ve had just about enough of her and her husband too.
Well said!
Bill''s support for HIllary does nothing to damage the legacy of his presidency! What a stupid article!
What exactly did you except her to say? Woo hooo, congratulations Mr. Obama, your racial BS worked??? You did good?
The media has decided to paint Obama as a candidate in a race with a racist bigot whose husband is full of dirty tricks.
In my book, the bias evidenced by the media against Bill clinton is shocking, disappointing, and above all, not at all proven or to be believed. The press is mischief-making in this campaign and they are going to get us another Republican in the White House just like they got us into Iraq.
It would seem that I am for Hillary. Actually, I am an Edwards backer because his progressive agenda is to my liking. I wouldn''t have the slightest idea what Obama is for except "change" which means nothing and I think Hillary is too conservative.
When this campaign began I planned to support whomever the democrats chose because any of the democrats were better than any of the republicans. Now I%u2019m not so sure. Nice job Mr. President.
When this campaign began I planned to support whomever the democrats chose because any of the democrats were better than any of the republicans. Now I%u2019m not so sure. Nice job Mr. President.
When this campaign began I planned to support whomever the democrats chose because any of the democrats were better than any of the republicans. Now I%u2019m not so sure. Nice job Mr. President.
When this campaign began I planned to support whomever the democrats chose because any of the democrats were better than any of the republicans. Now I%u2019m not so sure. Nice job Mr. President.
When this campaign began I planned to support whomever the democrats chose because any of the democrats were better than any of the republicans. Now I%u2019m not so sure. Nice job Mr. President.
When this campaign began I planned to support whomever the democrats chose because any of the democrats were better than any of the republicans. Now I%u2019m not so sure. Nice job Mr. President.
Posted by briannorwood at 10:53 PM : Jan 26, 2008
What on earth are you talking about ? I just read her little speech on her website and there is ABSOLUTELY NOTHING crass or classless about it. She congratulates Obama and then says where she''s heading next and what the theme of her campaign is. As classy as can be. More lies from the Clinton-haters.
When this campaign began I planned to support whomever the democrats chose because any of the democrats were better than any of the republicans. Now I%u2019m not so sure. Nice job Mr. President.
Obama''s policies would be horrible for our country, but at least he is an honest man and would not resort to the same sorts of tactics that the Clintons have used time & time again to smear their opponents.
He may have a bad day but he was the messiah himself compared to that chimp idiot that we have right now. Unlike Dumya, Bill at least has a legacy to destroy.
Way too close to Bu$h for my comfort!
Should Clinton win the nomination by marginalizing Obama as a black candidate, she may well end up in the White House. The sign outside should read: Still wanted, the first black president.
Or the Democratic party will get another nasty shock, when Everyone beside the die hard party faithful, defect over to the Republican side--and vote for MCCain. I can just see McCain now while he stumps--saying he knows just how Obama must of felt coming up against the establishment that plays the race card--because what Bush did to him in SC is the sort of thing Hilary always tried. Old Washington never likes new blood--or mavericks that are not willing to keep the status quo. That would have been Obama for the Dems--or McCain for the GOP. When all that is left is Hilary and McCain--don''t count to much on people''s anger with the Repubs to elect Hilary. Many Dems are just as angry with the Dem Congress as they are with Bush and the GOP.
South Carolina has made me proud to be an American. While Obama got overwhelming black support, he received proportionate white support from a state where one would not think he would get it. This is great. This will give many whites and others the comfort to continue their overt support. Most Americans are decent and will ultimately vote what they know is right.
Martin Edwin Andersen
The "fairy tale" comment has ABSOLUTELY NOTHING TO DO WITH RACE. NICE TRY CBS.
"Bill Clinton has not been the only campaign surrogate to stoke the racial fires. References by at least two Clinton supporters about Obama''s past drug use, including a comment from one of the wealthiest African-American businessmen in the country."
Will someone please explain to me how commenting on past drug use has anything to do with race? Seriously, f*cking explain that to me!
That would include me. Billary''s smear tactics have cost them my vote. I voted twice for Bill in the 90''s. Adios.
NO ONE CARES ABOUT YOU AND YOUR VOTING STRENGTH.
VOTE FOR THE RIGHT CANDIDATE.
THE DEMOCRATS CONSIDER BLACKS AS COMPLACENT, NO BRAINERS.
WAKE UP BLACK AMERICA.
VOTE AGAINST HILLARY!!
VOTE FOR EDWARDS!
BETTER YET-VOTE FOR YOUR REAL PARTY OF CHOICE AND ARE AFRAID TO COME OUT FOR-REPUBLICAN!!!!
voted for Hillary ? How can Billy tarnish his legacy
by calling it like it is? Personally I do not think
Hillary stands a chance. She will get few black votes
(which of course means they are being racist) and of
course she will not get the chauvinists vote.
THIS IS FOR EVERYONE THAT THINKS HILARY BEING IN THE WHITE HOUSE WITH BILL MERITS "EXPERIENCE" POINTS:
"If time in the Oval Office was all it took to be a viable candidate Monica would be running...."
TOO FUNNY.
Posted by wright5579 at 12:36 AM : Jan 27, 2008
I believe the person said he was pushing another kind of business in the ''hood. Pushing is another word for selling drugs and invokes the image of a black male selling drugs in the ghetto. The other remark by a Hilary operative was making fun of Obama for ''trying to act like a real black person'' the operative said Obama was "shucking and jiving" which is the black vernacular for a buffoonish con artist--try to scam someone in the ghetto.
They were racially tinged and they backfired. Hilary needs not only to curb Bill but also her ardent black supporters, who are not above getting nasty when they feel their Hilary (and therefore their coattails to more power) could be in jeopardy. Both the pusher comment and the shucking comment were made by black supporters. (One was Andrew YOung, the former mayor of Atlanta and I believe the other was the President of BET) both millionaires-who have their own type of removal/segregation from the avg. Black community.
Yet the Clintons are ingenious in their own ways. They have come up with this absolutely incredible idea that no scientist could have ever thought of - a 100% effective mass destruction without nuclear weapon - JUST LET THE NEXT GENERATION LIE, HATE, ATTACK, and DO ANYTHING AT ALL COST TO SECURE SELF-GAIN!
voted for Hillary ? How can Billy tarnish his legacy
by calling it like it is? Personally I do not think
Hillary stands a chance. She will get few black votes
(which of course means they are being racist) and of
course she will not get the chauvinists vote.
Posted by borwell at 01:19 AM : Jan 27, 2008
then again, she will also lose the "decent Americans who don''t like people who will do or say anything to get elected vote" and no doubt the "people who can smell a rat and spurious agenda" probably won''t vote for her either.
That leaves the party elite , the establishment, and the few Democrats that have been in the party long enough to have been completely indoctrinated and either have rewards to seek, or are like the Bush faithful and see Hilary and Bill as royalty or goddettes. Either way, Hilary could get more mileage if she ran NOT on trying to denigrate Osama--(his inexperience will show in his answers and in the debates) she should run on the validity and merit of her own ideas and programs--we know that is not how it is done these days--but I have a feeling dirty politics and old established stumping is just what most of America is sick to death of and distrustful of , these days.
Posted by sara48909 at 01:25 AM : Jan 27, 2008
I am not an Obama supporter, (though I would vote for him over a Republican) but I have heard some of his ideas and specifics. He has them--but if you are biased and do not want to hear them--then for you they do not exist. I have even heard Hillary appropriating some of the things Obama has said....Next time --try to LISTEN to the man instead of being busy repudiating or finding fault--you might be surprised at what he has to say--I certainly was and I don''t impress easily from candidates from either party.
I for one am not interested in ever seeing Bill red faced and wagging his finger to scold anyone. Too remniscent of his past failings.
Anyway congrats to Obama for tonight. We''ll see what the party powerful have in store for him next. It''s not likely to be pretty.
In any other campaign the fairy tale remark would be a legitimate point but not this one for some reason. It somehow morphed into the race car and just because some of the media is called liberal by many, that doesn''t mean they don''t have a conservative or corperate agenda. Money trumps politics everytime.
Conventional wisdom dictates that republican''s and conservatives have been constantly attacking Hillary for the past year and a half for a reason and I''m highly suspicious that they haven''t laid a glove on Obama. Most of them in fact speak admirably about Obama so don''t get stuck on stupid. Their not willing to lose the election just to spite the Clintons. They think they can defeat Obama and their scared of Clinton in the general. The only thing their more scared of is Clinton/Obama which might explain why the media is so intent in dividing the democratic party lately.
Their going to take the gloves off in the general and while they''ve attacked Hillary so often that nobody even pays attention anymore, that will not be the case for Obama. They will ridicule him for being left of Dennis Kucinich and press him for specifics until he gives them and looks like a mere mortal, not to mention a naive one.
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
...
- 13
- next
See all 643 Comments