February 11, 2009 3:33 PM

Have Bod Like Jennifer Aniston, Or $1M

By
CBSNews
(CBS)  Women may say they'd do anything to have a figure like their favorite celebrity. But would they really?

An online poll conducted by Women's Day magazine and AOL Body asked women if they'd rather have Jennifer Aniston's physique or be a millionaire. Some 6,900 responded.

Only 22 percent said they'd prefer to look like Aniston, while 78 percent said they'd rather have the money.

Although every woman has her own answer to the question and reasons for it, some health care professionals are concerned about the survey's results.

"This survey maybe does suggest that women may be choosing wealth over health," observes clinical psyhcologist Rene Zweig. "Jennifer Aniston is seen as having the ideal body: She's toned, she's muscular, and she's not particularly underweight."

Zweig says she'd hope women would value being fit more than they do being rich.

"It's already an uphill battle for medical professionals to get people to a healthy weight; 65 percent of Americans are overweight. And if their values are not to be attractive and healthy, that would be concerning."

The survey also asked, "How do you feel about your body." Only 11 percent said great. Fifty-nine percent said OK, with some trouble spots, and 30 percent said they felt uncomfortable and ashamed.

"That really doesn't make very much sense," points out dietician Keri Glassman. "People are saying, 'I don't like the way I feel, I'm ashamed of my body, I'm uncomfortable, yet I'd rather have money than look great and be healthy.' "

Glassman says Americans should rethink what's important: "I think this survey absolutely points to the fact that our values are a little off."

But a lot of American women say they'd still prefer hard currency to hard abs.

"That just sounds like typical women," remarked one young woman on a Manhattan street. "We're very materialistic, so money comes first, especially if you can buy the body with the million dollars!"

Copyright 2009 CBS. All rights reserved.
Add a Comment See all 26 Comments
by skinnyminny2 January 23, 2008 10:42 PM EST
bfolts, give me a break. Healthy food isn''t always expensive--I know this having lived very cheaply as a vegetarian who actually lives on vegetables. As far as poverty, obesity and fresh produce, our local food pantries can''t even GIVE fresh greens away. No one wants them. Salad, broccoli, fresh spinach--all refused. They want the SPAM, bologna, white bread and hot dogs instead. They''re digging their own graves by refusing the very foods they complain they cannot afford. All you hear is excuses, excuses, excuses. Almost anyone can have Jennifer Aniston''s figure if they eat properly and work out, and it''s doesn''t cost a fortune to do it.
Reply to this comment
by bfolts-2009 January 23, 2008 5:38 PM EST
Buying fresh and healthy foods, finding time to work out....if I had Jennifer Aniston''s $$$$, I wouldn''t have to work, so would have the time to get back into shape and be able to afford fresh fruit, vegetables, leaner cuts of meat, and fresh seafood for my family. Have you done a study to see who''s more out of shape and obese? Is it the rich or the poor?
Reply to this comment
by augustfarm January 23, 2008 5:35 PM EST
CBS, I believe you owe your viewers a more realistic look at the problems of obesity than this one. If I could have, I would have given Keri Glassman a bop on the nose as she mindlessly went on equating something about this survey to real life issues.

Men and women who are overweight or obese need to live within a tight balance of trying to become more healthy and having to live their everyday lives being able to face the daily ridicule from others who think they have the answers; not unlike Ms. Glassman. To maintain, overweight and obese people often have to develop a strong protective layer against what life has given them as a serious challenge and their ability to go forward.

A survey asking women if they would rather have a body like Jennifer Aniston or a million dollars is a stupid waste of time and money. To draw conclusions regarding the real lives of people in relationship to the study is, or should be, unallowable.
Reply to this comment
by bfolts-2009 January 23, 2008 5:33 PM EST
Buying fresh and healthy foods, finding time to work out....if I had Jennifer Aniston''s $$$$, I wouldn''t have to work, so would have the time to get back into shape and be able to afford fresh fruit, vegetables, leaner cuts of meat, and fresh seafood for my family. Have you done a study to see who''s more out of shape and obese? Is it the rich or the poor?
Reply to this comment
by ianarthist January 23, 2008 4:59 AM EST
The segment misrepresented and almost deliberately misunderstood the attitudes towards wealth and health among American women. The question did not ask women if they would choose having a healthy body over money, but rather if they would choose %u201Chaving a body like%u201Da celebrity, who has that body partly because she is wealthy. Daily reports on the behavior of young celebrities such as super thin Paris Hilton,Britney Spears hardly makes looking like one of them more attractive than saving your home, not having to worry about credit card debt, an already present recession or Christmas presents, let alone never having to worry about having enough money to put ANY food on the table.Those results really show that American women are intelligent, well-informed,perhaps better than those conducting the survey, about the real world and the events swirling around them. Jennifer Aniston is beautiful, but without the explanation that her body is healthy a normal reaction with %u2018oh, have a body like a wealthy, too-thin looking blond over keeping my home, feeding my children, caring for their health and never having to worry about debt again? Thank you, I%u2019ll take the latter!%u2019 While children are starving our candidates argue like pre-adolescents and the media insists on representing Americans, particularly American women, as stupid, immature, irresponsible toddlers who know nothing of the real world. Please be more responsible and stop insulting your viewers.
Reply to this comment
by dgshiner January 22, 2008 8:27 PM EST
I would definitely take the money cause she by no way is all of that! I wish I had her contacts though so I could get some better deals on exercise equipment!
Reply to this comment
by random_radar January 22, 2008 8:16 PM EST
Given the fact that you probably aren''t going to get the money but you might get the body if you work at it, I would recommend trying for at least the best body you can get.

Everyone has some control over their diet, exercise, and health care even if it is hard. You can succeed in that.

But I suppose that taking the money is an admission that we really aren''t going to discipline ourselves to keep the body if we had it, right?
Reply to this comment
by sjw1253 January 22, 2008 8:05 PM EST
I have to say that Jennifer Aniston is not one that I would want to look like. I am not sure why she was used as an example.

I do not see anything healthy or vibrant about her at all. She seems to slump a bit and she is average in appearance. I would definitely take the $$$ as I like mine over hers any day.

I would take the money and buy a gym membership to help get my body healthier (get a personal trainer to help make me healthier as I am thin but not healthy and need to have my own issues addressed to make me stronger)...

This is the first time I do agree with someone saying that this example was a very poor one. Again - I am not sure I have ever heard anyone saying how great her body is???

I''m sure she is fit - but nothing above average that I have seen. I mean no disrespect to her whatsoever - she is an attractive woman but as far as having any striking beauty - I don''t see it...

I am a woman so it is not like the guy who said he wouldn''t want it.

The dietician who states her concerns about the results is not looking at the question... Many people may not be happy with the way they appear but to say I want to look like this person over taking the money to help make me healthier may be their thoughts (as this is the way I myself think)...



Reply to this comment
by johnstossel January 22, 2008 7:10 PM EST
I''m a guy and I would like to have Jennifer Annisto''s body. Hee-hee-hee
Reply to this comment
by terribayless-2009 January 22, 2008 6:32 PM EST
A woman''s #1 concern is Security. Looks may be high up there as well, but not first. It could only have been men who thought it would be different.
Reply to this comment
See all 26 Comments
.
Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook