Negativity Reigns Again In South Carolina

CBSNews.com Reports: Another GOP Primary In The Palmetto State Brings A Fresh Round Of Mudslinging

(CBS)  This analysis was written by CBSNews.com political reporter David Miller.

---

If North Carolina is the Tarheel State, neighboring South Carolina, host of Saturday's crucial Republican primary might aptly be called the Tar Pit State - at least when it comes to politics.

After a few weeks of relatively civilized campaigning in Iowa, New Hampshire and Michigan, the mud has flown freely during the last days of the South Carolina race. The top candidates are going after each other and outside groups have seemingly emerged from nowhere, using questionable tactics - some would say dirty tricks - that lift one candidate, bring down another, but risk tarnishing them all.

None of this, of course, is anything South Carolina voters haven't seen before. Infamous GOP strategist Lee Atwater, who once planted a reporter at a press conference to disclose an opponent's electroshock therapy treatments, was a fixture of state politics in the 1980s. In 2000, John McCain, then campaigning against George W. Bush, was the target of a vicious underground smear campaign, one Bush denied being involved with, that accused McCain, among other things, of fathering a black child out of wedlock and abandoning veterans, and claimed his wife had a drug problem.

That race has gone down in the state's political history as one of the nastiest ever waged. This year hasn't seen that level of mudslinging, but the tone of the race is undeniably more negative than in the states that came earlier on the calendar. The opening salvo may have come on Jan. 10 when Fred Thompson - who needs a strong showing on Saturday to keep his campaign afloat - came out swinging at Mike Huckabee during a debate in Myrtle Beach.

"This is a battle for the heart and soul of the Republican Party and its future," Thompson said at the debate. "On the one hand, you have the Reagan revolution. You have the Reagan coalition of limited government and strong national security. On the other hand, you have the direction that Gov. Huckabee would take us in. He would be a Christian leader, but he would also bring about liberal economic policies, liberal foreign policies. He believes we have an arrogant foreign policy in the tradition of 'blame America first.' He believes that Guantanamo should be closed down and those enemy combatants brought to the United State to find their way into the court system eventually. He believes in taxpayer-funded programs for illegals, as he did in Arkansas. He has the endorsement of the National Education Association, and the NEA said it was because of his opposition to vouchers. HE said he would sign a bill that would ban smoking nationwide. So much for federalism. So much for states' rights. So much for individual rights."

Thompson, appearing more animated than he has most of the campaign, ended with a stinging indictment: "That's not the model of the Reagan coalition - that's the model of the Democratic Party."

Since then, all the Republican contenders have been on the receiving end of some vicious barbs. McCain has once again seen his time as a prisoner of war in Vietnam questioned. This time, he's been accused of betraying his fellow POWs - a claim he and his supporters quickly, and strongly rebuked.

And plenty of attention has gone to the escalating tensions between Thompson, a former Tennessee senator, and Huckabee, who has joked that Thompson's debate outburst indicated he'd finally woken up. The animosity between the two camps really escalated, however, when an outside group supporting Huckabee, Common Sense Issues, started placing automated phone calls to South Carolina voters that effectively questioned Thompson's conservative credentials - particularly on abortion - under the guise of a poll.

Patrick Davis, the GOP consultant behind Common Sense Issues, denied that he's up to anything underhanded.

"The facts of a person's voting records, public statements and public positions are up for fair analysis in any election," he said. "We use the information we gather for where people stand on those issues to encourage them to support leaders who stand with those positions. Sen. Thompson and Sen. McCain and Gov. Romney and Gov. Huckabee are all mentioned in our phone calls."

But what Davis portrayed as a voter education effort has been labeled by others as a "push poll," phone calls that purport to be legitimate surveys of public opinion, but only serve the purpose of pushing negative - sometimes false - information about a candidate onto voters. And by South Carolina's standards, the anti-Thompson calls might actually be considered tame.

"I would have to say that, yes, it was a push poll, but it was kind of a nice one," said Neal Thigpen, a longtime GOP activist and political science professor at Francis Marion University. "This was genteel by South Carolina standards."

Other candidates haven't been spared, either. Mitt Romney's rightward shifts on social issues and Mormon faith have been frequent targets and Thompson has been strongly critical of his opponents on immigration.

Perhaps remembering the treatment McCain endured in 2000, his campaign has tried to stay out of the fray and, at least publicly, denounced the fighting between Thompson and Huckabee even though they might stand to benefit.

"I think that anytime someone is partaking in these negative activities, it only hurts all of us. It's detrimental," McCain spokesperson B.J. Bolling said. "I think it would be purely speculative to say that Gov. Huckabee and Sen. Thompson or any other candidates going back and forth helps a third candidate."

So why is this Palmetto State primary, like others in years past, standing out for its negativity? The makeup of the Republican electorate may play a role. In contrast to Iowa, no one candidate seems to have a lock on evangelical Christians and other socially conservative voters - sparking a fiercer competition, especially when several of the candidates could see their White House hopes extinguished by a poor showing.

Huckabee resoundingly won over social conservatives in the Hawkeye State and his odds of winning Saturday will rise if he can do the same in South Carolina - something Thompson's camp doesn't think will happen.

"I think Gov. Huckabee has relied upon social conservatives to build his campaign starting in Iowa but the socially conservative voter in South Carolina is different than the average socially conservative voter in Iowa in that they're a big picture voter," Thompson spokesman Jeff Sadosky said. "They're interested in tax issues, national security issues."

But whether it's national security and taxes in 2008, or the Confederate flag in 2000, the mud is always sure to fly in South Carolina, and splatter anyone who's unfortunate enough to be standing nearby - after yet another negative campaign, it makes one wonder why the state comes so early in the process, instead of toward the end.

[taotxzen]

Just One More Year! Good Riddance to George W. Bush

Arabia is the land of illusion and desert mirages. And as he jetted last week from kingdom to sheikdom, to be regaled with feasts and falcons, jewels and ornamental swords, George Bush might have imagined that all was well with his presidency. But this, his longest and most ambitious trip to the Middle East, will surely be remembered - if it is remembered at all - as a gaudy, irrelevant footnote to a presidency that has long since failed.

Today is a sombre milestone, marking the start of the last of Mr Bush%u2019s eight years in the White House. This being a leap year, exactly 366 days remain until 20 January 2009, when his successor will be sworn into office. It is a time when incumbents look to their legacies. And for this President the view could scarcely be bleaker.

(cont)

[taotxzen]

(cont)

Is he the worst President in US history? Mr Bush faces stiff competition from the likes of James Buchanan, who watched as America slipped towards civil war, or Warren Harding with his corrupt administration, or Herbert Hoover, who failed to halt the slide into the Great Depression, or, more recently, Richard Nixon, the only President to be forced to resign. But in terms of dogmatism, incompetence, ignorance and divisiveness, Mr Bush surely compares with any of the above.

His first, albeit far from most important, bequest is seemingly inevitable defeat for his own party in November, ending almost 30 years of Republican dominance since Ronald Reagan took power. As David Frum, a one-time Bush speech-writer, put it the other day: %u201CI fear the Republicans are heading to an epochal defeat, 1980 in reverse. Every gain we have made since then has been wiped out since 2002.%u201D

Published on Sunday, January 20, 2008 by the Independent/UK

[glaswolf]

Possibly the negativity arises because of southern culture which is pretty vulgar, from what North Carolinians emphasized to me. Bible Belts are cloaks concealing laminations of rather vulgar social interactive phenomenon. I could not believe the constant cutting and insults which existed in the southern work environments I encoutered in a 9 month pass thru. Curiously, when they found out how repulsed I was by degenerate dialectics, they systematically stopped exposing me to their base vulgarity which I respected and some of them complained because their bosses insisted they accommodate me by withholding the seemingly constant flow of vulgarity when I was present. I usually have a standing rule: If you cuss in front of me, I will no longer interact with you or your friends ... there are exceptions, but I am very strict about the pristine rule, as I am extremely introverted and interact with others only as a community responsibility of coadaptive citizenship. Honest good people benefit from the short time I have of life, otherwise I will attend to my personal research related thought or my holistic arts and sciences cross correlations for personal illumination of coadaptive functionality. So, from the outside we see evangelicals, from the inside we see vulgar mean spirits who mudsling as an art form.

[glaswolf]

j-whitman: In the military, expacifists and exseminary students make the best interrogators historically. Perhaps it because false arguments are something they have been drenched in. Don''t confuse pacifism with cowardice. Often pacifists are extremely martial but are committed to not over reacting. For example, in six years two (2) jews have been killed from another article, for this the "martial jews" with our weapons and intel assist torment over a million palestinians. NOT exactly what I would call martial functionality. A pacifist would take a balance more realistic and honest view. The Israelis are cowards who quash everything that is relatively weak and their judeo christian rightist drain our resources protecting them because the GOD HUSSLE of murderers and liars. A pacifist would not go along with the criminal god hussling nor the drain of our resources we need for our national survival organized by Trotskyite NeoCons. In war, we need someone who response to reason, not people who get sidetracked by their criminal god''s sadism.

[Ruidu]

To clarify what happened in South Carolina tonight, Fred Thompson split the ticket, as Ross Perot split the ticket on H Bush in South Carolina. Huckabee supporters must start today answering the established media%u2019s attack on Mike Huckabee and expose the records of McCain, Romney, and Thompson.

[candide777]

Posted by candide777 at 05:45 PM : Jan 19, 2008

Actually, I meant to say Nixon rewarded Rhenquist by making him a Justice; Reagan rewarded him by elevating him to Chief Justice, my bad.

[candide777]

When Republicans do it, they simply show up and harass and intimidate black voters across the country on election day.
Posted by jon2012 at 03:31 PM : Jan 19, 2008

Yes, let''s not forget that William Rehnquist was one of those people who used physical intimidation to prevent blacks from voting. Ronald Reagan, pig that he was, rewarded Rehnquist for his racism by making him a Supreme Court Justice and then elevating him to Chief Justice. No wonder people are astonished by Obama''s recent praise of Reagan. I doubt Obama remembers that when Rhenquist was nominated, people testified at his confirmation hearings about how he had used physical intimidation against black voters. Bygones, I guess.

[tylenol6]

John Mc Cain?? John Mc War????? No!!!!! It''s Juan McCain.

[j-whitman]

carolrhill,,,, Bush has also shown you can get the job without an employment verification or background security investigation

[j-whitman]

carolrhill,,,, McCain is the old school politician we are trying to get away from now. And he is one of the many who knew what was needed in Iraq & refused to speak up to power.
---- Is he capable of being President ?? I think Bush has proved Howdy Doody could get the job

[carolrhill]

I wish all of this would just come to an end. I think that McCain would make an excellent President but he just does not enough people the way I think.
He has nothing to prove he what he is. He is as honest as can be and that is a fact. But HONESTY just does not fly it just does not, and that is fact.
MAY GOD BLESS MCCAIN AND HIS FAMILY NOW AND FOREVER AS I AM SURE HE WILL!!!

[j-whitman]

Johnfrost,,,,, If I''m not mistaken, Mormans have a strong belief in pacifism. Is that really what we need in the War on Terror ???

[j-whitman]

Johnfrost,,,,, You gotta wonder which side Romney''s going to end up on when he stops flip-flopping.

[j-whitman]

Let''s talk about how Bush''s Christian political hacks are Swift Boating John McCain calling him "The Hanoi Songbird".

[jon2012-2009]

No Alqaidademocrats in the WhiteHouse, ever!!!
Posted by Johnfrost at 02:03 PM : Jan 19, 2008

An Alqaidademocrat is someone like ... ? Let''s talk about real things here, not something that may exist only in your fevered imagination. But first things first. No Republicans in the White House next year.

[jon2012-2009]

WHY MUST I LIE ABOUT HILLARY GOING TO COURT TO TRY TO PREVENT WORKING CLASS PEOPLE FROM VOTING IN NEVADA? I WANT TO BE GOOD, BUT I JUST CAN''''T!!!!

Posted by CBSVerified at 09:26 AM : Jan 19, 2008

Frankly, I doubt anybody can "prevent people from voting" by using the courts.

When Republicans do it, they simply show up and harass and intimidate black voters across the country on election day.

[johnfrost-2009]

The Obama''s Church believes Blacks are superior to all other races and that other races should be subservient to Blacks.

Oprah, Obama, Louis Farrakahn and his followers believe that if Obama convinces Whites, Latins and Asians to vote for Him, that will prove Blacks are superior mentally to other races and them should serve Blacks as slaves. Black supremacists forget crime statistics which say Blacks kill and rob people of all races on a daily basis.

[johnfrost-2009]

Cocaine crack addict winning in Nevada with tricks and scams, like Chicago politics.

[jon2012-2009]

Got to love the Christain values don''''t you. How come the Republicans spend so much time throwing mud at everyone. Is it because they really have nothing to say.
Posted by antoniof123 at 12:43 PM : Jan 19, 2008

The people of the Palmetto State are your typical Republican constituency. Long on "faith" and "moral values," they are somewhat handicapped in being unable to discriminate between what is real and what is merely made to appear real. Mudslinging works well with this type of audience.

[wdrussell1]

Nooooooooooobody expects the Spanish Inquisition.
Except Huckabee supporters.
They are cheering for it.