Frustrated GOP Supporter Hedges His Bets

Washington Post: In Michigan, Disgruntled Republican Donates To Romney, Giuliani - And Clinton

(Washingtonpost.com)  This story was written by Krissah Williams.

---

James Esshaki pilots his black Mercedes down the main strip of what's left of the high-end shopping district here, coming to one of the 11 buildings he owns. "Esshaki Properties for Lease" posters hang in the windows where mannequins modeling the latest fashions should be. For three months, it has been like this. No major stores, it seems, want to take a chance on Maple Avenue anymore.

"When you make a cold call to a national retailer and you mention you're in Michigan, they shut down," he said, turning the corner and eyeing a plot where he'd like to build, if the economy ever picks up.

As is the case for many businessmen in Michigan, a place that former Massachusetts governor Mitt Romney says is going through a "one-state recession," prospects are not good for Esshaki. The state's unemployment rate has risen to 7.4 percent, the highest in the nation, and an estimated 70,000 homes in nearby Detroit have risked foreclosure in the past two years.

In many ways, those are the least of the worries for Esshaki, a Detroit-born Iraqi American who has lost relatives to the war tearing through his ancestral homeland. As much as he wants an end to his state's economic hardships, he wants the war to stop and some semblance of order to return in Iraq.

"Things will change with a new president," he said. "Things will change."

Esshaki (pronounced e-SAH-key), 43, has been a Republican all his life and a staunch party supporter for a dozen years, giving more than $10,000 to local and national candidates. But this year, none of the Republicans running for president is speaking to his concerns. Iraq rarely comes up in debates or on the campaign trail, he said, and candidates began to talk about the economy only last week, after an exit poll in New Hampshire showed it to be the most pressing issue on voters' minds.

"I'm frustrated," Esshaki said, as talk of the New Hampshire primary's outcome buzzed on the flat screen in his spacious office. "All of the Republican candidates are just lacking something."

For months, social issues, illegal immigration and anti-terrorism efforts were the dominant issues in the campaign. For those same months, Esshaki watched his expenses mount. Oil hit $100 a barrel, and gas prices crept above $3 per gallon. The value of the dollar declined, and his global buying power shrank. As automakers laid off more than 100,000 workers over the past two years, he felt the sting of yet more bad news.

If Michigan's economy is not righted, the value of Esshaki's $30 million real estate portfolio - which he built by taking a loan against his mother's house 22 years ago, then leveraging his life's savings with each subsequent purchase - could be in jeopardy. Last year, his rental revenue sank 15 percent.

Some of Esshaki's tenants in the downtown district of designer boutiques here watched their sales dip. They responded by threatening to leave his buildings for cheaper spaces. He made concessions, offering free rent for a month.

"I'm working harder," he said. "Five years ago, if a client called and wanted to see a space, I'd send the maintenance guy or the secretary to open the space," he said. "No more. I'm going out there. I know I can close the deal."

He's less sure that the Republicans running for president can close the deal. Esshaki has not heard anything that leads him to believe that they have plans to keep the country from going into a recession, and he has been dismayed that they haven't focused more on the economy.

Former New York mayor Rudolph W. Giuliani proposed a tax-cut package. Romney promised to restore jobs lost to globalization. Sen. John McCain (Ariz.) has pledged to extend President Bush's tax cuts.

"Tax cuts are not a solution," Esshaki said. "They are only one part."

He doesn't know all the answers; he just knows he hasn't heard them yet.

Esshaki's parents immigrated to Michigan from Baghdad in the 1950s, and he was raised in one of the city's tightknit Arab American enclaves. He can speak a little Arabic and networks regularly with other Iraqi American businessmen. His family is Iraqi Chaldean, a Christian group that has settled among the 1.2 million residents of Oakland County, where Birmingham is located. They are mostly are well-to-do Catholics who tend to vote Republican and for the most part are allied with the party's fiscal and social platforms.

Esshaki has always sided with Republicans because of their business stances: lower income taxes, smaller government and tax breaks for business owners. On foreign policy, he enthusiastically supported Bush's effort to bring down Saddam Hussein, whom Esshaki viewed as a threat to the world. When weapons of mass destruction were not found, Esshaki felt deceived.

"The war in Iraq started with a lot of facts. As they unraveled, these facts are no longer facts. It's almost a fabricated war," Esshaki said. "We have lost faith in [President Bush] as a community, as Chaldeans, as Arab Americans. We have members in our family that have lost lives, that have been hurt."

Chaldeans made up about 6 percent of Iraq's population before the war, but the community has since been almost entirely killed or chased from the country, according to news reports. One of Esshaki's elderly aunts and an uncle died in the midst of the fighting.

Esshaki puts the blame on Bush, rather than the Republican Party as a whole. He is not sure the GOP will retain the White House, but he is not voting for a Democrat. He doesn't agree with the Democratic Party's economic priorities or its calls for a swift move to exit an already destabilized Iraq. So he has been searching for a Republican to back.

Playing pundit along with the suits on his television, he parsed the front-runners.

"McCain's going to run out of money. ... I don't think Mitt Romney is passionate. I need to see that. ... He almost looks like a movie star that's playing the role of a president.

"[Mike] Huckabee seems honest and humble," Esshaki went on, though he later said the former Arkansas governor's proposal to eliminate the income tax and replace it with a national sales tax is crazy.

Esshaki favors Giuliani, with some apprehensions, because of his tenacity. "He was a prosecutor. His track record speaks for itself. He broke up the Mafia in New York," he said. "That's tough."

Esshaki, who volunteers once a week as a sheriff's deputy and dreamed as a kid of being a police officer, thinks it will take a tough guy to stick it out in Iraq and ensure that an effective government is restored. Giuliani, who has built his candidacy on fighting terrorism, makes him believe that.

"Everything becomes, do you believe they can do it?" Esshaki said.

Giuliani is barely competing in this state, and Esshaki thinks the candidate's strategy of skipping the first primaries could cost him the nomination. Many in this corner of Michigan, only a few miles from the big lakeside homes of Bloomfield Hills, where Romney grew up and went to high school, lean toward Romney. They know the Romney name because his father was governor of Michigan from 1963 to 1969.

The Giuliani campaign sent Esshaki an invitation to a donor's banquet Monday in Detroit, about 30 minutes south of Birmingham, but the candidate has held only five campaign events in the state. Romney and McCain have held four times as many.

"Should I jump ship? Everyone wants to bet on a winning horse," Esshaki said. "My problem is I'm so loyal. You watch your guy and hope it works out."

He will vote for Giuliani, but he is spreading his donations around. This month, he wrote $1,200 checks to Romney's and Giuliani's campaigns.

Because Esshaki thinks there is a good chance they could both sink, he wrote a check to Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton (D-N.Y.), too. She is the only Democrat on the ballot in Michigan because of restrictions placed on the state by the Democratic National Committee. Last summer, Esshaki gave her campaign $1,000, and he went to a donor's banquet and shook her hand. In an 8-by-10 photo leaning atop his cherry file cabinets, Esshaki and Clinton are standing side by side. That image is surrounded by photos of Esshaki grinning with Bush years ago.

Esshaki is hedging his bets this time. He made the decision to give to Clinton when a Democratic business associate called and asked him to write a check to her campaign. He figured he would help a friend and still come out a winner if his team lost.

"I'm a businessman," he said. "Whatever you do ... you need to diversify at some point."

[samsel3]

We can all talk about the past, but what about now and the future ? Presently the CNP Council for National Policy is planning your future. This secretive organisation of several hundred of the richest men in the USA put Bush & Cheney in office to accomplish their global agenda. In September 2007 they met again in Salt Lake City. Cheney & Mitt Romney were keynote speakers. Romney wants their backing. The CNP wants to continue their agenda in global market control for BIG OIL & allied industry in the next election. National media outlets are owned by their members. Who will expose them? Who will stop their insanity and destruction of constitutional freedom ? Who will stop their misuse of the military to promote their global agenda? Paul Wolfowitz,Don Rumsfeld, Scooter Libby, George Bush, Richard Cheney, Eliot Cohen. Zalmay Khalilzad, Steve Forbes, Donald Kagan, Pete Rodman, Henry S Rowen, Dan Quale, William J.Bennett, Jeb Bush, they are all members of the PNAC Project for a New American Century.

[giantrobot2]

Alert *** Alert *** Alert ***

Question:
Would you like to own a brand new high definition 60" LCD / Plasma TV with reclining chair with large cup holder for your cold beverage of your choice?

Answer:
Huckabee! He is the ONLY candidate out of the presidential field willing to implement the "Fair-Tax" system.

Look at your paycheck and see how much they are taking out of your paycheck for taxes... go ahead go look at it now.

Now take the cost of a brand new 60" LCD / Plasma high def TV and reclining chair (& cup holder) and divide that number by how much taxes they are taking out.

Example:
$3,000 (TV cost, chair) / $325 tax holding each week = 8 weeks

That''''s it, only 8 weeks to get this great deal!!!

But if you vote for any other candidate it will take years to save up for this! Say you put away $10 each week, well that''''s 4 years!

So if you want to become poorer then vote for McCain, Romney, Thompson, Guiliani, Paul, Clinton, Obama, Edwards..... but if you want to become richer vote for Huckabee!

[ov442]

Trust me, Mitt Romney is nothing like his father the former Michigan Governor.
He wont succeed at anything worthwhile. Its always easy to succeed in business if your a snake with a brain. Unfortunately for GWB, he doesnt have a brain.

[missingamerica]

Imagine a nation with no natural resources being able to rally its citizens into such productivity, and the stark contrast with thier sister cities here in the U.S. with thier Retirment Home
politicians, dead beat depressed not able to run as
simple a thing as a campaign bus, what a stark contrast in leadership

Posted by fuzzybear9 at 09:38 AM : Jan 14, 2008

If you''re referring to Japan, interestingly enough we rebuilt their economy for them.

Unfortunately, over the intervening decades we''ve become burdened with a cult of business and political leaders who don''t understand that permitting CEO pay to reach 200, 300, 400 and more times their average workers pay or allowing the top 10% of America to get more of America''s income than all of the rest of America combined is nothing less than cultivating an overclass of parasites.

Parasites who sap America''s strength in their egocentrical pursuit of more, more, more simply so they can pleasure themselves as they ponder their placement on the various Forbes lists of the megawealthy...

[missingamerica]

"Michigan...Mitt Romney says is going through a "one-state recession...".

Huh. Does Romney believe that only one state is in a recession, or is Romney only smart enough to think about one state at a time?

Either way, not good for someone who will be responsible for the well-being of all 50 states and a number of territories as well as D.C.

[perception5]

Let hope the folks in Michigan vote for "Mr. Fixer" .................aka Mitt Romney.

No one else running has the knowledge or experience that''s needed in Washington DC today

then Mitt Romney...........................GO MITT !

[glossypan]

This story makes the case for campaign finance reform. When the electorate perceives - probably correctly - that contributors will be treated better by the elected than non-contributors, action must be taken.
Support public campaign financing, even if it takes a constitutional amendment.

[antoniof123]

Buddy, in case you don''''t know, fasism IS socialism! Hitler was democraticaly elected and his party was called National Socialist, all for the good of the people. Communism, Socialism, Fasism are basicaly the same thing. Monopoly control of capital, the means of production. There is only an illusion of private property, the state controls all. Most of the Communist Manifesto has already been implemented in America and the noose is tightening.

Posted by krisd999 at 02:30 AM : Jan 14, 2008

You must be getting sound bites from the right wing conservative crowd. Hitler was an occults sorry he was fanatical in his views in fact he got the Pope to bless his troops. Just because you give your self the name National Socialist doesn''t make it true the fact is fascism became so popular because it was intense hate for the Soviet Union. A little fact that the right wing tends to leave out.

[brianbwb-2009]

"More on Ron Paul''''s voting record (or lack thereof) can be found here:
http://projects.washingtonpost.
com/congress/members/p000583/votes/"
Posted by TheGateway1

We may disagree on most everything else, but on this one, I''m with the Gate-man. Paul is not what America needs right now.

By the way Gateway1, you forgot to mention his most loyal campaign contributors, the kkk, aryan nations, the Michigan militia, and other virulent right wing neo nazi groups.

[brianbwb-2009]

"On foreign policy, he enthusiastically supported Bush''s effort to bring down Saddam Hussein, whom Esshaki viewed as a threat to the world. When weapons of mass destruction were not found, Esshaki felt deceived.
"The war in Iraq started with a lot of facts. As they unraveled, these facts are no longer facts. It''s almost a fabricated war," Esshaki said. "We have lost faith in [President Bush] as a community, as Chaldeans, as Arab Americans. We have members in our family that have lost lives, that have been hurt."

And still he votes for the fascists, I guess he, like the Republicans feel that his dead loved ones aren''t worth losing profit over.

As Bugs Bunny says "what a maroon"...

[krisd999-2009]

"fascism is faaaar worse than so-called "socialism"."

Buddy, in case you don''t know, fasism IS socialism! Hitler was democraticaly elected and his party was called National Socialist, all for the good of the people. Communism, Socialism, Fasism are basicaly the same thing. Monopoly control of capital, the means of production. There is only an illusion of private property, the state controls all. Most of the Communist Manifesto has already been implemented in America and the noose is tightening.

[tylenol6]

To all Clinton kool aid drinkers
Where do you think Hillary got that $100 million campaign donations from? She got it from the military
complex that wants to keeps the wars going. Do you think they gave it to her because she is cute? They expect Hillary to return the favor and keep these wars going. Hillary WILL NOT END THE WAR.
John McCain, another warmonger dosen''t care if our troops are in Iraq for 100 years. The crazy thing is
the american people would vote for this IDIOT. Like
Ron Paul said, the U.S. is BANKRUPT. WAKE UP PEOPLE...

[iceman_1960]

Also, Ron Paul is a gynecologist.

You want his hand on the nuclear button ?



(You didn"t say they had to be a good reasons.)

[iceman_1960]

"My question is: Would someone tell me why we should NOT elect Ron Paul?"
- Posted by DenisL1 at 05:39 PM : Jan 13, 2008

He"s too short.

[homespunlady]

It''s the FLOW of money not it''s accumulation that keeps an economic engine running.
When it bottlenecks in the hands of a few then the flow slows an the engine sputters to a stop.

[homespunlady]

If the MAJORITY of the citizens have NO money to spend in the shops Esskasi built OBVIOUSLY nobody will want to open a business that will go under.

If the MAJORITY of citizens actually HAD money to spend - that''s prosperity.

If most of the wealth is tied up in a TINY few hands the ONLY prosperous businesses will be in catering to that TINY few but Obviously "economy of scale" cannot take place and the few can only buy so much.

Then their wealth is SET ASIDE to accumulate rather than stimulate the economy.

Concentration of more than 28 percent or so of TOTAL wealth has historically led to major downturns of whatever country it has occurred in with out massive and economically risky "programs" to prop it up.

The Great Depression was brought about because of concentration and manipulation of that wealth. It took a HUGE infrastructure building and WW II buildup with all it''s rationing to get us out of it.

[homespunlady]

Esshaki''s learning that WITHOUT dollars in the hands of those LESS fortunate the wealthy investor will join them when things collapse.
I suggest he check out what Ron Paul has to say rather than trying to position himself for special favors from the "expected" winner.

Some evidence and a CLUE of what the REAL problem with the economy is and where it is heading comes from a 15 Dec NYT article by David Cay Johnson.
HE reported on the GROWING CONCENTRATION of WEALTH AT THE TOP

"The increase in incomes of the top 1 percent of Americans from 2003 to 2005 exceeded the total income of the poorest 20 percent of Americans, data in a new report by the Congressional Budget Office shows.

The poorest fifth of households had total income of $383.4 billion in 2005, while just the increase in income for the top 1 percent came to $524.8 billion, a figure 37 percent higher.

The total income of the top 1.1 million households was $1.8 trillion, or 18.1 percent of the total income of all Americans, up from 14.3 percent of all income in 2003. The total 2005 income of the three million individual Americans at the top was roughly equal to that of the bottom 166 million Americans, analysis of the report showed.

Earlier reports, based on tax returns, showed that in 2005 the top 10 percent, top 1 percent and fractions of the top 1 percent enjoyed their greatest share of income since 1928 and 1929."

Take Note of those DATES - they are the trigger years to the GREAT DEPRESSION.

[rowdytexan2]

Posted by michaelt302 at 07:29 PM : Jan 13, 2008

Michael still lives in the hologram the Neocons keep spinning.

[scalliwagrx8]

Haha!!!! It is kinda funny to see a repulican actually get a dose of bad medicine from the people he supported.

[realpatriot1]

michaelt302,

Actually, it''s pretty good being a liberal right now because the decrease in violence and the insistence by conservatives that everything is peachy only gives credence to the effort to have the Iraqis defend themselves.

Bush is now saying that he''ll leave it up to Petraeus to decide when to pull our troops out and in the same breath says we may have to postpone the previously promised reductions. That doesn''t sound like success to me.