June 18, 2009 6:27 PM

Campaign Diary: Celebrity Showdown In N.H.

By
CBSNews
(CBS)  This campaign diary is written by Andrew Kirtzman, a veteran correspondent for WCBS-TV in New York City. Kirtzman is the author of "Rudy Giuliani: Emperor Of The City," an account of the former mayor's stormy tenure as the Big Apple's chief executive. He will be writing regularly on the presidential campaign for CBSNews.com.


It's 1am in my hotel lobby, and it's growing crowded in here. An ear-splitting fire alarm has gone off in every room and hallway, jolting guests out of their beds. Now over a hundred of us are gathered in sweatpants and t-shirts in front of the reception desk as management searches for a key or a computer code to shut the thing off. The siren noise is making my head pound.

Nice hotels are hard to come by in this state, and I'm stuck in the town of Bow, at the lowly Hampton Inn. Unlike the Des Moines Marriott, there are no camera crews in the lobby, no European reporters riding up and down the elevators. Ron Paul isn't sitting in the restaurant here - there is none - and Tim Russert has been replaced by a drunk with a beer bottle.

At times, the whole clubby atmosphere of the campaign bubble seemed like half the reason to be on the trail - until Barack Obama won the Iowa caucuses. At that instant, everything changed. This feels less like covering a horserace than witnessing history.

Earlier in the evening, I'd been to the annual 100 Club Democratic fundraiser in Milford, an event so large that its 3,000 guests filled a dome covering an area the size of a football field.

It became a kind of celebrity showdown between Hillary Clinton and Obama, with supporters of one trying to out-shout supporters of the other. You'd think that Clinton, the candidate of the establishment, would have been able to rig a party event pretty easily - and, to be fair, a large sign-waving crowd gave her a noisy greeting. But when Obama appeared, the noise reached a roar, the aisles grew clogged with supporters and the event turned into a gigantic rally.

The candidate seemed exhausted, and went through his familiar lines with less conviction than usual. But, like a rock star playing a beloved song, Obama can buzz a crowd just by reciting some familiar lines. As he talked about "change" and "hope," a college-aged woman to my left literally jumped up and down, screaming like a Beatles fan at Shea Stadium. I thought she might faint.

Earlier, Clinton delivered a rendition of what you might call the "don't believe the hope" speech, the one about how it takes experience to achieve the kind of change Obama seeks. It's an eat-your-peas lecture about the importance of working hard, and it's a major downer. It's not hard to tell these days that Clinton resents being cast as Hubert Humphrey to Obama's Bobby Kennedy, but disparaging his optimism only reinforces the generational chasm. As we know by now, it hasn't worked.

This week she finally dropped the speech in favor of extended question and answer sessions with regular folk. At one event I attended, she was barraged with questions about health care, her forte, and Clinton answered them at length and in great detail. It didn't seem unusual that one audience member shouted out "what about dental?" Not surprisingly, she riffed at length about the importance of dental benefits. I tried and failed to imagine Obama getting a similar question at one of his recent events. He's been way passed dental for a long time now.

The parking lot for this event was a mile away, and organizers provided yellow school buses to shuttle guests from the hotel. I was the last one aboard one of them. I squeezed past row after row of white passengers until I found an empty seat next to a young black college student from Houston, Texas named Todd Hendricks. He had spent his Christmas money to pay for his trip to New Hampshire and have the opportunity to knock on doors for Obama. On his lap was an "Obama" sign from the event, which he was keeping as a souvenir.

I asked him what he thought about Clinton's speech. "Standard Hillary," he said. "It seemed like the complete opposite of Obama - just flat, insincere and contrived, every sentence screened by a focus group."

Obama, he said, "was so pure, so real." His face lit up when he talked about him.

The image of that student remains in my head as I sit in this lobby with the ringing alarm. Is this all for real? Is Obama The One, chosen by history to reach Martin Luther King's promised land? The kid on the bus clearly believed so, and had come here to be a part of his journey.

The implications of the senator's rise in the Democratic race are so potentially momentous you almost don't want to let yourself go there. And yet as I lay down to sleep this evening, I can think of little else. The fire alarm finally ceases. But events tonight are conspiring to keep me awake.

Copyright 2009 CBS. All rights reserved.
Add a Comment
by prinzowhales January 8, 2008 1:53 PM EST
It simply horrifies me that there are people walking around this land like the young woman described by Mr. Kirtzman...This is the kind of response that you can see in the faces of the German-on-the-street who was woo''ed by the rhetoric of Hitler...Both Hucksterbee and Obama seem to have the ability to get people to disengage their brains and let them manipulate their hopes, their fears, their desires.

American info-tainment and ''education'' has created this kind of ''junior high pep rally'' politics... where people cheer for their hopes and dreams in support of candidates who support the very things that they ''hope will change.''...it is a magnificent and horrific accomplishment by masters of mass psychology.
Reply to this comment
by rickidaylove January 8, 2008 1:20 PM EST
my comment is Obama, the winner,
we the Democrats in L.A. will
not vote.
We have been Clinton people forever
We were John Kennedy people also.
Take that to New Hampshire.
Reply to this comment
by rickidaylove January 8, 2008 1:18 PM EST
Read my writing, if Obama, continues this lead,
as a blockbuster Democrat, I will not vote for him
and the talk on the Los Angeles Streets/ Bev. Hills
included, do not want this person as President,
and if McCain does win out, oh well, alot of people
will jump their party.
Hillary Clinton, does not have to bring tears,
and where is Barbara Streisand, to help her,
like Oprah got on Obama''s neck?
I am appalled, that New Hampshire is the ruler.
Well here in California, Los Angeles, proper, we
will show New Hampshire, what we think!
Reply to this comment
by Razzl January 8, 2008 12:45 PM EST
Every prophetic or electrifying figure has a handful of those key moments, when a question gets asked and the room goes quiet, and the prophet either aces the answer or stumbles--like Jesus building a movement on little answers about "giving unto Caesar what is Caesar''s" or about rich men passing through the eye of a needle. Make enough good answers, and you build a movement. Make enough disappointing answers, and you sink back into the pack. Obama is finding his rhetorical stride and if he maintains consistency over the coming movements, if his message remains pure, then he''ll have to be considered the real deal. For now he''s still being contrasted with the ordinary joes he''s in competition with and being judged in relation to their bland, ordinary, process-driven mentalities. The public, however, is thirsting for inspiration, as the growth of the misbegotten evangelical movement demonstrates...
Reply to this comment
by reader42 January 7, 2008 11:34 PM EST
Sorry. I don''t think much of this ad. First off, it has an error "it''s" = it is. The ad should have read ". . . its President." That shows a lack of attention to our language and its construction. I mean, really, can''t this person spell??

Also, I''m not impressed by simply printing words over pictures without any reference to ideas or anything else. Shallow and manipulative. "Education, Security, Energy," etc. etc. So what is that supposed to mean?

Having said all that, I don''t think the suggested ticket would be bad. I just think the ad stinks.
Reply to this comment
by tibu987 January 7, 2008 9:06 PM EST
It just goes to show how distant the Republicans are from the electorate.
Let me give them a clue.

Any available medical insurance is too expensive for the average American.
The immigration problem, while important, should NOT take center stage above all the other problems the average American has.
What we want is "change", yes, change from the old pols resposible for the mess this country is in. A new, fresh outlook that takes into consideration all Americans and not just the wealthy.
We want an end to the war(s) in the Middle East, and our troops to come home.
We want a stronger economy and more jobs.
We want our infrastructure to be safe and well maintained.
We want to have the best schools and teachers for our children.
We want to be safe on our streets.
We want the wishy-washy politicians, purveyors of pork, out of office.
We want to be rid of the staus quo politicians who line their pockets and feed from the public trough.
We demand honesty from our government officials.
I believe those are some of the major issues and needs of the majority of the average voting public, and they get scant attention from the candidates.
Most of the presidential candidates are multi-millionaires that long ago lost touch with the average American and have no inkling about what our needs and sufferings are about.
And that is why Obama is in the lead, he is the only one who has shown some concern for the average American.
''Nuff said.

Reply to this comment
by obama1289 January 7, 2008 7:59 PM EST
Obama supporters and everyone:

Check out this very moving video that changed my mind about Obama

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jPev5sEdTjg
Reply to this comment
by jack3213 January 7, 2008 3:10 PM EST
If anyone thinks of this as "Celebrity Showdown" perhaps your priorities are upside down. This may appear to be all about "popularity" although it is about a forthcoming President, whom, by the way, we might not like for doing what is right for the country. It is about a country at war, mostly, for withour a country you would not have a home. Bush may be unpopular, but no one has given him the credit he deserves, a sign for which they take their lives for granted. Typical Americans.
Reply to this comment
.
Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook