GUANGDONG PROVINCE, China, Dec. 18, 2007

Keeping An Eye On Chinese Toymakers

CBS News Goes Inside A Toy Factory To See What New Checks Are In Place

  • Play CBS Video Video U.S.-Made Toys In High Demand

    With time running short until Christmas, parents who've sworn off toys from China are facing a dilemma: where to find toys they can trust to be safe for their kids. Joie Chen reports.

  • Video Inside A Chinese Toy Factory

    China's toy manufacturers are trying to convince U.S. buyers their products are safe, after a lead-paint scare threatened what has become a multi-billion dollar industry. Barry Petersen reports.

  • A Chinese worker makes Santa Claus toys at a toy factory in Guangzhou, in southern China. Photo

    A Chinese worker makes Santa Claus toys at a toy factory in Guangzhou, in southern China.  (Imaginechina via AP Images)

  • Interactive Toyland 2008

    Top toys, government recalls, plus tips to play it safe well beyond the holidays.

  • Photo Essay Hazardous Toys

    W.A.T.C.H. Out! Group names 10 worst toys of 2007.

(CBS)  The Big Brother cameras monitor factory floors and via the Internet American buyers can also watch in their offices back in the United States, CBS News correspondent Barry Petersen reports.

CBS News was shown all this because China desperately wants to convince America it is cleaning up its toymaking act.

“There is an old Chinese saying,” says one officer. “If you can see it, you’ll believe it.”

Seeing to believe it is why we were invited to this factory in southern China, with its own quality control manager.

Only good quality, says quality control manager Eric Chin of Guandong, will give customers confidence.

This eagerness for openness comes because China's multi-billion dollar toy industry is under threat.

So, no surprise we were assured that supplies like paint are now triple-checked.

But the reality is that other factories are not so careful. Since the toy recalls started in the United States, Chinese authorities have shut down some 800 manufacturers.

And authorities are lighting a fire under state testing labs.

U.S. companies share the blame, pushing so hard to cut costs that some Chinese makers use cheaper lead paint.

Officials say the lab Petersen visited is working flat out - people are on overtime, more staff are being hired, and no wonder. They say they’re doing five times as many tests as they did just a year ago. And China’s government has sent some 200,000 inspectors across the country, checking all kinds of plants and manufacturers, from pharmaceuticals to farming.

But the main focus is toys - where China admits it is hurting.

All toy manufacturers, said a government-run newspaper, will feel the chill this winter.

Experts say China is getting better.

“But it still has half a century to go to catch up to where the United States is,” said Daniel Rosen of the China Strategic Advisory.

China's ambition is selling America high-end products like TVs and cars.

But if they can't get simple wooden toys right, the world may turn its back on anything with a tainted label: "Made in China."

© MMVII, CBS Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Video and Galleries from CBS Evening News

Add a Comment See all 26 Comments
by mcv57 December 18, 2007 7:16 PM PST
Hey Drew Peterson, EX-COP who beat and kills wifes is being sued (other than a member of his family). Drew is a racist too, it turns out.

Why aren''''''''''''''''t you folks at CBS covering the developing story. This low-down dog has stashed away $250,000 and is advertising donations for legal fees. This is the dirt that people want to read about Chicago''''''''''''''''s finest police officer.

Is foreign toymakers more important than U.S. LAW ENFORCEMENT MURDERERS, is not news? CBS needs to get out of the news business.
Reply to this comment
by djberson December 18, 2007 7:20 PM PST
"This eagerness for openness comes because China''s multi-billion dollar toy industry is under threat."...

not enough of a threat if you ask me... not with business'' voracious appetite for funneling cheap (not inexpensive) products into the US.
Reply to this comment
by cpaide December 18, 2007 7:25 PM PST
"All toy manufacturers, said a government-run newspaper, will feel the chill this winter."

if the chinamens think that''s cold, just wait until us evangelical christian zealots send them to our icy cold hell. at best, they get the mormans heaven, if they are baptize for the dead--whatever that is.

that''s what they get for messing with the toys and such. so how can we celebrate jesus and make money for business with all these lead toys? something isn''t right here.
Reply to this comment
by usayesterday December 18, 2007 7:35 PM PST
(from a different article):

"Ever since we won the war in Iraq there hasnt been any article worth to comment."

Posted by BaghdadsHere at 06:58 PM : Dec 18, 2007
................

You see ladies and gentlemen... the above quote is the result of someone who has sucked and chewed on his lead based toys all throughout his childhood.

This is a clear and obvious example of lead poisoning over a period of time.

It''s a crying shame.
Reply to this comment
by hypnotoad72 December 18, 2007 7:48 PM PST
"If you can see it, you can believe it".

Did Harry Houdini or David Copperfield ever say the same thing before performing their acts? :)

BTW: Why is the article US-centric? China makes products for every country.
Reply to this comment
by condumbism December 18, 2007 8:00 PM PST
CBS has been sued so many times that to play it safe they now only report on some dead chick in Aruba that nobody cares about except Southern couch potatoes, or they slander Hillary or Obama each and everyday with fictitious stories with little or no substance, or they publish crappolla about a group of Chinese toy manufactures that may have in total harmed one dumb, obese inbred Southern child because the child sucked down .0000001 mL of lead.
Reply to this comment
by mattcbsmatt December 18, 2007 8:26 PM PST
CBS News Goes Inside The Chinese Hineses and proves appeasement and understanding and explaining.
Asian advertising, the Asians *** eye advertises
CBS News gets and accepts the Asians *** eye advertising money

Reply to this comment
by erasmus6 December 18, 2007 8:43 PM PST
On the news last night, our Premiere here in Canada has said there will be some major changes to stop the toxic food and stuff from coming here and also making changes to the inspection process.
Reply to this comment
by hissteps4u December 18, 2007 8:53 PM PST
I wonder how long it will take for China and India to get on the ball and seek higher wages for their actions? just how long will it take for companies to not be able to save any money by going overseas?

Time will tell and when it does the worlds work force will wield a collective Hammer on us all.

Sooner than later I imagine.

Reply to this comment
by cbs_oliver December 18, 2007 9:10 PM PST
"%u201CBut it still has half a century to go to catch up to where the United States is,%u201D said Daniel Rosen of the China Strategic Advisory."

The problem really is that where the United States "is" is a long gone fantasy.

Manufacturing in the United States is done in China where it is cheaper. Especially with cheaper labor.

Our companies would use slaves again if they could get away with it.

They''ll settle for slave wages.
Reply to this comment
by usayesterday December 18, 2007 9:47 PM PST
Posted by hissteps4u at 08:53 PM : Dec 18, 2007
..........

What is somewhat ironic, but quite sad really...

...is that people in China want "power" but cannot have it.

In America, the people have "power", but the majority do not use it.

I often laugh when the government of China calls themselves "The Peoples Republic of China". "Peoples Republic"... as if the Chinese government has ever given a rats A$$ about their own people!
Reply to this comment
by erasmus6 December 18, 2007 10:45 PM PST
"What is somewhat ironic, but quite sad really...

...is that people in China want "power" but cannot have it." posted by USAyesterday


Hmmm, I wouldn''t say that exactly, the U.S. owes trillions of dollars to China and they supply just about EVERYTHING to your country. I would say they have quite a bit of power over the U.S.
Reply to this comment
by americandave December 18, 2007 11:26 PM PST
Stick to American Made its better for our dollar, our jobs, our kids. What is happening in China is due to some very greedy people including some Americans who were asleep at the wheel! Try http://www.americansworking.com for a directory of American Made Products!
Thanks
Reply to this comment
by blazercoach1 December 18, 2007 11:42 PM PST
Want a strong homeland defense? BUY LOCAL.

Support your local economy. Buy organic.
Reply to this comment
by rfcnj68 December 19, 2007 12:14 AM PST
It is time to show corporate America that we will no longer suffer through them cutting jobs in the USA and sending them overseas where safety and fair labor rates do not exist. we want to make things here and sell them to other countries to bring back the proud working class that once existed. Let them send the bad stuff to third world countries who do not seem to care about their people.

We need to stop being anal and realize that cheaper usually means cheaper material and we are letting our kids play with these things. So if you hate your kids buy made in China if you care and love your kids buy made in the USA.
Reply to this comment
by erasmus6 December 19, 2007 1:18 AM PST
If you want to buy things that are made in the U.S.A., come to Canada, not EVERYTHING here is made in China.
Reply to this comment
by violet74 December 19, 2007 2:12 AM PST
ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA! ARUBA SUCKS! BOYCOTT ARUBA!
Reply to this comment
by usayesterday December 19, 2007 4:59 AM PST
I would say they have quite a bit of power over the U.S.

Posted by erasmus6 at 10:45 PM : Dec 18, 2007
..........

When I said "power" I was referring to the power that the Chinese people want to have over their government and the direction of their government. Similar to the "power" Americans have over their governmental system, but as I said before, very few of us Americans exercise that power... by voting... by helping others to vote or register to vote... etc.
Reply to this comment
by jetranger7 December 19, 2007 6:00 AM PST
Better not only eye CHINA, but also the US TOY makers who moved to CHINA, for cheap labor and to avoid paying some Taxes, while closing down some factories and laying off workers here to be able to make their JUNK in China !! Somebody should research and investigate just how many US Toy makers have moved to CHINA in the last 15 to 20 Years, and set up shop over there too !!! Far as I''m concerned they can take their so called Global Economy and stick it right up their Frickin Azz, along with that Frickin NAFTA & GATT & WTO ! You listinin you dumb azz politicians, wake up, pull your head out from between your cheeks, you dumb S.O.Bs !!!
Reply to this comment
by nativewoman December 19, 2007 6:25 AM PST
~But if they can''t get simple wooden toys right, the world may turn its back on anything with a tainted label: "Made in China."~

Yeah, ask Japan about that. Back in the day "Made in Japan" was synonymous with shoddy workmanship and considered an insult.

In March 2007, Consumer reports came out with its auto reliability and survey rankings. For the second time in 10 years, Japanese automakers took the top 10 spots.

We need to look in the mirror before we condemn others.

For example, the temporary ban from 2003 against allowing "downer" cattle into the human food supply was not made permanent by the FDA until July of this year. However, the FDA was aware at least as early as 2003 that European surveillance indicated that cattle with clinical signs of a CNS disorder, dead cattle, and cattle that can not rise from a recumbent position have a greater incidence of BSE (Mad Cow disease) than healthy cattle. DUH! Ya think?

Many European nations test up to half the cows slaughtered for human consumption, and Japan tests every head of cattle intended for the human food chain. Yet the FDA, Bush and large meat packers are opposed to increased testing due to the cost burden.

The United States allows pesticides banned for domestic use to be sold to other countries.

I guess the joke''s on us about that one though since we import food from the countries using these banned pesticides that we sold them.
Reply to this comment
by runningralph December 19, 2007 8:23 AM PST
hissteps4u,
You have put your finger right on the bottom line of the trade relationship betwen China and India and the Western countries. You wonder when Chinese and Indians will organize for better pay. The Chinese show the real result of Communist revolution. Underpaid workers. Under Communism everyone works for the government, so that if workers agitate they are rebelling against the government. The repercussions are much more serious than rebelling against a private company. Unions know this so they won''t try to organize in China. As far as India, there seems to be some sort of cult that believes poverty is true enlightment. That may be true. Jesus said that it''s easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to get into heaven.
Reply to this comment
by pollroller1 December 19, 2007 8:59 AM PST
I don''t care what China does, I will not buy their toys for my grand kids and I don''t think I am the only one that feels this way.
Reply to this comment
by allunknowing December 19, 2007 9:22 AM PST
I''m pretty sure that 99% of the toys I played with as a kid were made in China. And I''m not too screwed up. Does this mean the next generation of ChinaToy-free/peanut-free/sugar-free/soda-free/cupcake-free/obesity-free/drug-free/gasoline-free/se.xually-abstained/ritalin-induced children are going to be Super Kids?

We have become such a Nanny-based society. If you all believe everything the news spoonfeeds you, you might as well go join PETA and start burning down libraries.
Reply to this comment
by nexgen99 December 19, 2007 10:50 AM PST
1. Kids have too many toys
2. If it says made in China, don''t buy it.
3. Be an entrepreneur and start a new American toy company.
Reply to this comment
by lochlan-2009 December 19, 2007 10:53 AM PST
I don''t buy from China. These stories don''t effect me anymore.
Reply to this comment
by pinpo12 December 19, 2007 12:33 PM PST
If we stop doing business with the chinese all together our economy would suffer even more than it has been, I think going to police our supplies is a smart move, but still I will be careful of what I buy that says "Made in China"
Reply to this comment
See all 26 Comments
  • MOST POPULAR
  • Viewed
  • Commented
Latest News
Featured Blogs