GOP Hopefuls Restrained In Iowa Debate
Fewer Fireworks Than Usual In What Could Be The Last GOP Debate Before Iowa Caucuses
-
Play CBS Video
Video
GOP Debate Keeps It Clean
GOP candidates used the Des Moines Register debate to address the key issues of their presidential campaigns and not to muddy the names of their competition. Jeff Greenfield reports.
-
Video
Poll: Huckabee, Giuliani Tied
Republican presidential contender Mike Huckabee may become the candidate to beat if he can afford to stay in the race. Bob Schieffer discusses a new CBS News/New York Times Poll with Harry Smith.
-
-
Photo
Republican presidential hopefuls, former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani and Rep. Duncan Hunter, R-Calif., right, participate in the Des Moines Register Republican Presidential Debate in Johnston, Iowa, Wednesday, Dec. 12, 2007. (AP)
-
Photo
Republican presidential hopefuls, former Sen. Fred Thompson, R-Tenn. left, and former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney, share a laugh before the Des Moines Register Republican Presidential Debate in Johnston, Iowa, Wednesday, Dec.12, 2007. (AP)
-
Photo
Republican presidential candidates, from left to right, Mike Huckabee, John McCain, Rudy Giuliani, Alan Keyes. Duncan Hunter, Tom Tancredo, Ron Paul, and Mitt Romney are seen on stage before the Des Moines Register Republican Presidential Debate Wednesday, Dec. 12, 2007, in Johnston, Iowa. (AP)
-
Photo
Republican presidential hopeful, Rep. Ron Paul, R-Texas, arrives for the Des Moines Register Republican Presidential Debate Wednesday, Dec. 12, 2007, in Johnston, Iowa. (AP)
-
Photo
Republican presidential hopeful, former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney, right, greets supporters as he arrives for the Des Moines Register Republican Presidential Debate Wednesday, Dec. 12, 2007, in Johnston, Iowa. (AP)
-
-
News Tools
Campaign Calendar
The latest list of primary and caucus dates as states continue jockeying for position.
-
Interactive
The Money Race
See the latest campaign finance tallies from Obama and McCain.
"The sacrifice we need from the American people is saying, 'Let the programs go that don't work. Don't lobby for them forever," said former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney, one of nine GOP presidential hopefuls sharing an Iowa stage little more than three weeks before the state's caucuses provide the first test of the campaign. (Check out CBSNews.com senior political editor Vaughn Ververs' live blogging and analysis of the debate.)
Former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani called for across-the-board cuts of up to 15 percent, including reduced federal spending on health care. "Rather than relying on a nanny government, let's rely on people to decide their own health care," he said.
The debate was the Republicans' last before the Iowa caucuses on Jan 3, and it punctuated a remarkable period of turmoil in their race for the presidential nomination.
Former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee has eroded Giuliani's lead in nationwide polls, and he has overtaken Romney in public surveys of likely caucus goers in Iowa. The result has been an increase in testiness - Romney on Tuesday became the first candidate to assail another in a TV ad, hitting Huckabee for his position on immigration.
But all nine men on the debate stage were on their best behavior for an Iowa electorate notoriously scornful of political attacks, and the subject of education produced the only semblance of sparks.
"On subjects ranging from the national debt to education and free trade, there was more agreement than disagreement in this final debate before the January 3rd Iowa caucuses," said CBSNews.com's Ververs.
"Unfortunately for any voters tuning in looking to find distinctions between the candidates, it didn’t do much to help their search," he added.
Moments after Huckabee said schools should provide all students with music and art instruction at all grade levels, Colorado Rep. Tom Tancredo took him to task. "That's not the job of a president. It's the job of a governor," he said. "That's what you should run for if you want to dictate curriculum."
Huckabee responded by saying that in his decade as governor he had the "most impressive education record."
Huckabee's tone, including a plea to end long-standing polarization between liberals and conservatives, evoked one of the Democratic candidates more than it did any of the fellow Republicans on stage, CBS News senior political correspondent Jeff Greenfield said.
"As far as Mike Huckabee was concerned, he used his time to inoculate himself against attack by sounding a little bit like Barack Obama," said Greenfield, who characterized the debate as an "extremely civil exchange."
That brought a polite disagreement from Romney - also a fellow governor. "I just wanted a small adjustment to what Governor Huckabee had to say. And I don't believe you had the finest record of any governor in American on education," he said, eliciting laughter from the debate audience.
Former Sen. Fred Thompson of Tennessee was an exception to the general agreement on spending and sacrifice. "We've got to spend more for the military as a matter of fact, but we've got to look at Social Security and Medicare and do some things that won't hurt anybody badly," he said. Thompson, alone among the White House contenders in both parties, has called for steps to reduce the benefits promised to future retirees. He has also said he supports changes in Medicare, but has yet to outline a specific proposal.
Carolyn Washburn, editor of The Des Moines Register and the debate moderator, brought about a mini-revolt at one point when she asked all the candidates to raise their hands if they thought global warming was a serious threat caused by human behavior. "I'm not doing hand shows today," said Thompson.
Ultimately, no one disputed global warming was a problem and humans at least contribute to it.
"I know it's real," said Sen. John McCain of Arizona, who advocates legislation to tackle the problem.
"Climate change is real. It's happening. Human beings are contributing to it," agreed Giuliani.
The final pre-caucus Democratic debate is set for Thursday.
©MMVII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.





- 1
- 2
- next
See all 82 CommentsNo Fans needed ! I want to,..And I want as,.I want leaders,..I want solutions,..I want bold,.I want optimistic,..I want,..Wow! I was Impressed !" Yes or No ?" ~Give a minute to say,~....Typical Pols!!
Only one problem nut jobs your base is all you are going to attract this time around.
Folks are now saying Huck is ...........Huck-a-bomb!
Mitt crushed his opponents today with clear specific answers.
Remember the Tea Party this coming Sunday, we will blow these other warmongers for a loop.
I do agree with you Mitt did a good job, as did Ron Paul.
Posted by bobmarisol
Bob, you claim to be a "lifelong Democrat" but toe-tap and squeal like a Republican pig. What''s up?
CFR SCUM CFR SCUM They are LIES LIES LIES LIES LIES
They are owned by the council of foreign relation LOOK IT UP www.myspace.com/kurtcobain22067 OR youtube New world order CNN "ALL the candidates except for Kucinich, Gravell, and Ron Paul are CFR.......... object width="425" height="355" param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/JIRK1y52FTQ&rel=1&border=0" /param param name="wmode" value="transparent" /param embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/JIRK1y52FTQ&rel=1&border=0" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" wmode="transparent" width="425" height="355" /embed /object
CFR several large businesses holding additional corporate memberships. Corporate members include:
Halliburton of Dubai, British Petroleum, Dutch Royal Shell, Exxon Mobile, General Electric (NBC), Chevron, Lockheed Martin, Merck Pharmaceuticals, News Corp (FOX), Bloomberg, IBM, Time Warner, JP Morgan/ Chase Manhattan, CBS, CNN, CFR SCUM Yeah If this poll was correct Ron Paul 96% You all work For a DEVIL secret *** www.CFR.org GO DO YOUR RESEARCH PEOPLE oh yeah CBS YOU SUCK
Not to worry, Bob, those folks have been cutting off each other''s nuts since the Prophet died and went to hell, so if "victory" means peace, the Repugs have only 2 chances, slim and none.
If "victory" means permanent US bases in Iraq and permanent occupation of the oil fields, we got that already. But you don''t see many of the Repug "leaders" with family in Iraq. Romnuts has 5 sons and not one is serving. Bushit''s two daughters are off writing books and making their father look stupid. War is a lot of trouble, and nobody in power wants to actually be in one.
I guess we''re in for a couple thousand biblical references from this pandering hack over the next year.
I don''t think the Wizard of OZ can keep the curtain closed on Iraq for another 11 monthes.
There''s no benefit to anyone if the violence spikes but it''s highly likely that it will. Why? For one thing, the British & Australians are pulling out in the next couple monthes. If the insurgency decides to launch a new offensive wherever we aren''t, we''ll either have to sprad our existing troops thinner or have an additional surge. This month has already started off more deadly than recent months.
But let''s be optimistic and assume that the lower levels of violence will hold. That only raises expectations for Iraqization and the withdrawal of Amrican forces. The neocons want to say we''ve won and everything is peachy but we can''t leave; not a cedible case to take to a sceptical electorate.
If violence picks back up the Republicans will have to explain why they wasted a period of relative calm with no significant diplomatic effort to pressure the Iraqi government to reform or to bring in international reconstructive aid.
I''m one liberal democrat who can''t wait for that debate!
That''s a hoot. Repugs couldn''t bring about a successful outcome if their lives depended on it. Big car bombing today--surge may not be the instant cure. Of course Bushit will proclaim victory, but everyone except a few morons and shills now know he''s lying every time his mouth is moving.
Dems can also point to the wonderful state of the economy--housing in the toilet, stock market tanking, etc. Plus how the richest 10% are getting all the gravy.
So the Dems should do pretty well this time around.
I guess we''''re in for a couple thousand biblical references from this pandering hack over the next year"--Posted by marcodele
Yes, we can expect a lot of tripe from the Arkansas snake oil salesman.
- gkc99
Stock market "tanking"? I wouldn''t go that far bud; and the richest 10% getting "all the gravy"; typical socialist income redistribution line...work harder or get smarter and then you can be one of that 10%; until then quit whining; its not the rich people''s fault you aren''t smart enough to get to the top...
The bombing today? That was Shiite Mahdi Army vs Shiite Badr; wasn''t the sectarian civil war you defeatists have invested so heavily in, nor Al Qaeda...we also have NO coalition forces in that province, so commenting on that as part of a discussion of the "surge" is ridiculous; that area is not part of that strategy as it was already handed over fully to Iraqi national forces.
Posted by gkc99 at 04:32 PM : Dec 12, 2007
You are wrong on this point. The top 1% of income earners are paying 35% of the tax bill. The top 10% of income earners are paying 68% of the total tax bill. The bottom 50% of income earners are paying only 3.2% of the total tax bill.
Sorrry Guys
So where was the tax reform and less government spending in the past seven years when they had total control?
They might as well get back into the Jesus Wars. Their playbook is old, and their records don''t match their rhetoric.
The socialists / marxist / communists attatudes you guys have does not set well with real America
But there is hope for America. Dr. Ron Paul will if elected President of these United States of America roll back the institutional Marxism endemic to the Federal Government
But there is hope for America. Dr. Ron Paul will if elected President of these United States of America roll back the institutional Marxism endemic to the Federal Government.
But there is hope for America. Dr. Ron Paul will if elected President of these United States of America roll back the institutional Marxism endemic to the Federal Government.
But there is hope for America. Dr. Ron Paul will roll back the institutional Marxism endemic to the Federal Government.
But there is hope for America. The only physician running for President will roll back the institutional Marxism endemic to the Federal Government.
I am truly enraged at the overwhelming bias in the media! It does not shock me but it does in fact appall me.
I have heard no mention of Ron Paul in ANY media announcement or coverage in any presidential debate.
This only proves the bias and power of ''control'' the media has on our country.
An unfair presidential run? We have seen this in the past, we have had to struggle with it, or in the case of my fellow brothers in Iraq, DIE with it!
This is the type of thing that pushes me even further to support Dr. Paul. To be honest it is also the type of action that has made me ashamed to be a citizen of the United States of America!
The only action I can think of to fight this blasphemy of lies and deceit is to spread the word even further! Spread the word of understanding and truth!
SPREAD THE WORD OF RON PAUL FOR PRESIDENT ''08''!
But there is hope for America. Dr. Ron Paul will if elected President of these United States of America roll back the institutional Marxism endemic to the Federal Government.
I am truly enraged at the overwhelming bias in the media! It does not shock me but it does in fact appall me.
I have heard no mention of Ron Paul in ANY media announcement or coverage in any presidential debate.
This only proves the bias and power of ''control'' the media has on our country.
An unfair presidential run? We have seen this in the past, we have had to struggle with it, or in the case of my fellow brothers in Iraq, DIE with it!
This is the type of thing that pushes me even further to support Dr. Paul. To be honest it is also the type of action that has made me ashamed to be a citizen of the United States of America!
The only action I can think of to fight this blasphemy of lies and deceit is to spread the word even further! Spread the word of understanding and truth!
SPREAD THE WORD OF RON PAUL FOR PRESIDENT ''08''!
But there is hope for America. Dr. Ron Paul will if elected President of these United States of America roll back the institutional Marxism endemic to the Federal Government.
is the frontrunner but his poll numbers are down. Explain that one to me!! For anyone out there who supports Huckabee, are you aware that Huckabee supports
ILLEGAL IMMIGRANT AMNESTY despite the majority of americans are AGAINST IT??? HUCKABEE=OPEN BORDERS
We cannot afford $70 Billion for that! We need to get out of Iraq now. It''s killing us financially.
You and I are supposed to kiss domestic programs good-bye while they continue to plow our treasury into a trumped-up war in the Middle East.
Under any of these candidates how many more cities will drown? How many more bridges will collapse? What will be left of our already-crippled right to privacy?
These people make me sick.
Posted by neoconism at 07:13 PM : Dec 12, 2007
bobmarisol is not a democrat. He is lars008 under a different name and is as much a democrat as Dic*k Cheney.
1. He will Eliminate the IRS:
This means you will receive 100% of your paycheck.
2. He will drastically reduce Gas prices:
Switch to alternative fuels, changing supply/demand.
3. He will reduce global warming.
Switch to alternative fuels, no carbon dioxides.
4. He will reduce threat of terrorism.
New fuels cause middle east gov. crack down on them.
5. He will reduce rising Health care costs.
New programs that prevent diseases, not just fix them.
6. He will lead up not just hard right or hard left.
Excellent communicator, will bring parties together.
7. He will lead with principles rather than money.
He cares everybody not just those on Wall Street.
8. He will give Hope to America and enthusiasm.
He plays bass guitar in a band, dynamic personality.
9. He will carry out his goals, not talk about them.
Lost 110 pounds, kept it off, ran 4 Marathons-26.2m
10. He knows the American people is the real boss.
As Governor, his picture frame only shows citizens.
Vote for Mike Huckabee, otherwise you will not be able to enjoy these benefits
Since the other candidates don''''t have anything to say on what they can do for America, they take the easy road and resort to taking cheap shots at Mike. Don%u2019t fall into their trap any longer with negative attacks, let''''s show the critics and the naysayers that Americans have pride and we are ready to elect an honest, humble, trustworthy man for US President.
Then, whether Bin Laden was for real or a front for something else, his threat to destroy the US will have been a flawlessly "accomplished mission" by his family''s friend George Bush.
Ironically I see NO END in sight with this CONTRIVED war for wealth transfer to a selected few - if ANY of the candidates - Democratic OR Republican get in with the slightly possible exception of Ron Paul.
With the MSM blacklisting him and the dirty tricks squad focused on him; I doubt he''s got a chance.
The newest "dirty trick tactic" is to claim to be "for" Paul and be the most annoying obnoxious a**hole as possible in order to obscure the message and anger people.
Apparently, if it works we''ll soon be seeing a whole new type of campaign dirty trick happen to all the candidates!
Let''s call them "Anti-supporters".
My guess is that they''ll be coming to "support" YOUR favorite candidate soon no matter who he or she may be.
I''ve seen hints of this already cropping up with other candidates and I''m not sure once it starts how ridiculous, frustrating and vote destroying it could become.
One thing is for sure - it''s already turning into a "dirty" and misleading election and the primaries haven''t even happened yet!
Since WHEN was LYING and pretending to be some crazy fanatical supporter meant to anything other than a totally UNETHICAL and CHILDISH form of bullying meant to underhandedly support the opposition.
FOR SHAME!!
The voters finally caught on to "swift-boaters" so now is this the NEW Rove style backup dirty trick??
Excellent communicator, will bring parties together.%u201D
* Unfortunately his leadership is less than desirable. Suggesting we %u201Cisolate%u201D AIDS patients and then encouraging the release of convicted rapist Wayne DuMond.
%u201C7. He will lead with principles rather than money.
He cares everybody not just those on Wall Street.%u201D
* If his track record tells us anything, he%u2019ll more likely lead with spending your money.
%u201C9. He will carry out his goals, not talk about them.
Lost 110 pounds, kept it off, ran 4 Marathons-26.2m%u201D
* It%u2019s great he can carry out goals that benefit him. Too bad he can%u2019t stay on track with fiscal goals to benefit the people he represents. Huckabee received an "F/D" for fiscal policy of governors from the CATO institute, while most Democratic governors received higher grades.
%u201C10. He knows the American people is the real boss.
As Governor, his picture frame only shows citizens.%u201D
* An act. He%u2019s also selling himself as the Christian%u2019s candidate which is downright condescending. Are Christians to ignore his track record of increased spending just because they share the same religious beliefs?
%u201C1. He will Eliminate the IRS:%u201D
* Huckabee stole this theme from Ron Paul. The only difference is Huckabee plans to replace the IRS with a %u201CSales Tax Bureau%u201D whereas Ron Paul would actually reduce the federal government.
%u201C2. He will drastically reduce Gas prices:
Switch to alternative fuels, changing supply/demand.%u201D
* Sounds like more wasteful federal subsidies. I don%u2019t see how this will save people money. The gas I purchase now has 10% ethanol and the only significant reduction is a decrease in gas mileage.
%u201C4. He will reduce threat of terrorism.
New fuels cause middle east gov. crack down on them.%u201D
* Huckabee%u2019s Energy Independence policy is 50% rhetoric and 50% letting lobbyists pull his strings. Ethanol will cost us more and bring us neither security nor oil independence. However, he will make the NCGA happy.
%u201C5. He will reduce rising Health care costs.
New programs that prevent diseases, not just fix them.%u201D
* AKA more inefficient government programs
Re: "GOP Hopefuls Restrained In Iowa Debate"
This is encouraging. They should be kept restrained on all occasions, until they can appear before a judge, especially when they are in the presence of young boys.
They want to give tax breaks to the rich and tax food and consumer goods that the poor can already I''ll afford.
I swear that Obama is looking better with every passing day.
- 1
- 2
- next
See all 82 Comments