Dec. 12, 2007

Who Endorses The Endorsers?

Contributor Lloyd Garver Says Celebrities On The Stump Can Work For And Against Candidates

  • Interactive Campaign 2008

    Profiles of the candidates, polls, fund-raising, blogs, video and more.

  • In The Spotlight Campaign Watch '08

    Check out the latest campaign ads in the race for the White House.


(CBS)  Unless you've been living in a cave, you know that Oprah Winfrey campaigned for Barack Obama last week. Because of her, tens of thousands of people heard the candidate speak. This whole celebrity endorsement thing got me thinking. I don't believe many people are going to vote for somebody just because someone who is on television or in the movies says they should. But as with Oprah, voters may come to see the celebrity, but they also end up hearing the candidate. Obviously, this can backfire if they don't like what they hear. Also many people resent celebrity endorsers and have the attitude, "Just because they're famous doesn't mean they know anything about politics." So, there is considerable debate about whether celebrities actually help. However, I think I have a sure-fire way for celebrity endorsements to help get a candidate elected.

Because of the season, the competition for celebrities reminds me of the competition among neighbors for the most ostentatious Christmas and other holiday decorations. When it was announced that Oprah was supporting Obama, Hillary Clinton's people quickly announced that Barbra Streisand was supporting her. It's just like that neighbor of yours who puts up a hundred lights and a ten-foot Santa Claus in front of his house, and then another neighbor quickly decorates his house with 200 lights and an even bigger Santa. Now that wrestler Ric Flair (aka "The Nature Boy") is supporting Mike Huckabee, does that mean there will be a scramble to get the endorsement of "Undertaker" or "Rey Mysterio?"

Nobody knows which celebrities will be helpful to them. So we have Rudy Giuliani endorsed by Robert Duvall, Sean Penn rooting for Dennis Kucinich, and Red Sox pitcher Curt Schilling campaigning for John McCain. Martin Sheen, who played the president on television, endorses Bill Richardson, and acclaimed actor Harry Belafonte, who also gained fame singing "The Banana Boat Song," is for John Edwards. Sometime actor Fred Thompson is being endorsed by sometime actor Fred Thompson.

In a way, candidates even try to get certain dead people to endorse them. All of the Republican candidates have evoked Ronald Reagan's name, and of course, many of those running quote Abraham Lincoln or the Founding Fathers. I wouldn't be surprised if digital technology were used to put a candidate in a television commercial with somebody from the past. It would be like those macabre commercials that put famous dead actors in a modern home using some new appliance. I'm sure there's a way that we could end up seeing and hearing, "This is Alexander Hamilton for Ron Paul."

Your Turn

E-mail your questions and comments to Lloyd Garver

But again, nobody seems to know how much an endorsement really helps a candidate. So I have a way to take all of the doubt out of the celebrity endorsement sweepstakes. Instead of candidates and political parties seeking endorsements of famous people, I think they should secretly get inappropriately famous people to represent their opponents. It would work like this: Let's say Mike Huckabee ends up being the Republican nominee. The next day, Madonna comes out for him. The day after that, people like Democrat activist/actor Tim Robbins endorses Huckabee. If they really want to play hardball, the Democrats can always try to get atheist Dr. Michael Newdow to say he's for former minister Huckabee. Suddenly, the nominee's base will start asking themselves if Huckabee really represents their point of view.

Similarly, think what an endorsement from jailed polygamist Warren Jeffs would do to Mitt Romney's campaign. I believe we could say "bye-bye to Biden" if Rush Limbaugh came out for him. And could Rudy Giuliani get elected if disgraced athlete Michael Vick endorsed him?

If Barack Obama is the Democratic nominee, the Republicans could get John C. Sigler, the president of the NRA, to say wonderful things about Obama while Trent Lott applauds the gun guy's speech. It would be interesting to watch anti-feminist Phyllis Schlafly campaign for Hillary Clinton. And if the Republicans really want to destroy John Edwards' campaign, the person they should get to endorse him is George W. Bush.

Maybe I shouldn't be suggesting all this, because some political operatives might be tempted to take my suggestion seriously. Actually, considering how dirty politics always becomes, I'm surprised that they haven't already used this technique. Wait a minute! How do we know that they haven't? I mean, will we ever know the true political philosophy of Ric "The Nature Boy" Flair?



Lloyd Garver has written for many television shows, ranging from "Sesame Street" to "Family Ties" to "Frasier." He has also read many books, some of them endorsed by celebrities.

By Lloyd Garver
© MMVII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.

PARTNERS

Weekly Standard The Nation The New Republic
The Christian Science MonitorNational Review Online

Share:
  • Share
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Mixx
Add a Comment
by cpaide December 14, 2007 1:59 PM EST
a guy named nielsen told me that only 5 million prozac-poppers watch oprah. so look who''s "endorsing" lady o. she'' right up there with judge judy.

oh, and i guess those girls from oprah''s south african school watch in their room/cells while they are locked up in houston being "taken care of" until the lawsuit dies down.

she made the silk purse out of a sow''s ear once: right, "doctor" phil? maybe she can do it again.
Reply to this comment
by neoconslayer December 14, 2007 12:42 PM EST
If Oprah, or Brangelina, or a pro athlete trips and falls and skins a knee, it makes the front page. Everything they say and do is news (Albeit for vacuous people).
Suddenly, when the topic is politics, suddenly they need to shut up. Suddenly, they need to behave as though they weren''t photographed and their words fauned over by thousands of people.
Reply to this comment
by denn034 December 13, 2007 7:54 PM EST
We endorse them or not by our vote. Period!
Reply to this comment
by cbs_oliver December 13, 2007 3:52 PM EST
Ronney Reagan - actor - was a big Republican endorser before he decided to endorse himself.

Didn''t he and Gabby Hays and a few others do the celebrity Republican speaking tour together?
Reply to this comment
by quatrops December 13, 2007 1:27 PM EST
Why, one might ask, has the subject of potential candidacies been the major news story for over a year, and we have almost a year to go before the election? In all likelyhood, all of this attention will have NOTHING to do with who is nominated or who will become president.

This issue is the creation of the mainstream media and its desire to sell advertising for soap, cars, clothes, and yes, even candidates. The MSM has led us to imagine this is an IMPORTANT story simply to increase its readership/viewership.

The "candidate coverage" story is the best example of a created "non-event" one can imagine. We all should spend our time doing something nourishing and constructive rather than participating in their money-motivated creation.
Reply to this comment
by johnshaft4 December 13, 2007 12:58 AM EST
The Illuminata...
Reply to this comment
by ianlou December 12, 2007 6:58 PM EST
There is a difference between an actor and a talk show host.
A actor spends his/her life reading from a script.
A talk show host maintains conversations from a general list of topics. Their opinions, attitudes, beliefs and intelligence level normally show through.

There are millions of voters out there who believe they know Oprah at a level well beyond any candidate running on either side, and they are going to listen to her.

Reply to this comment
by ianlou December 12, 2007 6:49 PM EST
Who Endorses The Endorsers?
The American public based on their past behavior!
Who else?
Reply to this comment
by eggy1620 December 12, 2007 2:25 PM EST
%u201CI don''t believe many people are going to vote for somebody just because someone who is on television or in the movies says they should.%u201D

It happens. Just like people vote for a candidate just because their pastor, union president, or the AARP says so.
Reply to this comment
  • MOST POPULAR
Discussed
  1. Tempers Flare In Climate Change Flap

    (676 recent comments)

Latest News
News in Pictures
Scroll Left Scroll Right
  • Kennedy Center Honors Kennedy Center Honors

    Stars and Politicians Step Out to Honor Bruce Springsteen, Robert DeNiro, Mel Brooks and More

  • Return to Toyland Return to Toyland

    Behind The Scenes: Singer Emily Osment, The "Big" Piano and More From Inside FAO Schwarz

  • 2009 L.A. Car Show 2009 L.A. Car Show

    Concepts, Hybrids and Alt-Fuel Vehicles

  • Verdict In Italy Verdict In Italy

    American Amanda Knox and Italian ex-boyfriend Found Guilty in Murder of British Student

  • Celebrity Circuit Celebrity Circuit

    "Everybody's Fine" in New York; Plus, Matt Damon, Madonna and the Jonas Brothers

  • Day in Pictures Day in Pictures

    A Glimpse at the Day's News as Seen Through a Camera Lens

Connect with CBS News

Stay connected with the CBS News using your favorite social networks and online news applications: