Pig Farmer Convicted Of Six Murders

Canada's Worst Suspected Serial Killer Hears Verdict In First Of 26 Cases

(AP)  A pig farmer accused of being Canada's worst serial killer was found guilty of second-degree murder in the deaths of six women Sunday.

Robert 'Willie' Pickton was facing the first of 26 murder charges for the deaths of women, most of them prostitutes and drug addicts from a seedy Vancouver neighborhood.

Pickton, 58, was found guilty of the murders of Mona Wilson, Sereena Abotsway, Marnie Frey, Brenda Wolfe, Andrea Joesbury and Georgina Papin. The defense acknowledged that their remains were found on Pickton's farm outside Vancouver, but denied he was responsible for their deaths.

Pickton listened to the verdict with his head bowed. He will receive life in prison and will not be eligible for parole for at least 10 years when he is sentenced Tuesday. The jury had no recommendation Sunday on whether to extend that 10-year period. When the jury entered the courtroom again for that announcement, Pickton smirked.

Two jurors, both women, wiped tears from their eyes while the verdict was read.

The jury of seven men and five women took 10 days to reach a verdict. They had the option of finding Pickton guilty of first-degree murder, second-degree murder or manslaughter or not guilty on any of the six counts.

Second-degree murder is a lesser charge that means a murder was not planned. First-degree murder, which means a murder was planned, also carries a mandatory sentence of life in prison but does not offer parole eligibility for 25 years.

"It should have been first degree," said Rick Frey, father of Marnie Frey. "You don't have six murders over that time and not have first degree."

Family members and friends gathered for a candlelight vigil outside the courthouse after the verdicts.

Last week, Judge James Williams reviewed the transcript of a videotape in which Pickton is heard telling an undercover police officer that he had planned to kill one more woman before stopping at 50, taking a break and then killing another 25 women.

"I was going to do one more; make it an even 50," Pickton told the officer, who had been planted in the accused killer's cell and gained his trust.

A day earlier, Papin's three sisters cried and clutched each other's hands in court while the judge reviewed the testimony of witness Lynn Ellingson, who said she walked in on a blood-covered Pickton as Papin's body dangled from a chain in the farm's slaughterhouse.

The judge also reviewed testimony of prosecution witness Andrew Bellwood, who said Pickton told him how he strangled his alleged victims and fed their remains to his pigs.

Pickton has been charged in the slayings of 26 women, but almost 40 others are on a police list of missing women. The investigation into their disappearances is ongoing.

Prosecutors said Pickton will be tried for the 20 other murder charges later, but no date has been set.

Health officials once issued a tainted meat advisory to neighbors who might have bought pork from Pickton's farm, concerned the meat might have contained human remains.

[nirak2-2009]

Since this happened close to where I live in Canada it has been of great interest to me.
For the life of me, I can''t figure out how the jury could come up with second degree murder?
Could it be these were not little innocent kids he killed, but Prostitutes?
Not even Prostitutes deserve to be killed and fed to the pigs on his farm.

[erasmus6]

"Since this happened close to where I live in Canada it has been of great interest to me.
For the life of me, I can''''t figure out how the jury could come up with second degree murder?" posted by nirak2

I also live close to where this is.

"Second-degree murder is a lesser charge that means a murder was not planned. First-degree murder, which means a murder was planned..."

He told the cop he was going to make it an even 50, doesn''t that mean it was planned?

[erasmus6]

"...he''''s off the streets for the rest of his life..." posted by Nancy_Naive


Not necessarily, he is eligible for parole in 10 years.

[ozonmojo]

nirak2 is absolutely right.The second degree stuff is utterly senseless in this case of brutal,deliberate murders.That the victims were helpless,drug addicted prostitutes should have weighed far more with the jury.Does Canada have death penalty ?I don''t think it does.That is another loophole for gross miscarriage of justice in the case of this monster killer.

[yohnvilson]

I wouldn''t sweat it, there''s no way he''ll actually *get* parole. Charlie Manson comes up for parole regularly too, never gonna happen.

[cfin5]

What a sicko. But I''m not sure with the verdict who is the stupidest, him or their justice system. If that pig farmer was only slightly more intelligent he would have fed the bodies to his pigs. I''ve heard of farmers slipping in the pig pen and getting knocked out perhaps,......and the ONLY thing they found of him were his boots. Pigs are pigs indeed and they will eat almost anything. One notch down from a goat, so be careful around them.........Well, the farmers going to a different pig pen for awhile, not nearly long enough though.

[cfin5]

Whoa, missed that part about what he did with them. Can''t talk and read at the same time I guess.

[sgtrds]

This story is going to make more then one person take an extra long look at their Honeybaked Christmas Ham.

[nwihoosier]

Nancy, Nancy, Nancy, you truly are naive or plain stupid. Schoolyard fight? No way. Those pigs should have been charged with a hate crime, but weren''t.
It''s time for your meds, Nancy. Ha Haaaa

[harp1963]

"He will receive life in prison and will not be eligible for parole for at least 10 years when he is sentenced?"

"The jury had no recommendation Sunday on whether to extend that 10-year period?"

The Canadian far left must be as brain dead as the American far right.

Just sentence this freak to life in prision without the possiblity of parole and save the Canadian taxpayers the waste of money to have the parole process even take place.

Or, maybe we could put the far left and the far right people on a space shuttle to Pluto. That may be a better solution to the planets problems.

[radiob-2009]

Pickton is accused of luring women to his pig farm outside Vancouver, where investigators say he threw drunken raves with prostitutes and drugs. After his arrest in February 2002, health officials issued a tainted meat advisory to neighbors who may have bought pork from his farm, concerned that it may have contained human remains.

Tainted meat? This man is sick like Dahmner, Hitler, Manson etc. and should be immediately executed.

[rational_1]

Six bodies found on his farm and it ISN''T first degree murder? Okay, I might grant him a break if it was two or three because, ya know, accidents happen {sarcasm}, but six? Those jurors are brain dead. I moved to the States from Canada about 15 years ago and even then I thought the Canadian legal system was a bit soft in the head. Apparently nothing has changed. Those idiots will probably end up releasing this psycho dirtbag.

[nirak2-2009]

I agree erasmus
If that wasn''t planned I don''t know what planned is!

However I am glad Canada doesn''t have the death penality. Let him rot in Prison!
One innocent person sitting on death row is too much for me and we all know there are many in the States and here who have been found guilty and were innocent.

[runningralph]

Nancy-naive,
As a matter of fact, Mychal bell was only given 18 months with credit for time served. The only reason he got that much was because of prior convictions. The justice system was very lenient. All the rest of the perps walked persumably because they had shorter criminal records.

[incog-nito]

I happen to think that the death penalty as it is applied in the U.S. is expensive, unnecessary, and not as punitive as it sounds. I believe a much more severe punishment is to put murderers in solitary confinement for life. Solitary confinement is commonly used to punish unruly people who are already in prison. Why? Because it is downright unbearable, a fate worse than death for most. It can drive people insane. I believe it is a much more effective deterrent than even capital punishment, as people learn about the severity of its condition from the prisoners serving it.

[scarletphd]

Don''t worry this motherfu(ker will meet the same end as Jeffrey Dahmer did when he goes to prison. Psycho fu(ks like this don''t last long.

[b-easy63]

I believe a much more severe punishment is to put murderers in solitary confinement for life.
Posted by incog-nito at 11:29 PM : Dec 09, 2007


actually, some people in prison have been shown to adapt to general population or solitary confinement very well. (Even the supermaxx 23 hours in solitary, 1 hour out per day kind) You do not believe in the death penalty--that is obvious--but keeping someone alive and healthy for the rest of their life is more expensive than simply killing them even with appeals. Do not delude yourself, even cons who do not get the death penalty tie up the system and exhaust it with numerous appeals. the good thing about the death penalty is that they never return to do repeat their types of crime. They really don''t. Check the stats, less than .0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000% come back and sucessfully kill. You want to justify keeping them alive--try a better rationale, those who support the death penalty are not into torturing people or punishing them harder--you miss the point--it is to provide surcease to society, on behalf of the victims family and it is to also ensure the killer never does it again. Most who oppose the death penalty argue similarly to you--but the funny thing is, they fail to understand why so many endorse it--because it works--not to stop new killers, but to stop ones already caught from repeating the offense.

[nathan8804-2009]

What are they going to feed the pigs now? Who is going to feed them? Maybe he can get work release? I cannot imaging that being out of the question in Canada.

[erasmus6]

"Maybe he can get work release? I cannot imaging that being out of the question in Canada." posted by nathan8804

That would completely be out of the question in Canada but NOT the U.S.

[erasmus6]

"No death penalty for six murders and up for parole after 10 years. The Canadian justice system is whacked."

There is no way that this guy will ever get parole.

And his sentence was decided by the JURORS when they made it second degree murder.

I am pretty sure that there were more than 6 murders, that is just all they could get him on.

[kaelinda]

Canada doesn''t have the death penalty, so I would think a man who has committed six murders at six different times would have been found guilty enough that he deserved life behind bars with no chance of parole at all ever under any circumstances.

I don''t believe in the death penalty anymore; not since over 200 people have been completely exonerated by the Innocence Project in the United States just since 1999.

[republic1776]

Man,
This is exactly why we don''t want a socialist, liberal America.
This is NOT Justice it''s Repulsive!

[incog-nito]

b-easy63: You got it wrong. I have no problem with offing murderers. But I also think that the possibility of putting to death an innocent person is in itself a heinous crime. Not only the person is killed, but his name and reputation is forever impugned. And don''t tell me no one has ever been wrongly convicted. The kind of confinement I''m talking about is not 23/1 but 24/7/365. It''s a living death. Maybe some can adapt to it, but it won''t be fun. You probably can accept the fact that a few innocents are wrongly put to death for the greater good of society, but I don''t.

[excoachken]

I think I saw this guy on T.V. He called his farm the Bunny Ranch.

[yankeerebel7]

For cases as extreme as this, Canada should definitely consider capital punishment as a justifiable. Mass murderers really don''t deserve to live out the rest of their lives.

[carolrhill]

He finally got what he deserves but it took so long.
I really feel so badly for the families of these people that fell into this very sick person.
Finally the family members can put this entire horrible part of their lives to rest. There is no way shape or form that the family members will rest but at the very least they will be able to feel better about the situation.
This man will be able to get parole? I just do not get it at all.
MAY GOD BLESS ALL THE FAMILY MEMBERS OF THESE PEOPLE THAT ARE NOW ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE CURTAIN AND RESTING FOR THE FIRST TIME IN YEARS!!!

[nolalou]

I agree that this should have been a 1st degree murder conviction, but the article said "Robert ''Willie'' Pickton was facing the first of 26 murder charges for the deaths of women". I assume from that statement, that his is facing further charges in the other murders. Lets hope the next jury gets it right!

[toolmangler-2009]

"I was going to do one more; make it an even 50," Pickton told the officer, who had been planted in the accused killer''s cell and gained his trust.



with 49 murders admitted to he could never be allowed to live in America, However according to erasmus6 Canada is glad to make sure he lives the rest of his life without any problems or worrys.

[b-easy63]

"Pickton listened to the verdict with his head bowed. He will receive life in prison and will not be eligible for parole for at least 10 years when he is sentenced Tuesday. The jury had no recommendation Sunday on whether to extend that 10-year period."

The sick fact that a man could kill 26 people and be considered for parole in only 10 years, should be enough to have all of America''s serial killers scurrying to cross the border into Canada.

[b-easy63]

Posted by incog-nito at 04:38 AM : Dec 10, 2007

Yes. I can accept the fact of mistakes--it is a part of life and unfortunately, it will and does happen. You may be able to accept the fact of life in prison, but since sentences are often communted or can be reversed or people receive credit for time or the prisons get overcrowded, etc to propose life in prison is not a guarantee and many men PREFER life in prison as it is the only life that they know. As for solitary confinement and Supermaxes, they cost about 3X times the price as general population. Once a sentence is given, what happens down the road as parole boards, gov. and the system changes is out of our hands. It''s okay if you cannot stomach or countenance the loss of even one innocent life. That is why we have the "state" assuming the ultimate role of victim and executioner--to recuse individuals from the huge weight of error and horror of murder themselves.

As Mr. Spock said: "The needs of the many must outweigh the needs of a few" Not a perfect system, not a panacea, but the murders and murderers are not stopping or even slowing down due to the moral dilemma of some.

[fibonacci_]

What a title of an article: "Pig Farmer Convicted of Six Murders".

[writescripts]

Why would you not execute this man for pre-meditated murder? Legal system really stinks!

[usbrit-2009]

If you''re interested in reading more about this creature try www.crimelibrary.com/serial_killers. The full story is even worse than described here.

[ivandrago]

This should make an interesting horror movie. I just hope that it doesn''t focus so much on the torture like Saw, or Hostel, but tries to build suspense and foreboding.

[erasmus6]

"For cases as extreme as this, Canada should definitely consider capital punishment as a justifiable. Mass murderers really don''''t deserve to live out the rest of their lives." posted by yankeerebel7

We don''t get that many extreme cases like this.
We do have the death penalty for people that kill cops.

[erasmus6]

"This man will be able to get parole? I just do not get it at all." posted by carolrhill

This guy ain''t going to get parole. They will never let him out.

[erasmus6]

"I assume from that statement, that his is facing further charges in the other murders. Lets hope the next jury gets it right!" posted by nolalou

There are many more woman that are missing they just haven''t found them yet.

The only reason the jurors came up with a 2nd degree murder conviction is because they figure that he was not alone in these crimes. Also, even though the bodies were found on his property, I don''t know if they actually found any of his DNA on anything.

[erasmus6]

"Canada is glad to make sure he lives the rest of his life without any problems or worrys." posted by ToolMangler

If he was dead, he would have no more worrys but he ain''t and so therefore he is going to have plenty of worrys. His worrys begin when he has to start bending over for all his cell mates.

[erasmus6]

Pickton was sentenced today to life in prison and he will not be eligable for parole for 25 years, not 10. He will be AT LEAST 83 by the time he is able to get out but I doubt he ever will.