Dec. 9, 2007
Prescription For Addiction
60 Minutes' Scott Pelley Reports On A New Addiction Treatment
-
Play CBS Video Video Prescription For Addiction Prometa is touted as a new treatment for addictions, especially to meth, but some doctors say its claims are unverified, even though addicts and other doctors say it works. Scott Pelley reports.
-
(AP)
-
News Tools 60 Minutes
Email AlertSign up for our 60 Minutes email alert.
MP3 Audio
- 60 Minutes
This episode of 60 Minutes is available as a free audio podcast. Click here to listen or download.
"We’re providing information of certain medical treatment that they -- a physician, in their discretion, will use in the practice of medicine to treat their patient. We are not a pharmaceutical company," Peizer explains.
"Come on. You're going to these doctors and you're saying here are three drugs. Here's how you administer them. Here's how much you administer. Here's how many days you administer them. And this is how this works. And you’re telling me in this interview that you are not prescribing a drug protocol," Pelley says.
"We’re not prescribing, factually we’re not, only doctors can prescribe," Peizer says.
"You’re playing with words," Pelley says.
"I’m sorry but I don’t think so," Peizer replies. "We make it very clear is this a physicians decision, you’ve talked to physicians that have used it right? What do they say about it?"
"The physicians that we’ve talked to say they’ve seen results, other medical researchers we’ve talked to say they’ve never seen any treatment program developed in this way and they don’t mean that as a compliment," Pelley says.
"So we’re supposed to watch patients die, how many lives do you want to save before it's relevant?" Peizer asks.
"Someone might say, 'Sure, it'll be great to spend five or ten years studying this medication.' But we don't have that kind of time. People are dying by the hundreds and thousands in America from meth addiction," Pelley tells Dr. Mendelson.
"That’s correct," he replies. "They raised an incredible amount of money. They raised $140 million. If they'd spent 100 million of that on research, they would have had their answer today."
"The criticism is the research is weak. There's a simple way to fix that. You do the studies. You do the trials. You go to the FDA. You have the FDA sign off on all of this. Why don't you do that?" Pelley asks Peizer.
"Well, we do have studies in place. We actually…I mean, we're really excited. We just saw the top line data from a double blind placebo-controlled study, which is the gold standard of science," Peizer says.
After more than four years treating patients, Prometa just completed its first double blind study. It's not published yet, but Peizer says the results are positive. The study was done by psychiatrist Harold Urschel. He’s run a number of drug trials for government and drug companies.
But we noticed that while testing Prometa, Dr. Urschel's own addiction clinic was selling Prometa.
"This is the gentleman who’s supposedly doing the independent research to see if it works. Seems like a conflict?" Pelley asks.
"Well, I assure you there’s no conflict," Peizer says. "I can’t speak to what goes on in his medical building. I have no idea."
Dr. Urschel told 60 Minutes he didn’t have a financial interest in his clinic’s Prometa sales and he sees no conflict. But it's not the first time Prometa has hit questions on the fast track to market. Remember the model program in Tacoma drug court? It turns out some of the top people in the private, non-profit group running the program for the county, who were so enthusiastic, were also buying Peizer’s stock.
"My name is John Neiswender. I'm the Chief Financial Officer for the Pierce County Alliance. And, yes, I'm one of those who bought stock," John Neiswender told Pierce County commissioners at a hearing.
The county's commissioners didn't like the sound of that. They didn’t like the results of the county auditor’s report. Forty addicts from drug court had been treated. After 14 months, 57 percent were clean. But the auditor said that’s no better than the usual therapies. After spending nearly a quarter million dollars on Prometa, the commissioners pulled the funding.
"You know, there are some eminent scientists in this field who know the biology of addiction. And they look at the Prometa drug protocol and they say, 'We can't see how this works,'" Pelley tells Dave Smart.
"I don't care how it works. But I know it does work. That's the bottom line," Smart replies. "The alternative is a hopeless life on dope living in my truck."
Terren Peizer has commissioned four more studies, betting his company and $150 million that the medicine will catch up with his marketing.
"Depending and who you talk to, you're either a revolutionary or a snake oil salesman," Pelley tells Peizer.
"Let the patients decide," Peizer says. "If it shows dramatically better results shouldn't every state be using it to get patients better? To lower healthcare costs? So more people could get treated? Isn't that what it's really about? So snake oil? I think not."
Produced By Henry Schuster and Rebecca Peterson
© MMVII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Recent Segments
Scroll Left Scroll Right

- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
... - 6
- next
See all 109 CommentsThank You, David Smart
http://news.morningstar.com/news/View
News.asp?article=/BW/20071031006250_univ
.xml
http://url.rexroof.com/16455
The Pierce County Alliance (the Alliance) today released a statement providing additional information and addressing inadequate analysis .... which resulted in termination of county funding for its PROMETA-based Treatment Program
The PROMETA Treatment Program pilot was offered to clients from [the] MOST DIFFICULT group, and not the average population we encounter. Of the 40 people that were included in the pilot, three people did not complete treatment and two people were transferred to receive appropriate mental health treatment.
Of the remaining 35 individuals, 86% did NOT return to drug use over the first 14 months of the PROMETA Treatment Program. In addition, 98% of all urine drug screens that were taken were negative. The reduction in cravings experienced by PROMETA-treated patients resulted in significant reductions of drug use and contributed to the [positive] outcomes for this difficult to treat group.
The outcomes ... in the Family Drug Court are even more compelling. The participants treated ... had 53 children between them, and when these cases were reviewed between March 2006 and June 2007, 51 of those [53] children were either reunited with their parents or voluntarily placed in guardianship or adoption ...
In summary:
-- The authors of the briefing report had no background or expertise with drug treatment processes, non-profit organizations, nor were they familiar with treatment outcome measurements.
-- The writers provided ... assessment without offering the Alliance opportunity to respond, clarify or explain any points or apparent discrepancies.
-- Because both successful and non-successful clients reported vastly reduced cravings, the writers question[ed] the value of [reduced] cravings in predicting success. Their analysis ... is incomplete and does not take into account the dramatic reduction in drug use that was found across most subjects ... whether or not they completed drug court.
-- The writers of the briefing paper concluded that a performance audit would not be useful [because of competition from] state funded University of Washington ... contracted through the state''''s Department of Alcohol and Drug Abuse.
-- The report implied a lack of support ... The Alliance provided the County Council with letters of support from the following:
-- Justice Charles Sandoval of Collin County, Texas'''' 380th Judicial
District Court
-- Jerry Madden, Chairman of the Texas House Corrections Committee and
Congressional representative for the 67th congressional district
-- Justice Deidre Monroe of City Court of Gary, Indiana''''s Second
Chance Drug Court Program
-- Mitch Lyles, Director Adult Probation for Denton County, TX
-- The report cites three data outcomes ..., ignoring ... many additional measures ... without seeking explanation
-- In addition to not factoring into their analysis individuals recharged on their original offense and retroactively deemed ineligible for drug court, the briefing report also failed to take into account positive outcomes from a drug treatment perspective for non drug court graduates such as:
-- Individuals voluntarily released from drug court after regaining
employment and/or regaining custody of their children and
demonstrating to the court that they had not returned to drug use
-- Individuals with psychiatric co-morbidities discharged to mental
health services after demonstrating to the court that they had
not returned to drug use
For 35 years the Alliance has fought the incessant linkage of drugs and crime, ... secured multi-million dollar grants to pioneer felony, family, and juvenile drug treatment courts in Pierce County. ... The Alliance has led the way on all of these efforts, including the adoption and use of the PROMETA Treatment Program.
About Pierce County Alliance ...
About Hythiam, Inc. ... For further information, please visit www.hythiam.com.
Pierce County Alliance :: Terree Schmidt-Whelan, 253-572-4750
=======[[xnip]]=========
Friday HYTM close before Sunday 60 mins report == $3.99
Monday HYTM close after Sunday 60 mins report == $3.35 -16.04%
Tuesday HYTM early-afternoon after Sunday 60 mins report == $2.91 -27.07%
so much for profit-mongering
IT COST 1200.00 FOR ONE TREATMENT THAT I CHOSE TO HAVE IN CHICAGO. I HAVE BEEN CLEAN FOR 4 MONTHS TO THE DAY I RECEIVED THE TREATMENT.
THE TREATMENT I HAD WAS NALTREXLONE. PLEASE IF ANYONE IS STRUGGLING WITH THIS ADDICTION CALL HYTHIAM.
I HAVE NO AND I MEAN NO CRAVINGS WHAT SO EVER.
I HAVE MY LIFE BACK. IT SAVED MY LIFE!!!!!!!!!!!!!
STACY
I say let''s try to get the treatment out there to as many folks as we can for free. It''ll be cheaper in the long run than prison, institutional care or burying them. I''ve loss my son to drugs and alcohol. Oh, he''s still breathing but his soul and mind are gone. I am one of those parents who would try anything because I have nothing to lose.
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
... - 6
- next
See all 109 Comments