Sudan Protesters: Execute U.K. Teacher
Teacher Jailed For Naming Teddy Bear "Muhammad" Appeals For Tolerance Towards Muslims
-
Play CBS Video Video Angry Mobs Condemn Teacher As many as 10,000 protestors swarmed the streets of Khartoum, Sudan, many calling for the execution of a British teacher who named a class teddy bear "Muhammad." Richard Roth reports.
-
Video Teacher Sentenced In Sudan After allowing her students to name a teddy bear Muhammad, British schoolteacher Gillian Gibbons has been sentenced by a Sudanese court to 15 days in prison and deportation. Charlie D'Agata reports.
-
Video Teacher Faces Lashing In Sudan A British teacher was arrested in Sudan after her class named a toy bear "Muhammad." She faces a public whipping and the incident has caused tension with Britain. Charlie D'Agata reports.
-
-
The Sudanese ambassador to the United Kingdom, Omer Mohammed Ahmed Siddig, leaves the Foreign Office in London, where he met with Foreign Secretary David Miliband Thursday Nov. 29, 2007. (AP Photo/Steve Parsons/PA Wire)
-
A Sudanese man walks by the Unity High School in central Khartoum, Sudan, on Wednesday, Nov. 28, 2007. This elite private school is shut down since one of its teachers, Briton Gillian Gibbons, 54, was arrested on blasphemy charges for letting her students name a teddy bear Muhammad. Gibbons was charged Wednesday and faces up to 40 lashes, six months prison and a fine under Sudan's Islam-based legal code. (AP Photo/Alfred de Montesquiou)
-
Gillian Gibbons, 54, was found guilty of "insulting the faith of Muslims" and sentenced to 15 days in jail, followed by deportation, said Ali Mohammed Ajab, a human rights lawyer on the defense team. (AP Photo/PA)
-
-
Interactive The Fundamentals Of Islam Learn about the Muslim religion and find out where the largest Muslim populations live in the U.S. and around the world.
-
Fast Facts Sudan Learn about the people, economy and history.
"One of the things my mum said today was that 'I don't want any resentment towards Muslim people'," her son John Gibbons told The Associated Press. "She's holding up quite well."
Earlier, thousands of Sudanese, many armed with clubs and knives, rallied Friday in a central square and demanded the execution of a British teacher convicted of insulting Islam for allowing her students to name a teddy bear "Muhammad."
The protesters streamed out of mosques after Friday sermons, as pickup trucks with loudspeakers blared messages against Gillian Gibbons, the teacher who was sentenced Thursday to 15 days in prison and deportation.
They massed in central Martyrs Square, outside the presidential palace, where hundreds of riot police were deployed, although they did not attempt to stop the rally.
"Shame, shame on the U.K.," protesters chanted.
They called for Gibbons' execution, saying, "No tolerance: Execution," and "Kill her, kill her by firing squad."
The women's prison where Gibbons is being held is far from the site, as is the Unity High School where she taught, which is under heavy security protection.
In response to the protests, Gillian Gibbons was moved from the women's prison near Khartoum to a secret location said her chief lawyer Kamal al-Gizouli shortly after visiting her to discuss the verdict.
"They moved this lady from the prison department to put her in other hands and in other places to cover her and wait until she completes her imprisonment period," he said, adding that she was in good health. "They want by hook or by crook to complete these nine days without any difficulties which would have an impact on their foreign relationship."
Some of the protesters, who an Associated Press reporter at the scene said numbered as many as 10,000, carried clubs, knives and axes but not automatic weapons, which some have carried at past government-condoned demonstrations, suggesting Friday's rally was not organized by the government.
The teacher wept in court Thursday as she heard her prison sentence, insisting she never meant to offend. She avoided a much heavier possible punishment of 40 lashes.
The sentence and quick seven-hour trial Thursday were aimed at swiftly resolving the case, which had put Sudan's government in an embarrassing position - facing the anger of Britain on one side and potential trouble from powerful Islamic hard-liners on the other.
The defense said the case was sparked by a school secretary with a grudge. But it escalated as Muslim clerics sought to drum up public outrage against what it called a Western plot to insult Islam's Prophet Muhammad and demanding Gibbons be punished.
The government, which has often touted its Islamic credentials, encouraged past protests over cartoons seen as insulting the prophet published in European papers. But its moves in this case suggested it feared the case could hurt its reputation in the West.
The teacher, Gillian Gibbons, "was in tears" when she testified in court Thursday, a member of her defense team, Abdel-Khaliq Abdallah, told The Associated Press.
"She said that she never wanted to insult Islam" by allowing the children to name the stuffed toy Muhammad, a common name among Muslim men, the lawyer said, speaking outside the courtroom. Media were barred from the chamber.
Gibbons, 54, was found guilty of "insulting the faith of Muslims" and sentenced to 15 days in jail, followed by deportation, said Ali Mohammed Ajab, a human rights lawyer on the defense team. The charge is a lesser offense in the article of the criminal code under which she was tried, which includes several possible charges.
Prosecutors had pressed for conviction on a heavier charge under the same article - inciting religious hatred, which carries a punishment of up to 40 lashes, six months in prison and a fine.
A judge leaving the courtroom confirmed the verdict to reporters, but refused to give his name.
It's just a teddy bear.
Robert Boulos, School directorIn London, British Foreign Secretary David Miliband summoned the Sudanese ambassador after the verdict and sentence. During the 45-minute meeting, Miliband "expressed in the strongest terms our concern at the continued detention of Gillian Gibbons," the Foreign Office said in a statement. Miliband also spoke on the phone with Sudan's acting foreign minister.
Gibbons' supporters in Khartoum were divided over the verdict. Ajab, a human rights lawyer on the defense team, called the ruling "very unfair," blaming "hard-liners trying to make some noise."
But the director of Gibbons' Unity High School, Robert Boulos, said the lawyers hired by the school would not appeal, noting she could have received a heavier sentence. He said Gibbons, jailed since Sunday, has already served five days in prison and would only have to serve 10 more.
The case began with a classroom project on animals in September at the private school, which has 750 students from elementary to high school levels, most from wealthy Sudanese Muslim families.
Gibbons had one of her 7-year-old students bring in a teddy bear, then asked the class to name it and they chose the name Muhammad.
Each student then took the teddy bear home to write a diary entry about it, and the entries were compiled into a book with the bear's picture on the cover, titled "My Name is Muhammad," Boulos said.
But an office assistant at the school, Sara Khawad, complained to the Ministry of Education that Gibbons had insulted the prophet. Khawad testified at Thursday's trial, chief defense lawyer Kamal Djizouri said.
Khawad "was doing this out of revenge against the administration," Djizouri said. He did not elaborate. But the director of the school's Parent-Teacher Association, Isam Abu Hasabu, claimed Khawad had argued with the principal before the incident.
Comparing the Prophet Muhammad - Islam's most revered figure - to an animal or a toy could be insulting to Muslims. But Boulos said that, contrary to earlier reports, no parents had complained.
"It's just a teddy bear," Boulos said.
The government issued orders to clerics not to deliver inflammatory sermons Friday about the case or against foreigners, a senior government official said, speaking on condition of anonymity because the government had also ordered officials not to discuss the case.
The north of Sudan bases its legal code on Islamic law, and President Omar al-Bashir often seeks to burnish his religious credentials, playing up to his hard-line supporters.
But in Gibbons' case, the government appeared reluctant to let hard-liners steer it into tensions with Britain and the West. Sudan is already facing international scorn and charges of war crimes in Darfur, where the government is waging a brutal fight against non-Muslim rebels, reports CBS News correspondent Richard Roth.
Public pressure by Western governments over the Darfur conflict has eased recently, with a U.N.-African Union peacekeeping force preparing to deploy.
© MMVII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.
- Mom_O_Truth, Sep 11th was not what caused America to go to Iraq, it was just the last straw, America had put up with American places being bombed since the 1970''s,, ships etc...and your people did nothing about it...
Most of those who burn American churches are Muslims..Around Jewish synagogues they have to have guards in all other non Muslims countries, why, to protect them from Muslims, and some even have high wired fences, Why,,,,
When your clerics, leaders and teachers stop preaching hatred, and tell their people that what they do is wrong and when it is taken out of the quran about killing all infidel until all the world is for Allah then we will know that we can live in peace with you... Mohammad raided and raided other towns even when they were sometimes asleep.. he skited that he had chased the Jewish people off their land killing the men and taking the women and children.. so dear Mom it could be that your ancestors were in fact Jews, as mohammad and his merry men married or had so many thousands of the jewish women for their slaves (with who mthey were allowed to have *** with).. hmmm These are of course the people that Mohammad said were pigs and apes.. - Reply to this comment
- sorry nggr... but in some areas the men will get nothing as the courts will say that she must have provoked them and she will either be stoned to death or receive lashes, and might as well be dead, other places are not so harsh on the girl...If this girls family dare complain???
It is a very evil war cult.. I have read much of their holy books, and other than the first quarter of the quran it is a horrific book...
They will sort of live in peace amongst us until they have multiplied to become a force just as mohammad did. - Reply to this comment
- Was the bear executed (pun intended)?
- Reply to this comment
- Common SENSE facts:
Posted by Mom_O_Truth at 11:49 AM : Dec 01, 2007
sorry,
but my common sense does not dictate that 10000 people protesting in favor of killing a woman by firing squad because she and her students named a teddy bear muhammad is justifiable.
not matter what the locale.
if this is such common sense to you, then go live there.
these type of people are all that is wrong with the world. i get a little crass and silly on these message boards, but i''m a reasonable guy to deal with in real life. the mindset of these people is barbaric.
why aren''t they in the street demanding that the men who pulled a woman out of a car and gang raped her be killed by firing squad? different culture, i know, in my opinion a barbaric culture that should be wiped off the foce of our current planet.
that makes common sense to me. - Reply to this comment
- Common SENSE facts: 1) She is a teacher obligated to be sensitive to cultural and religious issues especially that 2) she chose to teach in a different country of non-Christian religion, she should live by the rules of that country and respect it%u2019s culture and it%u2019s religion. She chose to teach in Sudan. 3) After all she a mature woman of 54 and well aware of the history of Sudan as a former British mandate full of accumulated anger towards Brits because of how they lynched Sudanese and executed them publicly to set an example of terror back then 1956. She and the school director knew they live in a boiling pot and hence should have carefully considered each word and action. 4) There are 5% Christians living in Khartoum and south Sudan and none of those would name any animal %u201CJesus or Moses%u201D in respect of the Prophets names. 5) The Sudanese Government allows Christian missionaries and teaching of Christian and Jewish religions beside Islam in public and private schools following the Egyptian education system next door, while teaching religion is prohibited in U.S. schools. 6) GO CLEAN UP those who burn your Churches in Alabama and Georgia. AND ***%u2019s mob who is sucking your money in gas prices, spending half a $Billion/day on a war that killed over 4000 of our youth, 40,000 civilians to retaliate for 3,500 dead in 9/11, INSTEAD OF BLAMING the %u201Cescape goat%u201D for your own problems.
- Reply to this comment
- Keithle1 Where do you think that welfare came from originally, it was not atheists, who did the teaching of children before governments took over.. it was not governments who did the nursing for nothing of the sick people, it was not the governments who took food out to the poor, etc it was people who believed in God who were giving of their time and money to help..yep they were stupid, they should just have let these people die as now no one gives them credit for giving so much to the people..
And yes you will come back and tell me that religion has done a lot of damage and you would be right, but I am talking not of religion but of the billions of people who really believe and who have helped others, this is where todays values come from and now people who believe and don''t believe in a God try to follow these values.. Love one another..
We must not put all Christians in the same basket when religious people do wrong just as we must not put all business men in the same basket as some who cheat and lie, and we dont put all sports men in the same basket when some go and get drunk and rape girls.. Christians are just like you and me, trying to do their best to not hurt anyone and sometimes failing just as you and I do.. - Reply to this comment
- Organized religion does so much good in the word. Especially Islam.
There''s...uh...and then there is...er...ah...uh...well you have...uh...hmm...er...don''t forget about uh...don''t forget about uh... - Reply to this comment
- zertrat, yes there is some Christians who believe in evolution, simply because they dont think for themselves but most bible beliving people dont believe in evolution, it is very hard to believe that first of all there was nothing out there and nothing caused that nothing to explode.. There are many scientists who dont believe it zertrat, but unfortunately the media wont tell the world that it is something that has to be researched out for ourselves, I suppose simply because most of the media in the world is left and are pushing us towards a one world control or one world government.. the left have said openly that that is what they want...
- Reply to this comment
- zertrat, visiting Muslim countries does not show a thing it is what is written in their books that is important so that when the time is right and they are called they are to do their dirty deed just as they have done throughout history.. We have non stop world wide violence what does that say?? I know people who have lived in Muslim countries and or traveled through them.. in one country the Muslim people were lovely then, but now they have become militant.. We have had a Muslim lass staying with us, and she was also lovely, but in her country at this stage they are peaceful, again, I say at this stage.. they are slowly being woken up to the command of the Quran that they are to take the world for allah..
Michael is right, he has not just read one or two books he has read some of the Quran by the looks of it as indeed so have I.. The first part of the Quran is full of love, peace, tolerance etc then when mohammad s numbers become a force, he became a force, raiding village after village as he marched across the land, all you have to do is read Muslim books yourself to see.. or I could post some on here for you...Mohammad even skited that he chased the Jewish people off their lands and took their homes for himself.. and their women.. - Reply to this comment
- Start calling Islam what it is.
Call it a toxic ideology, a death cult, even your death sentence. In fact, Islam, among other things, is a vicious political movement, which gives itself a mantle of respectability and gets away with its actions only by providing itself with the "cloaking device" of religion. Islam is totalitarianism. It wants to conquer you, and kill you and yours. It wants to destroy everything you value.
If you do not withdraw your sanction of Islam, you will play right into the Islamists'''' hands. This is happening right now at the highest level of government. We watch our highest officials bowing and scraping to their future Muslim killers, while reassuring our people that Islam is peaceful, that Islam is a great religion, that Islam is wonderful, and worst of all, that Islam has been hijacked by some bad guys who twist it to their uses. Don''''t be played like a Wurlitzer. Islamists are selling you sanitized Islam while practicing the real thing. It is terribly important to remember that lying and deceit are among Islam''''s most valued weapons.
Jump over the religion barrier. Keep your own peaceful religion, which teaches that the initiation of force is wrong, but that self-defense is right. Recognize and reject Islam, which has as a central commandment to erase the Infidel -- that''''s you -- from the face of the earth. - Reply to this comment
- Start calling Islam what it is.
Call it a toxic ideology, a death cult, even your death sentence. In fact, Islam, among other things, is a vicious political movement, which gives itself a mantle of respectability and gets away with its actions only by providing itself with the "cloaking device" of religion. Islam is totalitarianism. It wants to conquer you, and kill you and yours. It wants to destroy everything you value.
If you do not withdraw your sanction of Islam, you will play right into the Islamists'''' hands. This is happening right now at the highest level of government. We watch our highest officials bowing and scraping to their future Muslim killers, while reassuring our people that Islam is peaceful, that Islam is a great religion, that Islam is wonderful, and worst of all, that Islam has been hijacked by some bad guys who twist it to their uses. Don''''t be played like a Wurlitzer. Islamists are selling you sanitized Islam while practicing the real thing. It is terribly important to remember that lying and deceit are among Islam''''s most valued weapons.
Jump over the religion barrier. Keep your own peaceful religion, which teaches that the initiation of force is wrong, but that self-defense is right. Recognize and reject Islam, which has as a central commandment to erase the Infidel -- that''''s you -- from the face of the earth. - Reply to this comment
Zertrat, you''re clearly a fool, a Muslim, or both. or a Muslim. I don''t have to go to Muslim countries to know what Islam is all about, anymore than I need to fly to the Sun to know that''s hot up there. I also don''t need to kick a tiger to know I''ll get bit, and I don''t need to jump off a 500 meter building to know it will kill me. You''re obviously a simplistic as*shole and I have no idea, in fact, why a person of my educational status is even wasting time writing to you. I certainly hope you don''t live in the US, but if you do, we can all hope you are soon deported back to whatever shi*thole corrupt Arab country you came from. Meanwhile, you need to go to bed, because your taxi shift starts in a few hours.Goodbye, Mr. Muslim Terrorist.- Reply to this comment
- Have any of you ever travelled outside your neighborhood???? Geez, the *** that is posted. Do you realize that all of your honored opinions (every American is free to express their opinion or their ***), is closer to *** than real? Please, just slow down and think about it. Put yourself in the position of someone else on earth, besides the beknighted YOU who believes in a particular god (Baptist, i would bet, even those of you who are not Baptist. Did you know that Catholics, Mormons, Episcopalians, Lutherans, are all cool with evolution No!! You have been hijacked by a bunch of florckin baptists. shame shame.) Learn your own religion, don''t buy political religion (uh, did i mention baptists), get your head out of the sand. Do something with your lives instead of following this incredible scam. If I met you on thge street and said that a yellow goblin told me the Celtics would lose to the Heat, would you believe me. Oh, sorry, of course not. Jesus is the son of god. giggle
- Reply to this comment
- "Here, then, is a summary of some of what we know about Islam thus far:"
What a foolish statement for false scholarship. In some cases, these are good observations, in other cases, wildly wrong. Only Christian would make the simplistic staement that they had a summary of a religion in a few lines. If I did that for Christiantiy, they would go bonkers: "Oh this is so unfair."
Travel to Muslim countries. Do that first. If you don''t do that, it is like reviewing a wine without tasting it. - Reply to this comment
- Start calling Islam what it is.
Call it a toxic ideology, a death cult, even your death sentence. In fact, Islam, among other things, is a vicious political movement, which gives itself a mantle of respectability and gets away with its actions only by providing itself with the "cloaking device" of religion. Islam is totalitarianism. It wants to conquer you, and kill you and yours. It wants to destroy everything you value.
If you do not withdraw your sanction of Islam, you will play right into the Islamists'' hands. This is happening right now at the highest level of government. We watch our highest officials bowing and scraping to their future Muslim killers, while reassuring our people that Islam is peaceful, that Islam is a great religion, that Islam is wonderful, and worst of all, that Islam has been hijacked by some bad guys who twist it to their uses. Don''t be played like a Wurlitzer. Islamists are selling you sanitized Islam while practicing the real thing. It is terribly important to remember that lying and deceit are among Islam''s most valued weapons.
Jump over the religion barrier. Keep your own peaceful religion, which teaches that the initiation of force is wrong, but that self-defense is right. Recognize and reject Islam, which has as a central commandment to erase the Infidel -- that''s you -- from the face of the earth.
Thank you for your time. - Reply to this comment
- Let us make the emotional leap, a leap that is really a small, intellectual step: Stop regarding Islam as a "great religion," worthy of your protection it from scrutiny and criticism.
Call it a religion, if you must, because it uses your religion''s language and has many believers. But, recognize it for the political evil that it is and its unremitting agenda of world-wide conquest. Your life, the lives of your loved ones, the existence of your country, and of all your values depend on it. You will never be able to stop Muslims and their apologists from proclaiming Islam to be a great religion. They will always demand that you respect it and give it a blank check. You cannot reason with them, so stop trying. Reason only with yourself and other rational human beings. Stop buying into Muslim psychopathology.
Start calling Islam what it is. - Reply to this comment
- What does Judaism or Christianity do when one of their faithful renounces his or her faith? The Church or Synagogue attempts to persuade, or even pressure, the person, friends, and family to stop this person from becoming an apostate. They may disown or shun him. In the long run, however, apostasy has no more impact than dropping a magazine subscription. Such is not the case for Islam: If you renounce Islam, you are condemned to death. This is not negotiable. This is Islam, the Islam that tries to call itself a "religion."
- Reply to this comment
- Any and all religions fall into the same mudhole, Islam or Baptists or Hopi. I gotta say, the Baptists are the scariest. They are fake and *** and manipulative and false and did I mention they are untrue? Why do posters act like religion is a topic worth discussing? Oh, sorry, is that an insult? OK, bring it on. Tell me why I should believe in a creation story dreamed up by one local culture in one historical context. I like the Navajo version better than any others. Spider Woman beats Jesus any time. Do you folks know that one? No??? Then why are you arguing for your silly view, when you do not even know the silly views of others? Religion is the ultimate conceit. It is the ultimate way to declare yourself RIGHT, to wear the crown. Do any of you see that this is laughable?
Get a life. You are of the earth. All of you. You know it in your bones. You feel your roots. You know the ignorant country preacher cannot really have it right. I just have to suffer watching you all choosing to be stupid. Go to class, read up on science. Send your children to college. Go to the local museum or science center. This is not politics, this is fact, and it is so sad that people do not know the overwhelming facts of their own ancestry. FACTS. Your history lies aong the animals, not with Mr. God or happy dude Jesus. - Reply to this comment
- How do Judaism and Christianity deal with criticism of their faiths? They offer arguments in their defense. They do not issue "fatwas" against the critics (a "fatwa" is a religious edict with the power of law).
How does Islam take criticism? It does not. Official doctrine condemns critics to death. In some cases, Islamists provide the non-Muslim critic with an opportunity to convert to Islam. If he refuses, he may be condemned to death. If the critic is a Muslim, then criticism brings him death. No one is allowed to question the truth of Islam, even where contradictions are obvious. One must accept, submit, believe, or face horrendous, Koranic-style punishment.
Islamists regard "good Muslims" as those who are fully consistent practitioners of Islam. Wahhabis from Saudi Arabia and Khomeinists from Iran are the best of these "good Muslims." All other Muslims are considered evil because they do not practice Islam consistently. Therefore, they are as much targets of the "good Muslims" as Americans and other infidels are. - Reply to this comment
- 6. Muhammad created Islam as a means to achieve power over Arabia and to plunder it; he also used it as a means to effect revenge on those who opposed him. Muhammad was one of the bloodiest terrorists and conquistadors in history. He acted out all of his profound evil in the name of his creation "Islam" and called the process "Jihad."
7. Islam is a political movement and a scam, a con game, run by clerics and warlords for their personal profit and to keep and expand their power base.
What we really know about Islam is that it is a set of lies, confabulations, and above all, justifications for totalitarianism. It is immensely attractive to those who feel incompetent and lack self-confidence because it provides them a psychological and moral "exoskeleton," superficially masking their inadequacies. It is as alien to the spirit and teachings of most other religions as though it had come from an extraterrestrial source. If it did not have the 1400 year history of acceptance by millions of adherents, it would be held in the contempt and ridicule is deserves, and summarily discarded by all humans who become aware of it. The success of its continuing presence and influence comes from how Islam is culturally transmitted, a story for another time. - Reply to this comment
The road ahead in Afghanistan, and the crucial decision Obama faces.



