NEW YORK, Nov. 30, 2007

Giuliani's Stump Stats Often Off The Mark

The Skinny: Ex-Mayor Makes Statistics A Centerpiece, But Often Gets Them Wrong, Says NY Times

  • Play CBS Video Video Giuliani Speaks Out

    "Only on the Web": Giuliani lashes out at allegations he misused New York City taxpayer money when he was mayor...and whether there was an effort to cover up an extra-marital affair.

  • Video Giuliani's Expense Mess

    NYC tabloids are buzzing over allegations that Rudy Giuliani misappropriated tax money for his security and tried to hide it. He defends his actions in an interview to Katie Couric.

  • Video Giuliani's Expense Mess

    NYC tabloids are buzzing over allegations that Rudy Giuliani misappropriated tax money for his security and tried to hide it. He defends his actions in an interview to Katie Couric.

    • Rudy Giuliani Photo

      Rudy Giuliani  (CBS)

    • Republican presidential hopeful, former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney, left, interrupts Republican presidential hopeful, former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani, during an exchange on immigration at the CNN/You Tube debate in St. Petersburg, Fla. Wednesday, Nov. 28, 2007. Photo

      Republican presidential hopeful, former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney, left, interrupts Republican presidential hopeful, former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani, during an exchange on immigration at the CNN/You Tube debate in St. Petersburg, Fla. Wednesday, Nov. 28, 2007.  (AP)

    Previous slide Next slide
  • Photo Essay Rudy Giuliani

    September 11th made this combative New Yorker "America's Mayor." Will he also be America's president?

(CBS)  The Skinny is Keach Hagey's take on the top news of the day and the best of the Internet.


Rudy Giuliani loves numbers - and not just "9" and "11." He adores statistics of all varieties so much that he has made them a centerpiece of his campaign.

The only problem, reports the New York Times' Michael Cooper, is that they are often incorrect. Not just occasionally, and not just a little, but, shall we say, a statistically significant percentage of the time.

For example, he told a television interviewer that New York was "the only city in American that has reduced crime every single year since 1994." Wrong. Chicago has done it too.

In New Hampshire last week, he told a public forum that when he became mayor in 1994, New York "had been averaging like 1,800, 1,900 murders for almost 30 years." That's not really true. New York averaged 1,514 murders for that 30-year period. It didn't record 1,800 murders a year until 1980.

And he recently boasted at a Republican debate that "under me, spending went down 7 percent." Uh, no. His own memoir says that spending grew an average of 3.7 percent for most of his tenure. An aide said that what he meant to say was that he has proposed a 7 percent per capita reduction in spending during his time in mayor.

Lately, Mitt Romney and Giuliani's rivals have begun pointing out these errors. Giuliani's campaign says they're nitpicking.

"The mayor likes detail, and uses it frequently on the campaign trail in ways the other candidates don't," said Maria Comella, a campaign spokeswoman. "And at the end of the day, he is making points that are true."

Except when they aren't.

One unchecked fact has been getting him in a lot of trouble lately. In a recent radio advertisement about his health care proposal, Giuliani, who has had prostate cancer, asserted that his chances of surviving prostate cancer were 82 percent, while his chance of surviving in England would have been only 44 percent. His point was that the American health care system is far superior to England's government-run system, which he refers to as "socialized medicine."

The figure came from an article written by one of Giuliani's health care advisers, but was soon discredited: the actual five-year survival rate in Britain is 74.4 percent - lower than the U.S., but not by much. Romney has recently begun capitalizing on this, saying Giuliani's crime statistics are "about as accurate as his prostate cancer survival numbers for England."

Probably most troubling about the whole thing is that Giuliani stood by the discredited statistic and the ad, though it has since gone off the air.

Iowa Hearts Huckabee

"One of the biggest surprises of the presidential race."

That's what the Los Angeles Times is calling Mike Huckabee's recent surge in the polls in Iowa, where he's now running nearly even with longtime front-runner Mitt Romney.

There's been a crescendo of pro-Huckabee rumblings in the mainstream media in recent weeks, but the former Arkansas governor gave himself a huge boost in this week's Republican debate with some witty one-liners that made him seem like a likeable human being.

This is very bad news for Romney, who, though arguably likeable -- if, by "likeable," you mean "possessing the qualities that surveys say people like" -- has had trouble convincing people that he is actually a human being.

He's spent a fortune, much of it his own, on television ads in Iowa. Earlier this month was leading Huckabee by double digits. Meanwhile, the cash-strapped Huckabee went door-to-door, working that "likeable" thing.

It appears to have paid off, and now the Romney campaign is giving quotes-of-the-doomed.

"It would be nice if Romney won," said Doug Gross, an attorney overseeing Romney's Iowa campaign. "If he finishes in the top two, he's fine."

Ouch.

Texas Educator Said she Was Ousted For Endorsing Evolution

It was a big day for creationists in today's papers. First you have Mike Huckabee, who has publicly voiced his support for creationism, surging in the polls in Iowa. And then you have Chris Comer, Texas' director of science curriculum, forced out of her job by officials who said she had given the appearance of criticizing the teaching of intelligent design, according to the New York Times.

Comer was placed on 30 days' paid administrative leave in last October, resulting in what she called a forced resignation.

The move came shortly after she forwarded an e-mail message announcing a presentation by Barbara Forrest, an author of "Creationism's Trojan Horse." The book argues that creationist politics are behind the movement to get intelligent design theory taught in public schools. Comer sent the message to several people and a few online communities.

Comer, who held her job for nine years, said she believed evolution politics were behind her ousting. "None of the other reasons that they gave are, in and of themselves, firing offenses," she said.

Education agency officials declined to comment on the matter. But they explained their recommendation to fire Comer in documents obtained by The Austin American-Statesman through the Texas Public Information Act.

"Ms. Comer's e-mail implies endorsement of the speaker and implies that T.E.A. endorses the speaker's position on a subject on which the agency must remain neutral," the officials said.

A NOTE TO READERS: The Skinny is available via e-mail. Click here and follow the directions to register to receive it in your inbox each weekday morning.


©MMVII, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Video and Galleries from CBS Evening News: The Skinny

Add a Comment See all 53 Comments
by gkc99 November 30, 2007 10:46 AM PST
""Creationism''s Trojan Horse." The book argues that creationist politics are behind the movement to get intelligent design theory taught in public schools."


Gosh, who could think that, just because these so-called "creation scientists" constantly spout biblical theories! Sounds like it''s Scopes Monkey Trial time all over again.

Of course in Texas many are not descended from apes, but from substantially lower life forms much more recently.
Reply to this comment
by slim1h2o November 30, 2007 10:46 AM PST
Another liar we will have to defeat. Come November 08!
Reply to this comment
by debluezzman November 30, 2007 11:35 AM PST
they all shood be shot
Reply to this comment
by nerfff-2009 November 30, 2007 11:36 AM PST
You are biased. Only Dems will listen to you.
Reply to this comment
by gunownerdan November 30, 2007 11:38 AM PST
Giuliani is just another member of the CFR(Council on Foreign Relations) just like Clinton, Obama, Huckabee, Edwards, Romney, Biden, McCain, Richardson, and Thompson to name a few.
The CFR has hijacked the foreign policy of both parties and their main goal is to destroy American sovereignty and our constitution leading to the formation of a North American Union with Canada and Mexico.
Please learn more about the CFR and their agenda to destroy America!
Reply to this comment
by random_radar November 30, 2007 11:49 AM PST
"Of course in Texas many are not descended from apes, but from substantially lower life forms much more recently.

Posted by gkc99 at 10:46 AM : Nov 30, 2007"

But we are still an improvement over you ;)
Reply to this comment
by oscarez November 30, 2007 11:52 AM PST
Mike Huckabee, who has publicly voiced his support for creationism and that the earth is only 6,000 years is a nut case and a very dangerous man. The USA is moving into a dark time, the new dark ages.
Reply to this comment
by Con Mohrat November 30, 2007 12:19 PM PST
We already have a deceiver in the White House. Why would we want this Catholic with 2 divorces and three First Ladies in there next ?

We read in the current papers he let New York City taxpayers psy to transport his paramour around the city while still married to Wife Nbr 2.

Now, the other repub candidates say he is putting out deceitful info in his campaign propaganda.

Ignore the little man and nip his candidacy in the bud.
Reply to this comment
by mike71067 November 30, 2007 1:04 PM PST
Hmmm - I don''t recall reading about any of Hillary''s lies in this column. I guess you have to be a GOP candidate to be put under the microscope here. No big surprise - the liberal media will bash Republicans and support Democrats every chance they get.
Reply to this comment
by newideas1 November 30, 2007 1:14 PM PST
I respect people who are passionate about their beliefs, but I don''t have much respect for someone who derides the beliefs of others. That is why I admire Mike Huckabee''s approach to the debates and his campaign.

If you want a President who is intelligent, compassionate, and tempered in his judgment, I encourage you to take my challenge and visit: www.abuckforhuck.com.
Reply to this comment
by jasonmcj November 30, 2007 1:21 PM PST
You people are STILL on the "liberal media" rant? LOL...wow!

Don''t you realize only Fox News clowns and Rush zombie beleive that nonsense? Which are you?
Reply to this comment
by jasonmcj November 30, 2007 1:26 PM PST
Talk about conspiracy nut jobs...you Republicans are out there%u2026 You claim everything is a liberal conspiracy%u2026always the victim%u2026Yet, facts proves everything the media says to be true. Your %u201Cliberal%u201D conspiracy theory is the BEST (and most ridiculous) conspiracy theory of all%u2026.and its funny too since you can%u2019t force the hand of the nation anymore with your Christo-fascism.
Reply to this comment
by rational_1 November 30, 2007 1:40 PM PST
Mike Huckabee, who has publicly voiced his support for creationism and that the earth is only 6,000 years is a nut case and a very dangerous man. The USA is moving into a dark time, the new dark ages.
Posted by Oscarez at 11:52 AM : Nov 30, 2007

Maybe he was bitten by one of the rattlesnakes he was handling during a service and the toxins have affected his reasoning abilities.
Reply to this comment
by pepperp1 November 30, 2007 1:42 PM PST
Wait a minute, you sure Rudy is still a Catholic and not thrown out, I know he got an annulment from his cousin the first wife, but not the 2nd one before he married the third one did he don%u2019t they throw bums like that out of the church. And beside with that goofy group the Catholic League Donahue guy acting like they he speaks for all Catholics who becomes so rattled by fairy tales instead of the real crimes of their church, who would want to be a member anyway. Even their pope said the Leagues rejection of evolution was absurd and it is.



AND no wonder the kid dosent like his pop found this gem unrefutted by the way.....this isnt Judith for those of you keeping score On Father''s Day, 1995 Giuliani had told reporters that he was returning to Gracie Mansion to play ball with Andrew. However, he instead went to City Hall, to a basement suite with his press secretary. Three hours later, Hanover, angered, appeared at City Hall; yet a mayoral aide prevented her from entering the suite.



What did this guy do invite the press to participate in this humliation of his then wife how arrogant...
Reply to this comment
by gunownerdan November 30, 2007 1:42 PM PST
Rich and powerful politicians like Hitlery and Giuliani will often say and do anything that they think could give them more power. Even if it''s using an obvious lie!
Reply to this comment
by ov442 November 30, 2007 1:48 PM PST
hah! Whatever! The Media''s job is to report whats going on in politics, its their constitutional check on the government''s criminal wrong doings.
The fact is they arent picking on the Republican or White house... The GOP controlled the Congress for like what 15 yrs? so they were at fault for everything, Bush controlled the white house since Jan 2001. Period, its their job and they are doing it.
If it seems like there is more media coverage of the GOP wrong doings, its only because there are more wrongdoings to cover.
Besides, complaining about the coverage of the crimes and immoral acts, makes those complaining sound like they want those acts to continue and would rather them be covered up instead.
Theres your republican party for ya.
Reply to this comment
by November 30, 2007 2:04 PM PST
Romney thinks its ok for people to not make religion an issue when he is running for President, but that its ok for him to say that no Muslim will be in his cabinet...wow!
Reply to this comment
by November 30, 2007 2:04 PM PST
Romney thinks its ok for people to not make religion an issue when he is running for President, but that its ok for him to say that no Muslim will be in his cabinet...wow!
Reply to this comment
by random_radar November 30, 2007 2:06 PM PST
Since when do we expect politicians to tell the truth? This is the first time anyone has intimated that there is a place for veracity in civic affairs. I thought "lie" and "statistics" went together like strawberries and whipped cream.
Reply to this comment
by jcr103 November 30, 2007 2:20 PM PST
It hardly matters if Guiliani enages in fuzzy math. Bush engaged in statistical illusions throughout both of his campaigns and as President but Republicans could care less. There''s not terribly interested in objective facts anyway. Let''s be honest, reality often as a liberal bias.
Reply to this comment
by timoteotk November 30, 2007 2:39 PM PST
Howard Scream, Al Bore, & Bob Dull...all lost because they were either to boring, condescending or arrogant..they didn''t have something that Clinton(I hate to admit) and now Governor Mike Huckabee have in spades....Likeability...and that goes along way with the coveted independent voters. All of the attemts to make him look like a backwoods bible thumper or a liberal on spending or whatever is only going to backfire. Ordinary people see through this inquisition-style, branding politics. Once again the salt of the earth folks in the middle states, God-willing, will set the "wisdom" of the east coast intellectual elitists & left coast communists on their head!!! And they will still wonder how & why.

Huckabee and McCain are far and above the other candidates...only one problem...Huckabee is going to win without McCain.

Finally after all the verbal stumbles of the Bush presidency we have finally discovered someone who can communicate republican principles with wit & wisdom.

As far as Huckabee''s conservative credentials the way he is running a campaign tells me about that. He is not buying votes like the rest.

Reply to this comment
by jcr103 November 30, 2007 2:49 PM PST
Likeability is indeed one of the main reasons people vote for a particular candidate. But, don''t we deserve competence and honesty above all else? Bush seems like a very likeable guy but his administration is a disaster. Don''t we deserve better than this?
Reply to this comment
by king16x November 30, 2007 2:52 PM PST
Another blogger misrepresented Huckabee''s statements when the blogger claimed that Huckabee handles snakes during church services.

In the recent debate, Huckabee said that, while he agrees in general with the Bible, he believes that some of the passages are allegorical, and are NOT to be taken literally!

In the Republican debates, most of the candidates try to posture themselves as the biggest, baddest world bullies. Huckabee, meanwhile, said that if you''re looking for a candidate that is mean and angry, then he is not your man. Unlike George W. Bush, Huckabee is truly a compassionate conservative.
Reply to this comment
by king16x November 30, 2007 3:23 PM PST
How does Rudy Giuliani like the number "343"? That is the number of New York City firefighters who died in the World Trade Center on 9/11/2001. Their radios had been ineffective, the firefighters had been complaining about that for years, and a 1994 mayoral study had confirmed that the radios were faulty. On 9/11, those substandard radios were still in use but not working correctly when the Fire Department chiefs ordered the firefighters to evacuate the towers.
Reply to this comment
by denn034 November 30, 2007 3:31 PM PST
Mistakes sometimes is understandable but, Giuliani''s mistakes have become a trend if the story is correct. Perhaps, Giuliani needs a better speech writer if it''s the writer''s fault that is.
Reply to this comment
by lanefiller1 November 30, 2007 3:56 PM PST
Anyone interested in what Huckabee is really like face to face should try this funny (but it actually happened) column:
http://goupstate.us/index.php/lanefiller/2007/11/02/title_14
Reply to this comment
by ixoye_02 November 30, 2007 4:14 PM PST
Do we need another liar and pretender holding the office of president of the USA? NO!!! Giuliani = Sleaziani. If the GOP chooses Sleaziani as the nominee, it just proves to me that the GOP had long abandoned principles of integrity and honesty. No party holds the moral advantage anymore. The GOP seems to have gotten stuck with so many cheaters, liars, and perverts even at the leadership levels. Guiliani is a pretender and a liar just like George W Bush. God help our country!!!
Reply to this comment
by actornaught November 30, 2007 4:51 PM PST
It''s be hard to take Rudy Empty Suit seriously if it wasn''t for w in the white house. Never underestimate the power of stupid people wanting to elevate their own.

But seriously, rudy''s career has been strictly making something out of nothing. He has near zero popularity with his former constituents in NYC. (Another w parallel, yikes...)

After ronnie, bush 1, and then w, the only conclusion is that the ''pubs manage to get the stupid past the electorate, because they''re easily manipulated by corporations and cronies.
Reply to this comment
by nyckate November 30, 2007 5:01 PM PST
Gee, you mean Rudy hasn''t been honest or forthright in his statements??

LOL -- of course he hasn''t -- he''s this elections new Georgie Boy for pete''s sake.

Hasn''t this country had enough of these sorts of candidates?? WHy are the so-called conservatives so determined to be stupid about it??
Reply to this comment
by lnardozi November 30, 2007 5:09 PM PST
How lovely it would be if there were streaming fact checking while the candidates were talking. It''d be ringing off the hook for everyone except Dr. Paul
Reply to this comment
by gunownerdan November 30, 2007 5:19 PM PST
"Hasn''t this country had enough of these sorts of candidates?? WHy are the so-called conservatives so determined to be stupid about it??"

Posted by nyckate


We the people don''t have much of a choice anymore.
Whichever candidates are best at selling themselves to big money and corporate interests will get the most media attention. That''s why we hear so much about Giuliani, Clinton, Obama, and Romney.
Reply to this comment
by ghostcommand November 30, 2007 7:00 PM PST
I think I will run for the Presidency. I want to blackmail you by promising to cut taxes, but later I will give the tax cut to the top 1%. I will increase the National Debt by over 57% and increase privatization of the government over 23%. I will also award no-bid and over-inflated contracts to my criminal cronies. I will use the War on Terror as a smokescreen to pull off the largest robbery in history of present and future taxpayer dollars. Do not worry Grandpa and Ma you will not have to pay for this but your children and grandchildren sure will for 30-40 years. I will also reduce our good standing in the world immensely. I will reduce the value of the dollar from 25-40% and the price at the pumps will skyrocket. That tax cut for the wealthy will be great--they will convert their dollars into Euro''s rather than invest in the USA. I will initiate a buyer beware program which will be beneficial to companies/countries that make shoddy or dangerous products. Polluters can do what they want, mine owners do not have to obey safety rules, and I may have all traffic signs removed so you can drive as fast and reckless as you want. Every family can have machine guns, mortars and 500 lb. bombs. Hallejulah! Praise the Lord and be sure you vote for me twice!
Reply to this comment
by kansas1946 November 30, 2007 7:08 PM PST
The only problem, reports the New York Times'' Michael Cooper, is that they are often incorrect. Not just occasionally, and not just a little, but, shall we say, a statistically significant percentage of the time.
*****************************
And this is news? He is a Republican. What do you expect.
Reply to this comment
by lawyertom1 November 30, 2007 8:27 PM PST
Given that virtually everything Rudy claims about himself and his contribution to life, liberty, and security is an exaggeration or inaccurate, why is it surprising that his "stat''s" are guano?
Reply to this comment
by skyk-2009 November 30, 2007 9:17 PM PST
Whichever candidates are best at selling themselves to big money and corporate interests will get the most media attention. That''''s why we hear so much about Giuliani, Clinton, Obama, and Romney.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Posted by gunownerdan at 05:19 PM : Nov 30, 2007
+ report abuse

Now dan I have to call you on this one because when the debate raged about stopping the money Politician''s can collect and how much people can give YOU were opposed to the cut off of that process. We should allow the canidates a specific amount and give them air time to debate the issues, that''s it.
Reply to this comment
by bhappy2-2 November 30, 2007 9:52 PM PST
Giuliani: Kids Of Illegal Immigrants OK

That''''s because Giuliani is an IDIOT! He doesn''''t understand that We, the citizens of America, DO NOT WANT these ILLEGAL ALIEN INVADERS. We DO NOT support AMNESTY, in any way. We DO NOT support giving these ILLEGAL ALIEN INVADERS any Drivers license, free medical care, housing, jobs or ANY OTHER form of REWARD for VIOLATING OUR LAWS. These ILLEGAL ALIEN INVADERS need to be dealt with and our borders SEALED.
Reply to this comment
by cyberus-2009 November 30, 2007 9:55 PM PST
ROFL!!!!
Does anyone actually expect them to actually tell the truth or be accurate?????
Only thing that bothers me is that if McCain or Obama spouted nonsense like that it would be a *SPECIAL REPORT* on every news channel.
Reply to this comment
by rowdytexan2 November 30, 2007 11:09 PM PST
What gets me is he suspects everybody to believe all these lies he spouts. To me that shows his contempt thinking we''re all stupid.
Reply to this comment
by bettybb2 December 1, 2007 12:38 AM PST

Huckabee cannot win the election. No independant or Dem will vote for a creationist. First of all, they are anti science, and our country''s wealth is based on science. Second, another who believes such nonsense is dumb as post.
Reply to this comment
by excelsior9 December 1, 2007 1:26 AM PST
If this came from the New York Times, it has democrat newspaper all over it. Thats why I take anything from NYT with a political grain of salt. I do agree the English health care system is not as good as ours. I have used it and the American system is much better. Thier hospitals look like something from the 50''s. The docs there cannot make money under thier system so do not care and are not motivated. Our doctors are motivated by money in most cases, but at least they are motivated by something.
Reply to this comment
by creeper00 December 1, 2007 8:52 AM PST
Don''t you love it? Rudy lies like a rug and when his opponents point out those lies they''re "nitpicking."
Reply to this comment
by watcher269-2009 December 1, 2007 9:07 AM PST
Republican Math. Thats all it is. This is what you children are learning under Republicans. Lack of education - and they - the republicans - flaunt it.

They laugh at these guys in Europe and Everywhere.

The new TV show coming out is - first, have you heard of the TV show, "Are you smarter than a 10 year old"?

Well the New show is - "Are you smarter than an American"!

Well deserved too.
Reply to this comment
by Ed0719 December 1, 2007 9:45 AM PST
It is documented fact that Rudy lies to his wives and family, so is it any surprise he''d lie to everyone else, as well? He is a GOP candidate, after all, and their entire platform is built upon lies. Lies to explain other lies.

The entire GOP candidate parade should be laughed out of the country at best, or shot as traitors, along with their president.
Reply to this comment
by chalres-2009 December 1, 2007 10:10 AM PST
I love the way BUSH has lowered the bar so much that these kinds of candidates are even considered. Since Bush was a C student, cocaine using draft evader, with silver spooned rich kid background, what is next? One of these guys? Say it isn''t so...
Reply to this comment
by blazercoach1 December 1, 2007 10:48 AM PST
Noting how often the NY Times fudges things and gets conclusions from data completely wrong.....I find this topic ironic.

However,www.factcheck.org busts BOTH sides. Giuliani is mentioned quite a bit, most often, in fact...but so are Edwards and Clinton.

Check it out folks....www.factcheck.org I''m a statistics teacher. I use these folks quite a bit. They are VERY unbiased, in my opinion. They bust EVERYONE.
Reply to this comment
by fairandbal December 1, 2007 12:04 PM PST
Rudy''s ''*** on the City'' scandal is really a hoot. Can the GOP really seriously claim the moral high ground anymore? Can the hard core GOP really vote for this clown? Stay tuned.
Reply to this comment
by fairandbal December 1, 2007 12:06 PM PST
Rudy''s ''S-E-X on the City'' scandal is really a hoot. Can the GOP really seriously claim the moral high ground anymore? Can the hard core GOP really vote for this clown? Stay tuned.
Reply to this comment
by ioweign December 1, 2007 12:22 PM PST
Giuliani''s Stump Stats Often Off The Mark

###############


Well, he is trying to get Bush''s job isn''t he ?

Out Bush, Bush !
Reply to this comment
by iceman_1960 December 1, 2007 1:51 PM PST
"And at the end of the day, [Rudy Giuliani] is making points that are true."

He should be doing it all day long.
Reply to this comment
by iceman_1960 December 1, 2007 1:52 PM PST
"It would be nice if Romney won," said Doug Gross, an attorney overseeing Romney"s Iowa campaign.


Oh come on, Doug, you"re just saying that because you work for him.
Reply to this comment
See all 53 Comments
  • MOST POPULAR
  • Viewed
  • Commented
Latest News
Featured Blogs