
WASHINGTON, Nov. 16, 2007
Farm Subsidies Going To The Wealthy?
$20B In Tax Dollars Is Allocated To Keep Farms Afloat - And Some Lawmakers Are Benefiting
-
Play CBS Video Video Farm Subsidies For The Rich? Farm subsidies are designed to help American farmers in years when crops don't grow or prices are weak. But some wealthy beneficiaries are cashing in, too. Sharyl Attkisson follows the money.
-
Video Rep. Marion Berry On Farming "Only On The Web": CBS News' Sharyl Attkisson speaks to Rep. Marion Berry, D-Ark., about his family's history of farming in Arkansas and subsidies they've received from the federal government.
-
(AP / file)
-
Interactive 110th Congress The balance of power shifts and new leadership takes control as the latest session convenes.
-
Photo Essay Amazing Mazes Just in time for fall, creative cornfields are cropping up across the U.S.
Ken Cook, who researches the issue, says it makes about as much sense as putting a milk bucket under a bull.
“The big farms get most of the money. Ten percent of the beneficiaries get over 70 percent of the payments, because the bigger your farm, the more money you get,” said Cook, who is president of the Environmental Working Group.
At their best, farm subsidies help American farmers who do well some years, but would go out of business other years when crops don't grow or prices are weak.
But just look at the number of beneficiaries who live - of all places - in New York City. They’re often people who've bought or inherited land that qualifies for subsidies, though they live in high-rent city homes.
Even New York billionaire Edgar Bronfman Sr. receives farm subsidies. Even the members of Congress who vote on farm subsidies and earn $165,200 government salaries can get payments. A dozen of them or their close family have gotten a total of $6.2 million dollars over 10 years.
One of them is Arkansas Rep. Marion Berry.
He's grown rice his whole life, and has collected subsidies from the start.
Today, he and his family members have interests in several farm corporations. Attkisson asked him: “You and your family’s interests received almost $2.4 million in federal payments from 1999 to 2005 according to records?"
Berry said: “I don’t have any idea. That sounds like an awful lot of money to me.”
Whatever the amount, most Americans would hardly envision Berry as the disadvantaged farmer.
“Can you tell me what your net worth is?” Attkisson asked.
“My net worth? I don’t have any idea,” Barry replied. “Well, it’s not very much I know.”
"This range says $1.7 million to $6.6 million,” Attkisson read to him.
“That’s probably pretty close,” Berry said.
The new farm bill working its way through Congress attempts to cut off some of the wealthy. Under one version, no one earning more than $1 million a year could get subsidies.
That wouldn't affect Berry. He's worth a lot, but says his yearly income falls below the million-dollar mark.
There's nothing illegal or improper about the wealthy receiving farm subsidies. Cook says it's just not fair to taxpayers.
“Shouldn’t we ask farmers when they come in the door, like we ask so many other people, for government food programs, ‘do you need the money? How are you doing financially?’” Cook said.
For some well-to-do farmers, the harvest is especially bountiful: They're sowing the land and reaping your tax dollars.
© MMVII, CBS Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
- what i don''t like is buying a can of beans or box of soap and knowing that a portion of that purchase is very likely going to some floosie and fool on the t.v.
- Reply to this comment
- How many more stories of Corruption and Collusion between the Wealthy, Politicians, and our Government are we going to read before we take action and start a Second Revolution to take back this country?
- Reply to this comment
- How many more stories of Corruption and Collusion between the Wealthy, Politicians, and our Government are we going to read before we take action and start a Second Revolution to take back this country?
- Reply to this comment
- With food prices now soaring and farmers still receiving $20 billion in subsidies, the program obviously is NOT working.
That is the same thing that happened with the pharmaceutical industry (among others). The government subsidized research and yet gave the pharmaceutical companies exclusive patent rights with no realistic time limit, and no price limit, imposed.
Now they charge $50 per pill for medicine that costs no more thane 2 cents to make.
They sell the same medicines to other countries for pennies on the dollar of what they charge at home, and the FDA will not allow people to buy these same medicines from these other countries because they are, supposedly, not safe.
Anyone who cannot see that the Government is now owned/controlled by big business is either in denial or profiting from - Reply to this comment
- With food prices now soaring and farmers still receiving $20 billion in subsidies, the program obviously is NOT working.
That is the same thing that happened with the pharmaceutical industry (among others). The government subsidized research and yet gave the pharmaceutical companies exclusive patent rights with no realistic time limit, and no price limit, imposed.
Now they charge $50 per pill for medicine that costs no more thane 2 cents to make.
They sell the same medicines to other countries for pennies on the dollar of what they charge at home, and the FDA will not allow people to buy these same medicines from these other countries because they are, supposedly, not safe.
Anyone who cannot see that the Government is now owned/controlled by big business is either in denial or profiting from - Reply to this comment
- How many more stories of Corruption and Collusion between the Wealthy, Politicians, and our Government are we going to read before we take action and start a Second Revolution to take back this country?
- Reply to this comment
- How many more stories of Corruption and Collusion between the Wealthy, Politicians, and our Government are we going to read before we take action and start a Second Revolution to take back this country?
- Reply to this comment
- How many more stories of Corruption and Collusion between the Wealthy, Politicians, and our Government are we going to read before we take action and start a Second Revolution to take back this country?
- Reply to this comment
- How many more stories of Corruption and Collusion between the Wealthy, Politicians, and our Government are we going to read before we start a Second Revolution and take back this country?
- Reply to this comment
- How many more stories of Corruption and Collusion between the Wealthy, Politicians, and our Government are we going to read before we start a Second Revolution and take back this country?
- Reply to this comment
Author Thomas Friedman on Obama's Afghanistan plan and the war on terror.




