Nov. 8, 2007
For Candidates, Web Is Power And Poison
Washington Post: Clinton, In Particular, Draws Equal Parts Cash And Vitriol
-
Photo
Among the presidential candidates, Sen. Hillary Clinton has been the biggest target on the Internet. One group against her on Facebook has more than half a million members. (AP)
-
Play CBS Video
Video
Internet Helps Underdogs
GOP Presidential candidate Ron Paul raised over $4 million in one day through the internet. Jeff Greenfield talks with Katie Couric about how the internet helps fringe candidates.
-
Interactive
Campaign 2008
Profiles of the candidates, polls, fund-raising, blogs, video and more.
-
In-Depth
2008 Presidential Hopefuls
Profiles and the latest news on the Democrats and Republicans running for the White House.
Candidates use the Internet to generate buzz, draw grass-roots support and raise record amounts of money. But in the intense, round-the-clock world of online presidential campaigning, the good comes with the bad.
"The pool of negativity is much bigger, and it spreads virally," said Mindy Finn, chief online strategist for former Massachusetts governor Mitt Romney's Republican presidential campaign. "The Web can be hateful."
Just ask Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton (D-N.Y.).
Sites such as StopHerNow.com and AgainstHillary.com, funded by conservatives who have followed her political career since the 1990s, are easily searchable on Google. Unflattering online videos, including the "mash-up" page that portrayed the Democratic front-runner as an Orwellian Big Brother, are heavily viewed on YouTube. And Facebook, the online sociopolitical hub of the moment, is the unofficial capital of anti-Clinton country: One group, Stop Hillary Clinton, has more than half a million members, compared with the nearly 51,000 who have signed up as supporters on her Facebook profile. It's the largest group on Facebook against a candidate.
In many ways, the Web is more effective than television advertising and direct mail, the traditional methods campaigns and independent groups have used to try to define their opponents, political analysts say. It's cheaper, and it spreads information more quickly. But so far, anyway, its potential for affecting a presidential campaign is relatively untested.
"Imagine if the Swift Boat group posted their ad on YouTube before airing it on TV," said Victor Kamber, author of "Poison Politics: Are Negative Campaigns Destroying Democracy?" "With the enthusiasm that these campaigns are drawing right now, it'll be easy to find supporters who can spread whatever they want to spread -- and make sure that their fingertips are not on it."
Kamber was referring to the TV ads aimed at discrediting Sen. John F. Kerry's war record four years ago. Relatively few of the ads actually ran, but they were frequently rebroadcast on news and cable shows. On the Web, the ads had relatively little impact -- after all, YouTube, which popularized video sharing, wasn't born until February 2005.
On sites such as YouTube, humor, originality and, most of all, creativity are rewarded, setting a relatively high bar for getting noticed but opening up the possibilities of poking fun at opponents -- or possibly smearing them -- to virtually anyone.
"The key, of course, is coming up with material that's funny, racy and special enough to capture people's attention," Kamber said.
Online negative campaigning dates back at least to 2000 and the e-mail chains that attacked Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.) and Vice President Al Gore. But there are far more weapons today. "You have to go multimedia when you're attacking now," said Kathleen Hall Jamieson, a longtime campaign expert who has studied negative ads. "Send an e-mail, embed a YouTube video, send a link to your site. It's much more sophisticated."
On the Web the technology is relatively simple, and it can be difficult to trace a blog or a video. Though Romney's campaign was linked to a site attacking former senator Fred D. Thompson (R-Tenn.), it was quickly taken down, and the bulk of attacks so far have been launched by amateurs, who are usually able to remain anonymous.
"Campaigns have no control on what's already out there and what will get out there," said Joe Rospars, new-media director for the campaign of Sen. Barack Obama (D-Ill.).
The devastating impact last year of the "macaca" video on the Senate reelection campaign of George Allen (R-Va.) illustrated the kind of nightmare a candidate could face online. So far in 2007, the best example of a successful viral attack has been the March video targeting Clinton, inspired by an iconic 1984 Apple Computer commercial.
It casts the former first lady as the droning voice of totalitarianism, and it's one of many homemade YouTube videos ("Hillary Clinton Is Satan," "10 Things I Hate About Liberty, Starring Hillary Clinton") attacking her. A few days after the "1984"-themed anti-Clinton video was uploaded on YouTube, it was blogged, linked to and, weeks later, picked up by news organizations. It's been viewed more than 3.8 million times.
Phil de Vellis, who posted it anonymously before being identified by bloggers, came up with the idea while sitting in his Washington apartment. Its purpose, he said, was as clear as its title: "Vote Different." De Vellis was working for a Web design firm hired by the Obama campaign at the time, but he insists that he produced the video on his own.
"The video is effective because it says something that a lot of people, a lot of Democrats, are thinking but weren't saying. It hit a nerve," said de Vellis, 34, a lifelong Democrat who now works for a media company advising candidate Bill Richardson, the New Mexico governor.
© 2006-2007 The Washington Post Company





- 1
- 2
- 3
- next
See all 144 CommentsSO GO AHEAD AMERICANS BE WEAK, THIS IS COMMING....IT IS TIME FOR A REVOLUTION,TIME TO STOP BUSH/CHENEY
The violence broke out after an estimated 80,000 ant-iBUSH demonstrators - led by university students - marched peacefully to the Supreme Court to protest constitutional changes that would greatly expand BUSH/CHENEY power if voters agree to the changes in December. Unrest, if it continues, could mar a Dec. 2 referendum on the controversial reforms
The amendments being protested would abolish presidential term limits, give the president control over the Central Bank and let him create new provinces governed by handpicked officials.
The protesters demand the referendum be suspended, saying the amendments would weaken civil liberties and give BUSH AND CHENEY unprecedented power to declare states of emergency.
``Don''''t allow AMERICA to go down a path that nobody wants to cross , during the march to the Supreme Court.
BUSH, who was first elected in2000, denies the reforms threaten freedom. He says they would instead move AMERICA toward what he calls ``21st century socialism.''''''''
In televised comments prior to the unrest, BUSH urged ALL AMERICANS to turn out en masse to vote for the reforms. In reference to the opposition, he said: ``Don''''t go crazy.''''''''
SO GO AHEAD AND VOTE HER IN AMERICA, AND SEE WHAT WILL HAPPEN. THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT THEY WANT...
WITH 250 MILLION AMERICANS THEY CANT KILL US ALL..TIME FOR A REVOLUTION
Actually, we also have elections after few days.
let%u2019s instead compare democrat vs. democrat..
let%u2019s say Clinton vs. J.F. Kennedy.
The CLINTON and CURRENT Democrat philosophy on governing/government is:
1)%u201CBig Government will provide for you%u201D, &
2)%u201CFrom cradle to grave, Big Government will take care of you%u201D, &
3)%u201CIt takes a Village%u201D(Big Government)
WHEREAS J.F. KENNEDY said :
%u201CAsk not what your country can do for you, but rather what you can do for your country%u201D
These two philosophies (both democrat) are complete polar opposite of each other.
I would much rather be a J.F. Kennedy democrat than a Clinton socialist.
J.F. Kennedy also instituted tax cuts on the top rates to spur a sluggish economy.(hmmmm%u2026%u2026.sounding familiar)
Sounds like the NeoCommies and MoveOn.org have hijacked a democrat party
that I once knew and respected.
But I%u2019m not a republican, so what%u2019s an average American supposed to do ??
.
let%u2019s instead compare democrat vs. democrat..
let%u2019s say Clinton vs. J.F. Kennedy.
The CLINTON and CURRENT Democrat philosophy on governing/government is:
1)%u201CBig Government will provide for you%u201D, &
2)%u201CFrom cradle to grave, Big Government will take care of you%u201D, &
3)%u201CIt takes a Village%u201D(Big Government)
WHEREAS J.F. KENNEDY said :
%u201CAsk not what your country can do for you, but rather what you can do for your country%u201D
These two philosophies (both democrat) are complete polar opposite of each other.
I would much rather be a J.F. Kennedy democrat than a Clinton socialist.
J.F. Kennedy also instituted tax cuts on the top rates to spur a sluggish economy.(hmmmm%u2026%u2026.sounding familiar)
Sounds like the NeoCommies and MoveOn.org have hijacked a democrat party
that I once knew and respected.
But I%u2019m not a republican, so what%u2019s an average American supposed to do ??
.
The violence broke out after an estimated 80,000 ant-iBUSH demonstrators - led by university students - marched peacefully to the Supreme Court to protest constitutional changes that would greatly expand BUSH/CHENEY power if voters agree to the changes in December. Unrest, if it continues, could mar a Dec. 2 referendum on the controversial reforms
The amendments being protested would abolish presidential term limits, give the president control over the Central Bank and let him create new provinces governed by handpicked officials.
The protesters demand the referendum be suspended, saying the amendments would weaken civil liberties and give BUSH AND CHENEY unprecedented power to declare states of emergency.
``Don''''''''t allow AMERICA to go down a path that nobody wants to cross , during the march to the Supreme Court.
BUSH, who was first elected in2000, denies the reforms threaten freedom. He says they would instead move AMERICA toward what he calls ``21st century socialism.''''''''''''''''
In televised comments prior to the unrest, BUSH urged ALL AMERICANS to turn out en masse to vote for the reforms. In reference to the opposition, he said: ``Don''''''''t go crazy.''''''''''''''''
SO GO AHEAD AND VOTE HER IN AMERICA, AND SEE WHAT WILL HAPPEN. THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT THEY WANT...
WITH 250 MILLION AMERICANS THEY CANT KILL US ALL..TIME FOR A REVOLUTION.
Youtube viewers can choose to subscribe to their favorite candidate''s youtube page for the latest updates.
Who is the one candidate that has more subscribers than Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama, John Edwards, Joe Biden, Mitt Romney, Rudy Giuliani, Fred Thompson, and John McCain COMBINED??
Candidate / Number of Youtube Subscribers as of Nov. 8, 2007:
Obama = 12,384
Clinton = 6,661
Edwards = 4,437
Biden = 1,483
Romney = 3,231
Giuliani = 2,645
McCain = 1,740
Thompson = 760
TOTAL = 33,341
Dr. Ron Paul = 35,855
This is no accident or typo, Dr. Ron Paul is #1 on the internet! Why? Because the internet is not controlled by a handfull of huge corporations.
Peace and liberty are popular.
ronpaul2008.com
This is no accident or typo, Dr. Ron Paul is #1 on the internet! Why? Because the internet is not controlled by a handfull of huge corporations.
ronpaul2008.com
The violence broke out after an estimated 80,000 ant-iBUSH demonstrators - led by university students - marched peacefully to the Supreme Court to protest constitutional changes that would greatly expand BUSH/CHENEY power if voters agree to the changes in December. Unrest, if it continues, could mar a Dec. 2 referendum on the controversial reforms
The amendments being protested would abolish presidential term limits, give the president control over the Central Bank and let him create new provinces governed by handpicked officials.
The protesters demand the referendum be suspended, saying the amendments would weaken civil liberties and give BUSH AND CHENEY unprecedented power to declare states of emergency.
``Don''''''''t allow AMERICA to go down a path that nobody wants to cross , during the march to the Supreme Court.
BUSH, who was first elected in2000, denies the reforms threaten freedom. He says they would instead move AMERICA toward what he calls ``21st century socialism.''''''''''''''''
In televised comments prior to the unrest, BUSH urged ALL AMERICANS to turn out en masse to vote for the reforms. In reference to the opposition, he said: ``Don''''''''t go crazy.''''''''''''''''
SO GO AHEAD AND VOTE HER IN AMERICA, AND SEE WHAT WILL HAPPEN. THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT THEY WANT...
WITH 250 MILLION AMERICANS THEY CANT KILL US ALL..TIME FOR A REVOLUTION.
Go Hillary!!
Youtube viewers can choose to subscribe to their favorite candidate''''s youtube page for the latest updates.
Who is the one candidate that has more subscribers than Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama, John Edwards, Joe Biden, Mitt Romney, Rudy Giuliani, Fred Thompson, and John McCain COMBINED??
Candidate / Number of Youtube Subscribers as of Nov. 8, 2007:
Obama = 12,384
Clinton = 6,661
Edwards = 4,437
Biden = 1,483
Romney = 3,231
Giuliani = 2,645
McCain = 1,740
Thompson = 760
TOTAL = 33,341
Dr. Ron Paul = 35,855
This is no accident or typo, Dr. Ron Paul is #1 on the internet! Why? Because the internet is not controlled by a handfull of huge corporations.
You won''t hear this from the "mainstream media", but
peace and liberty are very popular!
ronpaul2008.com
I expected a run down of ALL the Internet political activity and got a laundry list of complaints about the net being mean to one candidate.
I don''t think the Internet is going away too soon and articles such as this seem to be aimed at calling for MORE control over it rather than accepting that it''s become the NEW TOWN SQUARE.
Since the "crazy" guy on a soapbox has been BANNED in the parks and squares of most American cities of course he/she had to go SOMEWHERE.
It''s no longer safe to freely speak your mind anywhere but on the net some people still hope they can. We''ve LOST SO MANY freedoms in the past few years for the sake of hope maybe this one might at least APPEAR to be available.
The net is Like the Town Square of old - people can choose whether to pay attention or not.
Personally I ignore the crazy rhetoric the same as I''d walked by the Hari Krishnas in the airports in the 70''s.
To Paraphrase an old declaration - I may NOT agree with what is said but I will defend the right to say it.
Youtube viewers can choose to subscribe to their favorite candidate''s youtube page for updates on their latest videos.
Dr. Ron Paul has more subscribers in Youtube than Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama, John Edwards, Joe Biden, Mitt Romney, Rudy Giuliani, Fred Thompson, and John McCain COMBINED.
Candidate / Number of Subscribers as of Nov. 8, 2007:
Obama = 12,384
Clinton = 6,661
Edwards = 4,437
Biden = 1,483
Romney = 3,231
Giuliani = 2,645
McCain = 1,740
Thompson = 760
TOTAL = 33,341
Dr. Ron Paul = 35,855
This is no accident or typo, Dr. Ron Paul really is #1 on the internet! Why? Because the internet is not controlled by a small handfull of huge corporations, it''s controlled by WE THE PEOPLE.
You won''t hear this from the mainstream media, but peace and liberty are very popular!
ronpaul2008.com
Posted by TopProphet at 04:03 PM : Nov 08, 2007
+ report abuse
Dude, you keep saying the same thing, but I don''t think anyone is listening. Republicans are the ones who are enabling the president to do whatever he wants.
the Pacifist Party.
- Thomas Paine
"Liberty, when it takes root, is a plant of rapid growth."
- George Washington
"First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win."
- Mahatma Gandhi
There is simply no other American politician like Ron Paul. He understands the ills of our nation and how to cure them. The Doctor is in!
He just needs to take it back from the corrupt neocons who hijacked the party in 2000.
The party now only represents sleazeballs, adulterers, warmongers, war profiteeres, and haters of every stripe.
We need a President who can face any question down, even if the answer isn''t detailed at that moment, and can do it without butchering the language or trying to incite WWIII, and we need to show the rest of the world a woman can be the leader of the free world. What would Islamic fundamentalists do then? Oh, yeah, they''d have to deal with their own cattle... I mean, wives.
We need a President who can face any question down, even if the answer isn''t detailed at that moment, and can do it without butchering the language or trying to incite WWIII, and we need to show the rest of the world a woman can be the leader of the free world. What would these backwards Islamic fundamentalists do then? Oh, yeah, they''d have to deal with their own cattle... I mean, wives.
He is ANTI-WAR, PRO-LIBERTY, and FOR our Constitution.
He is also the strongest supporter of freedom in congress. He doesn''t even accept his lucrative congressional pension. His voting record in congress is rock solid and he never supports anything that''s unconstitutional(unlike most politicians!).
ronpaul2008.com
The CFR has hijacked the foreign policy of both parties and their main goal is to destroy American sovereignty and our constitution leading to the formation of a North American Union with Canada and Mexico.
Dr. Ron Paul is NOT a member of the CFR and he will never support the destruction of American sovereignty.
the Pacifist Party.
Posted by One_American at 04:05 PM : Nov 08, 2007
Guiliani and Clinton should start their own party:
The Oh My Gawd! Party
You can all run around in front of a King Kong movie and see who can make the biggest arse out of themslves yelling Oh My Gawd!
Could be more fun than Karaoke.
Idiot!
She draws a big mustache on her face like the rest of you tools.
What next? The horse and buggy is a great new invention?
the Pacifist Party.
Posted by One_American at 04:05 PM : Nov 08, 2007
Unreal, what a moron you are!
The Pacifists go to all the gun shows...LOL!
You are the Valley Boys! ... Like, Oh My Gawd!... fer sure fer sure. Growdy, Growdy to the max...
Posted by antoniof123 at 04:38 PM : Nov 08, 2007
Like:
Q:Why are even the men screeming Oh My Gawd?
A:It is a popular American Phrase.
Q:But I''m an American. It''s what f*gs say?
Like - totally (valley girl)
Encino is like so ******* (valley girl)
Theres like the galleria (valley girl)
And like all these like really great shoe stores
I love going into like clothing stores and stuff
I like buy the neatest mini-skirts and stuff
Its like so ******* cuz like everybodys like
Super-super nice...
Its like so *******...
On ventura, there she goes
She just bought some ******* clothes
Tosses her head n flips her hair
She got a whole bunch of nothin in there
9/11....
- 1
- 2
- 3
- next
See all 144 Comments