Wildfire Relief Efforts Leave Some Behind

The Nation: Undocumented Mexican Workers In California May Be Shut Off From Aid

(The Nation)  This column was written by Amanda Martinez.

---

The relief efforts in the Southern California fires have been praised as effective, but they've missed a population that has long been in the shadows: undocumented workers living along San Diego's hillsides and canyons. These men, who represent some of the most essential workers in one of the biggest local industries, have slipped through the cracks in the county's relief and evacuation efforts -- so much so that Mexican government officials are filling in the gaps.

"The Mexican Consulate are the ones who have led the relief effort to the farmworkers in the canyons," says Eddie Preciado, director of La Posada de Guadalupe, the only homeless shelter for male farmworkers in San Diego County. He says the consulate has organized partnerships with groups like his in order to conduct searches and provide supplies to the canyon dwellers.

Immigrant advocacy groups are uncertain how these workers are surviving. They say the fires have left the workers scattered and unaccounted for. Evacuation orders have closed off access to these communities, making it very difficult for support teams to assess the population's needs and nearly impossible to determine how many living quarters have been destroyed in the fires.

The farmworkers are hard to reach physically, living in the remote areas of the canyon, but they are also linguistically isolated. Many are members of Mexico's indigenous Mixtec and Zapotec communities and do not speak English or Spanish.

"Indigenous Mexicans who speak languages such as Mixteco are at high risk of being in danger because they don't understand warnings being given in English or Spanish and they are not likely to trust people unless they are approached speaking their language," says photojournalist David Bacon, who has documented farmworker communities in rural California.

It has been estimated that there are more than 1,600 agricultural workers and day laborers living in the area in makeshift settlements, according to the Regional Task Force on the Homeless in San Diego. This is probably a low estimate of those affected by the fires because it is impossible to know exactly how many workers live this way. Described as "rural homeless," they scrape by without electricity, a water supply or sanitation systems in order to be close to the farms where they work.

These workers make up an essential agricultural labor force in San Diego County, which is one of the top agricultural producers in California and ranks second in the nation in its number of farms, according to the Regional Task Force on the Homeless.

Yet despite the industry's reliance on these laborers, they could be left out of the Federal Emergency Management Agency's relief aid because, without papers, they have very limited access to FEMA funds.

Konane Martinez, of the National Latino Research Center, anticipates that documentation will be a requirement for most federal government agencies providing relief in the area. As a result, Martinez is collaborating with eighteen different organizations to collect money and resources for displaced farmworkers looking for aid once the fires subside.

"I don't think anyone will be turned away from immediate assistance," says Dorothy Johnson, an attorney with California Legal Rural Assistance, which provides farmworkers with legal support. And though no one has reported being denied help, many undocumented immigrants are not seeking aid because they do not know which rescue workers they can trust. Many see the risk of deportation as more dangerous than the fires themselves.

"I wouldn't be surprised if they avoided firefighters," says Bacon, adding that many undocumented workers are wary of law enforcement for fear of being detained or deported.

"Many of these workers have experienced intense situations of danger just to get into the United States" and earn money to send to their families back home, explains Bacon. They are willing to endure very harsh conditions, he says, to avoid being caught by Border Patrol or ICE agents.

The Spanish-language publication Enlace, in San Diego, reported on Monday that some farmworkers have chosen to remain in the canyons despite warnings to evacuate because they do not want to leave.

Meanwhile, some who do are not being allowed to leave. "Some farmers are not following evacuation orders and have kept workers in the fields despite orders being given to evacuate," says Christian Ramirez of the American Friends Service Committee.

But if they stay they should know that, as Ramirez explains, "the atmosphere conditions are not safe to be working in." His organization has been sending volunteers into the fields to supply farmworkers with eye drops, face masks and goggles.

Apparently unconcerned that the use of Border Patrol agents might discourage undocumented residents from seeking help, the San Diego County Office of Emergency Management called on the U.S. Border Patrol to help with the emergency relief efforts. Matthew Johnson says about 300 agents are now "watching for looters, monitoring affected neighborhoods and safety control" during the fire relief efforts.

Some agents were working alongside local police when six undocumented immigrants were arrested Wednesday outside Qualcomm Stadium, one of the main fire relief sites.

Those arrested were reportedly seen stealing relief supplies consisting of fold-up cots and bottles of water from Qualcomm. Police Sgt. Jesse Cesena told the San Diego Union-Tribune that "they were stealing from the people in need." The police turned the immigrants over to Border Patrol agents.

Although Border Patrol agents are busy with local relief efforts, Johnson says they are still watching the border. Since the start of the fires, he says, they have apprehended 200 immigrants trying to cross into the United States.

Ironically, Leo Estrada, professor of urban planning at UCLA, believes the undocumented workers shouldn't worry. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) won't be conducting raids anytime soon, he says.

In fact, he predicts, immigrant workers will be needed in reconstruction efforts after the fire. More than 410,000 acres of land have burned, and clean-up efforts will be critical. "With more than 1,000 homes being demolished," he notes, "contractors will be looking to immigrant labor forces to demolish, cart away and rebuild houses."

"We saw it in New Orleans," says Estrada. Undocumented immigrants from Mexico and Central America were among the largest groups employed in rebuilding the city after Hurricane Katrina.

"At the time of reconstruction, nobody bothered them. It will be interesting to see," says Estrada. "They will be bringing back a labor force they have been trying to get rid of."

[johnstossel]

It just breaks my heart that these ******* illegal
aliens are getting left behind!!!

[cyberus-2009]

OMFGBBQ!!!

You mean our tax dollars may actually go to the aid of LEGAL residents?!?!?!?! (faint)

[blazercoach1]

Perhaps they apply to the MEXICAN government for aid? Of course, they would have to GO BACK HOME TO GET IT!

[krotec54]

I heard about a contractor that hired illegal workers on a project then called police on payday.

[CA11550]

First, undocumented equals illegal, why not call it what it is! If illegal, the ONLY aid they should get is to point them South and send them OUT of California and USA. We do not owe them a penny of any kind of relief!!!!!!

[jairod]

johnstossel: your comment has been noted and recorded in the Book of Life.

[tucano2]

By "undocumented" do you mean Illegal Aliens?
These are the criminals who set the fires!

[keev8]

"Yet despite the industry''s reliance on these laborers, they could be left out of the Federal Emergency Management Agency''s relief aid because, without papers, they have very limited access to FEMA funds."

Access to FEMA funds? Are you even #@$%ing kidding me?!?! These are people who are here illegally and you have the nerve to suggest that they are entitled to funds that are provided by our tax dollars? Unbelievable.

[Syndicate]

Part of the reward for being "Documented" is being able to receive help from the government. I know of these people they talk about. They live in make shift tents. If you want to help these people buy them a new tarp. I think all the illegals should be rounded up and sent home. If the farmer can''t afford to have his fruit picked then he should go out of buisness. If the contractor can''t afford to loose a little profit then he can go out of buisness too. I''am not willing to tolerate spanish television and radio nor spanish billboards any longer just so a farmer can save some money. I am not willing to put up with illegal imigrants driving on the road with out a license or insurance. IF they don''t have to obey the laws, neither do I.

[quatrops]

The derogatory and quasi-racist nature of the comments offered so far needs to be addressed. The reality of undocumented workers is, indeed, a legitimate concern, but those concerns can be expressed without the pejorative commentary about those who break our immigration laws.

They are, universally, from countries less fortunate than ours; countries who for various reasons have economies that do not provide opportunities for many of their citizens to feed hungry children and families. If you want to be ticked off at the governments of Mexico, El Salvador, et al, then so be it. But please don''t express it by denigrating the humanness of the poor peons who are trying to feed their families.

I doubt there are any of us who, had we been born into a poor, foreign farm family, or an urban slum, would not take the risk of breaking US immigration law.

If you''re concerned about "them" getting "government handouts", reflect on the fact that most comprehensive studies indicate thet "illegals" are a boon to our economy. They contribute more (via tax $ withheld by legitimate employers, reduced prices for agricultural products and other services, etc.) than they take out (schools, welfare, etc.).

Yes, campaign for whatever immigration policies and controls you want, but please don''t belittle the "undocumented" in the process.

[alomarsmom]

They are not undocumented they are law breakers. Criminal alians is the proper term. Having no respect for this country and claiming to allegience to it, it is not surprising when they continue breaking other laws and abusing this country''s generosity. We are a nation of immigrants and there are procedures to follow for those who wish to join us legally. Those who choose to ignore our laws need to be deported. Legal immagrants and Americans will be glad to work for a living wage and our middle class can be restored.

[Netterz]

Shoudnt have been there, so shouldnt be getting funding from my taxes. I dont care what there here for, I sure as h3ll dont get any help when I break the law.