February 11, 2009 4:05 PM

Storm Of Murder

By
CBSNews
(CBS)  This story was first broadcast on Oct. 13, 2007. It was updated on Aug. 14, 2008.

Artists Dinerral Shavers and Helen Hill - he a musician, she an independent filmmaker - may not have known each other. But they both returned to New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina with a vision to revive the storm-ravaged city.

But as correspondent Erin Moriarty reports, they both fell victims to a storm of murder.



Exactly one year after Hurricane Katrina drove them away, Paul Gailiunas and his wife Helen Hill, full of hope, had moved back to New Orleans. "She embraced it. She really did. She loved everything about New Orleans," Paul remembers.

Helen's imagination was just one of the qualities that made her so endearing. "I think of that wonderful, smiling, sunshine face coming at me. She was always right there with you," remembers her stepfather, Kevin Lewis.

Helen was raised in Columbia, S.C. by her mother Becky and her stepfather, both college professors.

Helen was only nine years old when she discovered what she wanted to do with her life. "That's when she decided she wanted to become an animator," her mother Becky recalls.

Helen's first film won an award, and the quirky animated movies that followed always retained a sense of playfulness and wonder. "She wanted their films to have a childlike appearance. And wanted that to come through in her mature, adult films which were full of ideas," Kevin Lewis says.

When Helen was in college at Harvard, she met Paul Gailiunas. They were just friends when they moved to New Orleans after graduating, but there the friendship deepened into something more.

They shared a love for New Orleans as well, and after they got married made the city their home.

Paul, now a doctor, opened a clinic that served the poor; Helen taught and worked on her films at home. Life seemed complete when in 2004 Helen and Paul had a child, Francis.

It was about one year later that Katrina hit. The day before the storm arrived they bundled up their one-year-old son and their pet pig Rosie and drove to Helen's parents' house.

"We just thought we were gonna be back in about two or three days," Paul recalls. But things didn't turn out that way. It wasn't until weeks later that Paul was even able to wade to their house. They lost everything.

But Helen had no doubt what she wanted to do: "Helen was very, very determined to move back to New Orleans," Paul explains.

But Helen's mother had reservations. "Well I would have preferred her to stay here," she admits.

In fact, Becky begged her not to return, and even Paul had his doubts. "Well, I think he was … a little bit more cautious," Becky says.

And when Helen and Paul did go back, Paul was unnerved by how different the city felt. "There's huge areas that are kind of ungoverned," he says. "It's not a city where you can feel entirely safe anywhere."

It was Jan. 3, 2007, and Paul and Helen put two-year-old Francis to bed. "We stayed up and looked at these pictures of him and he just looked so cute. And we just laughed and laughed. And that was pretty much my last memory," he remembers.

The nightmare began around 5:30 a.m. "I was woken up by the sound of Helen's voice sounding very anxious and frightened and yelling, 'Get out, get out. Don't hurt my baby, get out right now,'" Paul remembers.

Alarmed, Paul grabbed his son. "I had Francis in one arm and I got up and I called out, 'Helen, are you okay?' And I saw right away that there was a man restraining her at the front door. And she was struggling and she yelled out, 'Call 911,'" he recalls.

But it was too late. Helen was shot. With his son in his arms, Paul ran to the back of the house and tried to hide. "And it was only a few moments later that I saw a man walk into the kitchen towards us, and he took a few steps towards us and held out a gun. At that point I turned my head down to protect myself and Francis. And I heard you know, two or three shots, gunshots," Paul remembers.

And then everything went silent. The gunman was gone but the horror for Paul was just beginning. "She was lying there and wasn't moving. And her eyes were closed. And there was blood by her head. And Francis saw it too," Paul says.

Helen was killed instantly by one gunshot to the neck. Paul too had been shot, three times. Francis had somehow escaped injury.

Helen's stepfather and mother were at home in South Carolina when they got the news. "It was just a awful day. I don't remember a lot about that time," Becky tells Moriarty.

"We haven't been able to explain why this happened to someone who intended so much good in the world," she adds.

"There are many angry people in New Orleans that took this personally and they want to find the person who did this to Helen," says Helen's older brother, Jake Hill.



Copyright 2009 CBS. All rights reserved.
Add a Comment See all 28 Comments
by cokowalker October 15, 2007 9:13 PM EDT
New Orleans is a dangerous and corrupt city. It is filled with wonderful people but they seem powerless to overcome the inept officals and so called city leaders who are only interested in covering up the crime instead of protecting the people who live there. If they are safe, the city will be saved.
Crime remains THE roadblock to recovery and those in charge are only interested to minimizing the danger to keep students and tourists coming to the city instead of taking real steps to create a safe city for all residents, not just the wealthy ones who can afford their own private security patrols and the layers of security needed to live and move about the city safely. The true heros of that city are the residents who rebuild in the face of this lack of leadership, of skyhigh insurance and energy rates, they band together with the help from people from ''the outside'' and get things done. Also hats off to the honest police officers serving in conditions that are totally unsupportive. The people of New Orleans know what is important, to band together to reduce crime, too bad the leaders don''t get the same message. Stay safe y''all and stay together!
Reply to this comment
by cokowalker October 15, 2007 8:41 PM EDT
New Orleans is a dangerous and corrupt city. It is filled with wonderful people but they seem powerless to overcome the inept officals and so called city leaders who are only interested in covering up the crime instead of protecting the people who live there. If they are safe, the city will be saved.
Crime remains THE roadblock to recovery and those in charge are only interested to minimizing the danger to keep students and tourists coming to the city instead of taking real steps to create a safe city for all residents, not just the wealthy ones who can afford their own private security patrols and the layers of security needed to live and move about the city safely. The true heros of that city are the residents who rebuild in the face of this lack of leadership, of skyhigh insurance and energy rates, they band together with the help from people from ''the outside'' and get things done. Also hats off to the honest police officers serving in conditions that are totally unsupportive. The people of New Orleans know what is important, to band together to reduce crime, too bad the leaders don''t get the same message. Stay safe y''all and stay together!
Reply to this comment
by nynola-2009 October 15, 2007 8:05 PM EDT
I am sick and tired of the national media''s portrayal of New Orleans as a place where anarchy and lawlessness are pervasive. The murder of Helen Hill is tragic; it is tragic no matter where it happened, be it in New Orleans or New Mexico. Crime is a problem in New Orleans, just as it is in Baltimore, Detroit, or any other one of a number of cities. But New Orleans is a proud city, a city that is rebuilding on the heel of the greatest disaster in American history. Much has already been accomplished. Six years after 9/11, the WTC site still remains empty. By contrast,80% of the pre-storm population of New Orleans is back. Homeowners have started to rebuild in Lakeview, New Orleans East, and St. Bernard Parish. The French Quarter is better than it has been in years. Nowhere else in the country can one find the history, culture, cuisine, and hospitality found in New Orleans. Shame on the media and country for its portrayal of such a great, vital city. I only hope CBS has the courage to not continue to play in to the media bias against New Orleans and run a story about the great things average New Orleanians are doing to rebuild their city despite government apathy and fickle national attention and sensationalism.
Reply to this comment
by nynola-2009 October 15, 2007 8:03 PM EDT
I am sick and tired of the national media''s portrayal of New Orleans as a place where anarchy and lawlessness are pervasive. The murder of Helen Hill is tragic; it is tragic no matter where it happened, be it in New Orleans or New Mexico. Crime is a problem in New Orleans, just as it is in Baltimore, Detroit, or any other one of a number of cities. But New Orleans is a proud city, a city that is rebuilding on the heel of the greatest disaster in American history. Much has already been accomplished. Six years after 9/11, the WTC site still remains empty. By contrast,80% of the pre-storm population of New Orleans is back. Homeowners have started to rebuild in Lakeview, New Orleans East, and St. Bernard Parish. The French Quarter is better than it has been in years. Nowhere else in the country can one find the history, culture, cuisine, and hospitality found in New Orleans. Shame on the media and country for its portrayal of such a great, vital city. I only hope CBS has the courage to not continue to play in to the media bias against New Orleans and run a story about the great things average New Orleanians are doing to rebuild their city despite government apathy and fickle national attention and sensationalism.
Reply to this comment
by jhamiltoniii October 15, 2007 7:01 PM EDT
RE investigating her husband. He was a Dr. dedicated to helping the poor in New Orleans. How anyone could be so thoughtless to suspect this loving husband. If you knew New Orleans as we did (my wife used to live there) it is becoming more and more common for this outrageous behavior in a city that time has forgotten. Would you move to a city, dedicate your life to helping the poor and even live in this area. Shame on you.
Reply to this comment
by jhamiltoniii October 15, 2007 6:58 PM EDT
I did not know about this and Helen was my cousin. Does anyone know how I can obtain a copy of the broadcast. It is important to my family. This is absolutely terrible and to my understanding they dedicated their lives to the impoverished in NO. This is terribly upsetting. I would like to obtain this broadcast.
Reply to this comment
by mikewilliam8 October 15, 2007 1:55 PM EDT
Have the police fully investigated Helen Hill''s husband as a suspect in her murder? Something about his story doesn''t ring true. How convenient that his only description of the "intruder" was a black male. And that his only wounds were superficial. Brings back memories of Charles Stuart who killed his wife, shot himself to make it look like he, too, had been a victim and then blamed it all on a "black man in a track suit."
Reply to this comment
by kmsoap October 15, 2007 1:10 PM EDT
In response to benj2007.

You are correct. The police were just down the street at the B&B when the shots were fired. But they WAITED UNTIL DISPATCHED to respond to live fire in a residential neighborhood.

The NOPD was reeling after the indictment by Eddie Jordan of the Danziger 7, police officers who shot a man in the wake of the storm. Because of this, they were doing the bare minimun required, thus waited to be sent to the scene.

Would they have captured Helen''s murderer if they responded promptly? We will never know. But the odds of them apprehending a viable suspect at this point in the game are very slim indeed.

The people of New Orleans are rebuilding. The common conception is that this has been done with the help of the government, but nothing could be further from the truth. Private citizens and businesses from around the world have donated time and money to assist with the rebuild, but government response has been painfully slow when it comes at all.

A broken dam, earthquake, flood or even a dirty bomb could easily put anyone in America in similar peril. We, as a nation, need to wake up and pay attention. It''s OUR country. Time to take it back.
Reply to this comment
by maggie601 October 15, 2007 12:19 AM EDT
You made New Orleans seem like a scary place. I hope it doesn''t deter volunteers from coming to help rebuild the city because of FEAR. New Orleans has had the highest murder rate before Katrina. The deaths of Dinerral and Helen are truly tragic to a city already struggling just to survive, but the crimes committed against them are not "native" to New Orleans: home invasion and gang-related deaths happen in the best of cities. Getting eye witness testimony in a gang murder when fear of retribution looms can''t be easy for any city court system let alone the one in New Orleans. Kudos, however, to the citizen action against the current violence. Fear sells and that seems to have been the point of your story.
Reply to this comment
by denaye90 October 14, 2007 11:02 PM EDT
This was a wonderful piece.
I am so ANGRY AND OUTRAGED at how people have such little value on life or the lives of others.

The lives of 2 beautiful souls were lost behind IGNORANCE. I''m sure there were plenty of other lives that were just as promising as Mrs. Hill''s and Mr. Shavers lives.

I''m also glad that the citizens decided to march for these murder victims. Keep up the good work New Orleaneans!
Reply to this comment
See all 28 Comments
.
Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
48 Hours New iPad app A perfect companion to TV's most popular true-crime series.
48 Hours on Facebook