February 11, 2009 4:09 PM

Iraq PM: Senate Proposal A "Catastrophe"

(CBS/AP)  Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki on Friday rejected a U.S. Senate proposal calling for the decentralization of Iraq's government and giving more control to the country's ethnically divided regions, calling it a "catastrophe."

The measure, whose primary sponsors included presidential hopeful Sen. Joseph Biden, D-Del., calls for Iraq to be divided into federal regions for the country's Shiite, Sunni and Kurdish communities in a power-sharing agreement similar to Bosnia in the 1990s.

In his first comments since the measure passed Wednesday, al-Maliki strongly rejected the idea, echoing the earlier sentiments of his country's vice president.

"It is an Iraqi affair dealing with Iraqis," he told The Associated Press while on a return flight to Baghdad after appearing at the U.N. General Assembly in New York. "Iraqis are eager for Iraq's unity. ... Dividing Iraq is a problem and a decision like that would be a catastrophe."

Iraq's constitution lays down a federal system, allowing Shiites in the south and Kurds in the north to set up regions with considerable autonomous powers. But Iraq's turmoil has been fueled by the deep divisions among politicians over the details of how it should work, including the division of lucrative oil resources.

Many Shiite and Kurdish leaders are eager to implement the provisions. But the Sunni Arab minority fears being left in an impoverished central zone without resources. Others fear a sectarian split-up would harden the violent divisions among Iraq's fractious ethnic and religious groups.

On Thursday, Iraqi Vice President Adel Abdul-Mahdi said decisions about Iraq must remain in the hands of its citizens and the spokesman for the supporters of radical Shiite cleric Muqtada al-Sadr agreed.

"We demand the Iraqi government to stand against such project and to condemn it officially," Liwa Semeism told the AP. "Such a decision does not represent the aspirations of all Iraqi people and it is considered an interference in Iraq's internal affairs."

In other developments:

  • Turkey and Iraq signed a counterterrorism pact Friday aimed at cracking down on separatist Kurdish rebels who have been attacking Turkey from bases in Iraq. The agreement, however, falls short of meeting Ankara's demand to send troops in pursuit of Kurdish rebels fleeing across the border into northern Iraq, Turkey's Interior Minister Besir Atalay said. "It was not possible to reach a deal on chasing Kurdish rebels, however, we hope this issue will be solved in the future," Atalay said. "We are expecting this cooperation against terrorism to be broadened as much as possible."

  • A military panel on Friday acquitted Spc. Jorge G. Sandoval on charges he killed two unarmed Iraqis, but it convicted him of planting evidence on one of the men in attempt to cover up the shooting. Sandoval, 22, had faced five charges in the April and May deaths of two unidentified men. While prosecutors said Sandoval did nothing to stop the slaughter of unarmed men, his defense lawyers said he was only following the orders of his superiors in both the April and May incidents.

  • South Korea plans to send an assessment team to Iraq next month to help determine whether to end or extend its 1,200-troop mission there, a Defense Ministry official said Friday. The team of about 10 officials will make a weeklong trip to Iraq, and their findings will be reflected in a report to parliament next month.

  • Australia said it has taken command of the multinational naval task force guarding Iraq's two oil terminals in southern Iraq for the third time. The job protecting the vital facilities rotates between Australia, Britain and the United States.

    Iraq's prime minister also said he discussed the role of U.S. troops and private security contractors in the country, stressing that Iraq is a sovereign nation and it should have control over its own security.

    Security "is something related to Iraq's sovereignty and its independence and it should not be violated," he said.

    Al-Maliki's comments come after a Sept. 16 shooting in central Baghdad that killed some 11 Iraqi civilians allegedly at the hands of Blackwater USA guards providing security for American diplomats.

    The North Carolina-based company said its employees were acting in self-defense against an attack by armed insurgents. Iraqi officials and witnesses have said the guards opened fire randomly, killing a woman and an infant along with nine other people, but details have widely diverged.

    In a related story, a congressional investigation publicized Thursday found that Blackwater triggered a major battle in Iraq by sending an unprepared team of security guards into an insurgent stronghold, a move that led to their horrific deaths and a violent response by U.S. forces. (Read more)Peter Singer, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, has been warning about the dangers of relying on private contractors since early in the war, reports CBS News national security correspondent David Martin.

    The Washington Post reported Friday that a preliminary U.S. Embassy report found the shooting involved three Blackwater teams.

    It said one was ambushed near a traffic circle and returned fire before fleeing the scene, another was surrounded by Iraqis when it went to the intersection and had to be extracted by the U.S. military and a third came under fire from eight to 10 people in multiple locations.

    The report said the three teams had been trying to escort a senior U.S. official who had been visiting a "financial compound" back to the U.S.-protected Green Zone when a car bomb struck about 25 yards outside the entrance. The official was unharmed, it said.

    An unnamed U.S. State Department official described the report to the newspaper and stressed it was only an initial account.

    The New York Times also reported Friday that the shootings occurred as Blackwater was trying to evacuate senior American officials with the United States Agency for International Development after an explosion occurred near the guarded compound where they were meeting.

    Participants in the operation said at least one guard continued firing on civilians while colleagues called for the shooting to stop, according to the newspaper's account, which cited American officials who have been briefed on the investigation.

    It also said those involved have told U.S. investigators they believed they were firing in response to enemy gunfire but at least one guard also drew a weapon on a colleague who did not stop shooting.

    American officials have publicly remained mum on their findings pending the results of a series of investigations.
  • © 2009 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.
    Add a Comment See all 109 Comments
    by getloud1 September 30, 2007 2:26 AM EDT
    ***** Stop The War & Restore America *****

    Why Don''t You Know Ron Paul??????

    The corporate media will not give Ron Paul any Exposure. Because, NBC is owned by GE. GE is one of the world''s largest war-makers. They make things that go boom. They make $Billions on war. A Ron Paul administration would be bad for business. CNN is owned by AOL. Majority share holder is Saudi Royal Talal who is also partners with GHWBush in The Carlyle Group. Another major warmaker. And on and on. You get the picture. This is why they are doing a Media Blackout on him.

    Because they don''t WANT YOU TO KNOW THE TRUTH!

    Who is Ron Paul?
    http://www.ronpaul2008.com/about

    Join A ReVoLuTiOn Group In Your City:
    http://ronpaul.meetup.com/cities/

    Ron Paul Has WON 10 Straw-Polls!
    http://www.ronpaul2008.com/straw-poll-results/

    RESTORE YOU LIBERTY & FREEDOM
    SPREAD THE WORD ABOUT RON PAUL 2008!

    ** Stop Iraq War Immediately
    ** Eliminate IRS
    ** Eliminate Federal Reserve
    ** Eliminate Government Wasteful Spending
    ** Restore America''s Work Force & Values
    ** Restore America''s Freedom!

    HE HAS RAISED ALMOST 1 MILLION DOLLARS IN 5 DAYS!
    Check out www.ronpaul2008.com

    GET UP AND GET ACTIVE TODAY!!!
    VOTE RON PAUL 2008!
    Reply to this comment
    by getloud1 September 29, 2007 5:35 PM EDT
    If Americans don%u2019t wake up their will be nothing left, our Nation is broke and Wall Street is the only people making a profit. While the Hidden inflation tax continues to rise and the value of the dollar declines. Ron Paul is the only one who truely understands this, and honestly if he is not elected America should be prepared for a real economic depression like it has never seen before.

    Unless you want a North American Union and a new currency the "Amero" split with Canada and Mexico. And lose all your rights and freedom. Vote For Ron Paul 2008!

    So my advice is to bypass the media and spread the word to your family and friends about him. The power of the People is far greater than a campaign spending 10''s of million to buy an image. Because this man is a real American Hero. He has dedicated his life to this country and everyone in it, and now he is trying to save it from disaster.

    Spread The Word! Go Ron Paul 2008!

    Ron Paul Has Raised 838,000 in 5 Days from people who really love this country and their freedom!

    http://www.ronpaul2008.com

    Join The ReVoLuTiOn:
    http://ronpaul.meetup.com/cities
    Reply to this comment
    by v_1618 September 29, 2007 2:40 PM EDT
    THE NEW PLAN OF BUSH IS TO DIVIDE THE REGION . COME ON MR. BUSH THEY''RE NOT STUPIDS THE ONLY STUPIDS IN THIS WORLD IS YOU MR. PRESIDENT BUSH AND THE PEOPLE WHO''S SUPPOTING YOU .. GET OUT FROM IRAQ IDIOT. YOUR WAR IS ILLEGAL AND YOUR FREEDOM AND DEMOCRACY PUT IT IN YOUR OWN AZZ BAZTARD.....
    Reply to this comment
    by ioweign September 29, 2007 2:26 PM EDT
    Ioweign,

    I think you are a victim of selective reading.

    UN has approved the invasion and that is why US troops and leaders are immune from prosecution. Quote last week used in a CBS article.

    Posted by donbl1 at 08:59 PM : Sep 28, 2007




    War critics astonished as US hawk admits invasion was illegal


    Oliver Burkeman and Julian Borger in Washington
    Thursday November 20, 2003
    The Guardian

    International lawyers and anti-war campaigners reacted with astonishment yesterday after the influential Pentagon hawk Richard Perle conceded that the invasion of Iraq had been illegal.

    In a startling break with the official White House and Downing Street lines, Mr Perle told an audience in London: "I think in this case international law stood in the way of doing the right thing."

    President George Bush has consistently argued that the war was legal either because of existing UN security council resolutions on Iraq - also the British government''s publicly stated view - or as an act of self-defence permitted by international law.

    But Mr Perle, a key member of the defence policy board, which advises the US defence secretary, Donald Rumsfeld, said that "international law ... would have required us to leave Saddam Hussein alone", and this would have been morally unacceptable.

    French intransigence, he added, meant there had been "no practical mechanism consistent with the rules of the UN for dealing with Saddam Hussein".
    Reply to this comment
    by socrates392 September 29, 2007 2:56 AM EDT
    Oh, no, all my wonderful power . . . I''m melting, I''m melting!

    Bye, bye, Maliki!
    Reply to this comment
    by nearl4511 September 29, 2007 2:49 AM EDT
    Mr. al-Maliki is mistaken.

    Noone''s plan for a different form of government for Iraq is a catastrophe. The senate''s plan may be short-sighted, but at least it is a discussion of something different.

    What are catastrophes are (1) the state of the current Iraqi Government, (2) prospects for a viable economy in Iraq without oil production, (3) any chance that the US can be extricated from Iraq in the next decade.

    After the "surge" is drawn back down, there is no forward plan for anything....which is devastating to the Iraqi people, the US military, the US economy, and the next President of the US (and Iraq).
    Reply to this comment
    by klifton2-2009 September 29, 2007 1:49 AM EDT
    To describe the US'' conflict of choice in Iraq as a ''war'' is a misnomer. Iraq never declared war on the US. The US invaded Iraq, period. A more appropriate term would be ''invasion of Iraq.'' The word ''war'' used by Bush and the media serve to deceptively legitimize the conflict, because invasion of a sovereign nation is against international law. Bush and company have committed war crimes and crimes against humanity within the definition under international law. If the US today is a second-rate country, Bush and company would have rounded up to answer for their crimes. The International Court of Justice would then love to get their hands on these criminals. Power comes from the barrel of a gun, and the US has demonstrated this time and time again. American Justice is only for the rich and powerful. Saddam, like Bin Laden, is a product of US global covert operations. Uncle Sam created and supported them when their services were needed. There are no heroes in the US Government, only rogues, scoundrels, and criminals in suit.
    Reply to this comment
    by feelfree1 September 29, 2007 1:22 AM EDT

    CBS,

    Re: The latest on al-CIA''da. They "killed" another "#1". I think that they are hoping that you will hype this nonsense up a bit.

    Re: "Top al-Qaida operative in Iraq killed"

    BAGHDAD, Sept. 28 (UPI) -- U.S. military officials Friday said a top al-Qaida terrorist cell leader in Iraq was killed this week by coalition forces.

    Characterizing him as a "senior foreign al-Qaida terrorist," U.S. Army Brig. Gen. Joseph Anderson, chief of staff of the multinational forces in Iraq, spoke during a press briefing on the death of Abu Usama al-Tunisi, whom the general called "a close associate and part of the inner circle of close advisers to Abu Ayyub al-Masri ... the overall leader of al-Qaida in Iraq."

    ###

    Ooga-booga!
    Reply to this comment
    by seven-pesos September 29, 2007 12:58 AM EDT
    never a war the south couldn''t lose.

    jefferson davis lost his,
    johnson lost his
    bush will lose his.

    the south has lost every war they started.

    idiot southern creeps are only good for sunday afternoon parades

    in their tight-butt uniforms.

    ha,ha,ha.

    war, division, arrogance, phony christian creeps, crooked republican snakes...

    nothing good comes out of the south!
    Reply to this comment
    by v_1618 September 29, 2007 12:47 AM EDT
    OH MY GOD... IF THIS IS THE SENATE PROPOSAL SOLUTION OF THE UNITED STATES GOVERMENT ON IRAQ OH MEN ... MAYBE THE UNITED STATES MUST GET OUT FROM IRAQ NOW BEFORE IT''S TOO LATE.. THIS IS NOT A STUPID GAME.. ALL THE REGION WARNED THE UNITED STATES NOT TO SUPPORT SUNNI MILITIAS BECAUSE THEY''RE VERY DANGEROUS... NOW THE UNITED STATES WANTS THIS MISSION IMPOSSIBLE COME ON. GET OUT FROM THE REGION NOW.. IDIOTS... OR COULD AFFECT U.S. SECURITY...
    Reply to this comment
    See all 109 Comments
    .
    Scroll Left
    Scroll Right More »
    CBS News on Facebook