1 Million Chinese-Made Cribs Recalled
CPSC: Deaths Of 3 Children Linked To Simplicity And Graco Cribs
-
Play CBS Video
Video
Dangerous Cribs Recalled
Almost 1 million cribs have been recalled after three infants have died. Sandra Hughes reports.
-
Photo
(CBS / iStock Photo)
"We were in so much shock," Liam's father Chad Johns told CBS News. "It took a very long time before we could sit down and grieve."
About 1 million Simplicity and Graco cribs are being recalled after Little Liam and two other children became entrapped in their cribs and died of suffocation, the Consumer Product Safety Commission said Friday.
Liam had been sleeping in a Simplicity crib.
A year after Liam's death in 2005, six-month-old Edward Millwood was found dead in his Simplicity crib in Georgia.
The two died in the recalled cribs which were sold through May 2007. A 1-year-old child died in a newer model of the cribs, which has not been recalled but is being investigated by the safety agency, CPSC officials said.
In all three deaths, the consumer had installed the drop-rail side of the crib upside down, the CPSC said. This creates a gap in the crib that children can slide into and suffocate.
Seven other infants have been entrapped in the cribs, according to the CPSC. There have been 55 reports of the cribs' drop sides detaching or the hardware failing to hold the side to the crib.
Simplicity Inc., of Reading, Pa., is listed as manufacturer of all the cribs, which were made in China. The recalled cribs were sold nationwide, under the Simplicity or Graco brands, from January 1998 through May 2007. The recall involves multiple models and model numbers.
It's the largest crib recall in CPSC history, and now the one place parents are told they can safely leave their children without supervision is in question.
"Crib hardware failure is actually one of the most common causes of death in cribs," Nancy Cowles, a crib safety advocate, told CBS News correspondent Sandra Hughes.
In fact, according to Cowles' organization Kids In Danger, 30 children are killed and 1,200 are injured every year in crib accidents.
And while these cribs were made in China, in this case she says China isn't to blame:
"The problem is the design flaws that the U.S. manufacturers designed into the product," Cowles said.
"Simplicity strives to make safe products, that is our number one priority. That's why we worked with the CPSC to take this action," Simplicity president Ken Waldman said in a statement.
In a separate recall in June, the commission recalled about 40,000 Nursery-in-a-Box cribs, manufactured by Simplicity, because the assembly instructions incorrectly explain how to attach the drop side.
None of the cribs that Simplicity currently supplies to stores is included in a recall, the company said in a statement.
The commission, however, cautioned consumers who have the newer versions not covered by the recall to check to make sure the drop side is installed right side up and is securely attached. The newer hardware has a flexible tab at the top of the lower track and a permanent stop at the bottom. The older hardware has a flexible tab at the bottom of the lower tracks.
In an earlier Simplicity recall, a 19-month-old child in Myrtle Creek, Ore., died Jan. 6, 2006, in a crib that carried the Graco logo, the CPSC said in February 2006. Mattress support slats came out of the crib, and the child suffocated after getting trapped between the mattress and the footboard. That type of crib had been included in a December 2005 recall of about 104,000 Aspen 3 in 1 Cribs.
The company is offering free repairs for cribs with older hardware. For more information, consumers can contact Simplicity at (888) 593-9274.
© MMVII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.



- 1
- 2
- next
See all 58 CommentsAnd who designed it and gave those blueprints to the factory?
And if the consumer is installing it improperly, is it due to a bad instruction manual or the people just being dumb, forgive me? I''ve read some badly written manuals, complete with generic or poorly conceived diagrams, but it''s also not beyond my comprehension to know some people have IQs lower than the temperature of liquid nitrogen and not look for obvious mistakes... especially if it''s something for children; we''re supposed to cherish life, right?
THE BUSH ADMINISTATION, AND IT''S FAILURE TO ENFORCE SAFETY LAWS AND REGULATIONS, AND THE LACK OF SAFETY INSPECTORS, HAS ALLOWED THIS COUNTRY TO BE FLOODED WITH DANGEROUS AND DEFECTIVE PRODUCTS FROM CHINA.
THIS ADMINISTRATION HAS PUT OUR CHILDREN AT RISK, AND HAS A TOTAL DISREGARD FOR THE SAFETY OF THE AMERICAN PEOPLE.
WE SHOULD ALL BE OUTRAGED, AND DEMAND THIS PRESIDENT TO STEP IN AND PUT A STOP TO THE KILLING OF OUR CHILDREN AND PETS, BY CHINA.
STAY THE COURSE (MY ARSE) IT''S TIME FOR ACTION......
It won''t be long, the jobs that once left our country for cheaper wages, will soon return. For the wages are going up in other countries and corporations here in the States will see the cost of doing business is too costly through recalls, the need to pay more for shipping, etc.
STAY THE COURSE.............
Had they had the proper checks and balnces in place this may not of happened. Believe me I feel that we should bring more of our production back home and get off our lazy assests but until than companies need to be held accountable for the safety of there products not keep deflecting the blame.
Second, correct me if I am wrong, but I believe that there have been major recalls of cribs and strollers even when they were being manufactured in the U.S.
Finally, this recall is a drop in the bucket when compared to the total volume of goods manufactured in China.
The profit margin realized from manufacturing in China must be enormous; enormous enough to make our Business "leaders" into kow-towing supplicants of China.
And with so many media sources hyping up China and its "1.3 billion shoppers" (and media pirates, where one can buy a DVD for $1 over there and never mind all the software opportunities we''re missing out on...) all those Americans who put in hard work, just to see their jobs offshored to a country, of which more and more of their products are being made toxic or will break down around the time the warranty expires... who''s telling them to use lead paint and cheap capacitors? We just tell them how to make it; they do the actual work. There are problems in both sides, but most of the problems have less to do with "design flaws" than they do toxic materials.
Tell me where I''m wrong; I have been before.
Time to boycott all Mattel products. I will not pay extra for the mistakes that Mattel has brought on itself.
Ahhhh....so it was these company''s management that, in their push for cheaper, cheaper, cheaper, were really at fault.
Well, that''s ok then. Just as long as it isn''t some FOREIGN Business killing our children.
Darwin awards for all three please, at least since stupidity and failure to read instructions is genetic, they can''t pass along their STUPIDITY genes to those 3 who will in turn grow up and do things like drinking anti-freeze thinking it''s cool-aid because it''s green.
Posted by krotec54"
Good luck- EVERYTHING is made in China now, better actually read ALL the labels on every part. Their economy is BOOMING, the Euro is BOOMING while the US dollars sinks to $1.40 for 1 Euro, we are now like Canada was to the USA for the exchange rate- thanks to BUSH.
"poisonous detachable magnets"
ibsteve2u
Magnets are not ''poisonous'', the danger comes from swallowing TWO or more which attract one another thru the intestinal walls and can cause problems.
Be happy - Americans.
Be proud - Americans - enjoy everything labeled "Made in China" - (pet) food, (auto) tires, (baby) cribs...etc.
Foreign goods and labor are "Good for you"!
Americans - repeat after me - goods and labor "from China" are "Good for you"!
Be sure to thank GWB - all these wonderful things/events happened under his watch!
A little bit toe tapping/dancing here and there - "Happy days are here again"!
Isn''''t life grand?
Thank you - GWB - you make our lives complete!
Posted by Simplemind2
Vitamins and prescription drugs probably more it is coming out after we die toys with lead. See these corp. only care about the bottom line cheap labor, no laws to control them and no port inspections ain''t we lucky folks we have a leader that loves and takes care of his corporations NOV.08 remember all this
Posted by kkwas
The people will yell and scream but go right out and buy at Walmart but I have to say we sometimes can''t tell if Made In China is on all products but everything at Walmart just about comes from China
STAY THE COURSE.............
Posted by crater7 at 04:35 PM : Sep 21, 2
ROTFLMAO
Posted by WCBS4
WE OWE SO MUCH TO CHINA FOR THIS WAR THAT THEY PROBABLY WILL FORCLOSE ON US THANKS TO OUR LEADER
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Posted by starleo146
1.3 trillion of our debt is owed to China and counting.
Seriously, we need to boycott things made in China, but then Walmart would just lie to us again. Remember when Walmart bragged that everything they sold was ''made in America''? Then Walmart got busted.
...China has made our bed, now we must lie in it.
(Oh, there are so many inferences that can be drawn from that statement above)!
The short answer in NO!
Corruption is a way of life over there and all those dumb U.S. companies thinking they would reap windfalls in profits by outsourcing to China are now taking it on the chin, and deservedly so!
It is stated that "in all three deaths, the consumer had installed the drop-rail side of the crib upside down, the CPSC said."
The idiots (READ AMERICANS) installed the thing wrong now it is "CHINA''s FAULT" ?! ***??
And :
"The problem is the design flaws that the U.S. manufacturers designed into the product," Cowles said.
The fault lies in the design, which is designed by AMERICANS. YEP, AMERICANS. And yet the news blow it out of proportion to highlight China, which is unfair bias with racist overtone.
China should eventually be worried about Al Quaeda, but if the number of poisoned products continues (the Mattel toys'' magnets (but not the lead paint) and arguably this crib excluded because a designer may have more of the pertinent blame), global market consumers will rightly avoid China like they would the bubonic plague and the multinational companies will HAVE to relocate in order to save face. China is arguably in a worse position than the US thanks to deadly pet food, antifreeze-laden toothpaste, tainted human food, amongst other things...
Mechanically inclined?? this is a CRIB, you put bolt ''A" into slot ''B'' and tighten the nut, real rocket science there!
If someone is THAT stupid they shouldnt be breeding, Im serious, anyone who cant assemble a SIMPLE freaking thing like a baby crib needs mental help or to go back to grade school, this isn''t a computer controlled fuel injected car engine!
You only need to attain a level as high as ''idiot'' status in education to assemble something like a CRIB!
Someone who puts it together upside down should check out and save the rest of us from your stuidity.
These companies have become nothing more than a marketing entity for Chinese manufacturers. They only advertise, sell, and collect money and outsource everyting else to china with total ignorance to safety of their products.
Blame has to be shared by irresponsible companies who sell garbage and are only too ready to point fingers and the sky falls.
Prescott Bush
Chairman, U.S.-China Chamber of Commerce;
U.S.-China Chamber of Commerce - The membership roster includes United Airlines, American Express, McDonald''s, Ford and Arthur Andersen,
the Beleaguered company that audited Enron''s books.
These companies that do business in China - Have got to be paying some form of tribute to Prescott Bush.
Any person - Who enjoys - $9.00 a month - Slave Labor - Who also Allows - Lead Painted Toys - Defective Merchandise - Tainted and Poisoned Food Stuffs -
To be shipped to the US. - Intended for use and consumption by the American consumer and their children.
Knowing all the while - The Ratifications - of Poisoned Food - Lead Poisoning and potentially Defective and Hazardous products.
Knowing this - Yet - Continues to Allow those imports.
Needs to be : Held personally Responsible and Criminally charged and Prosecuted
Prescott Bush connections to an American firm, Asset Management, came into question in 1989, The company was the Only U.S. firm able to - Skirt - U.S. sanctions and import Communications (Spy ??) Satellites into China.
The FBI as well as the Justice Department - Has always worked on Behalf of the Political and Financial Objectives of the Republican (Nazi) party
With this incident - They are about to prove once again - Their Loyalty to The Republican (Nazi) Party
Lastdance
"The drop-side failures result from both the hardware and crib design, which allow consumers unintentionally to install the drop-side upside down."
Proper design would have brackets that could not be mounted incorrectly - they simply wouldn''t fit if assembled wrong.
Of course, it is cheaper to make four identical brackets, although I do not know if that is what happened in this case. For some reason you can''t get to the assembly instructions on Simplicity''s web site anymore.
DEMONIC-RATS SOLD THE USA OUT TO CHINA!!!
The tale of shady Chinese Clinton donors avoiding U.S. justice is a familiar one that dates back to the 1996 Clinton-Gore fundraising scandal known as Chinagate. The Clintons took millions in laundered foreign campaign donations from Chinese Communists in exchange for liberalizing trade policy with China, dropping pending indictments against influential Chinese figures, spots on a U.S. trade mission and overnight stays at the White House.
Many of the Chinagate donors were successfully prosecuted even though Clinton Attorney General Janet Reno blocked investigators%u2019 efforts at the Justice Department. More than 100 people connected to the fundraising scandal fled the country, however. Norman Hsu seems to be following their lead.
http://www.corruptionchronicles.com/2007/09/hillary_donor_flees_like_china.html
INVESTIGATION OF ILLEGAL OR IMPROPER ACTIVITIES
IN CONNECTION WITH 1996 FEDERAL ELECTION CAMPAIGNS
FINAL REPORT of the COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS
SENATE Rept. 105-167 - 105th Congress 2d Session - March 10, 1998
The China Connection: Summary of the Committee''s Findings Relating to Efforts of the People''s Republic of China to Influence U.S. Policies and Elections
The individuals who facilitated the contributions have either elected to take the Fifth Amendment or flee the country. Beijing has denied the Committee''s request for assistance. Moreover, after its hearings concluded, the Committee learned that the Chinese leadership was pleased no PRC agencies have yet been implicated in the campaign finance scandal.
http://www.fas.org/irp/congress/1998_rpt/sgo-sir/2-18.htm
Democratic Donor a No Show at Hearing
http://apnews.myway.com/article/20070906/D8RFKG500.html
Dems Dirty Donor Norman Hsu Fails to Show for Bail Reduction Hearing Leading to Speculation He''s On the Run
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,295828,00.html
china buys usa elections???
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=chinese+campaign contributions democrat
Big Source of Clinton''s Cash Is an Unlikely Address
Family''s Donations Closely Track Those Of Top Fund-Raiser
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB118826947048110677.html?mod=hpp_us_whats_news
Report: Hillary Clinton Big Money Donor Wanted for Grand Theft
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=Hillary Clinton Big Money Donor Wanted for Grand Theft&btnG=Search
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,295031,00.html
Leading Clinton Donor Stays Below the Radar
http://online.wsj.com/public/article/SB118835199704811801.html?mod=blog
''DIRTY CASH'' MAN FLEES
http://www.nypost.com/seven/03042007/news/nationalnews/pro_clinton_dirty_cash_man_flees_nationalnews_christine_field.htm
RNC pushing the China angle
http://www.politico.com/blogs/bensmith/0807/RNC_Pushing_the_China_angle.html
Democrats Turn From Big Donor Who%u2019s Fugitive
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/31/us/politics/31hsu.html?ei=5065&en=c3f5afa614172532&ex=1189224000&partner=MYWAY&pagewanted=print
Get off the net ! ! !
lars008
Only posts Spam to - Aggravate people and to
draw Attention to himself
Very Lonely and Pathetic person
Lastdance
FBI arrests 11 NJ officials for bribery
All of them are Democrats.
http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2007/09/fbi_arrests_11_nj_officials_fo.html
systemic corruption in the Democratic Party
Corruption sting crosses N.J.
12 charged in a widening investigation that began with contracts in an Atlantic County school district.
http://www.philly.com/inquirer/local/20070907_Corruption_sting_crosses_N_J_.html
Hillary campaign honcho among 11 busted in N.J. sting
http://www.nydailynews.com/news/wn_report/2007/09/07/2007-09-07_hillary_campaign_honcho_among_11_busted_.html
11 Arrested in N.J. Corruption Inquiry
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/07/nyregion/06corruptCND.html?em&ex=1189310400&en=b504d6c2fbd19cba&ei=5087%0A
Castro''s tip: Clinton-Obama the winning ticket
http://www.reuters.com/article/politicsNews/idUSN2825114320070829?feedType=RSS&feedName=politicsNews&rpc=22&sp=true
Kathleen Willey: Clintons stole my manuscript
House burglary over weekend targeted copy of book days after details leaked to press
http://www.worldnetdaily.com/staticarticles/article57498.html
- 1
- 2
- next
See all 58 Comments