February 11, 2009 4:16 PM

Paying Musical Homage To The Greats

By
CBSNews
(CBS)  Fans at the sold-out Hilton in Atlantic City could hardly believe their ears: Forty years after their last official concert, the Beatles, it seemed, were back.

But of course, it wasn't John, Paul, George and Ringo onstage a few weeks ago. It was Steve, Joey, Joe and Ralph (and a fifth fake Beatle, Mark). They are the members of Rain, one of the world's premiere tribute bands.

"I liken it to the authors of Beatles books," Steve told CBS News correspondent Antony Mason. "They write out their stories to try to explain to the world what the Beatles were like at that time. We do the same thing, only on stage using their music."

Song after song, note for note, Rain tries to "become" the Beatles, from "Sgt. Pepper" through the "White Album" and beyond. And it seems to work.

"Close your eyes and just listen to these guys and you're listening to the Beatles," a father who went to the show with his daughter said.

"I love it because it's almost like being able to go back and see the real Beatles on tour. It's like stepping back in time," a woman said.

If you thought tribute bands were nothing but cheesy wanna-bes in sequined Elvis costumes, think again. Rain will sell 100,000 tickets this year, and the competition among rock legend imitators is fierce. There are no fewer than 50 Beatles tribute bands in this country alone, with names like 1964, Get Back, and the Bootleg Beatles. There's the Fab 4, the Fab 5 and even the Fab Faux. They are first-rate musicians who make a living playing second-hand music.

"I think the potential is gigantic," said concert promoter Jeff Parry. "The audience satisfaction is so cool. Because you see people coming out and they're just blown away. They've had so much fun."

For Parry, who has been promoting concerts for 30 years, his fastest-growing product is three tribute bands: Rain, The Led Zeppelin Experience, and The Pink Floyd Experience.

"The music's, as they say, 'classic,' right?" he said. "I mean, people are still going to hear Beethoven and Hayden, etc. If this is the same sort of thing, it's classic music, it's survived the ages. And so people wanna see it. They can buy the records, download it, but the inevitable experience is seeing something live."

If you can't afford $200 bucks for a ticket to the Stones, go see the band Satisfaction. Need a dose of Aerosmith? A fix of Hendrix? Partial to Kiss? Name the band; there are a dozen clones out there playing their music. Led Zeppelin bands are everywhere. There's even an all-female band called Lez Zeppelin.

"Once the name arrived there was no not doing it," lead guitarist Steph Paynes said. "I have to say I think it's one of the best band names ever. There's a complete skepticism, and really what it is is sexism, which exists. That sort of works in our favor. They don't really expect to see the real thing and then you can see it on their faces as we begin to play."

The name is intentionally irreverent, which lead singer Sara McLellan says fits the music.

"We're not trying to be gimmicky. I'm not wearing a blond, curly wig and trying to be like Robert (Plant)," she said. "We're keeping the truth and integrity of what they were doing so people who are fans of Led Zeppelin, and are real passionate honest-to-God fans, can come and see us and feel like they have that same experience, you know?"

Who wouldn't want to experience Bruce Springsteen up close and personal in a small New Jersey bar? While the Boss has moved on to stadiums, Matt Ryan gladly fills in. Springsteen was born in the U.S.A. and Ryan was born in Toronto, but even at an early age, his friends saw a resemblance.

"It was very frustrating for me, because ever since I was 17, maybe 16 years old, been nicknamed 'Boss,' 'Boss,' from high school on, and I didn't like it. We all want to be individuals," he said.

An accomplished musician, he tried to make it as Matt Ryan, but could not escape the Bruce comparisons.

"Everything I seemed to do in my life came down to, 'Yeah, when you start singing when it's all coming together, you really look like Bruce,'" he said.

So he "became" Bruce and his career took off. The key to success, he says, is not taking it too seriously.

"We've managed to get the idea across that we have a sense of humor about this thing, about what we're doing and we're up here partying and enjoying these tunes as much as they are," Ryan said. "It's really just performance art with a slant of comedy, and good hearted kick-up-your-heels fun."

So much fun even Clarence Clemmons, the real saxophonist in the real Springsteen's E. Street Band, caught the act and posed with Ryan after the show. And as for Springsteen himself?

"He knows what we're doing," Ryan said. "He's seen the Web site. He knows all about us, his management does, and the fact that he's left us alone, just making jokes about me on stage every now and then, is perfect. It's like, 'Okay, he got you,' I hope."

Tribute bands must pay licensing fees for the songs they borrow, but don't otherwise share the profits, and while the original artists rarely endorse their imitators, they don't discourage them, either.

"Let's face it - having all these tribute/experience acts, whatever out there, it just increases their brand," Ryan said. "They're gonna sell more records, T-shirts, etc. It's almost free advertising for them. We're spreading their brand continually, so it's good for them."

The golden age of rock 'n' roll may be fading and many of the legends are gone, but the music will live on as long as people want to hear it. There will always be someone willing to play it.

Copyright 2009 CBS. All rights reserved.
Add a Comment
by npmclarry June 29, 2008 1:17 PM EDT
If you think these guys are good, you should see THE KLOCKS from San Antonio, Texas. These guys play everything and sound just like the original. Puts the ones your showed on tv this morning to shame. Come on down and check it out for yourself. Or go to their website....www.theklocks.com You are really going to be surprised!
Reply to this comment
by LindaS825 September 12, 2007 12:44 AM EDT
Rain is, by far, as musicians and performers, the best Beatles tribute band ever. My friends and I have gone to many of their performances and Rain never ceases to amaze their audience. Liverpool Legends... sorry, mate, they don''t even come close -- regardless if Louise Harrison endorses them. Put on a Beatles record and then listen to Rain... that''s all I have to say. The way the music is played and sung says it all.
Reply to this comment
by craigandtoni September 11, 2007 11:05 PM EDT
The members of Rain are a class act. The greatest Beatles Tribute you will find. We have seen this group many times over the past several years, and they never fail to impress. Not only do they perform the Beatle''s "Classics", but cover the majority of their vast catalogue as well. Each show is different. You never know what songs they will pull out of the hat. If you ever get the chance to see them, you will be blown away by their spot-on performance!
Reply to this comment
by bbloodvessel September 11, 2007 3:12 PM EDT
you have got to be kidding. Liverpool Legends was one of the WORST tributes I have ever seen! 1964 and the Fab Four (California/Vegas)and Rain are BY FAR the best out there. We drove all the way from Florida just to see them, and it was the silliest thing we have ever witnessed. The Lennon fellow sounded like Tiny Tim (with a low voice), the Paul was drunk or something, and Louise Harrison babbled on about who knows what, but it was nothing to do with the Beatles. The show was a complete horror. We were MORE than dissapointed. Poor George! They even had a guy doing Ed Sullivan-AND BARNEY FIFE!?!?!?! There''s a lot of good Beatle Shows out there, but Liverpool Legends ISN''T one of them.
Reply to this comment
by songman57-2009 September 10, 2007 4:28 PM EDT
One of the Best Tribute Beatle Band I have ever heard is The Liverpool Legends now playing in Branson Mo. Listen to 1 minute of the first song and you feel like you''re hearing the Next best thing to the real thing!(George Harrisons sister Hosts the show!!
I''m not old enough to have seen the Beatles, but the liverpool Legends give me an understanding of how Great the Beatles music is and what it must have been like to see them!

Ya! Ya! Ya!
Reply to this comment
by jabone12 September 10, 2007 3:48 PM EDT
I grew up with the Beatles music, but really appreciated it through my late husband''s love of it. I am so pleased you mentioned the tribute band, The Fab Five. I have heard them several times & their most recent accomplishment was phenominal. They played the ''Sgt. Pepper Album'' from start to finish at an outdoor venue, Papermill Island,in Baldwinsville, New York to benefit the Carol Baldwin Breast Cancer Research Fund. It was a fantastic event, called "All You Need is Liverpool" which will become an annual affair (the Fab Five hails from Liverpool, NY). They hosted Gerry & the Pacemakers & displayed Sir Paul McCartney''s hot rod in Memory of Linda McCartney! Everyone was blown away! The Fab Five was honored to perform at the Cavern Club in Liverpool, England in summer 2006. They plan to return in the near future. If you''re around central New York, be sure to check them out live or at www.thefab-five.com. - Pink
Reply to this comment
by amcpower September 10, 2007 1:24 AM EDT
To all those gravitating in the world of tribute bands,

My name is Martin Courtemanche. I am the president-founder of www.tributerockfest.com : a festival waiting for a messiah to resurrect it and a city to host it!!!

Anybody interested in this kind of project please contact me at info@tributerockfest.com

I seek no monetary compensation, seeing my festival being resurrected is all I''m hoping for and that will be plenty reward for me!!!

Martin Courtemanche
www.tributerockfest.com
Reply to this comment
by acelian2007 September 9, 2007 10:41 PM EDT
Choosing Lez Zeppelin as your only Led Zeppelin Tribute for an interview is like choosing a female impersonator for an Elvis tribute. It''s obvious that you did not do your research or give any of the other Led Zep tributes any respect, if you did you would realize two things that Lez Zeppelin will never be able to provide the serious Led Zep fan. The first is Lez Zep rarely plays the same room twice except for a few high density metropolitan crowds that satisfied their caranaval style audience. Second is that they will never be able to give the audience the masculinity that is required. Cmon Robert plant was a god in his time not a Goddess, its like having Bret Michaels trying to do a Janis Joplin tribute. Next time you want steak try using meat instead of a meat subtsitute.
Reply to this comment
by cmp271 September 9, 2007 8:52 PM EDT
Being copied is the finest form of flattery.

How do we think Mozart and Beethoven must feel, knowing their music is constantly being played.

The Beatles will always be The Beatles. Imitators do a good job at it. It also shows how overpriced the concerts are now, and no one is allowed to get close to the name brand players. This way consumers can experience the music and feel closer to the groups. Of course, going to Liverpool helps, I feel closer to the individual Beatles after seeing for myself how they grew up and what they came from. Very poor poverty really.
Reply to this comment
.
Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook