WASHINGTON, Sept. 6, 2007

Virus Is Newest Suspected Bee-Killer

Scientists Say The Israeli Acute Paralysis Virus Is Suspected Of Killing Billions Of Honeybees

  • Play CBS Video Video The Disappearing Bees

    Only On The Web: Beekeepers throughout the country are reporting a massive die-off of their hives, and researchers are still trying to figure out why this is happening. John Blackstone reports.

  • Video Where Have All The Bees Gone?

    A national taskforce is analyzing hive samples to see why bees around the country are disappearing. Beekeepers in 35 states are reporting a large drop-off in numbers. John Blackstone reports.

    • A virus previously unknown in the United States is the newest suspect in the deaths of billions of honeybees. Photo

      A virus previously unknown in the United States is the newest suspect in the deaths of billions of honeybees.  (AP)

    • Field collection materials for forensic samples from honeybee colonies. Photo

      Field collection materials for forensic samples from honeybee colonies.  (AP Photo/Science)

    Previous slide Next slide
  • Photo Essay Amazing Mazes

    Just in time for fall, creative cornfields are cropping up across the U.S.

  • Interactive The Nation We Live In

    Who are Americans and what do they do? A comprehensive look at our economic, sociological and racial breakdown.

(AP)  Scientific sleuths have a new suspect for what's been killing billions of honeybees: a virus previously unknown in the United States.

The scientists report using a novel genetic technique and old-fashioned statistics to identify Israeli acute paralysis virus as the latest potential culprit in the widespread deaths of worker bees, a phenomenon known as colony collapse disorder.

Next up are attempts to infect honeybees with the newfound virus to see if it's indeed a killer.

"At least we have a lead now we can begin to follow. We can use it as a marker and we can use it to investigate whether it does in fact cause disease," said Dr. W. Ian Lipkin, a Columbia University epidemiologist and co-author of the study. Details appear this week in Science Express, the online edition of the journal Science.

Experts stressed that parasitic mites, pesticides and poor nutrition all remain in the lineup of suspects, as does the stress of travel. Beekeepers shuffle bees around the nation throughout the year so they can pollinate crops as they come into bloom. The newfound virus may prove to have added nothing more than insult to the injuries bees already suffer, said several experts unconnected to the study.

"This may be a piece or a couple of pieces of the puzzle, but I certainly don't think it is the whole thing," said Jerry Hayes, chief of the apiary section of the Florida department of agriculture.

Still, surveys of honeybees from decimated colonies turned up traces of the virus nearly every time; bees untouched by the phenomenon were virtually free of it. That means finding the virus should be a red flag that a hive is at risk and merits being quarantined, scientists said.

"The authors themselves recognize it's not a slam dunk, it's correlative. But it's certainly more than a smoking gun - more like a smoking arsenal. It's very compelling," said May Berenbaum, a University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign entomologist.

The mysterious deaths have struck between 50 percent and 90 percent of commercial honeybee hives in the United States, sowing fears about the effects on the more than 90 crops that rely on bees to pollinate them.

Scientists previously have found blasting emptied hives with radiation apparently kills whatever infectious agent that causes the disorder. That has focused their attention on viruses, bacteria and the like, to the exclusion of other noninfectious phenomena, like cell phone interference, also proposed as culprits.

The earliest reports of colony collapse disorder date to 2004, the same year the virus was first described by Israeli virologist Ilan Sela. That also was the year U.S. beekeepers began importing bees from Australia - a practice that had been banned by the Honeybee Act of 1922.

Now, Australia is being eyed as a potential source of the virus. That could turn out to be an ironic twist, since the Australian imports were meant to bolster, not further damage, U.S. bee populations devastated by another scourge, the varroa mite. Meanwhile, officials are discussing reinstating the ban, said the Agriculture Department's top bee scientist, Jeff Pettis.

In the new study, a team of nearly two dozen scientists used the genetic sequencing equivalent of a dragnet to round up suspects. The technique, called pyrosequencing, generates a list of the full repertoire of genes in bees they examined from U.S. hives and directly imported from Australia.

By separating out the bee genes and then comparing the leftover genetic sequences to others detailed in public databases - a move akin to running a suspect's fingerprints - the scientists could pick out every fungus, bacterium, parasite and virus harbored by the bees.

They then looked for each pathogen in bees collected from normal hives and others affected by colony collapse disorder. That statistical comparison showed Israeli acute paralysis virus was strongly associated with the disorder.

The technique is a model for investigating outbreaks of infectious diseases in people too, since it can rapidly pinpoint likely causes, Lipkin said.

Sela, a Hebrew University of Jerusalem professor, said he will collaborate with U.S. scientists on studying how and why the bee virus may be fatal. Preliminary research shows some bees can integrate genetic information from the virus into their own genomes, apparently giving them resistance, Sela said in a telephone interview. Sela added that about 30 percent of the bees he's examined had done so.

Those naturally "transgenic" honeybees theoretically could be propagated to create stocks of virus-resistant insects, Lipkin said.


© MMVII The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Video and Galleries from SciTech

Add a Comment See all 34 Comments
by boldwin223 September 6, 2007 4:03 PM PDT
This is the natural order of things. Human beings just can''t except the concept that "What don''t kill you will make you strong".
Reply to this comment
by feelfree1 September 6, 2007 4:28 PM PDT

Re: "That statistical comparison showed Israeli acute paralysis virus was strongly associated with the disorder."

Do the Israelis ever stop thinking up new ways to harm Americans?
Reply to this comment
by bobnjersey September 6, 2007 4:42 PM PDT
[The authors themselves recognize it''s not a slam dunk, it''s correlative. But it''s certainly more than a smoking gun %u2014 more like a smoking arsenal. It''s very compelling]

smoking gun, smoking arsenal and slam dunk now are part of an official scientific hierarchy?
Reply to this comment
by spammi1 September 6, 2007 4:51 PM PDT
I''ll bee hornswoggled!!
Reply to this comment
by pepperp1 September 6, 2007 5:00 PM PDT



TOOOOO EASY, but the next President does need to look at the US Arab Israel policy. And Israel needs to move the settlers out of the occupied territories this behavior with a nod and a wink just inflames the region. Americas primary strategic interest in the Region is oil and our foreign aid and policies need to reflect that priority. And contrary to popular belief it is the American People who tell our elected officials what to do a reminder that appears overdue for the politicians and the lobbyist.

Hopefully a cure is coming the price of food will skyrocket.
Reply to this comment
by missingamerica September 6, 2007 5:04 PM PDT
Say what? Homeland Security let us down?

They''re supposed to be handling honey bee imports!

http://www.91101.com/laws/homeland-security-act.html

Weird, huh?

Wonder what lobbyist paid who, or who got promised what?

Some Republican get promised the position of Queen of the Honey Festival?
Reply to this comment
by ioweign September 6, 2007 5:07 PM PDT
smoking gun, smoking arsenal and slam dunk now are part of an official scientific hierarchy?
Posted by bobnjersey at 04:42 PM : Sep 06, 2007

Only for Wanna Bees !
Reply to this comment
by rray52 September 6, 2007 5:35 PM PDT
%u201CSmoking Gun%u201D %u201CSmoking Arsenal%u201D %u201CRock Snot%u201D CBS is the %u201CSlam Dunk%u201D winner of the creative writing award.
Reply to this comment
by jwhitmann September 6, 2007 5:44 PM PDT
A virus, huh


This will **** off the congregation of the
Church of Global Warming..

"Hail mother, full of Gore,
thou art blessed amongst liberal idiots"

LOL
Reply to this comment
by missingamerica September 6, 2007 6:08 PM PDT
Anybody feel like enlightning the bogus version of j-whitmann on what global temperature changes can do to the spread of diseases and the habitat range of their vectors?

No? Me, either.
Reply to this comment
by sjw1253 September 6, 2007 8:03 PM PDT

I am surprised that no one at CBS has been more creative in their title of this story...

I think it should have been titled "The Plight of the Honeybee"...
Reply to this comment
by nggr September 6, 2007 9:06 PM PDT
those jews are gonna have to pay the bees reparations for the holocost they hve put on them.


also, i think this means we have to give israel another 30 billion. its in the jewish lobbyist rulebook.
anytime a major news network says
"israel" we owe them 30 billion.
Reply to this comment
by mrhoppy-2009 September 7, 2007 12:53 AM PDT
Israel is a major produce producer and a bio weapon maker. Did they wipe out their competition by releasing a virus?

Would not surprise me a bit since they were behind 911 and everything else that is wrong with America.
Reply to this comment
by endofempire September 7, 2007 2:02 AM PDT
Disease vectors are affected by climate changes, removing some and adding others. The relationship you refer to, however, is not a direct one by any stretch of the imagination since, for instance, if a disease is carried by bats and that species of bats rejects the heat and migrates North, the vector may actually disappear. Of course, given that we are probably in a cycle, such as the one the earth went through in the 1100-1300s, when wine was produced in England, then the cooler weather could eventually return. If you google cold weather and Argentina, you will read they have had snow in Buenos Aires, which they had not seen since 1918!
Reply to this comment
by drinuk September 7, 2007 4:50 AM PDT
We need look no further than GM crops to determine the loss of another of God''s creatures. Monsanto have a hand in this, their evil knows no boundaries.
Reply to this comment
by rafterman1 September 7, 2007 7:15 AM PDT
"Hail mother, full of Gore,
thou art blessed amongst liberal idiots"

How pathetic does someone have to be to log in with a fake name? Really sad.

But it''s ironic that liberals are called idiots when it is the neocons denying science. Hilarious.


Reply to this comment
by jwhitmann September 7, 2007 8:07 AM PDT
A virus, huh


This will **** off the congregation of the
Church of Global Warming..

"Hail mother, full of Gore,
thou art blessed amongst liberal idiots"

LOL

Reply to this comment
by jwhitmann September 7, 2007 8:07 AM PDT
A virus, huh


This will **** off the congregation of the
Church of Global Warming..

"Hail mother, full of Gore,
thou art blessed amongst liberal idiots"

LOL

Reply to this comment
by jwhitmann September 7, 2007 8:07 AM PDT
A virus, huh


This will **** off the congregation of the
Church of Global Warming..

"Hail mother, full of Gore,
thou art blessed amongst liberal idiots"

LOL

Reply to this comment
by jwhitmann September 7, 2007 8:07 AM PDT
A virus, huh


This will **** off the congregation of the
Church of Global Warming..

"Hail mother, full of Gore,
thou art blessed amongst liberal idiots"

LOL

Reply to this comment
by jwhitmann September 7, 2007 8:07 AM PDT
A virus, huh


This will **** off the congregation of the
Church of Global Warming..

"Hail mother, full of Gore,
thou art blessed amongst liberal idiots"

LOL

Reply to this comment
by jwhitmann September 7, 2007 8:07 AM PDT
A virus, huh


This will **** off the congregation of the
Church of Global Warming..

"Hail mother, full of Gore,
thou art blessed amongst liberal idiots"

LOL

Reply to this comment
by jwhitmann September 7, 2007 8:07 AM PDT
A virus, huh


This will **** off the congregation of the
Church of Global Warming..

"Hail mother, full of Gore,
thou art blessed amongst liberal idiots"

LOL

Reply to this comment
by jwhitmann September 7, 2007 8:07 AM PDT
A virus, huh


This will **** off the congregation of the
Church of Global Warming..

"Hail mother, full of Gore,
thou art blessed amongst liberal idiots"

LOL

Reply to this comment
by aznyron-2009 September 7, 2007 8:40 AM PDT
it is sad I do hope they find a cure for these wonderful little creatures of nature and find it fast we need them more than than need us sadly I see people swat them out of fear leave them be and they will reward you with wonderful flowers ETC of all the insects we need the bees for our survival
Reply to this comment
by flreason September 7, 2007 9:24 AM PDT
jwhitmann: Your practice of spamming your comments suggests that you think that repetition bolsters the effect your opinion. Instead, it only reinforces the perception that your prejudice is exceeded only by your insecurity.

I''m relieved that a viral source for the problem has been identified--among other factors that aggravated the situation. There aren''t enough natural pollenators to offset the devastating effect their die-off has had on domestic and world agriculture.

I''m also concerned about global warming. I withhold my judgment about whether it''s a natural phenomenon associated with sun cycles, or manmade. The important thing is that there is a consensus that the warming is real. Whatever the cause, we need to deal with the effects to avoid a worldwide dust bowl type of depression.

That''s just common sense--something you seem to overlook in your constant need to attack and smear anyone whose politics don''t agree with yours.
Reply to this comment
by jwhitmann September 7, 2007 9:38 AM PDT
FLREASON

Science is based on facts, NOT consensus.

Remember your history,
at one time, it was scientific CONSENSUS that the earth was the center of the universe, and the sun revolved around the earth.

Until a fellow by the name of Copernicus came along and proved the consensus WRONG.




PS

Maybe the dingo''s ate your beebees.

LOL

Reply to this comment
by jwhitmann September 7, 2007 9:38 AM PDT
FLREASON

Science is based on facts, NOT consensus.

Remember your history,
at one time, it was scientific CONSENSUS that the earth was the center of the universe, and the sun revolved around the earth.

Until a fellow by the name of Copernicus came along and proved the consensus WRONG.




PS

Maybe the dingo''s ate your beebees.

LOL

Reply to this comment
by Krazcarl September 7, 2007 12:05 PM PDT
Thanks anzyron well put we need to help these creatures if we can the book says god gave us dominion that means take care of not extermenate and lets face it were interdependant. Who doesn''t like honey.
Reply to this comment
by zootallures2 September 7, 2007 1:09 PM PDT
Bomb Israel. The hate our feebees
Reply to this comment
by lastdance2 September 7, 2007 2:36 PM PDT
The - Federal Government - Has been purposely and intentionally killing people in the United States with viruses for Decades

Viruses - Bacterial Agents - Deadly Toxins

Sprayed over - Unknowingly Civilian Populated Areas Purposely injected into the Nation''s Water supply and Food chain

You people forget - April 28, 2007 - ABC News
Perchlorate, a chemical used in rocket fuel, is turning up in The nation''s Food and Water supply.
Centers for Disease Control last year found perchlorate in every single person tested

One of the reports - I became more familiar with - was the report of (07 thu 10 July, 1966:) Federal Agents - Dumping a : Flu Virus - Into the New York subway system. Later reports claimed the : The US Army dumped : The Virus - I tend to believe the Initial and the First reports - Federal Agents dumped the virus.

IE : 1966 July 7-10, The virus Bacillus subtilis was released throughout the New York subway system, Due to the vast number of people exposed it would virtually impossible to identify, let alone prove, any specific health problems resulting directly from this test.

In 1967 - it was rumored - Federal Agents - Dumped a Flu Virus into : The San Francisco - Los Angeles and Sea-Tac Airport''s

Research :
A History Timeline of Population Control
copy and paste (Google)

Today this should be - Considered a : "Terrorist Attack"
But it is not ! !

The Nazis : Performed the same Type of : Medical Experiments.

Lastdance
Reply to this comment
by bobbie19571 September 7, 2007 4:20 PM PDT
Parinoid much????
Reply to this comment
by kansas1946 September 7, 2007 7:39 PM PDT
A virus, huh

This will **** off the congregation of the
Church of Global Warming..
"Hail mother, full of Gore,
thou art blessed amongst liberal idiots"
LOL
********************
I have been following this bee story for about two years, and I don''t recall global warming being suspected as a cause. I am curious though, the earth is warming, there is no credible scientist that denies that, so I can''t for the life of me understand what the argument is about, and why it has anything to do with "liberal" or conservative politics. Whether humans have anything to do with it can be debated, but from what I can tell, all of the fixes suggested are good whether it slows the warming or not. I just don''t understand the name-calling, venom, and political rhetoric, about the weather.
Reply to this comment
by fizzal-2009 September 8, 2007 12:44 AM PDT
Every year the science teacher starts a holocost on to the insect world with thosands of pins and hairspray. Nowonder their just getting out of town. Can,t they just look at the pictures?






























Reply to this comment
See all 34 Comments
  • MOST POPULAR
  • Viewed
  • Commented
Latest News
Featured Blogs