Clinton, Obama Take Heat At AFL-CIO Forum
Hoping For Endorsement, Democrat Front-Runners Withstand Barbs On Terrorism, Corporate Influence
-
-
Photo
AFL-CIO President John Sweeney, left, Sen. Barack Obama, Sen. Joe Biden, Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton, Sen. Christopher Dodd and former Sen. John Edwards, D-N.C., stand onstage before a presidential forum hosted by the AFL-CIO in Chicago, Aug. 7, 2007. (AP Photo/Charles Rex Arbogast)
-
Photo
AFL-CIO President John Sweeney speaks at a news conference in Chicago, Monday, Aug. 6, 2007. The AFL-CIO is hosting a forum of Democratic presidential primary candidates at Soldier Field, on Tuesday, Aug. 7. (AP Photo/Charles Rex Arbogast)
-
-
Interactive
On The Job
Explore America's labor economy, track recent major layoffs and meet key economic players.
Illinois Sen. Barack Obama, running second to Clinton in most polls, leveled some of the criticism but was forced to defend his own recent statements on Pakistan during the 90-minute debate sponsored by the AFL-CIO at Chicago's Soldier Field.
“You will never see a picture of me on the front of Fortune magazine,” said former senator John Edwards of North Carolina, a dig at Clinton, who recently was featured on the business publication's cover.
Obama said U.S. trade agreements have tilted against workers because “corporate lobbyists” have had too much influence, a theme he has developed in recent days, especially when alluding to Clinton, the New York senator and former first lady.
Clinton, who appeared content with her front-runner status, replied: “The other campaigns have been using my name a lot.
“For 15 years, I've stood up against the right-wing machine,” she said, as many in the crowd cheered. “If you want a winner who knows how to take them on, I'm your girl.”
Obama's turn in the bull's-eye came when Connecticut Sen. Chris Dodd chided him for recently suggesting he would strike terrorist targets in Pakistan if he had information about the location of al Qaeda terrorists, even without the permission of President Pervez Musharraf.
“General Musharraf is no Thomas Jefferson,” Dodd said, but he is an ally in the war on terror.
Clinton joined in, saying to Obama, “you should not always say everything you think if you're running for president, because it has consequences across the world.”
Obama shot back: “I find it amusing that those who helped to authorize and engineer the biggest foreign policy disaster in our generation are now criticizing me.”
Dodd, Clinton, Edwards and Delaware Sen. Joe Biden voted to authorize the Iraq war in 2002. Obama, who was in the Illinois legislature at the time, spoke out against the invasion.
Although much of the heat was focused on Obama and Edwards, “every candidate on stage came under fire from one of their opponents, making this one of the more feisty events yet,” said CBSNews.com senior political editor Vaughn Ververs.
The seven candidates praised organized labor lavishly, seeming to jockey to portray themselves as the most committed to the cause.
“Edwards, who has energetically courted labor support, found himself defending his length of devotion to the causes important to the movement, while Obama was again taken to task for recent foreign policy statements and Clinton criticized as the favorite of insiders and powerful interests,” Ververs added.
Edwards twice told the crowd of some 15,000 that he has walked 200 picket lines in the past two years. “Who was with you in crunch time?” he asked. “Who will stand with you when it really matters?”
The stadium crowd was raucous and loud at times, cheering some candidates and interrupting others.
“Tonight’s forum didn’t do much to change the overall dynamics of the race, but it’s sure going to give these campaigns plenty to talk about going forward,” said Ververs.
At the debate's start, the candidates largely agreed that the nation should invest more money in infrastructure and less in the Iraq war, citing the Minneapolis bridge collapse as a symptom of neglect.
© MMVII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.



- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
...
- 7
- next
See all 309 CommentsAFL-CIO president John Sweeney
John must be looking at chart of chineeze labor.
Posted by S_Temper at 02:54 PM : Aug 07, 2007
You are sooo ignorant.
Posted by S_Temper at 03:11 PM : Aug 07, 2007
I have been a citizen for 60+ years - how about you?
Do you work? How many days a week do you work? Have you ever belonged to a Union? I have for 20 years and then went into management. I worked WITH the Union, next to the Union and found that the Union actually helped me more than anything else. It is not all about MONEY. People have problems and are sometimes reluctant to discuss and that is where the Union comes in. If you want to go back to the working conditions of the Dark Ages then go for it - move to China!!
Posted by diverinnl at 03:25 PM : Aug 07, 2007
What kind of collective bargaining agreement existed? If you had a stalemate in bargaining would it go to binding arbitration? As you can see, this can get complexed. Basically if you have a greedy company, the employees get that way too!
Posted by S_Temper at 03:32 PM : Aug 07, 2007
Well - there are good Unions and there are bad Unions - just like there are good companies and bad companies. I feel I was fortunate and
from all appearances, you and I won't have to move to China, it is moving and coming here!!
Posted by diverinnl at 03:45 PM : Aug 07, 2007
The Unions have political restrictions just like companies. Unions have financial reports to register with the DOL. Where I live, workers do not have to belong to a union but if the employee requests it, the Union still has to represent the Employee. Like I mentioned in an earlier post, I belonged to a Union for 20+ yrs and just paid dues. The Union was non-profit. The Company did not pay the Union anything. As for a Union being Socialist, alot of thing in our society is socialistic. Your local police and fire depts. are. Or do you have private police and fire where you live. There are professional unions too. Doctors and dentists belong to Unions - they call them Associations.
I worked in several unions when I was younger(UAW,AFL-CIO. IAM, SEIU,etc.) and I know that even a strong and effective national union can be plagued by corruption at the local level. I used to work in a metal-working factory where my dad was head engineer and friends with the CEO. He told me that the union reps were taking kickbacks from the company to go easy on wage demands. Like everything else in life there's corruption to deal with.
Unions may have played a part in jobs moving to lower wage countries but I don't think it's reasonable to put that all on unions, corporate greed has a dynamic all its own.
I now work in a right to work state and I would love the opportunity to be forced to pay union dues to corrupt officials if it meant that a company couldn't fire me because they don't like my age or race or hair color. Anyone who thinks right to work laws are great doesn't understand how they work..they mean they don't have to have a good reason for firing you and you have no rights whatsoever.
Posted by realpatriot1 at 04:02 PM : Aug 07, 2007
GA is a right to work state. For the reasons you state, you don't need a union. THere are federal laws to protect you.
Posted by diverinnl
Chevy CAN'T pay for it, even if the wanted to.
...they don't got that kind of money
Posted by S_Temper at 04:03 PM : Aug 07, 2007
The cheaper goods are not being locked out - they are coming in by the very companies that may or may not have factories making the same thing here.
In the 50s, 60s and early 70s, cheap Japanese cars were imported and American autos were made to compete against them. Now those Japanese companies have factories here in the states.
I worked for an electronic communication company (non-Union)and we had profit-sharing. The Japanese started exporting and the US started importing and my company did nothing to keep their product up-to-date. They ran to the Fed gov't and wanted protection. They then used our profit sharing money to keep their stock up. Lost my profit sharing and because of BAD managemnet the company went belly-up. The free market and no union involved.
...got a little secret to tell ya
"The Fat Lady?...she already sang"
"...Organized labor played a large role in Democrats taking over Congress in the midterm elections, Sweeney said, and is trying........ "
..and people THINK Bush can dish out B.S.??!!!!????
Posted by S_Temper at 04:28 PM : Aug 07, 2007
How are you going to enforce it?
Are you going to take them to court?
How much are court fees?
Are you going to represent yourself?
Who is going to prove that you were discriminated against?
SERVE GOD, YOUR CHURCH, YOUR FAMILY AND YOUR PLACE OF EMPLOYMENT AND YOU WILL NO HAVE ANY CHOICE BUT TO SUCCEED!
Unions just create complacency and cause jobs to get moved offshore!
Death to ABORTION and unions!
Posted by S_Temper at 04:49 PM : Aug 07, 2007
I had no Union problems and I had no company or management problems. I am retired now after 31+ years of Federal Service.
SERVE GOD, YOUR CHURCH, YOUR FAMILY AND YOUR PLACE OF EMPLOYMENT AND YOU WILL NO HAVE ANY CHOICE BUT TO SUCCEED!
Unions just create complacency and cause jobs to get moved offshore!
Death to ABORTION and unions!
Posted by gslinger3 at 04:48 PM : Aug 07, 2007
I did - I trusted God and my Church and my Family but not my employers, that's why you Union, to keep them honest. And sometimes that doesn't work.
Posted by S_Temper at 04:57 PM : Aug 07, 2007
My wages never came from the US Taxpayer and there is competition. The Union was a member of the AFL-CIO and run as a corporation.
SERVE GOD, YOUR CHURCH, YOUR FAMILY AND YOUR PLACE OF EMPLOYMENT AND YOU WILL NO HAVE ANY CHOICE BUT TO SUCCEED!
Unions just create complacency and cause jobs to get moved offshore!
Death to ABORTION and unions!
Posted by gslinger3 at 04:48 PM : Aug 07, 2007
How do you propose to do that Swastika Breath? Bigger men than you have tried to kill the right of people to be free and to associate in a Labor Union. It's as American as the Constitution itself. Stinky little fascist like you have always wanted to kill workers rights even to the point of supporting Hitler against your own country. God you fascist are disgusting little creatures! Absolutely disgusting. Sieg Heil Bush! Come on Sparky, get out that hood and sheet and help me out here!! SIEG HEIL!! SIEG HEIL!! "God Bless the Working Man and God Bless his Union", Rev. Ben Worth, 1939
IOWEIGN, you were a federal employee for 31+ years and never figured out where the US Government got the money to pay your wage? Please tell me you mis-quoted something there! You may have payed your union dues to a corporation, that's true but the US Government is not a corporation.
I feel for you, but how would a union have prevented your loss? As I said before, nothing is guaranteed in this life except for death and taxes, but unions are not the solution.
Posted by S_Temper at 05:03 PM : Aug 07, 2007
That is my point - do not blame unions for every problem a company may have.
Posted by S_Temper at 04:49 PM : Aug 07, 2007
Wow! You know so very little about Labor and the Law. A Union MUST represent all employees regardless. The problem is the same as it is with people in general, every worker thinks they are right and their position is right. The WHOLE thing is determined by the National Labor Relations Act and THAT Employee's Collective Bargaining Agreement. Your Mother had MORE rights than ANY non-union worker the minute she walked through the door. She COULD NOT be fired with Cause. Her Hours of Work and Conditions of Employment could NOT be changed without negotiating with her Union on those changes. She could Not be layed of except by the conditions and terms of her Agreement. I could go on for an hour but anyone who say's a Union Member is no better off than an Non Union one is simple blowing smoke... Sieg Heil Bush!!
IOWEIGN, you were a federal employee for 31+ years and never figured out where the US Government got the money to pay your wage? Please tell me you mis-quoted something there! You may have payed your union dues to a corporation, that's true but the US Government is not a corporation.
Posted by diverinnl at 05:10 PM : Aug 07, 2007
The "Postal Service" does not receive Tax Dollars and I had a typo it should say The Postal Service is run as a corporation and it is.
Does that help?? Postal employees are Federal employees and their wages come solely from the services provided by the Postal Service. the Postal Service is mandated by law to be non-profit.
Posted by S_Temper at 05:31 PM : Aug 07, 2007
USPS is mandated by Congress to have universal service - so in a sense it is a monopoly but also means that the Post Office can't pick and choose the profitable routes as UPS and FEDEX. In fact, they use USPS sometimes for the last leg of the delivery. Jobs can be outsourced (in the US) only if it does not hinder or infringe on the sanctity of the mail.
.......you have America's mob-run union the AFL-CIO together with one of America's most corrupt liberal wolfpack press in MSNBC.....together with the "weakest" bunch of Dems for President in American history.
None of these candidates are even "qualified" to be president.
FYI in all of American history only (2) Senators of been elected president......................and it won't be (3) in 2008. Not with this bunch of "left-wing" candidates............... boo......bad
Has anyone seen Jimmy Hoffa? I haven't seen him since lunch.
Instead of pursuing Industrial Unionism, higher paid workers (who, amusingly, fancy themselves 'middle class') adopted bourgeois values and attitudes and began to look down on the more humble Joneses. The minimum wage in America is the best argument in the world against craft unionism whose members--with their fellow bourgeoisie (hahaha!) the bankers, the lawyers, the rentiers and the financiers--now excercise 'prudence' and 'concern' regarding the wages paid to the mere proles below them.
The International Workers of the World must have been doing something right...the Capitalists hated them and the Communnists did to!
Now, its the craft unions that are being bled white by the Corporations in the name of competition...competition with sweated labour in Mexico, Latin America and East Asia. Labour that is locked into their factories--like the Hamlet North Carolina workers at the Imperial Chicken plant who were locked into the plant with thousands of gallons of hot grease, natural gas leaking and an open flame...use your imagination if you are not familiar with that proud moment in the history of American Capitalism.
Its way past time for real unions, fighting unions, good unions...Industrial Unions!
Re: "Hillary Clinton defended the pact, saying the nation needs "broad reform" of trade. "NAFTA is a piece of it, but it's not the only piece," she said. Obama and Edwards also stopped short of saying NAFTA should be scrapped."
NAFTA should be scrapped!!! The end!!!
These three AIPAC-stained candidates are clearly unqualified to lead our country.
What's wrong with that picture?
Why doesn't the federal government demand all workers qualify with a union before they can become employed in any profession, such as they do with doctors, lawyers, animal doctors, dentists and other "professions"?
Both political parties cater to the rich and powerful to the exclusion of everyone else.
Hillary supports war profiteers, special interest groups, homosexuals and feminists having superior "rights," illegal immigrants, unnecessary wars, Israel, and government intrusion into our daily lives.
If you want another George Bush, vote for Hillary.
But, Democrats and Republicans are the same party wearing different disguises. Both represent the rich and powerful above all else.
Excellent points about the AFL-CIO.
Baloney, labor unions drove prosperity and created the middle class in this country, and then lost their way fighting for bad actors, non competitive change they refused to flex and so they became diminished as should happen, but they did not harm this country. Another RNC propaganda sound bite cause union folks do not vote Repug generally.
FEW CORRUPT PEOPLE WHO ARE THE OWNERS OF THE
INTERNATIONAL BANKS OR THE FEDERAL RESERVE
BANK. WHO MADE MONEY BACKING BY NOTHING WE ARE SLAVES
FROM THIS CORRUPT PEOPLE ....BUT TO KEEP
THEIR POWER THEY INVENT US ALL AROUND EUROPE
AND AMERICA THAT WE ARE IN WAR. TO KEEP THEIR
POWER MADE FROM NOTHING THEY ARE THE EVIL IN
THIS WORLD..LIKE HITLER FOR THE FEDERAL
RESERVE BANKS THE MOST LUCRATIVE THING !!!!IS WAR!!!
FORCES THE COUNTRY TO BORROW MORE MONEY AT INTEREST
THEY ARE THE MOST KIND OF THIEFS IN ALL TIMES OF
HUMANKIND. THE MONEY PAPER IS THE MOST ASTOUNDING
PIECE OF SLEIGHT OF HAND THAT WAS EVER INVENTED.
USURY IS THE MOST EVIL THING THAT MANKIND HAS INVENTED
IS THE DESTRUCTION OF ALL CIVILITATIONS.
USURY IS THE MONSTER AGAINST THE KINGDOM
OF GOD. AND THE U.N. IS MADE BY THE INTERNATIONAL
BANKERS. WHO CONTROL EVERYTHING AND CONTROL THE WAR
IN IRAQ AND IRAN SOONER. OUR RULERS ARE A BUNCH OF CRIMINALS
THE TRILATERAL COMMISSION IS THE WAY THAT ALL THE
PEOPLE AROUND THE WORLD WE'LL BE SOONER IN COMPLETE
SLAVERY UNTIL SOME REAL POWERS DEFEAT THIS EVIL ON EARTH.
WATCH.. WWW.ZEITGEISTMOVIE.COM
But you could see him on the cover of "Women's Journal", "Woman's Digest", "Men-o-Pause",...
Clinton takes "barbs" for her ties to lobbies??? What do these guys think the AFL-CIO is?
...
I don't.
America is a FASCIST NATION ruled by the American/Israeli Elite.
Our Government DOES NOT CARE ABOUT US.
OUR GOVERNMENT DOES NOT LISTEN TO US.
OUR GOVERNMENT WORKS FOR THE ELITE AND THE ELITE ONLY.
ZEITGEISTmovie.com.
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
...
- 7
- next
See all 309 Comments