New Yorker: CIA Tactics Amount To Torture
Magazine: The CIA Used Techniques Equivalent To Torture While Interrogating 9/11 Mastermind
-
Play CBS Video
Video
CIA Torture?
A new report says that the CIA used coercive tactics synonymous with torture while interrogating 9/11 mastermind. Russ Mitchell talks to The New Yorker's Jane Mayer about her article on the subject.
-
Photo
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed headshot, arrested Al Qaida leader and mastermind of September 11 terrorist attack, after his capture during raid in Pakistan, photo (AP)
-
Photo Essay
Al Qaeda Suspects
See the seven people wanted for questioning by the FBI.
After Mohammed's capture in Pakistan in 2003, the CIA detained him at one of several secret overseas prisons, known as "black sites," and subjected him to unusually harsh treatment, according to the article.
It was under these interrogation methods that Mohammed confessed to 31 criminal plots, including the murder of Wall Street Journal reporter Daniel Pearl, who was captured in 2002 in Pakistan and beheaded, Jane Mayer reports in the New Yorker.
Mohammed's interrogation was part of a fine-tuned CIA protocol of psychological coercion against al Qaeda figures, according to sources familiar with an International Red Cross report, Mayer writes.
"The Red Cross went in and got to interview these people for the first time," said Mayer on the CBS Evening News. "What these people described was hanging from the ceilings by their arms and being water-boarded, partially drowned, put on leashes and knocked into walls and basically deprived of all kinds of sensory imagery for years."
At a hearing in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, Mohammed said his testimony was freely given, Mayer adds, but he also said that he had been abused by the CIA.
"He was certainly coerced," Mayer told Russ Mitchell on Sunday. "These were certainly very coercive techniques. The problem with them is that you can't really tell what's reliable, what's the truth, what's not after somebody has been through these things."
Mayer's article further described the CIA program of physical and psychological abuse as completely regimented and deliberate.
"There have always been mistakes made in the past when prisoners have been abused in wars," Mayer told Mitchell. "But this is the first time it's been done on purpose."
The program was suspended last fall, following a Supreme Court ruling, Hamdan v. Rumsfeld, which ruled that all U.S. detainees must be treated in a manner consisted with the Geneva Conventions.
In an E-mail to CBS News the CIA responded that the article "recycles old allegations" and concluded by saying "the United States does not conduct or condone torture."
© MMVII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Video and Galleries from CBS Evening News
- Latest in CBS Evening News
- The Story Behind the Skating Babies
- Sagging Sales, Even in a Beach Paradise
- Grief, Outrage over Grave Desecrations



- 1
- 2
- 3
- next
See all 145 CommentsKSM and every other of these people so questioned are instead left capable of performing every act and retaining every skill they ever had.
If they could play the piano, they still can. If they can plot, manufacture bombs, or commit murder, they still have that ability.
Sleep deprivation, loneliness, and water boarding are not torture. They cause no great pain nor any humiliation. Those practices have saved American lives by the tens of thousands, yet we still have whiners complaining about these killers being discomforted .
Experts in witness interrogation will tell you that its not reliable--these people will tell you virtually anything they may think you want to hear in order to get the torture to stop.
Somer people here are confusing punishment for what he did for interrogation to get more leads, etc..
Unfortunately, we have no evidence to support that claim.
"yet we still have whiners complaining about these killers being discomforted"
That's not the point at all--the question is which interrogation method works--torture does not, never has, never will.
We can glean at least a couple of truisms from this article:
1) Since Khalid Sheikh Mohammed has "admitted" to being the "mastermind%u201D of the 9/11/01 attacks, and this "confession" is accepted by some, it stands to reason that Osama bin Laden was NOT the "mastermind%u201D of the 9/11/01 attacks, which would explain why he is not wanted by the FBI for these events.
2) Our CIA is, at least in part, a multi-billion dollar global terrorist network, complete with kidnapping teams, secret prisons, and torture chambers, and they have no credibility in identifying anyone else as a "terrorist".
Bin Laden financed the overall goals of the plan. KSM was the one who put it into action. Very big distinction. A CEO of a company/organization (Bin Laden) outlines the plan and then delegates authority to subordinates (KSM) to carry out the plan.
That is an important distinction.
Also, I'll take the CIA over Al Queda any day of the week. They are working to save your lame *** whether you like it or not.
Since you have volunteered to be the defense attorney for Bin Laden and KSM, you need to be corrected on your comments.
Re: "I'll take the CIA over Al Queda any day of the week."
What leads you to believe that these are not overlapping terrorist organizations?
Is bin Laden not a past (present?) CIA asset?
Have you ever seen his pink slip?
KSM and every other of these people so questioned are instead left capable of performing every act and retaining every skill they ever had.
If they could play the piano, they still can. If they can plot, manufacture bombs, or commit murder, they still have that ability.
Sleep deprivation, loneliness, and water boarding are not torture. They cause no great pain nor any humiliation. Those practices have saved American lives by the tens of thousands, yet we still have whiners complaining about these killers being discomforted .
Posted by kesac4650 at 07:15 PM : Aug 05, 2007
Do you still feel that way when it is applied to our troops when they are captured?
Or is it the next thing to come to a Water Park near you!!! Talk about Wet-N-Wild!!
So long as it does not result in verifiable ending of torture, the publicity will induce terror in prisoners and terror of becoming a prisoner in others.
Posted by fperra at 08:40 PM : Aug 05, 2007
And it was the Republicans that cried when Clinton fired Cruise missiles at bin Laden in 1998.
In response to the 1998 United States embassy bombings following the fatwa, President Bill Clinton ordered a freeze on assets that could be linked to bin Laden. Clinton also signed an executive order, authorizing bin Laden's arrest or assassination. In August 1998, the U.S. launched an attack using cruise missiles. The attack failed to harm bin Laden but killed 19 other people.
www.zeitgeistmovie.com
Is either insane, or a f@#$%ing ***!
Sleep deprivation, by itself, can drive any person totally insane. And, can you even imagine what it is like to be tied naked to a board and submerged in a vat of cold water, not knowing if you will drown, and being held there until just before (and sometimes, just after) you run out of air? Can you imagine what it is like to go through that over and over and over again, for years, without any hope of ever being released? For God's sake, man, the dreaded "Chinese water torture" simply consisted of a drop of water falling on your head, drip, drip, drip, and it drove people completely insane!
When Bush and his gang of violent criminal conspirators say "We don't torture" they mean: "We define 'torture' as *** and we do YYY, therefore 'we don't torture'." Anybody who falls for that line of bull deserves the eternal war that Cheney and Bush plan for us all.
By condoning torture, our government has sunk to the level of savage beasts. Those who support torture, whether or not they admit it is torture, are likewise animals. They are not fit to participate in any human society.
I think they are on the high ground here...
I think they are on the high ground here...
Posted by pjn440 at 09:37 PM : Aug 05, 2007
Yeah ain't that great... at least our guys aren't as bad as their guys! ROFLMAO Wonder how many future terrorist that will prevent from strapping on Explosives to blow us up? ROFLMAO When you are fighting a game of Hatred, you can't afford to be NOT quite as bad...
Posted by fperra at 08:40 PM : Aug 05, 2007
You know this how? You Fascist ALWAYS know what people are going to say and do when they didn't do anything or say anything. It's just amazing how you, with your VERY small and insignificant little minds, know these things. The FACT is that President Clinton NEVER ordered people TORTURED and President Clinton did NOT lie to We the People about it... so why sling your mud at your neighbors and fellow citizens.... especially those who KNOW how to fight and win against Terrorist. I'm sure glad you clowns were on the OTHER side in our fight with the Klan... They'd still be lynching Blacks in Mississippi other wise.
They may even mention drills.
That's how reporting from US sources changed in the past when US torture practices were first revealed.
I think they are on the high ground here...
Posted by pjn440 at 09:37 PM : Aug 05, 2007
So you're saying, at this point anyway, you THINK we're a little better than Al Qaeda! That's not real confronting when your enemy has used your tactics to completely rebuild... not real confronting at all. Sieg Heil Y'all.
All I know is, as long as this guy left with all his nails intact with toes and fingers as well as a tongue, I could care less. You got it, could care less.
Besides he looks like he could afford to shed a few pounds.
Posted by janem4 at 08:17 PM : Aug 05, 2007
You Nazi's and your One Party Rule is totally disgusting. The Geneva Convention DEFINES Torture you pathetic loser! God no wonder we're getting the c-r-a-p kicked out of us... no wonder our enemy has totally and completely rebuilt. With garbage like The Klan Man and people like you as poster childern, who in this world wouldn't want to blow us up? At the rate we're going there may not be anything left to save in 18 months... We've lost the fight WORLD WIDE for the hearts and minds of the people and right now if this nation were attacked I seriously doubt we've have anyone come to our aid. In fact, when you look at the southern fascist who run the Republican Party, the rest of the world may be ready to help them. Sieg Heil Bush!!
Yes, I know in past history, America has done some bad things, long before the neocons came to power. In WWII, some German prisoners were tortured (genitals on hot radiators, that sort of thing). But then, those things were illegal, as they should be. Now, thanks to the neocons, we have actually made those things legal and that is a disgrace. If we can't follow our own principles, even in times of crisis, then we are no better than the terrorists we fight.
If you weren't such a fing moron you'd know that.
Posted by kesac4650 at 07:15 PM : Aug 05, 2007
+ report abuse
You know this how? Because the Reich TOLD you so? ROFLMAO Yeah I know they told us we were Winning in Iraq and the insurgency was on it's last legs... they also told us we didn't need our friends and allys. Then they told us Al Qaeda was dead and didn't matter anymore. You know maybe you should take off the Hood and Sheet there Sparky and face the fact that your fuhrer and hero is the BIGGEST poster child for Terrorist Recruitment in the world. The ENEMY, you know the guys who actually planned and ordered the attack on us? THEY have completely rebuilt and we are no better off NOW than when this all started. That's called LOSING and means YOUR NOT WINNING the fight. Now MOST intelligent people would say when you are LOSING you need to try a new approach... Course if YOUR a Southern Fascist, your just plain STUPID and couldn't try a new course if you wanted too. Sieg Heil Bush!!
The morons still supporting Bush just aren't smart enough to see that they are living in that village!!
non muslims of the world unite... fight against the tyranny of the fascist nazi terrorslam imperialist empire of the darkside...
Our Prophet commanded us to fight the kaafirs when we are able and to attack them in their homelands and to give them three choices before we enter their lands: either they become Muslim and be like us, sharing our rights and duties; or they pay the jizyah (poll tax) and feel themselves subdued; or they fight, in which case their wealth, women, children and homes become permissible as booty for the Muslims.
http://islamqa.com/index.php?ref=13759&ln=eng&txt=before%20islam%20arabia%20pagan
If they can kill us, we can kill them
Qaeda warns of attacks 'worse than 9/11'
http://www.breitbart.com/article.php?id=070530102648.wuwa6k96&show_article=1
Hizbullah Deputy Sec-Gen Sheikh Naim Qassem: We Have Jurisprudent Permission to Carry Out 'Martyrdom' Operations, Fire Missiles on Israeli Civilians From Ayatollah Khomeini
http://memri.org/bin/latestnews.cgi?ID=SD154907
Switching Sides: Inside The Enemy Camp
But then in 2000, well before his arrest, something happened which would make Abas question everything he believed in: a fatwa, a religious edict, was issued by Osama bin Laden.
"It should be understood that killing Americans and Jews anywhere found are the highest act of worship and the highest form of good deeds in the eyes of Allah," Simon quotes bin Laden.
Abas and his fellow commanders were ordered to read the fatwa to their men and make sure they carried it out. The others obeyed, but Abas refused. It was his moment of truth. He firmly believed that jihad was to be fought only on the battlefield in defense of Islam; he had always been taught that the killing of civilians had nothing to do with holy war and that it was forbidden.
The fatwa justified killing non-Muslim civilians everywhere.
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2007/05/04/60minutes/main2761108.shtml?source=RSSattr=60Minutes_2761108
American Al Qaeda Member Threatens Attack
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2007/05/29/terror/main2865282.shtml
Part Members
I would like for them and the : "FBI"
To describe - Their own - Criminal Acts - Torture Techniques
They conducted against : Adolescent Young Children within :
U.S. Juvenile Detention Centers
Research :
The Monarch Project - MK-Ultra
copy and paste (Google)
(One of the main contributors was :
Sen Prescott Bush)
Girls were aged 9 thu 11
Boys were aged 10 thu 13
Sexual Abuse - Sexual molestation - Sexual assault
Torture - Sexual Torture - Sexual Torment
Some of these children, didn't survive the torture sessions.
Therefore : They were murdered
Some of those children, didn't survive the sexual encounters.
Therefore : were murdered.
One child after another.
When they were finished with one.
They started on another
Research :
George Bush, The CIA, Mind Control & Child Abuse
copy and paste (Google)
Excellent display of : "No Child Left Behind"
Now ! - Watch these Loyal :
Republican (Criminal) Party members.
Bury this - Statement - In doing so - Proclaiming -
Their own undying support of : - Child Abuse - and - Child Murder
Lastdance
We see that CBS Nooz scrubbed all of the comments that exposed the "American al-Qaeda" article, as a shabby hoax.
While it is disappointing that CBS would present this absurd and obvious propaganda creation as news, it is truly disgraceful that they would delete the entire comment section, which demonstrated that the "video" presented by CBS is a likely U.S. manufactured fake, designed to terrorize our own population.
This kind of yellow-journalism poses some real dangers to a lot of innocent people. This kind of irresponsible manipulation is really shameful.
Amazing this regime has to be told by a court to obey international laws and conventions it helped create and signed.
"...killers being discomforted .
Posted by kesac4650"
I take it you witnessed these people committing acts of murder, because if you haven't, but still call them killers, without credible evidence then by logic you are either lying, or a sociopath, probably both.
In 1786, Thomas Jefferson, then U.S. ambassador to France, and John Adams, then American Ambassador to Britain, met in London with Sidi Haji Abdul Rahman Adja, the Dey%u2019s ambassador to Britain, in an attempt to negotiate a peace treaty based on Congress%u2019 vote of funding. To Congress, these two future presidents later reported the reasons for the Muslims%u2019 hostility towards America, a nation with which they had no previous contacts.
%u2026that it was founded on the Laws of their Prophet, that it was written in their Koran, that all nations who should not have acknowledged their authority were sinners, that it was their right and duty to make war upon them wherever they could be found, and to make slaves of all they could take as Prisoners, and that every Musselman (Muslim) who should be slain in Battle was sure to go to Paradise.
Sound familiar?
Thomas Jefferson and James Madison defeated the fascist nazi muslims 200 years ago
And again 100 years ago with Theodore Roosevelt
Tunisia in 1881 by France and Libya in 1911 by Italy. By then most of the Islamic world was under Christian domination. With the Ottoman Empire defeated in WW1, secularist Turkish rebels in 1923 overthrew the last Islamic Caliphate,
http://www.hawaiireporter.com/story.aspx?6bdec278-6a71-4436-bc4d-29d1c54b0ad7
You would think people with access to the greatest information index in the known world, i.e., the Internet, would be better informed. And they would be, if they cared about anything besides stroking their egoes and venting their spleens.
but very few expect get well feed world folk to crime tho told to; &, more few expect wondet supet shero get sick tax world folk to crime
'i say 'dare' & kids bleed. i say 'shock & awe' & kids bleed. at least they know who to vote for!'
half make less than $2 a day, they've no lite, no toilet, no clothes, no food, no water; tho, few die of poverty: 3 & a half billion poor today will be 3 & a half billion poor tomorrow,
tho most are too young or old or impaired to labor, & most others are unemployeed or underemployeed, most are enjoying sum forms of charity:
maybe 97% share maybe 5% of global wealth all day each day, yet trails & pages don't tend to reflect the 'truth' of whut goes on behind 'closed doors'
lazy naked ignorant profane kids get battered into 'mourning attire'; yet, no one ever 'mourns' for 'them'?
generation dared shocked awed vs. generation daring shocking awing & generation shove daring shocking awing as 2% struggle to dance
get sick tax world most of the time: they bide most of their time dancing get well feed world
& the other 98% dance get well feed world most often & drip compost fertilize & drip water irrigate the spore bloom weed dragon trail fickle first aid lunch farm cottage studio trails for the epic quest to cure the common death
How misleading is this CBS headline?
The CIA Used Techniques Equivalent To Torture While Interrogating 9/11 Mastermind
...Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the man long alleged to have planned the September 11 attacks, ... Has never been formally charged with any crime.
BTW, is this the only picture that's ever been taken of Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, this picture must be from at least five years ago?
Aug. 5, 2007
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed headshot, arrested Al Qaida leader and mastermind of September 11 terrorist attack, after his capture during raid in Pakistan, photo
US says Khalid Sheikh Mohammed has admitted to 9/11 terror attacks ...Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the man long alleged to have planned the September 11 attacks, ... He's never been formally charged with any crime.
The alleged 9/11 mastermind, Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, ... the Independent newspaper that Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was an ISI asset
Re: "You bombed our land and killed our people..."
What does Cheney have to do with this?
Do you think that he will do it again?
Re: "BTW, is this the only picture that's ever been taken of Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, this picture must be from at least five years ago?"
Ha, ha!
I had the same thought, you would think that they could have snapped another photograph of him by now, between his torture sessions.
Even after his water-boarding torture treatments, you would think that he looked better than he does in this photo!
Re: "Independent newspaper...Khalid Sheikh Mohammed was an ISI asset"
Really? do you have a URL for that?
"You bombed our land and killed our people...
DUH..YOU THINK.. I might be a little rough in the interrogation..."
I believe he admitted to a lot of things that the CIA didn't know about to begin with as well.
For instance, he killed Daniel Pearl, he shot Mr Burns and he also shot JR Ewing.
Amazing the things you can find out when you torture someone.
Of course, he probably admitted to being your father during torture as well.
Another horse manure story and how old is that picture of Khalid Sheikh Mohammed? If he was the mastermind behind 9/11 why wasn't he tried in the US if he was captured?
PURE BS
Posted by FeelFree1 at 01:08 AM : Aug 06, 2007
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, Operation 9/11 and ISI
Saturday, June 02, 2007 - 09:49 PM EST - 60 Reads
http://www.dictatorshipwatch.com/modules.php?op=modload&name=News&file=article&sid=38
Thank you for the URL.
Good night.
See next time
+ report abuse
*****
The liberal media would hand my safety to the hands of our enemy on a silver platter if it means selling more subscriptions. Of course those pieces of sh it at the International Red Cross ARE TOO BUSY MAKING SURE THAT TERRORISTS AND CRIMINALS ARE BEING TREATED RIGHT that they dont have any more time for anybody else ...LIKE THE SOUTH KOREANS WHO GOT KIDNAPPED AND KILLED.
- 1
- 2
- 3
- next
See all 145 Comments