Bush Asks Congress To Expand Surveillance
Seeks To "Modernize" Wiretapping To Match New Technologies; Critics Warn Of Unchecked Privacy Invasion
-
Photo
(AP / CBS)
-
Interactive
Domestic Surveillance
The debate over the Bush administration's controversial wiretapping program.
-
Interactive
Bush Presidency
The president's agenda, plus facts, figures, major events and key personalities.
The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, or FISA, provides a legal foundation that allows information about terrorists' communications to be collected without violating civil liberties.
President George W. Bush wants Congress to rewrite the law to incorporate new advances in technology which, he says, are not covered by the FISA.
"This law is badly out-of-date," Mr. Bush said Saturday in his weekly radio address.
Mr. Bush noted that terrorists now use disposable cell phones and the Internet to communicate, recruit operatives and plan attacks; such tools were not available when FISA was passed nearly 30 years ago. (However, as he signed the Patriot Act on October 26, 2001, the president stated that existing law "written in the era of rotary telephones" was now updated to allow surveillance "of all communications used by terrorists, including e-mails, the Internet, and cell phones.")
He also cited a recently released intelligence estimate that concluded al Qaeda is using its growing strength in the Middle East to plot attacks on U.S. soil.
"Our intelligence community warns that under the current statute, we are missing a significant amount of foreign intelligence that we should be collecting to protect our country," Bush said. "Congress needs to act immediately to pass this bill, so that our national security professionals can close intelligence gaps and provide critical warning time for our country."
The 1978 law set up a court that meets in secret to review applications from the FBI, the National Security Agency and other agencies for warrants to wiretap or search the homes of people in the United States in terrorist or espionage cases.
Shortly after the Sept. 11 attacks, Mr. Bush authorized the NSA to spy on calls between people in the U.S. and suspected terrorists abroad without FISA court warrants. The administration said it needed to act more quickly than the court could issue warrants; it also said the president had inherent authority to order warrantless domestic spying in spite of Constitutional protections.
After the program became public and was challenged in court, Mr. Bush put it under FISA court supervision this year.
The national intelligence director, in a letter Wednesday to the House intelligence committee, stressed the need to be able to collect intelligence about foreign terrorists overseas. Mike McConnell said intelligence agencies should be able to do that without requirements imposed by an "out-of-date" law.
"Simply put, in a significant number of cases, we are in the unfortunate position of having to obtain court orders to effectively collect foreign intelligence about foreign targets located overseas," he wrote the committee chairman, Rep. Silvestre Reyes.
Democrats want to ensure that any changes do not give the executive branch unfettered surveillance powers.
Caroline Fredrickson, director of the Washington legislative office of the American Civil Liberties Union, contends the White House is asking for more power to conduct warrantless domestic and international surveillance.
"The administration claims the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act must be 'modernized,'" she said. "The reality is, their proposal would gut FISA.
"The President claims that they need to expand FISA based on new technology — they are wrong," said Fredrickson. "FISA was written to be technology-neutral. There is absolutely no new technology that cannot be intercepted with a warrant under FISA. None."
Frederickson also says that hidden within the bill is immunity from both criminal prosecution and civil liability for telecommunication companies who participate in the National Security Agency's warrantless wiretapping program, which would be retroactive.
This could affect a lawsuit before the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, in which the Electronic Frontier Foundation is suing AT&T for violating the rights of its customers by assisting the NSA with spying. The government has sought to have the suit dismissed on the grounds that state secrets would be exposed in a trial.
"It takes an enormous amount of hubris to ask for more power on the heels of revelations that the President tried to go around his own attorney general on his NSA domestic electronic eavesdropping program," Frederickson said. "The already-shaky legal ground on which this domestic spying program stood is crumbling beneath those who defend it."
The ACLU urged lawmakers to find out the full extent of current intelligence gathering under FISA before making changes.
"The only thing more outrageous than the administration's call for even more unfettered power is a Congress that would consider giving it to them," Frederickson said.
© MMVII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.



- 1
- 2
- 3
- next
See all 138 CommentsIn other words, he and his ran an illegal program until they were found out.....
be deployed at all times, to record all
the thoughts of all earth citizens not only
for posterity, but for security reasons.
we have the technology. let's use it.
time travel research has broken the barrier.
aladdin device is real. something from
nothing for nothing. let's get it on.
move forward, with great vigah.
Posted by tbweb at 01:40 PM : Jul 28, 2007
D@mn, we ain't even getting a reach-around.
VERY GOOD MR.PRESIDENT I WOULD SAY WE MUST INSTALL CCTV CAMERAS EVERYWHERE LIKE WE HAVE IN THE U.K
I WOULD BE GLAD IF YOU IMPLEMENT IT IN ORDER TO MAKE US SAFER THAN EVER!
I WOULD BE GLAD IF YOU IMPLEMENT IT IN ORDER TO MAKE US SAFER THAN EVER!
The u.k. is like nazi germany now....
They are a country of walking- filmed zombies.
They are prodded, tested, watched, monitored and mummified. It's a rich/poor country where the natives can barely find work and they are over-run with "immigrants" who have taken their jobs,housing and culture. This has nothing to do with monitoring "terrorist" - rather than controlling u.s. citizens *one way or the other*.
Drinkers face drug test as they enter the pub
Police seek DNA record of everyone
Senior police officers will call this week for the the national database of 2m DNA samples to be extended to everyone in the country.
Government wants file on every child in England
Blair plans law that will make it a criminal offence to criticise government policy
http://www.prisonplanet.com/archive_police_state.html
Game-Set-Match
Bush remains a liar. Next!
Thinking about this, one cannot but wonder how is sensitive info about individuals being gathered. To buy a air plane ticket, at least at the moment, does not require you to fill out a form asking you about "race or religion, political views or sexual preferences". So do authorities come by the info to share in the first place?
One day the truth will all come out anyway and 51% of legal Americans will learn what 49% knew from the get go but couldn't get them to listen to even after the 2nd stupid mistake.
How about you big talkers?
Posted by yurpallid at 04:16 PM
XXXXXXXX
The "big" talkers are days away - being "pre-occupied" in Iraq. Our military and most fighting age men are days away - leaving mostly the aged, young and women here. The production of tech. for Mass population control is astronomical...
Our military are being asked via "surveys" if they would "USE ARMS AGAINST THEIR FELLOW CITIZENS" and "FOLLOW THE COMMANDS AND PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE U.N. and we have U.N. troops IN AMERICA training. So yeh- SOME will be willing but not enough.
45. I would swear to the following code:
"I am a United Nations fighting person. I serve in the forces which maintain world peace and every nation%u2019s way of life. I am prepared to give my life in their defense."
46. The U.S. government declares a ban on the possession, sale, transportation, and transfer of all non-sporting firearms. A thirty (30) day amnesty period is permitted for these firearms to be turned over to the local authorities. At the end of this period, a number of citizen groups refuse to turn over their firearms. Consider the following statement:
I would fire upon U.S. citizens who refuse or resist confiscation of firearms banned by the U.S. government.
Strongly disagree/ Disagree / Agree
Such abuses are never what was intended by the founding fathers & is antithetical to American rights which have always been guaranteed by the US Constitution.
This is an Administration which has little regard for the Constitution & Bush II & his Administration have sought to undermine it whenever it seems to be in conflict with their corporatist or extremist Right Wing point of view.
I would hope this Congress would carefully consider past Constitutional violations by this Administration before granting them even more power to abuse the system.
Even the White House staff will have it's mail read. What's great about his program is that everyone loses their privacy equally. That's so Repug.
Are YOU that soldier running with gangs like you don't have the moral principles of the US Military? Are you ALL hoodlums? You aren't stopping the craziness. I think you all ought to be arrested.
Why would anyone expect - "Less" - from Bush
1934 :
Hitler replaced attorneys and judges.
With his own loyal party members.
Then totally ignored, the Fundamental Laws of Germany.
To study Hitler - Is - to study - Bush
To study Hitler - Is - to "PREDICT" - The Actions of Bush
Even "Caesar" thought of himself as a :
"God" like creature.
So did - Hitler - So did - Stalin - So does Bush.
They all dictated laws - They never obeyed any written laws.
Bush is in the direct image of : Hitler
If you understand the : National Socialism (Nazi) Ideology.
Then you have - "No Complaints" - Bush is right - " IN Tune"
With all What : Bush and The The Republican Party
Beleive in ! ! !
To replace a Democratic Government with :
A Monarch (Nazi) Ideology.... - Master - Slave Society.
Bush - The Republican Party - Criminal Corporate America -
The Department of Justice.
Every act of theirs - Is an act of
"Patriotism" - and - "Patriotic Values"
To the : National Socialism (Nazi) Ideology.
Just what is it going to take for you - To get Tuned In ???
To study Hitler - Is - to "PREDICT" - The Actions of Bush
To replace a Democratic Government with :
A National Socialism (Nazi) Ideology.
To Create a - "Master - Slave" Society.
Lastdance
-- Expanded Survailiance violates the courts & our Constitution -- It's another over reach of executiive power.
3,692 AMERICANS KIA FOR NO GAIN & 10'S OF THOUSANDS OF CIVILIANS -- TERRORISM HAS GROWN
j-whitman at 07:44 PM :
"What happened was the gradual habituation of the people, little by little, to be governed by surprise, to receiving decisions deliberated in secret; to believing that the situation was so complicated that the government had to act on information which the people could not understand, or so dangerous that, even if people could understand it, it could not be released because of national security ...
To live in the process is absolutely not to notice it -- please try to believe me -- unless one has a much greater degree of political awareness, acuity, than most of us ever had occasion to develop. Each step was so small, so inconsequential, so well explained or, on occasion, regretted.
Believe me this is true. Each act, each occasion is worse than the last, but only a little worse. You wait for the next and the next. You wait for one shocking occasion, thinking that others, when such a shock comes, will join you in resisting somehow.
Suddenly it all comes down, all at once. You see what you are, what you have done, or, more accurately, what you haven't done (for that was all that was required of most of us: that we did nothing) ... You remember everything now, and your heart breaks. Too late. You are compromised beyond repair. "
German professor after World War II describing the rise of Nazism to a journalist
-- Franklin D. Roosevelt
SHAMUTAS!!!!!!!!!!!
It's about balancing and "redistributing" wealth throughout the world. Which means we need to fall somewhere between where we WERE and were the poorest of poor nations are. Not good for US.
ELITE MEET BEHIND STIFF SECURITY
Secret Cabal Roosts at Ritz-Carlton; Riot Police Keep All But Invited
BILDERBERG 2007 REPORT
Among new climate related demands by Bilderberg is for the United State to increase gasoline taxes so the price will rise %u201Csignificantly%u201D to more than $6 a gallon. The argument is that this will reduce driving and thus emissions. They argued, with little or no dissent from Americans, that Europeans already pay that much or more.
Then the problem of the failure of the %u201CAmerican Union%u201D was addressed. %u201CWe must help the enlightened media, as opposed to small journals obsessed with national sovereignty, understand that it is the patriotic duty of the people to support the North American zone [U.S. Mexico and Canada] because it will bring prosperity to the poor and put food in the mouths of hungry babies,%u201D Henry Kissinger said. %u201CThen it can expand, as NAFTA was intended, to all the Western Hemisphere and evolve into the %u2018American Union.%u2019 %u201D
http://www.americanfreepress.net/html/bilderberg_2007.html
FOOL
Some months after Rove, et. al., have testified UNDER OATH, and likely been jailed - then might be a good time for Bush to stick his head up and ask (not demand, as that would be the style of a tyrant)nicely of Congress to take all the time Congress needs to fully debate the matter. In the meantime Congress ought to send a one-word reply (as the US Commander in Bastone replied to a Nazi demand for his surrender). The one word Congress ought to send Bush is "Nuts".
How about you big talkers?
Posted by yurpallid at 04:16 PM : Jul 28, 2007
So enlist. The Recuiting Office is probably closed on Sunday but be there bright and early Monday morning. They have lowered the standards too so it should be no problem getting in.
I have already served my country 68 to 72 if you wondered, so step up to the plate Bubba.
Posted by coffeehead at 08:32 PM : Jul 28, 2007
#1. You need to rephrase that statement. Read it closely and you should see why.
post #1
Posted by coffeehead at 08:32 PM : Jul 28, 2007
#2. That is the most stupid reason for justifying tax increases I ever saw. Make gas cost $6.00 a gallon. and inflation will go through the ceiling. Raise it to $10.00 a gallon and our economy will self destruct. The only way to stop the use of fossil fuels is to come up with a cheaper alternative. Since shrub and company onw most of the oil you know that wont happen. They will make sure that they get all the money they can wring out of it, and just before the world runs out, they will announce a "BREAKTHROUGH" in NEW technology. which they more than likely have had for some years already.
When I was younger, a friend and I modified a car to run on hydrogen and oxygen in 1955 and drove it back and forth between two local cities for a week but took it apart when we realized how dangerous it was (we didn't know enough to make it safe yet.)anyway, time put the kabosh on that idea and we drifted to other interests. (but not before 'we' knew it could be done) And no! we were not geniuses, so why hasn't it been done by Industry? GREED!!!
Post #2
Bush what he wants. I hope if we have an election,
all these TRAITORS in congress get voted out. They
have pretty much sold out America.
When we say we fight for our country, it is against fascist Bush-lovers like you who would throw our freedoms away so you can do any little thing to REAL AMERICANS that your fascist hearts desire. Don't have a working Constitution in your country do you? Red China? Russia? I'll be defending my country. The first 9mil is for you useless ignorant MOFOS. Go lick your master's azzes now- Bush and the rest need a good cleaning. Modernize this ..l.. LMFAO
%u201CThe liberty of a democracy is not safe if the people tolerate the growth of private power to a point where it becomes stronger than their democratic state itself. That, in its essence, is fascism - ownership of government by an individual, by a group, or any controlling private power.%u201D
-- Franklin D. Roosevelt
- 1
- 2
- 3
- next
See all 138 Comments