February 11, 2009 4:33 PM

Is Celebrity Rehab Effective?

By
Caitlin A. Johnson
(CBS)  Not so long ago, alcohol and drug addiction in Hollywood were considered taboo, something shameful. But now hardly a week goes by without a celebrity announcing they've checked into rehab.

Young Hollywood just loves to party but the seduction of alcohol and drugs has led many to rehab facilities like Wonderland, co-founded by Howard Samuels. It was reportedly where Lindsay Lohan went to get sober the first time.

"I have kids lining up at the door that are 19, 20, 21, that are on cocaine on a daily basis. They're doing ecstasy. They're smoking pot 24 hours a day," Samuels said.

Rehab has almost become a rite of passage. In fact, some critics complain that removing the stigma has made rehab appear cool. Combine that with spa-like facilities where they cater to Hollywood's pampered and privileged, and one can't help but wonder if rehab really is a doorway to recovery.

"Why do people have to go to a dump to get sober?" Samuels told Giuliana DePandi. "Why can't it be a beautiful environment? Don't people deserve that?"

Patients have dinner out on the patio, but even still some call it a prison.

2"It's not a prison, this is a place where we can do good work together, and change your life," Samuels said.

Just last week Lohan was celebrating her 21st birthday at an alcohol-free party in Malibu. But in January while she was supposed to be in rehab, Lohan was spotted shopping, leaving many wondering if there are two types of rehab: one for regular people and one for celebrities.

Photos: Lindsay's FINALLY Legal!
"Everyone talks about celebrities like they're some kind of alien race," Samuels said. "Celebrities are people. They have fears; they have insecurities, just like everyone else."

Samuels' staff will run errands with clients to help them incorporate recovery into their everyday life.

"If you don't take it out into the community, where are they going to learn it?" Samuels said. "If you just lock them up for 30 days and then let them out, it's like sheep being led to the slaughter."

Photos: Lindsay's Crash
An average month-long stay at Wonderland runs upwards of $40,000. Before Wonderland, Samuels ran Promises, another ritzy rehab center in Malibu where Britney Spears recently spent time, and Lohan is still an outpatient.

Now, despite evidence of bizarre behavior and excessive partying, Britney claims she didn't need help, but was forced into therapy by her mother and her manager.

Photos: Britney Spears
"She did have a problem, an emotional problem, after her second son was born and they even realized that in rehab that some of her behavior was attributed to post-partum depression," said Ashlan Gorse, editor of Life & Style Weekly.

A recovering heroin addict, Samuels says no one wants to go into rehab and many addicts suffer from denial. According to celebrity Web sites, Spears says rehab didn't change her because there wasn't anything wrong to begin with.

"She went on a 25-day binge, going out and going to the clubs," Gorse said. "There were reports of her physically getting ill in her car and outside of clubs because she was drinking too much."

However rehab is not an excuse for bad behavior.

"These celebrities are making rehab just seem cool rather than a really important way for people to heal themselves and get better," Gorse said.

From Robert Downey Jr. To Tom Sizemore, Keith Urban, Mel Gibson and Robin Williams, recovery can be a revolving door. Now Lohan has made a birthday wish for herself.

"Just to be safe and healthy and happy and stay sober," she told members of the paparazzi.

Copyright 2009 CBS. All rights reserved.
Add a Comment
by purveyor1 July 13, 2007 4:31 AM EDT
photos and articles of these girls' personal lives are no more valuable than toilet paper... perhaps less so.
Reply to this comment
by brianbwb-2009 July 13, 2007 4:09 AM EDT
Here's a question, If a marijuana user sees nothing wrong with his enjoyment of a natural herb, that numerous studies have concluded has many health benefits, not to mention fun, then what is the "goal" of rehab for "marijuana addiction" which doesn't actually exist, when one gets busted? "Clockwork Orange" style aversion therapy? Brainwashing? What happens in such rehab?

I can understand the need to rehab from alcohol, coke, heroin, and prescription pills, but pot? its actually good for you.

Just because something is illegal doesn't mean it is automatically an "evil" to be exorcized, just as many "evils" are indeed legal, that doesn't make them good.

Isn't that concept similar to the idea of Bushit's nominee for surgeon general, who once published a paper calling for similar treatments for homosexuals? Or Hitler's eugenics?

And we wonder why people snap and go on mass murder sprees, how long can one hold opposite ideas in one's head trying to reconcile both as truth?...
Reply to this comment
by Americanlady July 13, 2007 1:56 AM EDT
Wake Up America and get your heads out of the sand! There's no need to pick on the Hollywood celebs when 1 in 3 adults have reported having an alcohol problem at some time in there life!!! Check the stats on alcohol use and abuse and get the facts! Alcoholism is real and alive in America. It is time we all learned more about it...
Reply to this comment
by Americanlady July 13, 2007 1:54 AM EDT
Wake Up America and get your heads out of the sand! There's no need to pick on the Hollywood celebs when 1 in 3 adults have reported having an alcohol problem at some time in there life!!! Check the stats on alcohol use and abuse and get the facts! Alcoholism is real and alive in America. It is time we all learned more about it...
Reply to this comment
by Americanlady July 13, 2007 1:50 AM EDT
Wake Up America and get your heads out of the sand! There's no need to pick on the hollywood celebs when 1 in 3 adults have reported having an alcohol problem at some time in there life!!! Check the stats on alcohol use and abuse and get the facts! Alcoholism is real and alive in America. It is time we all learned more about it...
Reply to this comment
by hypnotoad72 July 12, 2007 7:59 PM EDT
No.

Rehab isn't luxury. It's about focusing and getting life back together.

Especially the news of these celebs going back into their "rehab" numerous times, something clearly is wrong.
Reply to this comment
by lynnrnbsn July 12, 2007 5:18 PM EDT
I hope these celebrities are paying out of their own purses for their rehabs. They have the money, and their tabs should not be paid by taxpayers. No one can tell me they don't know better than to act like they do. Although, I tend to think they (Brittany, Paris, and Lindsay to name a few) need extensive psych exams.
Reply to this comment
by misssuzq July 12, 2007 3:51 PM EDT

It is unfair to say young Hollywood likes to party.

There are plenty of young actors that control themselves just fine without making a$$es out of themselves.

The others are weak and, of course, their parents are weak.

And they make their choices just like the well behaved celebs, no excuses anymore!

Reply to this comment
.
Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook