Dead Wrestler's Doctor Faces Charges

Attorney Says Personal Doctor For Chris Benoit Is Charged With Improperly Prescribing Drugs

(AP)  The personal doctor of a pro wrestler who killed his wife and son before committing suicide was charged Monday with improperly dispensing painkillers and other drugs to other patients.

The seven-count indictment said Dr. Phil Astin, physician to wrestler Chris Benoit, dispensed drugs including Percocet, Xanax, Lorcet and Vicoprofen between April 2004 and September 2005. The recipients were identified in the indictment by the initials O.G. and M.J.; Benoit's initials were not listed.

U.S. Magistrate Judge Linda Walker ordered Astin held in lieu of $125,000 bond and said that regardless of whether he came up with the money, he would be in jail overnight. Astin will be under house arrest once he posts bond, she said.

A criminal complaint filed before the indictment and made public Monday said Astin had written prescriptions for about 1 million doses of controlled substances over the past two years, including "significant quantities" of injectable testosterone cypionate, an anabolic steroid.

The complaint by Drug Enforcement Administration Agent Anissa Jones said the amount of prescriptions was "excessive" for a medical office with a sole practitioner in a rural area like Carrollton, about 40 miles west of Atlanta.

The affidavit said Astin prescribed a 10-month supply of anabolic steroids to Benoit every three to four weeks between May 2006 and May 2007. It says that during a probe involving RX Weight Loss, Benoit was identified as an excessive purchaser of injectable steroids. Prosecutors would not clarify what RX Weight Loss is.

The affidavit also said Astin was identified as the supplier of various controlled substances, including injectable anabolic steroids that were found in Benoit's home.

Assistant U.S. Attorney John Horn said that when agents raided the doctor's office Wednesday, Astin was carrying Benoit's medical file.

Astin's attorney, Manny Arora, said the doctor had brought the file because he thought the authorities would want it.

Astin has not been charged with supplying steroids to Benoit, though U.S. Attorney David E. Nahmias said that the investigation continues and that more charges are possible.

Federal drug agents have taken over the probe into whether Astin improperly prescribed testosterone and other drugs to Benoit before the killings and suicide in the wrestler's suburban Atlanta home last month. State prosecutors and sheriff's officials are overseeing the death investigation.

Federal prosecutors are seeking the forfeiture of all property and proceeds Astin obtained through the illegal conduct if he's convicted.

Investigators have conducted two raids at Astin's west Georgia office since last week.

Astin prescribed testosterone for Benoit, a longtime friend, in the past but has not said what, if any, medications he prescribed when Benoit visited his office June 22, the day authorities believe Benoit killed his wife.

Toxicology tests on Benoit's body have not yet been completed, Fayette County District Attorney Scott Ballard said.

Anabolic steroids were found in Benoit's home, leading officials to wonder whether the drugs played a role in the killings. Some experts believe steroids can cause paranoia, depression and violent outbursts known as "roid rage."

"We're still asking questions and searching for answers with regard to the death so we can tie up loose ends," Ballard said.

Ballard said finding a motive in the case remains elusive.

"I think it will always be undetermined as to 'Why?"' Ballard said. "I think it's because there can't be any satisfactory reason why you kill a 7-year-old."

Authorities have said Benoit strangled his wife and son, placing Bibles next to their bodies, before hanging himself with the cable of a weight-machine in his home.

Benoit's father, Michael, said Monday that "it's impossible to come up with a rational explanation for a very irrational act."

"Let the cards fall where they fall, we have no control over it at this point," he said.

[boardofcerti]

you're right, eggy1620

[chinesespy]

Michael benoit should be wipped and put in prison for raising a murderer...

[eggy1620]

Would not be surprised if Benoit%u2019s steroid use caused his kid%u2019s condition.

[rushlimpdrug]

total dorks at CBs - gives no importance to the Libby discussion.
Last week Boob Shiefer's commentary laughed about not getting the Paris Hilton interview.
Maybe he was serious.
thanks CBScum

[juhatapani]

This thing that a child has an illness that is due to genes or braindamage (as my brother did), is something that is very hard to accept as a parent that there is nothing you can do to improve a childs situation or health is causing tremendious despair or hopelessness. Usually parents can`t accept it and the shots that were given to a boy tell`s me that they couldn`t take the burden or handel it. All is left is anxiety that destroys the marriage. Don`t judge so hard these two adults. I feel sorry for them.

[juhatapani]

You have to understand that Benoit was a father of a handicapped child and that is an enormous stress. They acted typically as parents who hadn`t solve or adapted the situation: isolation, they hid the child, secrecy and shame(?). Woman demanded husband to be at home: fear of beeing left and jealosy(?).Fear of income if left alone that caused to cling to husband. They did not asked for professional help that they had needed. That kind of tragedy could be one to struggle a lifetime. I know because my brother was cp-child. I remember.

[grazinggoat]

Dr. Phil Astin, should be working as Walking-Liar's private doctor... He'd do the Nation the best favor ever, we'd plead for him to be recognized as a national hero.

[annd2302]

BRIAN31462

You must have never seen Chris wrestle. I would swear the man could do super human things especially under an influence of steroids. He has pulled busses, clean and jerked almost twice his weight. The man as far as strength goes, is superhuman. Watch some of his re-runs, they are on now. Such a waste for his family and himself to die in such a manner.

I would almost side with the commenter about the third party forcing him to watch as his family was killed then he was murdered. Why not, stranger things have happened.

[annd2302]

beadazzle

What?

[nothappyatall]

"Assistant U.S. Attorney John Horn said that when agents raided the doctor's office Wednesday, Astin was carrying Benoit's medical file.

Astin's attorney, Manny Arora, said the doctor had brought the file because he thought the authorities would want it. "

Oh SURE!! looks like the doc should have ditched that file a little sooner than that- bad timing on the doc's part he got CAUGHT with the file in his hands before he could dispose of... er I mean; "turn it over to the authorities"... it so he couldn't be implicated.

Better luck next time doc!

[boardofcerti]

he is actually studddddderrrrrringgggggggggggg

[hedonist3]

beadazzle - What's with the asterisks??? Makes your post hard to read. Didn't finish it due to that. Just an FYI...

[peacethinker-2009]

Well, I looked in my mom's closet and saw what I was getting for Christmas, an UltraVibe Pleasure 2000.
Eric Cartman

[chinesespy]

THEY SHOULD PUNISH THe WRESTLER FATHER FOR RAISING SUCH A LOW LIFE SON

[brian31462]

Posted by rfcnj68 at 02:57 PM : Jul 02, 2007
To answer the questioin about the cable and the 249lbs, it is possible that if he set something up ahead of time so all he would have to do is put his head in and let what ever was holding it go. But I have to agree with everyone there are to many questions being left unanswered.

Don't you think that if he set it up befire hand and then released it after he put his head into it, that with the diameter and gauge of the cable, it would have completely or at least partially decapitated him? 240 - 249# dropped and a neck supports that? I don't think so. The human neck will not even support its own weight when dropped and a rope is around it. This was a cable, probably less than a 1/4", more like an 1/8", it would have cut his head off, unless the weight was let down slowly so as not to jerk into the neck.

[beadazzle]

***This*** ***case*** ***is*** ***so*** ***whacked*** ***out***. ***To*** ***many*** ***unanswered*** ***questions*** ***for*** ***sure***. ***We*** ***can*** ***sit*** ***at*** ***home*** ***and*** ***play*** ***dective*** ***but*** ***with*** ***out*** ***any*** ***evidence*** ***to*** ***go*** ***on*** ***besides*** ***what*** ***we*** ***see*** ***printed*** ***here*** ***makes*** ***it*** ***even*** ***harder*** ***to*** ***try*** ***and*** ***solve*** ***this*** ***case***.

***In*** ***a*** ***way*** ***I*** ***agree*** ***with*** ***some*** ***of*** ***you*** ***who*** ***think*** ***maybe*** ***someone*** ***did*** ***it*** ***and*** ***made*** ***Chris*** ***watch***.***On*** ***the*** ***other*** ***hand*** ***what*** ***were*** ***those*** ***text*** ***messages*** ***about***?
***No*** ***one*** ***has*** ***a*** ***perfect*** ***marriage*** ***but*** ***what*** ***was*** ***it*** ***that*** ***could*** ***have*** ***made*** ***this*** ***man*** ***kill*** ***his*** ***family***,***surely*** ***not*** ***just*** ***a*** ***steroid*** ***drug***,***there*** ***had*** ***to*** ***be*** ***something*** ***more*** ***to*** ***this***.

***Oh*** ***and*** ***why*** ***spread*** ***it*** ***out*** ***over*** ***the*** ***weekend***? ***How*** ***could*** ***a*** ***person*** ***sit*** ***and*** ***look*** ***at*** ***his*** ***dead*** ***wife*** ***then*** ***decided*** ***a*** ***day*** ***later*** ***to*** ***kill*** ***his*** ***son*** ***and*** ***then*** ***a*** ***day*** ***later*** ***himself***?

***What*** ***did*** ***he*** ***do*** ***to*** ***the*** ***son*** ***to*** ***keep*** ***him*** ***from*** ***seeing*** ***his*** ***mother*** ***murdered***,***before*** ***killing*** ***his*** ***son*** ***the*** ***next*** ***day***. ***Surely*** ***the*** ***child*** ***was*** ***aksing*** ***where*** ***is*** ***mommy***?

***Just*** ***way*** ***to*** ***many*** ***questions*** ***unanswered***.

[sandy19731]

do not think chris killed his wife little boy or hisself i think someone made him watch as they did it then killed him. if he would have done it i think he would have left a note so the police would not have to try to figure out what happened
Posted by tottaly_righ at 01:49 PM : Jul 02, 200

I also disagree with you based on your spelling, grammar, total lack of logic, and I would guess lack of csi knowledge. Besides, maybe he did leave a note.
Let the experts do their jobs.

[rfcnj68]

To answer the questioin about the cable and the 249lbs, it is possible that if he set something up ahead of time so all he would have to do is put his head in and let what ever was holding it go. But I have to agree with everyone there are to many questions being left unanswered.

[rfcnj68]

I have to disagree with you tottaly_righ about the note. It is not uncommon for someone in that state of mind not to leave a note. They may not feel as though they needed to leave one or even that there mental state did not allow them to write one. The more information I see though, makes me wonder if someone else was not present.

[russ1985]

You know, there are a bunch of questions that are not getting answered. How does the poster on Wikipedia just happen upon Chris' wife's death a half a day before anyone had been in the Benoit compound? The guy doesn't work for WWE, so he should not have had access to the communications between he and officials that weekend. Pulling down 240# is a bear with two hands. One handed, even with roid rage going supposedly would blow out muscles like crazy. This murder/suicide thing doesn't pass the smell test still.