May 18, 2007
The Amazing Doctor Q
A Brain Surgeon Has Surprising Roots: He Crossed The Border Illegally And Started As A Migrant Worker
-
Play CBS Video
Video
An 'American' Success Story
He's known now as "Dr. Q," a neurosurgeon at Johns Hopkins University. But not all that long ago, he was an illegal immigrant from Mexico picking crops in the U.S. Steve Hartman met up with him.
-
Video
First Look: An Immigrant Story
Only On The Web: "Dr. Q" is a Harvard-educated neurosurgeon, but he was once an illegal immigrant working as a migrant farm laborer. Steve Hartman previews a controversial "Assignment America."
-
Photo
Alfredo Quinones-Hinojosa, or "Dr. Q," entered the U.S. from Mexico by fence-hopping; he's now a brain surgeon at Johns Hopkins. (CBS)
-
E-MAIL US
Assignment America
Do you have a story for Assignment America? Send your idea by e-mail.
-
Photo Essay
Assignment America
Steve Hartman On Assignment. More Photos
-
News Tools
Immigration Reform Plan
President Bush lays out his vision for comprehensive immigration reform.
He's clinically brilliant and relentlessly charming — his patients say it's almost like he was born to be a doctor.
If they only knew.
"My very first job was with these very same hands — the very same hands that do brain surgery now, back then they pulled weeds," Dr. Q says.
Just 20 years ago, this renowned neurosurgeon was about as anonymous as a human being can get in America — just another illegal immigrant working the fields of California's San Joaquin Valley, CBS News correspondent Steve Hartman reports for Assignment America.
Born Alfredo Quinones-Hinojosa, he says that as a kid he dreamed of being a doctor. But even after he jumped the U.S.-Mexico border and took up residence in a leaky old trailer, he says the moon seemed closer than medical school.
"All that I had on my mind was just to make a little money, send it back to my parents — that's it," he says.
But he says he had this passion — to learn everything.
There were a lot of little steps.
He was picking weeds, then he got a job on a tractor. Then he was a welder. Then he went to community college and learned English.
"Then University of California-Berkeley," Dr. Q says. At Berkeley he got good grades. "Absolutely. My life began to really take off."
Next he got his U.S. citizenship and a Harvard Medical School scholarship — he graduated cum laude. He also squeezed in time for a family, and is now at Johns Hopkins, scrubbing those same weed-picking hands before performing brain surgery.
It's no doubt a remarkable American success story. But the fact that it all started with some fence-hopping makes it a controversial one, too.
"The last thing that I want is for people to think what I have done is justified," he says. "The only thing I can do is try to pay back with every single thing I do."
To that end, Dr. Q spends much of his free time in the lab — trying to find a cure for brain cancer. He hopes it makes amends, but admits he'd cross again in a heartbeat.
"It's human nature to try to find ways to survive," he says. "It's human nature, it's not rocket science."
It's not even brain surgery.
© MMVII, CBS Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Video and Galleries from Assignment America
-
Video
Kids' Ideas To Fix Recession
-
Video
Vietnam Vets Reunited
-
Video
Enemies Become Best Of Friends
- Latest in Assignment America
- Modern Day "Pride of the Yankees"
- Fighting In The Sky, Friends On The Ground
- Pint-Sized Pool Phenom Takes His Cue
This country and the American medical profession should be extremely appreciative that Dr. Quinones-Hinojosa chose to make America his new home base for his medical genius. Watch this man! Someday he will be well known worldwide for his contribution to eliminating the pain and hideous scourge of brain cancer.
You never acknowledge the other positive side of the issue. I would also point out that if the application processing mess was cured, the problem would be cut by almost 80%. Many cannot wait the 5 to 7 years it takes to process an application. They want a good life for their kids and one civil law will not stop them.
BTW, from the time you (and I) get up on Monday morning to late Friday PM, you would have violated any number of civil laws. You cannot help it, they are so many of them such as jaywalking, etc.
This Doctor is the exception to the rule. Yes, he did jump the border, but he became a citizen of the USA and he is a "PRODUCTIVE" citizen. He learned to speak English. He said he wants to give back what he can to a country that allowed him to have his dream.
The point you are missing is that with 99% of the border jumpers, this is not the case! They want a free ride and they want us to pay for it.
All we Americans want is for all Illegal Aliens to come into this country LEGALLY. Why do you suggest that they should be allowed to jump our borders which is the first crime they committ against the USA when they get here, and then move on to many other crimes after they are here? I don't want that it my country.
Oh, and something else, I never jaywalk!!!!
He may have come in illegally, but he took the steps necessary to become legal and he should be commended for that.
Ya think ??
Oh, I know, from Jose on the street corner.
By the way, who said that he became a citizen ??
The video clearly states Quiqones EARNED his American citizenship while attending Harvard Medical School.
Perhaps you should check out the many other Internet Sites which have in-depth information about this remarkable man. It's easy. Just google "Alfredo Quiqones-Hinojosa."
Perhaps you should also check the requirements of your own community college. Most allow entrance if the applicant can pass the appropriate academic exams. High School graduation is not required. However, Quiqones came to this country AFTER he had graduated from a Mexican college and was employed as a teacher.
He worked as a farm laborer, a tractor driver and a welder -- and worked full time while attending junior college. He went to the University of California, Berkeley on private scholarships NOT your tax dollars. He graduated with highest honors.
I'm sure Dr. Quiqones will be happy to send you a check for YOUR contribution to his education after HE pays off the many, many, tens of thousands of dollars of PERSONAL LOANS that enabled him to achieve the education that will save the lives of countless AMERICANS.
I find it interesting that those who know the LEAST are the ones who are most vocal with their condemning, vehement, unfounded bigotry.
Try googling "Alfredo Quinones-Hinojosa." There is only one "q" in the name "Quinones."
I am an american indian and did not invite all you whites of english dutch german and so on decent to my country and to take over and put us on reservations.
And may I remind you long before you came the spanish were here first. We have let you come and making a nice living and live in nice houses and drive nice cars,only to hear you moan and groan how bad it is. Bull,you made it that way for yourselves.
Your to good to get your hands dirty and take jobs like the illegals do. With every nationality there is a bad bunch in them but that doesn't make the whole race bad and that's plain stupid to even think that way whether,they are white or yellow or black.
So all you whiners get off your duffs and become more productive citizens,you'll feel better in the end.
Very well put. The gringo's have a saying, "Empty kettles make the loudest noises." My father's entry was similar. He too worked hard, paid his OWN way, learned the language, EARNED his citizen ship, and had to be begged to collect social security years after he qualified. His motto "We were raised to work hard, and never accept charity." He died at
90yrs of age, after working in his/our country for 75years.
If people could only accept the fact that we have good people in every race, that want to
improve their lives. Like Dr. Q, my dad, and many more. I am a proud daughter of an honorable man from Mexico.
My former husband, when six years old, was taken by his mother to a white building (# rooms) and was told that the building was school. He did not speack English, and peed his pants for the first few days because his teacher didn't speak GERMAN. Finally, some of the older children took him in hand and helped him learn. Although his family still speak their Alsatian dialect at home, he is fluent in English. And no Head Start program for him!
Is there a head start for me if I move to Mexico? Can I sing the USA national anthem? Can I get welfare or social security there? I don't think so.
BTW, I live in Texas, where there are many many illegals.
CBS is talking about THIS particular dedicated physician probably because it IS much more in vogue to TENACIOUSLY relay ONLY the stories about illegal immigrant drug dealers, rapists and murderers. It already IS the nefarious immigrants who receive the majority of the public's attention.
It's about time Americans hear the other side of the story. Many of the immigrants who once hopped the border fence are now extremely valuable American citizens. Some, like Dr. Quinones, are obviously so valuable they're INDISPENSABLE to our American society. Do we condemn them all?
Dr. Quinones has NOT been illegal since PRESIDENT RONALD REAGAN'S "Immigration Reform & Control Act of 1986." Dr. "Q" EARNED his American citizenship while studying at Harvard Medical School. What more would you demand from a
once-illegal-immigrant?
I am also against illegal immigration. But isn't it to our own country's benefit to act intelligently and reasonably and separate the good from the bad? Why not deport the illegal lawbreakers and leaches while still applauding those who have become an invaluable asset to our country?
INDISCRIMINATE hate and condemnation of ALL once-illegal-immigrants is not only outrageously unreasonable, it's also moronically STUPID!
Thank you, OpenMind56. Me too!
One has to wonder if all the unreasonable condemnation is nothing more than JEALOUSLY because a lowly young man with no worldly possessions, no influential family, even unable to speak English, was able to seek out America's vast educational opportunities that many Americans AVOID -- work his rear-end off for decades and become an esteemed neurosurgeon who every day saves fellow American's lives.
Those who have CHOSEN to be the least educated, and the most lazy -- and therefore the least successful, are always the most fervent, intolerant haters.
crossing the border is an act of an criminal. By supporting you too. Ignorant , STUPID and idiotic.We are expressing our opinion, write to CBS and not to individuals. Why want you invite him to your place without Rent. Give your TV.You are a Traitor.Aiding Abeting criminals are also a criminal act.
I will gladly let this Site's readers decide who is "STUPID" and who is not. As I've previously stated, it's the uneducated, inarticulate Americans who spew the MOST HATE toward immigrants who HAVE succeeded in this country. Obviously, some haters have not been successful with even a basic 8th grade English course.
The purpose of CBS's interview with Dr. Quinones was NOT to advocate illegal immigration. The whole point was to show that NOT all Mexicans who jumped the fence many years ago are a detriment to this country -- and some should be revered NOT condemned.
Dr. "Q" and those analogous are NOT 1%. There are more once-illegal-immigrants similar to Dr. Quinones already living in our country than any of the uneducated, bigoted haters like to believe.
Many have LEGALLY secured their green card, and have worked harder than most Americans even imagine working. By excelling at the difficult higher education that many Americans are too lazy to pursue, they have reached the pinnacle of humanity's highest valued expectations and therefore America's EARNED respect.
The best of the once-illegal-immigrents, like Dr. Quinones, have also STUDIED to earn their American Citizenship. I dare say Dr. "Q" understands our country's Constitution, laws, and history much better than YOU do, pearlleticia.
Those who TRULY CARE about our country's future do NOT condemn the immensely productive, unbelievably excellent once-illegal-immigrants along with the bums!
I am all for building the biggest - longest - strongest - border fence our engineers can construct. Yes, let's keep all FUTURE illegal immigrants out. And let's deport all the lawbreakers and bums.
However, it makes NO sense to condemn successful, taxpaying, once-illegal businessmen, teachers, nurses, etc., who are already here. Many brilliant, educated, hardworking immigrants like Dr. Quinones have obviously become nothing less than a TREASURE to our country.
In my opinion, Dr. "Q" should have earned the respect, admiration and WELCOME of all Americans the very first time he saved the life of a fellow American. Of course if it wasn't a life valued by YOU, pearlliticia, it wouldn't matter. The many, many lives Dr. Quinones has saved DO matter to other Americans.
Like useyourbrai1 so wisely stated, QUOTE: "We should celebrate that he, (Dr. "Q") was able to accomplish what most Americans cannot. He did this with hard work and determination."
If you, pearlleticia, are unfortunate to someday need a cancerous tumor removed from your narrow-minded brain, you can pick the AVERAGE neurosurgeon whose ancestors arrived in this country on the Mayflower. I will choose the once-illegal, genius miracle-worker, Dr. Quinones.
I'll bet most SMART Americans would also choose the very BEST -- no matter how they once arrived in this country.
ALL rules have EXCEPTIONS and some profoundly benefit American's lives.
Your arguments are baseless,false and unjustifiable.We do not need any illegal iimgrants. we need to enforce the border.
We do not need comprehensive immigration refoms, but the law should be enforce.As for brain surgery, i could recomend Dr Q.
Your comments are baseless and unjustifiable.
------------------------------------------------------
Take your vacant head out of the sand, pearlleticia. Whether we need illegal immigrants or not, we HAVE them. What do you suggest, piling ALL 24 MILLION of them on a Greyhound bus and shipping them back to their own countries?
How about YOU go find them all and pay for their trips? When they're all gone, YOU and YOUR family can pull the weeds and pick the crops in all the farmers' fields.
As I've already stated, I am a strong advocate of enforcing our borders. I'm also a strong advocate of being extremely careful about who we allow to FLY into our country on LEGAL visas.
The last time I checked it was NOT Mexican Nationals who were blowing up our landmark buildings, murdering thousands, and threatening to exterminate American civilization
My comments are baseless, huh? Yours are NOT even comprehensible! Perhaps you should have availed yourself of the good ol' American education that the illegals fight so hard to obtain.
I reiterate what i have stated earlier. Your comments are baseless, false and unjustifiable.
If the employers will not hire illegal immigrants they will go back.You could pay for transportation and pull weeds.
I will recomend Dr Q for brain surgery
Great idea pearlleticia ... and you even wrote an understandable sentence. Now all you have to do is convince the wealthy corporate farmers and ranchers to sacrifice their below minimum wage pay to the Mexican workers and replace them with much higher salaried American weed pullers and crop pickers ... IF they can find any.
While your at it, persuade all the multimillionaire factory and processing plant owners to sack the Mexican low paid workers so they can hire an American at twice or three times the pay. I'm sure they will love your suggestions. I don't understand why no one has ever thought of such a clever solution before. It's soooo simple.
QUOTE by pearlleticia: "You could pay for transportation and pull weeds."
Wow, TWO comprehensible sentences in a row! Hurrah! Sorry, pearlleticia, YOU are the one who wants ALL the illegal immigrants gone. Their transportation costs home and weed pulling chores are YOUR problems, not mine.
QUOTE by pearlleticia: "I will recomend Dr Q for brain surgery"
I'm sure Dr. Quinones will thank you from the bottom of his immigrant heart. YOUR recommendation is invaluable.
I recomende Dr. Q since you encorage illegal immigration.Without critizicing what is your solutions?
The problem is illegal immigrants, encorage illegal immigrations and the legal immigrants do not.Are you a illegal iimmigrant ?
-
by pearlleticia
May 23, 2007 1:45 AM PDT
- The problem is child abuse.The women get pregnant and deliver in the US. Once the kids become citizens they cry not to deport there parents.Kids Are in the front on immigration protest. This is child abuse.
-
Reply to this comment
-
See all 39 CommentsEurope put a stop to this. One parent has to be a citizen for the children to be citizen. we too shoul this.There are closing Medical facilities.They trash our cities.Illegal immgration is a cancer.