SHANGHAI, China, May 9, 2007

China Makes Arrests In Pet Food Case

Top Drug Regulator Also To Go On Trial, As China Promises To Boost Food And Drug Safety

  •  (AP / CBS)

  • In The Spotlight Pet Food Recall

    A complete list of products and answers to questions regarding the recall

  • Quiz Food Safety Quiz

    Are your kitchen habits endangering you and your loved ones?

(CBS/AP) 
Calls to office numbers at the companies rang unanswered on Wednesday. The mobile phones of managers at the companies were shut off.

Police at the local, city and provincial levels declined comment. A woman surnamed Cao at the Binzhou police in Shandong province said she could not comment because of the confidential nature of the case.

There were no listed telephone numbers for detention centers in the two areas.

The general administration statement said the companies had added melamine to the wheat gluten and rice protein in a bid to meet the contractual demand for the amount of protein in the products. It said doing so was against regulations.

However, the statement indicated the companies broke the law only when they mislabeled the exported products to avoid inspection.

The general administration said it ordered stepped-up inspections in the wake of its investigation, but that checks on 173 exporters in 11 provinces and cities had not turned up additional signs of melamine tainting after tests on 399 samples.

Additional checks for melamine were ordered on related products, such as processed meats and milk powder, but no contamination was found, it said.

The administration said it passed on those results to the FDA, officials from which were in China last week to meet government officials and visit companies. No details of the trip have been released, and it is not known if they are still in China.

"The U.S. side said it hoped for closer cooperation with the Chinese side in the area of boosting animal food safety," the notice said.

Melamine has no nutritional value but because it is nitrogen rich, it raises the nitrogen level of feed. That makes it appear to be higher in protein and, therefore, garnering a better price for the makers of feed for stock animals such as pigs, chickens, and fish, as well as companies that make prepared foods for household pets such as cats and dogs.

It is illegal to add melamine to food or animal feed in the U.S., although makers of the chemical and feed companies told The Associated Press last week the chemical was widely added to feed in China. They said they knew of no rules against the practice and were not aware that melamine could be harmful.

Xuzhou Anying managers have said they have no idea how the melamine got into the gluten, which they say was sourced from other firms and sold to a third company that exported it to the U.S.

However, suspicions were raised when the company was found to have posted an advertisement on the Web site of an online market in March seeking to buy melamine.

U.S. officials say they don't believe melamine to be harmful to humans, but say they have too little data to determine how it reacts with other substances.

American media reports have suggested the pet deaths might have been caused by melamine reacting with cyanuric acid, a similar chemical usually used to help keep swimming pools clean but which is permitted by the FDA as a feed additive in carefully limited amounts.

Sales managers at four Chinese chemical companies said they were unaware of cyanuric acid's use as a feed additive, although two others said they had heard of the practice but didn't know how widespread it was.

"As far as I know, it is seldom used in animal feed," said Chai Zhixian, a salesman with the Shanghai Experimental Reagent Co.


© MMVII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.
Add a Comment See all 31 Comments
by comfortmd1 May 10, 2007 6:02 AM EDT
china is simply making a face saving maneuver. they realize that with strongly subsidized food exports flooding this country, even our agricultural industry is going to self-destruct, just like our manufacturing has already. it is economic warfare, plain and simple.
Reply to this comment
by grammawhamma May 10, 2007 4:05 AM EDT
Our pets died of kidney failure not liver failure as the article states...does no one proof read these articles? Why is cyanuric acid allowed in foods at all? My dogs get home cooking now....and love it. Wonder how long "people" food will be safe.
Reply to this comment
by memerider May 10, 2007 3:34 AM EDT
China has never demonstrated strong ethics in any area--human rights, government, industry, etc. Why would we trust our food supply to a country which has only stolen us blind at every turn through things like software pirating, movie and music copying, designer knock-offs, you name it?! Are we crazy?!
Reply to this comment
by akrk33nnn May 9, 2007 9:32 PM EDT
cgene1 - I think you hit the nail right on the head! "Farmers" like that also get the benefit of low-tax agricultural exemptions. FDR ran for governor of New York, then later for President, claiming he was a "farmer".
Reply to this comment
by tbweb May 9, 2007 5:15 PM EDT
This incident and other Chinese domestic problems is further proof China is putting the cart before the horse spending its new found wealth on a military buildup to invade Taiwan, and make no mistake about it, when China thinks its ready and can get away with it Taiwan will be invaded and converted from a successful democracy to a communist nation. China should get its domestic house in order first and worry about spending on the military later.
Reply to this comment
by erasmus6 May 9, 2007 4:36 PM EDT
"....pet deaths might have been caused by melamine reacting with cyanuric acid, a similar chemical usaully used to TO KEEP SWIMMING POOLS CLEAN BUT WHICH IS PERMITTED BY THE FDA AS A FEED ADDITIVE IN CAREFULLY LIMITED AMOUNTS."

And we are worried about China?
So basically we need to be questioning even what our countries are putting in our pet food.
Actually we need to be questioning what is in all our food. We need to start DEMANDING that their are no chemicals and c-r-a-p in our food.

As far as China goes, why haven't they noticed their pets dying from it? Perhaps I can tell you why. It is either because they haven't been putting it in their food or when their animals die they don't give a ****. Why would they, they are going around and killing their animals anyway.

The problem with China is that after they PRETEND that they have dealt with this, everything will go back to the way it was. Maybe not with the melamine but it will be something else. We already know that there is rat poison it it, what is being done about that? All we are hearing about is the melamine.

Just remember that there could be ANYTHING in the food and the inspectors will not know that it is their unless they are specifically testing for that particular thing. And very little is actually inspected, PERIOD.
Reply to this comment
by cgene1 May 9, 2007 4:33 PM EDT
We buy tainted food items from forign countries and pay American farmers not to grow these things, makes no sense. I guess thats why when elected the first thing a politition will do is buy a farm so he can get paid for not growing anything.
Reply to this comment
by erasmus6 May 9, 2007 4:32 PM EDT
"....pet deaths might have been caused by melamine reacting with cyanuric acid, a similar chemical usaully used to TO KEEP SWIMMING POOLS CLEAN BUT WHICH IS PERMITTED BY THE FDA AS A FEED ADDITIVE IN CAREFULLY LIMITED AMOUNTS."

And we are worried about China?
So basically we need to be questioning even what our countries are putting in our pet food.
Actually we need to be questioning what is in all our food. We need to start DEMANDING that their are no chemicals and c-r-a-p in our food.

As far as China goes, why haven't they noticed their pets dying from it? Perhaps I can tell you why. It is either because they haven't been putting it in their food or when their animals die they don't give a ****. Why would they, they are going around and killing their animals anyway.

The problem with China is that after they PRETEND that they have dealt with this, everything will go back to the way it was. Maybe not with the melamine but it will be something else. We already know that there is rat poison it it, what is being done about that? All we are hearing about is the melamine.

Just remember that there could be ANYTHING in the food and the inspectors will not know that it is their unless they are specifically testing for that particular thing. And very little is actually inspected, PERIOD.
Reply to this comment
by bookwerm314 May 9, 2007 3:27 PM EDT
Our inspection process should be PAID for by the IMPORTERS! If business wants to import food products, they should pay a bonded independent agency for 100% inspection the full cost. The US Taxpayer should not pay.
For companies in the US, they are already inspected, plus we have some standards.. the Chinese think nothing of adding contamination to food items on purpose or by accident as long as they get paid..
Reply to this comment
by bookwerm314 May 9, 2007 3:27 PM EDT
Our inspection process should be PAID for by the IMPORTERS! If business wants to import food products, they should pay a bonded independent agency for 100% inspection the full cost. The US Taxpayer should not pay.
For companies in the US, they are already inspected, plus we have some standards.. the Chinese think nothing of adding contamination to food items on purpose or by accident as long as they get paid..
Reply to this comment
by bookwerm314 May 9, 2007 3:27 PM EDT
Our inspection process should be PAID for by the IMPORTERS! If business wants to import food products, they should pay a bonded independent agency for 100% inspection the full cost. The US Taxpayer should not pay.
For companies in the US, they are already inspected, plus we have some standards.. the Chinese think nothing of adding contamination to food items on purpose or by accident as long as they get paid..
Reply to this comment
by bookwerm314 May 9, 2007 3:27 PM EDT
Our inspection process should be PAID for by the IMPORTERS! If business wants to import food products, they should pay a bonded independent agency for 100% inspection the full cost. The US Taxpayer should not pay.
For companies in the US, they are already inspected, plus we have some standards.. the Chinese think nothing of adding contamination to food items on purpose or by accident as long as they get paid..
Reply to this comment
by bookwerm314 May 9, 2007 3:20 PM EDT
Our inspection process should be PAID for by the IMPORTERS! If business wants to import food products, they should pay a bonded independent agency for 100% inspection the full cost. The US Taxpayer should not pay.
For companies in the US, they are already inspected, plus we have some standards.. the Chinese think nothing of adding contamination to food items on purpose or by accident as long as they get paid..
Reply to this comment
by justrains May 9, 2007 3:12 PM EDT
Don't believe what they say or believe what they say they will do. America needs the loans from China to fight in Iraq. What will we do when China wants thier money at 27% interest? Thankyou! Mr. George W. Bush
Reply to this comment
by beanerman4 May 9, 2007 2:59 PM EDT
"Quote
The government must 'strengthen its investigations into protein products, especially melamine.'
government notice"

What government? Maybe, like whom?

"U.S. inspectors said the tainted gluten was used to make pet food and caused the deaths of an unknown number of dogs and cats through *liver* failure."

I thought it was kidney failure. Which is it? Or is it both? Are you making this up?

"The administration said it passed on those results to the FDA, officials from which were in China last week to meet government officials and visit companies. No details of the trip have been released, * and it is not known if they are still in China *." !!!!!

Maybe you are making this up...
Reply to this comment
by beanerman4 May 9, 2007 2:42 PM EDT
"Quote
The government must 'strengthen its investigations into protein products, especially melamine.'
government notice"

What government? Maybe, like whom?

"U.S. inspectors said the tainted gluten was used to make pet food and caused the deaths of an unknown number of dogs and cats through *liver* failure."

I thought it was kidney failure. Which is it? Are you making this up?

"The administration said it passed on those results to the FDA, officials from which were in China last week to meet government officials and visit companies. No details of the trip have been released, * and it is not known if they are still in China *." !!!!!

Maybe you are making this up...
Reply to this comment
by beanerman4 May 9, 2007 2:42 PM EDT
"Quote
The government must 'strengthen its investigations into protein products, especially melamine.'
government notice"

What government? Maybe, like whom?

"U.S. inspectors said the tainted gluten was used to make pet food and caused the deaths of an unknown number of dogs and cats through *liver* failure."

I thought it was kidney failure. Which is it? Are you making this up?

"The administration said it passed on those results to the FDA, officials from which were in China last week to meet government officials and visit companies. No details of the trip have been released, * and it is not known if they are still in China *." !!!!!

Maybe you are making this up...
Reply to this comment
by beanerman4 May 9, 2007 2:13 PM EDT
"Calls to office numbers at the companies rang unanswered on Wednesday. The mobile phones of managers at the companies were shut off.
Police at the local, city and provincial levels declined comment. A woman surnamed Cao at the Binzhou police in Shandong province said she could not comment because of the confidential nature of the case.
There were no listed telephone numbers for detention centers in the two areas."

Funny, all this stuff is on page 2, along with other interesting facts. Hope everyone caught it.

And who is "the general administration..." they keep quoting?
Reply to this comment
by bm6005 May 9, 2007 1:57 PM EDT
Who can trust America with their food industry? I certainly don't.
Posted by djermano1

Fine, don't eat then!!
Reply to this comment
by sevenveils May 9, 2007 1:33 PM EDT
Sorry for the multiple post, I swear I pushed the publish button only once.
Reply to this comment
See all 31 Comments

Exclusive Webshow

Best-selling author Mitch Albom on his first nonfiction work since "Tuesdays with Morrie." Watch Now

Latest News
News in Pictures
Scroll Left Scroll Right
Connect with CBS News

Stay connected with the CBS News using your favorite social networks and online news applications: