Obama Now Controls His Space On MySpace

Former Owner Says He Was Heartbroken Campaign Was "Bullying" Him Out Of Page He Founded

(AP)  Is MySpace always mine or can it belong to someone else?

At the cost of losing 160,000 friends, Democrat Barack Obama's presidential campaign has taken over control of the MySpace page listed under his name on the popular social networking site.

The case highlights the struggle between campaigns' desire to control their message versus the power of voter-generated material. And it shows how one person — in this case Los Angeles paralegal Joe Anthony — can become an influence on presidential politics through the power of the Internet.

The dispute between the Obama campaign and Anthony, a one-time supporter who started the Obama MySpace page, became such a concern for the Illinois senator that he personally tried to smooth things over Wednesday night.

Anthony felt he was mistreated by the campaign after he spent the past 2½ years running the MySpace page as an enthusiastic volunteer. At first, that arrangement was fine with the Obama team, which worked with Anthony on the content, promoted the link and even had the password to make changes.

But as the site exploded in popularity in recent months, the campaign became concerned about an outsider controlling the content and responses going out under Obama's name. It told Anthony it wanted him to turn it over.

In this new frontier of online campaigning, it's hard to determine the value of 160,000 MySpace friends — about four times what any other official campaign MySpace page had amassed. But the Obama campaign decided they wouldn't pay $39,000, which is what Anthony said he proposed for his extensive work on the site, plus some additional fees up to $10,000.

MySpace reluctantly stepped in to settle the dispute and decided that Obama should have the rights to control the Barack Obama MySpace page as of Monday night. Anthony had the right to take all the friends who signed up while he was in control, and that includes the right to tell them how he feels about the Obama campaign — although he said he was still locked out of the page with his contacts as of Wednesday.

Anthony wrote on his MySpace blog that he was heartbroken that the Obama campaign was "bullying" him out of the page he built. He initially said the candidate lost his vote, but Obama may have begun to win it back after a Wednesday evening phone call that Anthony called a great honor. Anthony said he was so nervous that he doesn't remember exactly what Obama said, but the candidate expressed his appreciation and they agreed everyone learned a lesson in this case.

"I assured him that this is just a horrible thing that happened and obviously he wasn't responsible," Anthony said in a blog post. "It'll take time for me to work this out and decide if I will personally continue to support Obama, regardless of how I feel about his campaign's handling of this situation."

Meanwhile, the Obama campaign was trying to rebuild his friends network from scratch and was up to more than 21,000 by Thursday evening.

Joe Rospars, Obama's director of new media, wrote in a blog post that the campaign "decided to take a leap" in teaming up with an outside organizer on MySpace. He said the arrangement worked at first, but campaign officials became uncomfortable when Anthony changed the password to prevent them from working on the site and made his financial requests.

"We're going to try new things, and sometimes it's going to work, and sometimes it's not going to work," Rospars wrote. "That's the cost and that's the risk of experimenting."

The campaign's fight drew widespread criticism among leading liberal bloggers who question why they would treat a volunteer like Anthony with such disregard. But Obama has some online defenders who say volunteer work should remain that way and not be held up for payment.

Advocacy Inc. CEO Roger Alan Stone collects and sells contact information to Democratic campaigns, lawmakers and advocacy groups, but says he isn't working for any of the current White House candidates. He says e-mail addresses collected for such a cause can go for $1 each, so in that sense the price Anthony was asking was low.

But Stone comes down on the side of the Obama campaign in this dispute.

"As something that was done on a volunteer basis that you want to charge for after the fact, that is ridiculous," Stone said.

[toolmangler-2009]

Burrito?
Posted by booyaw_77 at 11:36 AM : May 03, 2007


you are funnin, aint ya?

[toolmangler-2009]

If you are going to be MY VOLUNTEER, then you need to be on the SAME page I'M on!
You can't take MY NAME,
PRETEND to be MY volunteer,
GAIN FAME ON MY NAME
And then YOU, the VOLUNTEER, become the issue!
Who the hell is running for office here?
The VOLUNTEER or Obama?
Posted by Agnim at 11:54 AM : May 03, 2007


Gotta go with agnim on this one (dernit!)

[toldyouso21]

Go to you tube and see this video if you care about bringing the troops home--what's more, sign up and vote or leave a comment. Hurry, as fast as we tell people about this, CBS is closing down the blogs where it is mentioned. They must take their marching orders from Bush. Build momentum...See this--and let Congress Know!!!!

http://youtube.com/watch?v=nnH
kWfIAyHE&mode=related&search=

Pass this message on.

[agnim]

"It's all about "Control"
Posted by Gunnerv1 at 12:44 PM : May 03, 2007"

Yes!
Gun 'control' with tamp down gun violence from GUN NUTS! LOL

[gunnerv1]

It's all about "Control"

[agnim]

If you are going to be MY VOLUNTEER, then you need to be on the SAME page I'M on!

You can't take MY NAME,

PRETEND to be MY volunteer,

GAIN FAME ON MY NAME

And then YOU, the VOLUNTEER, become the issue!

Who the hell is running for office here?

The VOLUNTEER or Obama?

[agnim]

"I really thought Obama was different, but clearly he's not. Just another powerful, jerk politician pushing around the little guy. .....
If the Obama campaign had paid him for all the work he put into the site then everything would be fine.
Posted by alsdailynews at 10:03 AM : May 03, 2007"

If you are harping about money, then the guy was PAID $10,000 and a personal call and chat with a US SENATOR FOR WORK THAT WAS SUPPOSEDLY VOLUNTEER!

Moreover, it is important that the politicians be able to control their messages AND NOT THE VOLUNTEERS!

Which campaign you know allow VOLUNTEERS to control their content/presentation to the public?

[booyaw_77]

Everybody yer talk'n to here.. is 50 years old, unshaven, a big ugly beer belly, and with grey pubic hairs! DON'T USE! SHAABA SHAABA SHAABA! STAY FAR FAR AWAY! NOBODY ALLOWED!

Trust me.. You'll never be taken seriously.

sssssssssssss!!!!!!

[booyaw_77]

People call it this "freedom of expression" bullshyyt and they're not fooling anyone! STAY AWAY!

[booyaw_77]

X-Conservative here with some true advice fer Democrats (cuz I suddenly realized its never been more expensive than with compassionate conservatism):

DON'T USE THE INTERNET! THE INTERNET IS FULL OF PERVERTS AND WEIRDOS! POLITICIANS SHOULD STAY AS FAR AWAY FROM THE INTERNET AS IS HUMANLY POSSIBLE!

I don't care what ya gots to say! Nobody gets elected from the internet. Klatoo Burrito Nicto!

[booyaw_77]

Don't do a Howeird Dean.. fer gawd's sake. If yaz wanna win anyway.

[realpatriot1]

So Obama's a jerk because he didn't want to pay his "supporter" $49,000 in extortion to control the message being associated with his name and campaign?
I don't think so.

Anyone who would base their support in the Presidential race on this is a fool. This has about as much significance as a $400 haircut or what name Hillary goes by or whether we call Obama Barack or Barry.

infidel_US,

We've heard your fearless prediction for 2008...could you share with us what you predicted for last November?

didn'tinhale,
as usual your post confuses me. Since Obama's father was the Muslim and Obama is a Christian, where's the link to global terrorism? Is it like Sadaam and Al Qaeda...all in the imagination of small minds?

[thomas_veil]

This really doesn't surprise me. About six weeks ago, all of the Cafepress shop owners -- little people like Mr. Anthony -- suddenly found their use of the Obama campaign logo suspended on items like T-shirts and bumper stickers.

Now, they have the right to do that; they own the copyright to that design. And yes, the shop owners were making money off those products (usually a paltry amount). But it's interesting that none of the other Democratic candidates (that I know of) have enforced their copyright. Edwards, Biden and others are apparently more interested in getting their names spread around than in collecting copyright royalties. It's only Obama's campaign that's being a control freak about this.

[tcoleman12]

Wasn't Bolton criticized and eventually kicked out of his highly effective job as UN Ambassador for being called a "Bully"?

Sounds similar here... I think I am going to start looking at Fred Thompson, whenever he gets in the race!

[infidel_us]

It doesn't matter. He will not get the nomination, and he won't get elected.

[pghlady3]

well Barry, you just lost 160,00 of your closest friends. Too bad.

[dasclay]

I can see both sides on this one, I think I would of made him a offer of being part of the offical party. then if he declined, maybe gave him a choice abou the site.

[toldyouso21]

They should not have taken over his site. People who go on my space want that raw, freedom and to view what others think NOT to hear canned rhetoric from paid hacks. I doubt if the pages will be as raw or interesting now--Obama--like all politicians, is succumbing to handlers and proving in the end--he will be no different than the rest of them. START A NEW PAGE!! SEE if you can get more "friends" than the stolen one!

[tuckerndfw]

Most MySpace users are too young to vote. And, those who are old enough to vote, most likely won't.

Obama was correct to take over a site operated using his name, which he made popular, not MySpace.

And, is also correct for refusing to pay money for worthless email addresses or MySpace "friends."