BELTSVILLE, Md., May 2, 2007

Myths Abound About U.S. Bee Disappearance

So Far Nobody Can Explain The Disappearance Of One Quarter Of The Population, But Theories Abound

  • For many entomologists, the bee crisis is a wake-up call. By relying on a single species for pollination, U.S. agriculture has put itself in a precarious position, they say.

    For many entomologists, the bee crisis is a wake-up call. By relying on a single species for pollination, U.S. agriculture has put itself in a precarious position, they say.  (AP)

  • Interactive Contagious Critters

    Learn about some of the ways exotic and everyday pets can make people sick.

  • Quiz Are You Food Savvy?

    Have you consumed myths about diet and nutrition? Take these quizzes to find out.

(AP)  The answer to what happened to America's vanishing honeybees is simple, a caller told entomologist May Berenbaum: Bee rapture. They were called away to heaven.

No, wait, it is Earth's magnetic field, another caller told the University of Illinois professor.

And when Berenbaum went on the Internet, she found a parody news site that quoted her as blaming rapper Kevin Federline, Britney Spears' ex-husband, and his concerts for the disappearance of the bees. Berenbaum loved it.

The sudden disappearance of one-quarter of America's honeybees has brought out some strange ideas and downright myths.

“I just can't get any work done,” Berenbaum said. “I'm overwhelmed by e-mails. I can't keep up.”

A couple of bee myths are big on the Internet.

A small German scientific study looking at a specific type of cordless phones and the homing systems of bees exploded over the Internet and late night television shows. It morphed into erroneous reports blaming cell phones for the honeybee die-off, which scientists are calling Colony Collapse Disorder.

The scientist who wrote the paper, Stefan Kimmel, e-mailed The Associated Press to say that there is “no link between our tiny little study and the CCD-phenomenon ... anything else said or written is a lie.” And U.S. Department of Agriculture top bee researcher Jeff Pettis laughs at the idea, because whenever he goes out to investigate dead bees, he cannot get a signal on his cell phone because the hives are in such remote areas.

Also on the Internet is a quote attributed to Albert Einstein on how humans would die off in four years if not for honeybees. It is wrong on two counts.

First, Einstein probably never said it, according to Alice Calaprice, author of “The Quotable Einstein” and five other books on the physicist.

“I've never come across it in anything Einstein has written,” Calaprice said. “It could be that someone had made it up and put Einstein's name on it.”

Second, it is incorrect scientifically, Pettis said. There would be food left for humans because some food is wind-pollinated.

For his part, Pettis jokes that the bees are out creating crop circles “and it's working them to death.”

© MMVII The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.



The Christian Science Monitor is an independent daily newspaper, with news from around the world to help you understand this changing world.

Add a Comment See all 33 Comments
by itwasntme000 May 4, 2007 11:13 AM EDT
all plants contain natural pesticides, and often herbicides, and they are quite potent. Yes, and that includes organic foods. That's how plants defend themselves.
Posted by brucesmall at 05:55 PM : May 03, 2007

Any natural pesticides, ect evloved over time along with the bee's evolution. Thus, only the bees that werent effected survived. Or are you a religious man that dosent believe evolution ever happend.......haha figures
Reply to this comment
by honest_news May 4, 2007 3:07 AM EDT
Why can't this kind of thing happen to wasps, hornets and yellow-jackets, or to all types of biting flies, for that matter???
Reply to this comment
by processor2 May 4, 2007 1:43 AM EDT
I read a great article in National Geographic stating that a similar bee die-off occurred during the 1880's, in which over 90 percent died.

Just nature's way of thinning the herd that is not genetically diverse enough.

According to National Geographic, anyway.

...

Maybe the dingoes ate your beebees.
Posted by hawksprings at 11:21 AM : May 03, 2007

HAWKSPRINGS.......now that's funny sh.t

...
Reply to this comment
by entity2006 May 3, 2007 9:32 PM EDT
I just watched an old movie today (X-Files). After seeing that, I know what happened to the bees. They are being stored for use of spreading an alien virus.
Reply to this comment
by brucesmall May 3, 2007 8:55 PM EDT
I have to wonder if those who blame genetically modified plants realize that all plants contain natural pesticides, and often herbicides, and they are quite potent. Yes, and that includes organic foods. That's how plants defend themselves.
Reply to this comment
by roger_inkart May 3, 2007 8:55 PM EDT
Brngs to mind a bumper stick I recently saw:

"Nature Bats Last"

If the bees don't pollenate - we don't get food. We don't get food - we die.

We've been beating the H3LL out of the planet for centuries now. It's little wonder she's trying new and inventive ways to protect herself.
Reply to this comment
by mountainzen May 3, 2007 7:59 PM EDT
President Bush heard of "Spelling Bees," panicked, and had them labeled as enemy combatant-bees. You'll find them in Cuba.
Reply to this comment
by gc331 May 3, 2007 7:57 PM EDT
"Bzz..Bzzz" --

in english:

"Good bye, and thanks for all the pollen."

;-)
Reply to this comment
by itwasntme000 May 3, 2007 7:36 PM EDT
Someone should do a lord of the rings theme scenario. With gimbee/arabee/ damm been to long since i watched it i can only remember giblee and aragon's names haha
Reply to this comment
by mitywhity May 3, 2007 7:18 PM EDT
It's Bill Clinton's fault.
Reply to this comment
by itwasntme000 May 3, 2007 7:03 PM EDT
Sorry about my last post I ran short on time because some work came in and a few things had piled up. Geez and i was having fun here too.
It was originally gonna deal with iraq and the U.S. but strayed away. If it stays slow here I should be able to come with another one on that.

But first.

MAYBE... The male worker bees were fed up with low wages and disrespect they got while working as compared to the woman bee who made all the money and had the following of most the population. So they fley to big momma queen bush's "whitehive" to protest and big momma pre-emptively attacked them in fear they would try kill her.

grr work again had to chuck out some kind of ending!!!
Reply to this comment
by hunter10039 May 3, 2007 6:13 PM EDT

THE REASON FOR THEIR DISAPPEARANCE IS BECAUSE OF GENETICALLY ALTERED PLANTS

THAT WERE ALTERED TO PUT INSECTICIDE INTO THE PLANT SO FARMERS WOULD NOT HAVE TO SPRAY POISON.

THE INSECTICIDE WAS IN THE POLLEN AS WELL....

AND WHEN THE BEES COLLECTED THE POLLEN...THEY WERE POISONED .....INSTEAD OF THE BAD BUGS THE SCIENTISTS INTENDED TO KILL......

WAY TO GO ...SMARTY-PANTS-SENTISTS!!!!!!!

Reply to this comment
by itwasntme000 May 3, 2007 6:13 PM EDT
Maybe the peace tready between the bee and the horsefly populations fell apart when the bee's reportedly defaced a statue of the horsefly god jesusfly. Following this action the horsefly population and the free air states of the mosquito joined together to erradicate the godless bee population.
Reply to this comment
by itwasntme000 May 3, 2007 5:38 PM EDT
Maybe the queen bee was making unreasonable requests of her worker bees. So they decided to go on strike. Then to appease their seexual desires they all got gaay with each other and found out a lot less was demanded of them.

I forgot to add that this no longer perpetuated the species so they are now dying off. But that is just a logical deduction from the original post
Reply to this comment
by itwasntme000 May 3, 2007 5:34 PM EDT
Maybe the queen bee was making unreasonable requests of her worker bees. So they decided to go on strike. Then to appease their seexual desires they all got gaay with each other and found out a lot less was demanded of them.

Or the "war on drugs" bees found that most of the population was buzzing around the ganja and coocoa plants a little to much. Soo, in order to ensure the young population wouldn't be corrupted they send all the bad bees to bee jail to think about what they have done. As soon as they learn beehave they will be released.

I will try to think of more ideas haha
Reply to this comment
by itwasntme000 May 3, 2007 5:12 PM EDT
Maybe it was because we had a time period of extremely low temperaturas this winter. and where live at we had an above average amount of snow also. Granted the average temp for the entire winter was higher.
Reply to this comment
by helenuu May 3, 2007 4:11 PM EDT
Between spraying growing things from the air as
well as modifying so many types of plants, common sense would tell us it would kill the bees. Guess we'll have to arm everyone with soft brushes
and have everyone go out into the gardens and do the pollinization. Guess we'll need more immigrants to come to America, as most of us think we are too nice to do such menial tasks.
Reply to this comment
by processor2 May 3, 2007 3:21 PM EDT
I read a great article in National Geographic stating that a similar bee die-off occurred during the 1880's, in which over 90 percent died.

Just nature's way of thinning the herd that is not genetically diverse enough.

According to National Geographic, anyway.

...

I'm surprised that some democrat hasn't blamed George Bush yet, ha ha

...
Reply to this comment
by processor2 May 3, 2007 3:21 PM EDT
I read a great article in National Geographic stating that a similar bee die-off occurred during the 1880's, in which over 90 percent died.

Just nature's way of thinning the herd that is not genetically diverse enough.

According to National Geographic, anyway.

...

I'm surprised that some democrat hasn't blamed George Bush yet, ha ha

...
Reply to this comment
by kevboom May 3, 2007 3:19 PM EDT
I'm surprised some republican hasn't blamed Bill Clinton yet. ha ha
Reply to this comment
See all 33 Comments

Exclusive Webshow

Best-selling author Mitch Albom on his first nonfiction work since "Tuesdays with Morrie." Watch Now

Latest News
News in Pictures
Scroll Left Scroll Right
Connect with CBS News

Stay connected with the CBS News using your favorite social networks and online news applications: