GREENVILLE, S.C., April 26, 2007

McCain: Gonzales Should Step Down

Call For Attorney General's Resignation Is First Among Republican Presidential Hopefuls

  • Video McCain To Run

    CBS News Dep. Pol. Dir. Steve Chaggaris discusses Sen. John McCain's announcement that he's joining the 2008 presidential race and how his age and support for the war in Iraq may affect his campaign.

  • Video McCain Sings 'Bomb Iran'

    CBS News RAW: During a campaign stop in South Carolina, Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., parodied the tune "Barbara Ann" when questioned about Iran, singing "Bomb Bomb Bomb ... Bomb Bomb Iran."

    • Arizona Sen. John McCain, left, is the first Republican presidential candidate to call for Attorney General Alberto Gonzales to step down.

      Arizona Sen. John McCain, left, is the first Republican presidential candidate to call for Attorney General Alberto Gonzales to step down.  (CBS/AP)

    • Sen. John McCain, seen here shaking hands at his campaign kick-off in New Hampshire on April 25, 2007, has called for Attorney General Alberto Gonzales to resign over his role in the firings of eight U.S. Attorneys.

      Sen. John McCain, seen here shaking hands at his campaign kick-off in New Hampshire on April 25, 2007, has called for Attorney General Alberto Gonzales to resign over his role in the firings of eight U.S. Attorneys.  (AP Photo/Stephan Savoia)

    Previous slide Next slide
  • Who's Who Firings Firestorm

    Justice Department at center of controversy over firing of eight U.S. attorneys.

  • Who's Who 2008 Republican Hopefuls

    McCain and Giuliani head up the Republican pack chasing the presidency.

(CBS/AP)  Presidential contender John McCain reiterated Thursday that Attorney General Alberto Gonzales should leave office amid the growing furor over the firings of eight federal prosecutors.

"His best loyalty to the president would be served by stepping down," McCain said during a morning campaign stop in this early primary state.

The Arizona Republican senator told CNN in a report aired late Wednesday that he was disappointed with Gonzales and that the attorney general should step down. "I think loyalty to the president should enter into his calculations," McCain said in the interview with Larry King.

On Thursday, McCain was joined at his campaign stop by Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., and bantered with reporters about Graham being the perfect replacement as attorney general.

"It would be a very popular move in Congress," McCain said. Graham laughed, but did not address the remark and the two quickly joked when asked about sharing a presidential ticket.

"I think he'd make a lousy vice president," Graham said.

McCain's sense of humor has been criticized twice in the past week. On Tuesday night, he joked on Comedy Central's "The Daily Show with Jon Stewart," that he brought an explosive device back from Iraq as a gift for the show's host. Last week, while in South Carolina, McCain gave a rendition of the opening lyrics of the Beach Boys rock classic "Barbara Ann," calling the tune "Bomb Iran" and changing the words to "bomb, bomb, bomb, bomb, anyway, ah ..."

On Thursday, he said that people with military experience know that a sense of humor is vital.

"We veterans know how important a sense of humor is," he said, adding that critics have to "lighten up and get a life."

McCain is the first Republican presidential contender to urge Gonzales to resign, and the fourth Republican senator to do so, joining Tom Coburn of Oklahoma, Gordon Smith of Oregon and John Sununu of New Hampshire. Several others have stopped short of demanding Gonzales' resignation but have harshly criticized his leadership.

Mr. Bush has given Gonzales a strong vote of confidence, and the attorney general himself has vowed to remain in his post despite bipartisan criticism of his leadership. At a contentious Senate Judiciary Committee hearing last week, Gonzales claimed dozens of times that he couldn't recall key details about the firings or about a meeting that records show he attended.

During his morning speech to about 150 people in South Carolina, McCain also touted his experience and warned that a congressional timeline for pulling troops from Iraq will cause terrorism to "follow us home."

The Arizona senator lauded South Carolinians for their support of U.S. troops overseas and said he is a candidate who can wage war if necessary. "I know how to fight, and I know how to make peace,” McCain said, a day after formally declaring his second White House bid.

On Wednesday, the House brushed aside a veto threat and passed legislation that would order President Bush to begin withdrawing troops from Iraq by Oct. 1. McCain predicted dire consequences.

"A date of troop withdrawal is a date for certain surrender," McCain told The Early Show's Harry Smith. "We'd have to leave. Chaos would ensue in the region and they'd follow us home."

McCain, who planned a full day of campaigning in the state, made his remarks hours before Democratic candidates were to meet in South Carolina for their first debate of the 2008 election season.

He also evoked President Ronald Reagan as he took aim at congressional spending, reminding the crowd that Reagan said Congress tended to approve spending "like a drunken sailor." McCain pledged that his presidency would quash excessive spending.

"It will be brought to halt," he said. "We've got to get spending under control."



© MMVII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.
Add a Comment See all 37 Comments
by Joelran April 27, 2007 2:51 PM EDT
I am slowly realizing that people like didntinale truly hate america. They seem to enjoy seeing our country dragged through the mud and lose all respect in the world.
From now on, if I hear someone arguing for the war in Iraq, I will simply ask them what did the USA do to them that they hate it so much that they want our children, parents and spouses to die there. Hate it so much that they spit on our troops.
I pity them, really.
Reply to this comment
by azman80 April 27, 2007 12:27 PM EDT
I tell you what. This piece of hard-*** McCain needs to step down himeself. He is a huge @sshole and liar, and not to mention he hasn't done a D@mn thing for AZ in a long time. He is a waste of flesh.
Reply to this comment
by flreason April 27, 2007 12:14 PM EDT
"didntinhale" Omigod-I can't believe that you're labelling someone based on their middle name! And how did you get so full of hate?!!! Do you think that having the middle name Herbert made Bush1 a follower of Hoover's policies or a Quaker? You need to get over your neocon-induced paranoia. If you really want to convince anyone that you're anything but a crackpot, you need to argue based on reality and logic, rather than emphasizing your ignorance by using smear tactics. Do your homework--you might learn something and get a grip on reality.

As an Independent, I look at all the candidates. Obama regular attends a Christian church and just indicated his support for Israel in the debate last night. His statement about Palestinians was taken out of context. Heard in context, it is a statement of sympathy for the suffering of others. Isn't that a Christian virtue? Hate and false witness aren't.
Reply to this comment
by mizpah63 April 27, 2007 6:54 AM EDT
John McCain's opinion concerning any topic has no credibility. He has changed positions on virtually everything at least once. Sympathy votes based on age, diminishing hero status and declining mentation are not going to win him the nomination. Which prudent corporate CEO is going to obligate funds to support McCain's campaign? Of course, the big money players hedge their bets, but they are not fools who lavish dollars on has-been, hack politicians. They have expectations for a return on their investment. This begs the question, "What are McCain's sources of campaign financing?" Tell us about the soft money you were at one time so opposed to, Senator. You changed your position on that too, didn't you? Mr. McCain is an appalling example of what happens to a person's integrity when he or she is driven by power and avarice.
Reply to this comment
by randalds April 27, 2007 5:15 AM EDT
"Remember, it took a Republican controlled Congress to pass the FIRST prescription benefit EVER). Please, wake up and grow a brain....."
Posted by BIGDADPATRIO at 07:28 PM : Apr 26, 2007

You must not be a senior citizen. I know from my mother-in-law that your "FIRST prescription benefit EVER)" is not that great. You make it sound like they are giving away prescriptions. Not so, and they (those Republicans, again) refused to allow any sort of competitive bidding for prescription prices.
Posted by barbaraf4 at 11:57 PM : Apr 26, 2007

And the lack of competitive bidding means that the big drug companies can charge the taxpayers pretty much anything they want to for the drugs...and they do. The prescription drug program would be great IF if had competitive pricing, but Bush said he would veto any version that did. It is now a huge windfall for the drug companies hidden under a good sounding idea.
Reply to this comment
by April 27, 2007 3:13 AM EDT
tdweb wrote:

"Attorney General Alberto Gonzales claims he did nothing wrong, I agree with the 1st part of that statement, he did nothing! He did nothing while the U.S. inherited a new illegal minority population from Mexico some 18 million plus strong! Did Attorney General Alberto Gonzales look the other way and not go after the 18 million illegals because of cultural sympathy? Its a fair question! You are right sir, you did nothing and that's the problem! Very few people would stay in office and would have resigned under similar circumstances especially with so many U.S. Senators showing a lack of confidence. The U.S. Attorney General should not be a close friend of the U.S. President anyway, this is business, nothing personal!"

You know, for once I am inclined to agree with you on this one - at least in part.
Reply to this comment
by barbaraf4 April 27, 2007 2:57 AM EDT
"Remember, it took a Republican controlled Congress to pass the FIRST prescription benefit EVER). Please, wake up and grow a brain....."
Posted by BIGDADPATRIO at 07:28 PM : Apr 26, 2007

You must not be a senior citizen. I know from my mother-in-law that your "FIRST prescription benefit EVER)" is not that great. You make it sound like they are giving away prescriptions. Not so, and they (those Republicans, again) refused to allow any sort of competitive bidding for prescription prices.
Reply to this comment
by tbweb April 27, 2007 2:32 AM EDT
Attorney General Alberto Gonzales claims he did nothing wrong, I agree with the 1st part of that statement, he did nothing! He did nothing while the U.S. inherited a new illegal minority population from Mexico some 18 million plus strong! Did Attorney General Alberto Gonzales look the other way and not go after the 18 million illegals because of cultural sympathy? Its a fair question! You are right sir, you did nothing and that's the problem! Very few people would stay in office and would have resigned under similar circumstances especially with so many U.S. Senators showing a lack of confidence. The U.S. Attorney General should not be a close friend of the U.S. President anyway, this is business, nothing personal!
Reply to this comment
by tucano2 April 26, 2007 11:50 PM EDT
Why allow Gonzales to resign? Any boss with a backbone would have fired the s.o.b. months ago.
Get 'er done.
Reply to this comment
by djermano1 April 26, 2007 10:40 PM EDT
The whole lot of knuckleheads heads should resign. From GW Bushy with his wag attack dog Cheney. They should be impeached and locked up in Gitmo.
Reply to this comment
by bigdadpatrio April 26, 2007 10:28 PM EDT
bill1fj, then ALL Democrats should also resign from Congress, because it is their Political Correctness and the laws they have passed over the past years that have created much of the problems that you point to. What did they (Dems) do for the 40+ years they controlled Congress towards getting Americans healthcare? (Remember, it took a Republican controlled Congress to pass the FIRST prescription benefit EVER). What did the Democrats do regarding illegal immigration for those 40 years (nothing). What did they do to STOP the illegals from getting the FREE healthcare (nothing, because they were too busy kissing the Hispanics and the illegals *****, and they were afraid of PISSING OFF the same ones who vote to get them elected every time. Please, wake up and grow a brain.....
Reply to this comment
by poetrychaos April 26, 2007 10:23 PM EDT
Bertie's doin a heck of a job!"
Reply to this comment
by bigdadpatrio April 26, 2007 10:21 PM EDT
McCain has caved to the extreme left with this one!!! First, NO LAWS have been broken. He (Gonzales) can fire anyone he wishes for any reason he wishes. It may **** US OFF, but it doesn't rise the the levels of being against the law. Get over it Dems. Quit wasting our taxpayer dollars and our Confress' time fretting over a non-issue.
Reply to this comment
by rochest April 26, 2007 9:40 PM EDT
so McCain's said he would cut off excessive funding. I take that to mean the extra funds for the troops, their housing in the states and the schools their children go to, the new v-shaped Humvee that the army says will protect better against the IEDs and that you Senator McCain used while you were in Iraq or what about the extra money for the veterans a ministration and the hospitals it manages. So tell me what would you cut down of this budget? And tell me again how your supporting our troops by doing so and how this the administration with it's fine shrubbery is supporting our troops by vetoing this very necessary piece of legislation.
Reply to this comment
by kansas1946 April 26, 2007 9:40 PM EDT
Oh, gosh, now that McCain has been Bush's toady for six years, he is going to state his opinion that this lying, criminal, ammoral, POS, AG should step down so he isn't a drag on poor little King George. JOHN, what is the matter with you. This is the same Gonzales that, in his legal opinion, decided that it was okay to torture prisoners under our control. John you should really love that idea.
Reply to this comment
by bill1fj April 26, 2007 8:51 PM EDT
Resign Alberto.
McCain should also think about resigning, or retiring. He hasn't done his job in congress.
The middle east is in a mess. Millions of illegal aliens in the country. Companies and individuals endangering us all by hiring illegals with no fear of reprucussions. The lack of health care for millions of legal citizens is apalling, while billions are spent on health care for illegals.
Our education system needs to be improved. Badly.
McCain has been in congress while all this has happened and he has done very little.
Yep John - You should resign too.
Thank You
Reply to this comment
by adian1-2009 April 26, 2007 8:39 PM EDT
Two things to comment about what McCain said. First, Gonzales should not resign out of loyalty to Bush. That is not a good reason in the present circumstances. McCain did not have pants enough to say that Gonzales should resign because he is a proven liar and a proven incompetent. Second, McCain seems to be hung on the scare card. Withdrawing from Iraq will bring terrorists home. It will create a chaos in Iraq. And what is what America has created in Iraq? Isn't it chaos what we have there? He tries to scare us with his statement that terrorists will come here. Come on, McCain! Are you sure staying in Iraq or leaving Iraq will make a difference? Where is the connection between one thing and the other? Do you still believe in the lies aired by Bush and Cheney to justify the attack and invasion of Iraq you voted for?
Reply to this comment
by acauble1 April 26, 2007 8:20 PM EDT
Friends of Bush can get away with anything!

You have to wonder, how much does one of these 'friends' have to do in order for Bush to say enough is enough?!

Rape a 10-year-old?

I'm sure somehow Bush and his Neo-Con lemmings would probably find fault with the 10-year-old, and not the 'friend' who raped him.
Reply to this comment
by pakaal April 26, 2007 8:19 PM EDT
C'mon people, think! If everyone is out to get Gonzales, what does it mean? It means he must be doing something good.... C'mon, think it through. How could all of those people hate him unless he was doing something right.
Posted by SharnCedar

I'm sorry, what? People hate people when they're doing something right? By that logic, Hitler must have done more good things than any other 20th century leader, because he was so universally hated.

It's usually the case that people become upset with other people when they do something WRONG, like Gonzales has done from day one (torture memo) to today ("I don't know" 70 times in one day).
Reply to this comment
by hungry1968 April 26, 2007 8:10 PM EDT
SharnCedar

It's not that he did anything right or wrong. At the Senate hearings they handed him a piece of paper with the list of names of the attorney's to be fired. They asked him who sent it to him - he didn't know.

So he doesn't know who sent him the list, but he fired the people on it, because it said to? I sure hope Bush doesn't get a piece of paper telling him to launch nukes somewhere!!

The level of incompetence in the republican party is just terrifying!!!
Reply to this comment
See all 37 Comments

Exclusive Webshow

Best-selling author Mitch Albom on his first nonfiction work since "Tuesdays with Morrie." Watch Now

Latest News
News in Pictures
Scroll Left Scroll Right
Connect with CBS News

Stay connected with the CBS News using your favorite social networks and online news applications: