April 23, 2007 4:00 PM
- Text
Study: No Abortion-Breast Cancer Link
generic breast cancer womens health (CBS/AP)
(WebMD)
There is no link between abortion and breast cancer, a 10-year study shows.
Researchers base the findings on a study in which they followed 105,716 women for 10 years. They found no link between abortion and breast cancers that occur before menopause.
Earlier large-scale studies showed no link between abortion and breast
cancers that occur after menopause.
"The globality of evidence supports no link between induced abortion and breast cancer," Harvard researcher Karin Michels, Sc.D., Ph.D., tells WebMD.
The Michels study shows a longstanding "scientific consensus," says
Michael Thun, M.D., vice president for epidemiology and surveillance research at the American Cancer Society in Atlanta. Thun was not involved in the Michels study.
"There is no evidence that having had an abortion increases the risk of
breast cancer," Thun tells WebMD. "This is a subject that has received
a lot of visibility; something that has been looked at repeatedly. There is strong scientific consensus this is the case."
Abortion and Breast Cancer Risk
At one time, researchers did suspect a link between abortion and breast
cancer. Researchers who asked women about their abortion history found that women with breast cancer were more likely than healthy women to report having had abortions.
But this kind of study — called a case/control study — is not considered particularly reliable. A person with a medical condition is more likely to report an unusual or embarrassing event than is a healthy person. That's particularly true when the event is an abortion.
"Abortion is such a personal and sensitive piece of information," Michel says. "If just you just ask random people, you get much more
underreporting then you do when you ask women with breast cancer, who are much more likely to reveal all sorts of information if you ask them."
Three studies that looked at women's records about abortion before
breast cancer developed found no link to breast cancer. Three studies that asked postmenopausal women about their abortion history and then observed them for long periods of time also found no link to breast cancer.
In 2003, the National Cancer Institute convened an expert panel to analyze these studies. It concluded that abortion did not affect breast cancer risk. Michels was a member of that panel.
"No study should be interpreted on its own," Michels warns. This current study really supports the consensus that we came up with in 2003. So now we can close the loop and say the lack of abortion risk seen for postmenopausal breast cancer applies to premenopausal breast cancer as well."
Despite the scientific consensus, four states have laws on the books that require doctors to warn women seeking abortion that the procedure may cause breast cancer. Those states are Minnesota, Mississippi, Montana, and Texas. The law in Montana has been found unconstitutional and is not enforced.
This year, there were efforts to introduce similar laws in New Hampshire, North Dakota, and Wyoming, according to the Center for Reproductive Rights. All of these bills failed to pass into law.
Thirty-one states have laws that require "biased counseling and/or
mandatory delays which may include providing information on breast cancer and abortion," a spokeswoman for Physicians for Reproductive Choice and Health tells WebMD.
The Michels study appears in the April 23 issue of Archives of Internal Medicine.
By Daniel DeNoon
Reviewed by Louise Chang
B)2005-2006 WebMD, Inc. All rights reserved
Researchers base the findings on a study in which they followed 105,716 women for 10 years. They found no link between abortion and breast cancers that occur before menopause.
Earlier large-scale studies showed no link between abortion and breast
cancers that occur after menopause.
"The globality of evidence supports no link between induced abortion and breast cancer," Harvard researcher Karin Michels, Sc.D., Ph.D., tells WebMD.
The Michels study shows a longstanding "scientific consensus," says
Michael Thun, M.D., vice president for epidemiology and surveillance research at the American Cancer Society in Atlanta. Thun was not involved in the Michels study.
"There is no evidence that having had an abortion increases the risk of
breast cancer," Thun tells WebMD. "This is a subject that has received
a lot of visibility; something that has been looked at repeatedly. There is strong scientific consensus this is the case."
Abortion and Breast Cancer Risk
At one time, researchers did suspect a link between abortion and breast
cancer. Researchers who asked women about their abortion history found that women with breast cancer were more likely than healthy women to report having had abortions.
But this kind of study — called a case/control study — is not considered particularly reliable. A person with a medical condition is more likely to report an unusual or embarrassing event than is a healthy person. That's particularly true when the event is an abortion.
"Abortion is such a personal and sensitive piece of information," Michel says. "If just you just ask random people, you get much more
underreporting then you do when you ask women with breast cancer, who are much more likely to reveal all sorts of information if you ask them."
Three studies that looked at women's records about abortion before
breast cancer developed found no link to breast cancer. Three studies that asked postmenopausal women about their abortion history and then observed them for long periods of time also found no link to breast cancer.
In 2003, the National Cancer Institute convened an expert panel to analyze these studies. It concluded that abortion did not affect breast cancer risk. Michels was a member of that panel.
"No study should be interpreted on its own," Michels warns. This current study really supports the consensus that we came up with in 2003. So now we can close the loop and say the lack of abortion risk seen for postmenopausal breast cancer applies to premenopausal breast cancer as well."
Despite the scientific consensus, four states have laws on the books that require doctors to warn women seeking abortion that the procedure may cause breast cancer. Those states are Minnesota, Mississippi, Montana, and Texas. The law in Montana has been found unconstitutional and is not enforced.
This year, there were efforts to introduce similar laws in New Hampshire, North Dakota, and Wyoming, according to the Center for Reproductive Rights. All of these bills failed to pass into law.
Thirty-one states have laws that require "biased counseling and/or
mandatory delays which may include providing information on breast cancer and abortion," a spokeswoman for Physicians for Reproductive Choice and Health tells WebMD.
The Michels study appears in the April 23 issue of Archives of Internal Medicine.
By Daniel DeNoon
Reviewed by Louise Chang
B)2005-2006 WebMD, Inc. All rights reserved
Popular Now in Health
- Electronic cigarette explodes in man's mouth
- Skin cancer self-exam: What to look for (PHOTOS)
- Report: 400 types of lipstick contain lead
- Whitney Houston's autopsy: What's taking so long?
- All infant Tylenol recalled by J&J
- Christina Hendricks: Too Big for Hollywood?
- Things You Didn't Know About Your Penis
- Anti-Rape Condoms Fight World Cup Sex Assault
- PICTURES: 15 Shocking Sexual Fetishes
- HealthPop: Indulging, diagnosing and dying
- 8 Tips For Losing Weight After Pregnancy
- Caffeine inhalers - the next club drug?
- Heart Attack Grill owner responds to incident
- Cancer drug reverses Alzheimer's in mice: Study
- Mars to set calorie limit on chocolate bars
- New study is wake-up call for diet soda drinkers
- Orgasm Just by Thinking: Medically Possible?
Latest CBS News Headlines
on Facebook Most Discussed Stories
on CBS News
- NYC art sale to feature Munch's 'The Scream'
- Wal-Mart's 4Q profits slip; US business rebounding
- NY boy sleeps through theft of dad's running car
- Chinese carmaker opens plant in Bulgaria
on Facebook Most Discussed Stories
on CBS News
