Imus, The Duke Boys And Our Bloodlust
Dick Meyer: Thoughts On Building Up And Tearing Down Celebrities
-
Photo
Don Imus on Al Sharpton's radio program, April 9, 2007. (AP)
-
Photo Essay
Duke Lacrosse Case
Duke lacrosse players were charged with sexual abuse in high profile case that caused tension in Durham, N.C.
-
Photo Essay
Celebrity Circuit
Jessica's stadium cheer, Celine's swan song and Ashley Tisdale's new nose
We have become serial character assassins.
Don Imus is just the latest example of something sad and unattractive: we have an insatiable, mean bloodlust for bringing people down.
By "we" I mean me. And you. And Imus, who of course has made millions tearing people apart and cackling at the demise of other famous high and mighties.
The collective "we" that is, I suppose, contemporary American culture has made character destruction and celebrity-slaughter the gladiator sport of our day.
People don't get ruined in football and boxing except by accident. But it is the goal of the culture of the character assassins. And the Coliseum is columns like this, Web sites like this and television networks like this. The Coliseum is filled with people like you and me.
We are all part of it. Who hasn't enjoyed the downfall of some famous person — be it Mark Foley, Ted Haggerty, Bill Clinton, Sandy Berger, Britney Spears or Martha Stewart?
The merits or demerits, guilt or innocence of any of these names in the news are absolutely irrelevant to what I'm talking about. Some of us hate some people. Period.
Plenty of bad people get their just comeuppance; plenty of innocents get slaughtered too. I won't even bother to give my views about Imus. I can't believe anyone in the world cares what anybody else thinks anymore: every possible opinion on the matter has been stated somewhere in the yakking universe five times, loud and soft.
The point is this sordid personality destruction has become a repetitive public ritual and we're hooked on it. Numbers crunchers could probably make graphs of the frequency and intensity of Great Falls. And of our voyeuristic, uncharitable fascination with them.
The Duke lacrosse team learned it can happen to ordinary people too, that unknowns can become knowns — famous and infamous — in one fast news cycle. A year and $3.5 million later, the accused Duke players have legal redemption but untold scars as well.
Their problems weren't caused only by a morally bankrupt prosecutor, but by a culture that was rooting for the fall of these privileged white boys who played with strippers. They certainly had their defenders in the world of professional arguers as well. That just meant that the whole case became an "issue" — partisan, divisive, loud and cruel.
It isn't hard to understand why there are so many character lynchings. There are a lot of rats and phonies in this world. Is the national supply of famous creeps higher than at other points in our history? Absolutely, simply because the supply of media is so vastly greater. More media, more bandwidth to create celebrities and then stalk them.
And with the Internet and ubiquitous television, geographic proximity is no longer necessary for a mob mentality to arise. We have virtual mobs. For briefing, shiny sick moments all eyes are focused on Imus — or Anna Nicole, Michael Jackson, Jack Abramoff or Ken Lay.
Our media and our culture have become expert at creating celebrities and other phonies.
We can turn a contestant on a game show into a household name in a week. And like some cheesy Hollywood threat: "We made you, and we can break you."
So many of the celebrities in politics, sports and entertainment are undeserving, greedy, hubristic, ostentatious, coarse, egotistical or vulgar. Of course we love it when they crash and burn. We wouldn't be human if we didn't. Some of them deserve everything they get.
And spotting these parasitic unworthies, calling them out, cheering on their demises seems like the only tool we have to fight societal fakery and fraud. How else can we fight back this amorphous enemy but to collect scalps? We wait vigilantly for their flameouts to lighten the loads of our lives with a little innocent gloating.
I do this in my column all the time. An aspect of this process is, of course, necessary to check the people who have power and abuse it. The game is different for people who hungrily seek fame, fortune and power; they're in the game by choice, they know the stakes and the risks and they want to play. That doesn't mean we should be quite so happy when they fall.
The problem is that we are devouring ourselves. We can create celebrities, but not leaders. We generate fame, but not honor.
Perhaps the most we can do, you and I, is try not to let this unforgiving quality of public life seep into our private lives.
By Dick Meyer
© MMVII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
- Latest in Opinion: Against The Grain
- Do Democrats Fear Winning?
- Independents Win! Bloomberg Pulls Out
- The Decline of Blogs And Gaffes



- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
...
- 12
- next
See all 567 Commentsand I am sorry." Count for nothing? Does the punishment of taking away a man's livelyhood and reducing the ability of children black and white suffering from Sickle Cell Anemia count for anything? I find that Staples, Proctor and Gamble, and all the others who jumped on the firing of him from MSNBC leaves a bad taste for these companies and MSNBC. If CBS fires him I for one will not have very good feelings towards the people who caused this. Imus is coming on the heels of the Duke Boys who were exonerated. He is the blacks whipping boy. It is a very sorry state this world is in. Judge not, less you be judged!
While I condemn Imus%u2019s offensive words, I do also condemn the way he was treated on Al Sharpen%u2019s show by Rev Al Sharpen! I do not see how, Al Sharpen, a man of God allows his egotism to take over the Christian believes. What has happened to (love your enemy)? If you see Imus as an enemy to the black race! Rev Al Sharpen and Rev Jackson have an obligation to stress on what bring races closer in America for America for all races who are all human beings!! It%u2019s about time to deal with whatever offensive to any in a civilized dialogue! Imus should have contacted the university to arrange a meeting with the ladies who have got offended instead of putting himself in a humiliating way in Rev Al Sharpen%u2019s den! Imus owes an apology to no body but the ladies whose team I, guess was his favorite! For God%u2019s sake! Imus has been talking on air for 30+ years! Do not you expect slips of the tongue for a few times? Statistics, the science!, may challenge the unforgivable Rev AL Sharpen who should have known that forgiveness in Jesus%u2019 way has no room for splitting hair interpretation ! Imus has done more good than many of those who want to tear him down for slips of a tongue! Stop this madness!
It seems like we cannot move on and get past all of the racial statements. Imus? Shame on you .... you should know better. CBS? Please do something about this other than allowing Imus a two week vacation?
BTW the comment about %u201Cthe very basic Fascist concept of "Guilty until you can prove you aren't" is misguided. The burden of proof rests with the defendant at Civil Law (based on Roman law) which governs most of the civilized world (and much of the uncivilized world). In this country the overwhelming power of political judges and ambitious prosecutors sometimes makes a mockery of the presumption of innocence; in Civil Law countries the idea is to avoid bringing dubious charges in the first place %u2013 ergo the investigation by a special (non-elected) judge. Both systems have their merits and weaknesses but the civil law system is not a %u201Cfascist concept%u201D.
Sandie Carroll
Wilmington, DE
I was glad to get the list of hypocrites who
and sneaking out the back door ....there are
many kinds of boycotts ...those of us who are loyal to Imus boycott too....
Frankly I hope he takes the 2 weeks off to make a contract with Sirius and watch all of you whose
pay checks depend of his enormous talent just plain disappear into the shadows.
Suck it up CBS and stand by your man... the real money ...by those of us who work for our money and spend it are behind this unique and imperfect man who makes us laugh and think and
discourse ...and yes get offended once in a while.
The Rev Sharptongue should spend more time explaining his shameless public abuse of airwaves for a phoney rape charge years ago
which he never apologized for to the aggrieved accused nor to the public....oh thats right
Sharptongue doesn't make any money for you!!
Screw the sponsers leaving ...others will take their space....IMUS FOREVER
It can't be both ways, either no one says it or every one can say it. And were are the "I'm sorry, I was wrong" from Mr. Sharpton and Mr. Jackson for the Duke team???? Maybe they should be fired too.
It's getting to the point to where you can't say or do anything without offending someone.
Hypocrites.
I watched that show with Imus..what he said was not right,but how many people that are complaining about what he said have said the same things about other people....whitey...cracker ect where does it all end?
Imus has said he was sorry I believe him!
He has done more good for people of all races then the people that are trying to tear him done.
People need to clean up their own house before complaining about someone elses.
A Detroiter
I hope you will not follow MSNBC and cancell this show for its regretable mistake. How many hours of unrehearsed verbage does Don Imus and his staff put out yearly? Wow, I am amazed that a poor attempt at humor, three poorly chosen words, will cause such a stir. Our world is not perfect, nor is Don.
This whole issue is absurd if you listen to RAP or Chris Rock and all that came before him.
Look at your commercials for everything from "Natural Male Enhancement" to KY Jelly, FDS, Tampons, Depends and so on that offend me greatly. Homosexual behavior in programming also offends me.
Don Imus does not.
Why dont you report on the good he has created by his charitable ventures and the lives that has helped?
Know a man by his works.
David L. Shawver
Looks like what goes around comes around, huh? I have tried to warn different SHOCK JOCKs to be careful, but they won't listen. Now it's the JOCKs who are SHOCKED!
He really didn't need to apologize to Jackson or Sharpton. But to the team-yes-he should have. He showed his wimpness...HE BUCKLED.
BUT HE SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN FIRED.
I am not a big fan of Imus or Howard Stern or any other talk show host that is crude and insulting to others, but isn't that what made these shows rise in their ratings? Did CBC or MSNBC have a problem with Imus when he would insult any other race? But now that the media, Rev. Al Sharpton and Rev Jackson have decided to gain more fame from the remark that Imus made, CBC and MSNBC are worried about their ratings and their $$$$. If CBS had guidelines for Imus they should have made them known before this happened. Don't ruin a man's life because he made a mistake. What happened to loyalty and all the good Imus has done for the show.
As for Al Sharpton and Jessie Jackson, shame on both of you! Have you felt like you have been out of the spot light for a while? Do you come to every nationality's rescue when they have been slandered? I think you two have the prejudice here! You two call yourselves good Christians? Tell me neither one of you have said or done something that you regretted later. Look to Jesus for an answer to this situation and see what he would have done.
Was Imus wrong in what he said? Yes, he was. But, at least Imus was being consistent. I can't say the same for CBC, Sharpton and Jackson.
i will not have anything thing to do with any nbc media. i will not purchase anything from any nbc advertisers. if there happens to be a show i want to see i will tape it and not watch any advertisements.
i am through having the race ambulance chasers al sharpton & jesse jackson determine all media output in the united states.
i am through will all political correct speech. i do not practice hate speech to anyone and i quit watch imus years ago because of his scarcasim to all groups. but now i will find his radio show and have it on in defiance of all the media cowards that will not stand up to these self appointed morale police ie al sharpton & jesse jackson etal.
let imus appoligize and meet with the ladies he hurt and go from there.
http://www.artdish.com/ubbcgi-bin/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic&f=7&t=000210
I'd print it all, but there's no room here!
Firing him, however, would be inappropriate --- and I disagree with MSNBC's position in this matter.
A dismissal by CBS RADIO throws away the platform for both IMUS and the media to show that there has been a true change in attitudes in this country.
We have little hope of attaining true racial harmony if the only solution implemented is to " throw away" the offender---there are just too many of them for this to be a viable choice.
Throwing away the problem DOES NOT FIX IT --- "FIXING IT" fixes it !
The true opportunity is to retain IMUS (after suspension) and let a revised show format be demonstration of a correction of attitudes.
I find that every adversity faced in life, whether it is created by chance or our own making, sets the stage for us to come out a better person at the other end. Whether or not Don's job is been lost over this situation, he has been given a great chance to rise to greater heights in his personal life and career.
Regards,
"Who cares what you think?"
-- George W. Bush to supporter Bill Hangley Jr., July 4, 2001
"I would rather be exposed to the inconveniences attending too much liberty than to those attending too small a degree of it."
-- Thomas Jefferson, 1791
"If society fits you comfortably enough, you call it freedom."
-- Robert Frost
Will Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton will be big enough men to apologize to these innocent Duke boys for the false accusations and presumptions they stirred up in Durham, NC.
I won't be holding my breath.
...
Will Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton will be big enough men to apologize to these innocent Duke boys for the false accusations and presumptions they stirred up in Durham, NC.
I won't be holding my breath.
...
As for Imus, I have no intentions of buying any product from any of the company adverisers. I don't appreciate business thinking they can censor the media. The same for the two aforementioned idiots, they need to be censored for their racism against whites.
In the Imus case, it seems like people are divided into 3 camps on the issue - sympathetic to the women's basketball team, sympathethic to Imus, or like me feeling an urge to run away and bury my head in the sand.
Unlike the people who have picked a side, I feel for both parties and am frustrated with both parties. Like it's true that the women did nothing to deserve Imus' stupid comment and the contrast between the kind of comment they deserved for their accomplishments and one they got was gross. On the other hand, this is the first complaint Imus has gotten during a 40 yr career and seems to have tried his best to make amends. The women are upset by how their lives have been disrupted by the firestorm, but hasn't most of that been caused by Sharpton and Jesse Jackson stirring the pot? Also, who here hasn't been disrespected and had accomplishments overlooked - like it's always seemed to me that type A guys are just as harsh if not harsher to other guys. Then there's the influence of rap music which uses those same words all the time. On the other hand, with the nation's history of slavery and things not yet being equal, maybe Imus has to be held to a different standard given that he's got the power to shape the national debate.
I'm torn! This is sad! Duke makes me even sadder!
Amen!!! Well said. Political correctness is getting to the point of being ridiculous and unaccptable. THIS HAS OPENED UP A PANDORA'S BOX... Imus has the reputation of being callous but has gotten away with it up until now. The Duke Boys have a much larger issue and need apologies but I don't see much of that happening...What would have been the reaction if a comment was aimed at a group of German or Italian American students? Its always open season on them...
Like yes the women felt invalidated, but I don't think it's the best solution to demand an invalidation of the invalidator - that's vengeance, not progress imo.
Okay, I'm glad I stuck with this. Still avoiding the Duke situation though . . .
Ditto... we also will not purchase any products from the advertizers who "pulled out"... What has happened to this country that used to have the courage to defend and or forgive??? The backbone of the US has turned to cartilage...
Will Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton will be big enough men to apologize to these innocent Duke boys for the false accusations and presumptions they stirred up in Durham, NC.
I won't be holding my breath.
...
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
...
- 12
- next
See all 567 Comments