Professor: Lacrosse Case A Perfect Storm

Duke's James Coleman Said He Had Doubts About The Case From The Beginning

(CBS/AP)  All charges, including rape, were dropped against the three Duke University lacrosse players — David Evans, Reade Seligmann and Collin Finnerty — on Wednesday.

After a thorough investigation, the North Carolina attorney general found that there was a "tragic rush to accuse" and the players were absolutely innocent.

"There were many points in the case where caution would have served justice better than bravado," North Carolina Attorney General Roy Cooper said in a damning assessment of Durham County District Attorney Mike Nifong's handling of the sensational, racially charged case. "In the rush to condemn, a community and a state lost the ability to see clearly."

Cooper, who took over the case in January after Nifong was charged with ethics violations that could get him disbarred, said his own investigation "led us to the conclusion that no attack occurred."

Duke University law professor James Coleman was suspicious from the beginning.

"The D.A. said the students refused to cooperate, they wouldn't talk to the police and I knew that wasn't true," he told The Early Show co-anchor Harry Smith. "That's when I knew he was trying to build a case against these students."

Coleman was on a committee appointed to investigate rumors about the accused players and the men's lacrosse team and said that the circumstances surrounding the case ended up being "something of a perfect storm."

---

Click here to see photos of the Duke lacrosse case.

---

"It had all kind of elements, but we know now it was based on this false notion a crime had been committed," he said. "That generated everything. That gave energy to everything."

The story, as it was portrayed in the media, was about class and race in a community surrounding an elite university (Duke is called the Harvard of the South). The three accused represented — at least in the eyes of their critics — the privileged white students many felt were running wild on campus. But in the end, none of it was true, Coleman said.

"It got reported that way over and over, and then it became fact," he said. "You know, it took a year for the truth to catch up."

District Attorney Mike Nifong, Coleman said, was initially motivated by the belief that a crime had occurred but also saw it as an opportunity for him to gain fame and notoriety.

"He was in a political race," Coleman said. "You know, he rushed to judgment. I think the attorney general said it properly, he rush to judgment."

During the past year, there have been several stories about race and sports, including the recent debacle with radio host Don Imus and comments he made about the Rutgers women's basketball team. Coleman says they are all related.

"I think what's happening is that athletes are treated like disposable items," he said. "We forget they are human beings, students and have feelings, and we just ignore that. They are treated like commodities."

[arvid0823]

Mr. Nifongs handling of the case is chilling. The AG has declared the 3 students INNOCENT of all charges. I hope that the NC AG will be thorough in his review of Mr. Nifong.

Where are Reverend Sharpton and Reverend Jackson now -- to offer their support to the individual(s) wronged by this incident? A true man (or woman) of God would be offering comfort to the victim(s) -- regardless of race, creed, color, national origin, or sexual preference. Or is it the case for Reverend Al and Reverend Jesse that Samaritans or Irish need not apply for admission to their congregations?

[lizardbate]

Nifong is a *** crook and sheister!!!!!!!!!He was going to use his power to railroad these boys into a prison, knowing *** well they did not do anything!!!, BUT, he did not care, as long as he made him self look good. The people of Durham should run his sorry tail out of this state. By the way, you citizens of Durham, you voted this idiot in for another term during all this!!!! This idiot made a fool out of all of you voters who voted for him. TAKE HIS LICENSE TO PRACTICE LAW AND RUN HIM OUT OF THIS COUNTRY ----A GOOD PLACE TO SEND HIM IS TO IRAQ !!!!!!!!!!!!! BURN THIS GUY A NEW ONE, CAREER WISE AND FINANCIALLY.

[lizardbate]

Reverend Jackson and Reverend Sharpton, you sure are not saying nothing now?????? Atleast you could have the balls to apologize to these boys for what one of your people did. You expect us to apologize for slavery when we wasn't even there, well she is here, you are here and the boys are here. Help honestly bridge the race relations!!!!!

[gmoore7576]

Katie Couric's coverage from Duke missed the real question. Why did the DA, and most of America, assume the allegations were true? Could it be related to the unprosecuted and usually unreported rape of semi-concious coed's in our universities and their frat houses? A reality that set the stage?