WASHINGTON, March 30, 2007

Gonzales Admits "Confusion" In Firings

Attorney General Has No Intention Of Resigning Despite Criticism Over Termination Of Prosecutors

  • Play CBS Video Video Ex-Aide Contradicts Gonzales

    Only On The Web: Kyle Sampson, a former aide to Attorney General Alberto Gonzales testified that his boss was involved in the controversial firings of U.S. attorneys. Bill Plante reports.

  • Video Gonzales In Controversy

    Attorney General Alberto Gonzales is caught in a controversy involving the firing of eight federal prosecutors after the testimony of his former top aide, Kyle Sampson. Jim Axelrod reports.

  • Video Can Gonzales Save His Job?

    Bob Schieffer talks with Katie Couric about Attorney General Alberto Gonzales' political future and how the controversy is affecting fundraising for both parties.

    • Attorney General Alberto Gonzales he won't resign his post because he is

      Attorney General Alberto Gonzales he won't resign his post because he is "fighting for the truth."  (AP Photo)

    • Eight former U.S. attorneys, from top left to left: H.E.

      Eight former U.S. attorneys, from top left to left: H.E. "Bud" Cummins, Kevin Ryan, David Iglesias, and Daniel Bogden; and bottom, from left: Paul Charlton, Carol Lam, Margaret Chiara, and John McKay.  (CBS/AP)

    Previous slide Next slide
  • Who's Who Firings Firestorm

    Justice Department at center of controversy over firing of eight U.S. attorneys.

  • Interactive 110th Congress

    The balance of power shifts and new leadership takes control as the latest session convenes.

(CBS/AP)  Attorney General Alberto Gonzales, amid a growing clamor for his resignation, acknowledged Friday there is confusion about his role in the firing of U.S. attorneys and said he doesn't "recall being involved in deliberations" over which would be ousted.

"I believe in truth and accountability, and every step that I've taken is consistent with that principle," Gonzales said when asked why he is not heeding calls to resign. "I am fighting for the truth as well."

Gonzales said he had his former chief of staff, Kyle Sampson, coordinated performance evaluations for the 93 U.S. attorneys "to see where changes might be appropriate."

"I signed off on the recommendations and signed off on the implementation plan, and that's the extent of my involvement," he told reporters after a round-table discussion in the U.S. attorney's office in Boston with state and federal law enforcement officials about a Justice Department initiative to thwart online predators.

Sampson, testifying Thursday before the Senate Judiciary Committee, contradicted Gonzales' earlier accounts of not being involved in the decision-making. Calling them inaccurate, Sampson said he and the attorney general had talked several times about the firings and the process for carrying them out.

The administration maintains that the firings were appropriate because the prosecutors serve at the pleasure of the president.

The White House predicted Friday that Gonzales will survive the crisis.

"I can tell you that the president has confidence in him," said White House spokeswoman Dana Perino. President Bush "believes the attorney general can overcome the challenges that are before him," she said.

The president may still have confidence in Gonzales, but the exit door is always unlocked, CBS News senior White House correspondent Bill Plante reported.

Publicly, the White House has said continually that Gonzales retains Mr. Bush's confidence, even while it has also said that Gonzales and his department must address Congress' concerns and questions.

For his part, Mr. Bush was not rushing to defend his old friend from Texas.

Asked about Gonzales during a closed-door meeting with House Republicans on Thursday, Mr. Bush did not defend his longtime friend, according to one official who attended the session and demanded anonymity because it was private.

Instead, Bush tepidly repeated his public statement: The attorney general would have to go up to Capitol Hill and fix his problem, according to this official.

"It's hard to imagine that he (Gonzales) survives because there's so few Republicans that really want him to survive right now," Jim VandeHei, executive editor of Politico.com, told CBS' The Early Show.

In his meeting Friday with reporters, Gonzales said his "primary focus was ensuring that the White House was kept advised on what we were doing and that Kyle was consulting with the appropriate senior officials, people who knew about the performances of the United States attorneys."

"From time to time, Kyle would tell me things that would tell me that this effort was ongoing. I don't recall being involved in deliberations involving the question of whether or not a U.S. attorney should or should not be asked to resign. I didn't focus on specific concerns about individuals," he said.

In Washington, House and Senate investigators spent hours behind closed doors Friday interviewing Michael Elston, chief of staff to Deputy Attorney General Paul McNulty, about the firings and the different accounts of them.

Sampson's testimony did not go well for Gonzales or the White House. Sampson testified that prosecutors put on the list to be fired got there in part because they were not deemed "loyal Bushies." In the aftermath, Gonzales provided an inaccurate account of his own involvement, Sampson said.

"There obviously remains some confusion about my involvement in this," Gonzales said Friday. "At the end of the day, I know what I did. And I know that the motivations for the decisions I made were not based on improper reasons."

Sampson told the panel that the White House had a large role in the firings, not limited involvement as the Justice Department originally claimed.

One-time presidential counsel Harriet Miers joined Gonzales in approving them. And under questioning from Sen. Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., Sampson said that looking back, he should not have advocated the firing of one prosecutor in particular, New Mexico's David Iglesias.

Congress began its spring break Friday, but there were intense activities taking place behind the scenes.

Elston did not comment as about a dozen news cameras recorded his entrance to the Judiciary Committee suite, where aides to Schumer waited with House aides to question him. No lawmakers were expected to attend the session, spokeswoman Melanie Roussell said.

The congressional lawyers were expected to ask Elston about McNulty's account. McNulty in early February testified before Congress that seven of the U.S. attorneys were fired for performance reasons, and that one, Bud Cummins in Little Rock, Ark., was being moved out so he could be replaced by a former aide to White House political adviser Karl Rove.

Gonzales was upset with McNulty's testimony and would have preferred that he had said all eight were fired for performance reasons, according to Justice Department e-mails forwarded to the two committees. Bush has criticized the department for not giving Congress an accurate account of the firings.

© MMVII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.
Add a Comment See all 165 Comments
by inventagod March 31, 2007 8:17 PM EDT
"Alberto Gonzales is an old Bush crony."

Actually, he was THE Bu$h lawyer for many years, and continues to believe he is...

"As counsel to Governor Bush, Gonzales helped Bush be excused from jury duty when he was called in a 1996 Travis County drunk driving case. The case led to controversy during Bush's 2000 presidential campaign because Bush's answers to the potential juror questionnaire did not disclose Bush's own 1976 misdemeanor drunk driving conviction.[1] Gonzales' formal request for Bush to be excused from jury duty hinged upon the fact that, as Governor of Texas, he might be called upon to pardon the accused in the case.

As Governor Bush's counsel in Texas, Gonzales also reviewed all clemency requests. A 2003 article in The Atlantic Monthly asserts that Gonzales gave insufficient counsel, and failed to second-guess convictions and failed appeals. Only one death sentence was over-turned by Governor Bush (The state of Texas executed more prisoners during Gonzales' term, and still has more prisoners on death row, than any other state.)"
Reply to this comment
by starleo146 March 31, 2007 8:08 PM EDT
Believe me the republicans are scrambling around like chickens with there heads cut off. I wish they would not wait so long to have him appear before the judiciary committee too much wiggle room for those leeches. I watched the GSA investigation and they were planning what democrat where they were from and how to eliminate them at election time had there names and all. On the grounds of GSA during work hours one of Gonzales's guy held the meetings unbelievable. I hope they hang him at sunrise along with the rest Harriet M., Karl Rove *** Cheney etc.etc.
Reply to this comment
by starleo146 March 31, 2007 8:05 PM EDT
Believe me the republicans are scrambling around like chickens with there heads cut off. I wish they would not wait so long to have him appear before the judiciary committee too much wiggle room for those leeches. I watched the GSA investigation and they were planning what democrat where they were from and how to eliminate them at election time had there names and all. On the grounds of GSA during work hours one of Gonzales's guy held the meetings unbelievable. I hope they hang him at sunrise along with the rest Harriet M., Karl Rove *** Cheney etc.etc.
Reply to this comment
by inventagod March 31, 2007 8:02 PM EDT
'"I believe in truth and accountability, and every step that I've taken is consistent with that principle," Gonzales said when asked why he is not heeding calls to resign. "I am fighting for the truth as well."'

and then the scales swing...

"Gonzales also authored the Presidential Order which authorized the use of military tribunals to try terrorist suspects. He fought with Congress to keep Vice President *** Cheney's Energy task force documents from being reviewed. Gonzales was also an early advocate of the controversial USA PATRIOT Act. He is also accused of being involved in the decision to allow foreign combatants in U.S. custody to be deported to nations that allow torture"
Reply to this comment
by starleo146 March 31, 2007 7:56 PM EDT
Believe me the republicans are scrambling around like chickens with there heads cut off. I wish they would not wait so long to have him appear before the judiciary committee too much wiggle room for those leeches. I watched the GSA investigation and they were planning what democrat where they were from and how to eliminate them had there names and all. On the grounds of GSA during work hours one of Gonzales's guy held the meetings unbelievable. I hope they hang him at sunrise along with the rest Harriet M., Karl Rove etc.etc.
Reply to this comment
by starleo146 March 31, 2007 7:56 PM EDT
Believe me the republicans are scrambling around like chickens with there heads cut off. I wish they would not wait so long to have him appear before the judiciary committee too much wiggle room for those leeches. I watched the GSA investigation and they were planning what democrat where they were from and how to eliminate them had there names and all. On the grounds of GSA during work hours one of Gonzales's guy held the meetings unbelievable. I hope they hang him at sunrise along with the rest Harriet M., Karl Rove etc.etc.
Reply to this comment
by starleo146 March 31, 2007 7:52 PM EDT
Believe me the republicans are scrambling around like chickens with there heads cut off. I wish they would not wait so long to have him appear before the judiciary committee too much wiggle room for those leeches. I watched the GSA investigation and they were planning what democrat where they were from and how to eliminate them had there names and all. In the grounds of GSA during work hours one of Gonzales's guy held the meetings unbelievable. I hope they hang him on sunrise along with the rest Harriet M., Karl Rove etc.etc.
Reply to this comment
by starleo146 March 31, 2007 7:49 PM EDT
Believe me the republicans are scrambling around like chickens with there heads cut off. I wish they would not wait so long to have him appear before the judiciary committee too much wiggle room for those leeches. I watched the GSA investigation and they were planning what democrat where they were from and how to eliminate them had there names and all. In the grounds of GSA one of Gonzales's guy held the meetings unbelievable. I hope they hang him on sunrise along with the rest Harriet Miers, Karl Rove etc.etc.
Reply to this comment
by dallison7 March 31, 2007 7:05 PM EDT
As for pi$$ing off the Hispanic vote, give them some credit. A majority of Hispanics see the corruption of Gonzales too.

Posted by Rafterman1


Most republicans see minorities as 'less intelligent' and unable to make sound judgements. The fact is mosst 'PEOPLE' do not get upset when a criminal of their own race gets punished for his crimes. Example: I am a member of the white race and I look forward to the impeachment, prosecution, imprisonment and possibly execution of Bush and Cheney for treason.
Reply to this comment
by rafterman1 March 31, 2007 5:37 PM EDT
"Alberto Gonzales is an old Bush crony."

In other words, the only thing Gonzales ever did to distinguish himself in his career is to say to George Bush "yes sir", "no sir" and "whatever you say sir".

Actually, now that I think about it, "no sir" to George Bush probably never came out of Gonzales' mouth.
Reply to this comment
by iceman_1960 March 31, 2007 5:26 PM EDT
Alberto Gonzales is an old Bush crony.

"As counsel to Governor Bush, Gonzales helped Bush be excused from jury duty when he was called in a 1996 Travis County drunk driving case. The case led to controversy during Bush's 2000 presidential campaign because Bush's answers to the potential juror questionnaire did not disclose Bush's own 1976 misdemeanor drunk driving conviction. Gonzales' formal request for Bush to be excused from jury duty hinged upon the fact that, as Governor of Texas, he might be called upon to pardon the accused in the case.

As Governor Bush's counsel in Texas, Gonzales also reviewed all clemency requests. A 2003 article in The Atlantic Monthly asserts that Gonzales gave insufficient counsel, and failed to second guess convictions and failed appeals. Only one death sentence was overturned by Governor Bush (The state of Texas executed more prisoners during Gonzales' term, and still has more prisoners on death row, than any other state.)"

Wikipedia
Reply to this comment
by mcvet March 31, 2007 3:02 PM EDT
Funny, a racist telling Americans what to do....
Posted by pwrslm at 09:33 AM : Mar 31, 2007
+ report abuse
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
My my are we testy today or what. Didn't get up with the swastika in a bunch today did we Herr? LMAO Now IF this isn't the POT calling the Kettle Black? This MORON who wants to kill ALL Muslims? LOL Glad to know that you Fascist are still listening though. As long as you are LISTENING that means there is HOPE. You should start by UNDERSTANDING that American's THINK for themselves.
Reply to this comment
by rafterman1 March 31, 2007 3:01 PM EDT
"Hey Leftys....ATTENTION...NOBODY CARES ABOUT THIS....YOU ARE MAKING FOOLS OF YOURSELFS....GO AHEAD AND **** OFF THE HISPANIC VOTE.."

You righties and your desperation to sweep this undr the rug is almost to the point of being hysterical (not the funny kind, but the terrified kind). Of course, "no one cared" about this in 1974 either - until they impeached Nixon for it.

As for pi$$ing off the Hispanic vote, give them some credit. A majority of Hispanics see the corruption of Gonzales too.
Reply to this comment
by mcvet March 31, 2007 2:59 PM EDT
Hey Leftys....ATTENTION...NOBODY CARES ABOUT THIS....YOU ARE MAKING FOOLS OF YOURSELFS....GO AHEAD AND **** OFF THE HISPANIC VOTE..
Posted by b48151 at 11:02 AM : Mar 31, 2007

Don't get out much do ya? LOL Now I know you Fascist have a hard time with this BUT some of us REALLY like the idea of a Democracy and we now KNOW that Rove, Bush, et al were attempting to us our Justice System to rig the system with a heavy thumb on the scales toward ONE PARTY RULE. Now maybe that doesn't bother a small minded LOSER who put his party ahead of his Country but it does ME!! You can put one more tag on me. I'm AMERICAN and it's *** WELL time our Government started acting like they knew that!!
Reply to this comment
by diamtool March 31, 2007 2:14 PM EDT
Of course no laws were broken! (as long as they can plead the fifth about breaking them!)

No evidence of criminality! (as long as they can lie and say they don't remember anything!)

We would never inject partisan politics into Justice! (unless no one is watching!)

"At the end of the day, I know what I did. And I know that the motivations for the decisions I made were not based on improper reasons."
It's a shame you just can't quite explain what the reasons were!

God Bless our Troops
God forgive George Bush
Reply to this comment
by rafterman1 March 31, 2007 1:57 PM EDT
The best thing that could have happened for America and it's democracy was for Dems to win last year. Not because of what they may or may not do with legislation, but just for the threat of oversight. King George is merely President George now, as it should be. The fear of God (aka oversight) has been put into the Bushies and even if the Dems sit on their butts the next two years and do nothing, the checks on Bush's power alone are worth their weight in gold.

Reply to this comment
by forthepeaple March 31, 2007 1:50 PM EDT
I signed off on the recommendations and signed off on the implementation plan, and that's the extent of my involvement," he told reporters

NOW DOESN'T THAT SOUND JUST LIKE EVERYTHING ELSE IN WASHINGTON.

CLOSE YOUR EYES, AND JUST SIGN HERE. GREAT THANK YOU.

I CANT BELEIVE ANYONE IN WASHINGTON..THEY ALL LIE FOR THERE OWN REASONS..

TIME TO CHANGE..
Reply to this comment
by rafterman1 March 31, 2007 1:38 PM EDT
"This is a publicity stunt and it has one purpose, to divide the American people and thier government. It doesnt matter what party the idiots belong to that are running this circus, its wrong, and allowing it to continue only confirms the most negative relfections of America to the rest of the world."

Hilarious. Classic examples of accusing your opposition of what YOU are. Bush and the Repubs the last 12 years have done NOTHING but divide the American people - calling them traitors for political disagreements, shutting half the country out of all the politcal decisions, the Repub's "my way or the highway" approach to government. No, that's not dividing, is it? And the world has never had a more negative view of America thanks to Bush. We are hated more than ever now. Dem challenges to Bush will improve the world's view of America immensely.
Reply to this comment
by rafterman1 March 31, 2007 1:33 PM EDT
"This "investigation" is nothing more than a publicity stunt. "ABSOLUTELY" nothing has been uncovered that could or would carry "ANY" criminal charges."

I know you are deperate to rubber stamp anything and everything that the Bush administration does, but firing prosecutors to influence cases IS a crime. IT WAS NIXON'S SECOND ARTICLE OF IMPEACHMENT. When are you going to get that through your head?

If it isn't a crime, then why is everyone so afraid to testify under oath or in public or with a transcript?

Reply to this comment
by bobnjersey March 31, 2007 1:28 PM EDT
[This "investigation" is nothing more than a publicity stunt. "ABSOLUTELY" nothing has been uncovered that could or would carry "ANY" criminal charges]

ahhh ... the 'no laws were broken' defense!

a classic right wing mantra ... or touchstone principle ... or maybe just your lowly standard for living.

the holders of the highest seats of power in the us government should (unfortunately for you) be held to a higher standard than ... no crimes were committed.

the only thing bush and his co-conspirators can be given credit for is their strategic use of plausible deniability and successfully walking the line of legal ... or not.

some standard ... and you defend it?
Reply to this comment
See all 165 Comments

Exclusive Webshow

Best-selling author Mitch Albom on his first nonfiction work since "Tuesdays with Morrie." Watch Now

Latest News
News in Pictures
Scroll Left Scroll Right
Connect with CBS News

Stay connected with the CBS News using your favorite social networks and online news applications: