OROSI, Calif., March 29, 2007

Heartbreaking Mystery In California

DNA Tests Say 3 Babies Abandoned Since 2005 Almost Certainly Have Same Mom

  • Marely Pena (left), who found the body of a third abandoned baby in Orosi, Calif., last December, is seen here at a graveside service for the little girl, March 28, 2007, in Dinuba, California. Photo

    Marely Pena (left), who found the body of a third abandoned baby in Orosi, Calif., last December, is seen here at a graveside service for the little girl, March 28, 2007, in Dinuba, California.  (AP)

(AP)  The first newborn was discovered swaddled in a blanket on an outdoor bench, an umbilical cord still hanging from his tiny body. Then, at neat 11-month intervals, two more abandoned babies were found in parked pickup trucks in the same neighborhood.

This week, DNA tests established all three babies were almost certainly born to the same mother.

Now, in a heartbreaking mystery that has transfixed Orosi, California - a farm community of about 7,300 people - investigators are trying to find the mother and figure out what drove her to such desperate lengths.

"How can the relatives not see this girl pregnant, and then see that she's not pregnant anymore and not ask where's the baby? Somebody must know something," said Hortencia Espino, 81.

All three newborns were found within a two-block radius. The first two - a boy and a girl - survived and are now wards of the state.

The third baby was found dead of exposure on the cold night of Dec. 3. She was enveloped in a sweatshirt in the bed of a pickup parked near the high school, some 60 miles southeast of Fresno. The coroner concluded she was alive for less than a day.

On Wednesday, a Catholic church held a baptism and funeral Mass in Spanish and English for the baby girl, who was dubbed "Angelita DeOrosi," or Orosi's little angel.

Later, under the shade of a corrugated plastic awning, sheriff's officials and grandmothers delicately sifted handfuls of dirt onto her white coffin before it was lowered into the earth.

Marely Pena, who found the infant in her father's truck, cried behind dark glasses.

"I ask myself every day 'What if she had been alive?' We could have saved her," said Pena, 25. "I just hope the mother comes forward to please just make us feel at ease."

Orosi, a town encircled by fig and lemon orchards, has long been the kind of place where everyone seemed to know each other. But that is changing, with new housing developments going up and a burgeoning gang problem that has led to a rise in violent crime.

As upset residents built makeshift shrines in honor of Angelita, authorities interviewed local women they thought might be involved. But DNA testing eliminated them as the babies' mother.

After exhausting all leads, officials are asking the community for help finding the parents and are offering a $5,000 reward. Police said the mother could face criminal charges. But they also said they want to make sure she doesn't do it again and isn't in some kind of distress.

Investigators would not speculate as to the reasons for the abandonment, such as whether the mother might have been a prostitute or a rape victim.

"Whether the mother is in a physical state of danger or a mental state where she feels she can't ask for help, our heart goes out to her," Karen Franzen, manager of Dopkins Funeral Chapel in Dinuba, which donated a casket and cemetery plot for Angelita.

The first deserted newborn was found on Feb. 10, 2005, a barely breathing boy with a body temperature of just 85 degrees. On January 8, 2006, a resident discovered a full-term baby girl inside a pickup two blocks away, clothed in an undershirt and pants.

On Monday, sheriff's officials announced the DNA results. The first two babies probably had the same father, but Angelita was fathered by a different man.

California and 46 other states allow parents to legally abandon a child at a hospital or other designated safe zones within 72 hours of birth, no questions asked.

Since California's law went into effect in 2001, parents have safely surrendered 182 babies at fire stations, emergency rooms and other safe havens, according to state officials.

"This little community is a family. We know pretty much everyone else's business and they know ours," said Eugene Etheridge, principal of Orosi High School. "It's concerning that this could happen again when the most precious thing we have is our children."

By Garance Burke © MMVII The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Video and Galleries from U.S.

Add a Comment See all 133 Comments
by sandy777-2009 March 29, 2007 8:37 AM PDT
you will see more of this from other women, you need to thank the pro-life movement for this. when they take a woman's right to abortion away, naturally u will see more of this.

no one has the right to control a woman's right of choice. i am pro-choice and a woman and yes i had an abortion and i have had no regrets whatsoever. my life was in danger and having the abortion saved my life.
Reply to this comment
by yoopermom March 29, 2007 8:47 AM PDT
So far, no one has taken away a womans right to have an abortion. There is no way to excuse this kind of cruel abandonment and murder of an innocent child. There were many other options for this low life if she did not want her babies. She could have left these children in a safe place instead of leaving them to freeze to death!
Reply to this comment
by hlgplfe5 March 29, 2007 8:52 AM PDT
It is a load of baloney to blame this on the pro-life movement. There is no reason in the world for this to happen. First of all, they could have left the baby somewhere that was more safe, like a hospital or a church, and not in a truck. Second, there are plenty of ways to prevent an unwanted pregnancy. It is just plain ignorant and stupid and irresponsible to end up pregnant if you do not want children. You ought to be ashamed of yourself for being pro-choice.
Reply to this comment
by sandy777-2009 March 29, 2007 8:58 AM PDT
true..she could at least take the babies to a safe place but just assuming she's being raped by her father or other relative....she will have so much anger in her that she will not care what happens to the babies....she just wants to get rid of them. i am just assuming all of this. i know if i was being raped by a family member, i would have so much hate against that family member and not care what i do with it. JMO.

this does happen out there.
Reply to this comment
by cjhr43 March 29, 2007 8:59 AM PDT
Let's not put the blame on any part of society... the problem is increasingly clear. Too many "root causes"... Let everyone take responsibility for their own actions.
Reply to this comment
by sandy777-2009 March 29, 2007 9:01 AM PDT
i am PROUD to be Pro-Choice and NO ONE will ever change my mind.
Reply to this comment
by hlgplfe5 March 29, 2007 9:07 AM PDT
I suppose we all have a right to our own personal belief, and I respect that, however, on the pro-life topic, I have a hard time seeing the other side. I am proud to be Pro-Life, and I will never change either, so let's just leave it like that.
Reply to this comment
by hlgplfe5 March 29, 2007 9:07 AM PDT
I suppose we all have a right to our own personal belief, and I respect that, however, on the pro-life topic, I have a hard time seeing the other side. I am proud to be Pro-Life, and I will never change either, so let's just leave it like that.
Reply to this comment
by sandy777-2009 March 29, 2007 9:08 AM PDT
ok hlgplfe5....i agree to disagree.
Reply to this comment
by sandy777-2009 March 29, 2007 9:11 AM PDT
hlgplfe5...i may have said that in the wrong way...what i meant was i agree with you as far as we having our own different beliefs and i agree to leave it like that.
Reply to this comment
by hlgplfe5 March 29, 2007 9:15 AM PDT
I have several personal reasons to believe the way that I do, and I am sure you do as well.
I have to go now.
Reply to this comment
by smb221 March 29, 2007 9:18 AM PDT
You ought to be ashamed of yourself for being pro-choice.
Posted by hlgplfe5 at 08:52 AM : Mar 29, 2007

You are entitled your opinion. That's fine. But I'm proud to be pro-choice. Don't give people that *** of them being ashamed of themselves. Shame on you!
Reply to this comment
by cjhr43 March 29, 2007 9:19 AM PDT
Here we go again with the Christians... I thought all of of the persecutions ended with the fall of Rome. Hmmm ...History does repeat itself.
Reply to this comment
by cjhr43 March 29, 2007 9:22 AM PDT
On the point of abortion. Do all you pro-choicers realize the the initial population control was started by Margaret Sanger many years ago as a an attempt to control propagation of the "undesirables"?
Reply to this comment
by djberson March 29, 2007 9:29 AM PDT
Keeping down the population growth, especially that of "undesirables" is a better idea than ever! Many MORE people should have them.
Reply to this comment
by huskerarmy March 29, 2007 9:30 AM PDT
"You ought to be ashamed of yourself for being pro-choice."
Posted by hlgplfe5

I agree with the first part of your post. There is no reason for this to have happened. She, assuming she is not being controlled by someone else, could have left the baby at a hospital, church, etc. Or she could have had an abortion early in the pregnancy despite the barriers the so-called "pro-life" movement has placed on it. Be that as it may, in a democracy, people have choices. Having that choice prevents this kind of situation from happening much more frequently. At the end of the day, we really don't know what the circumstances are behind this tragedy. Certainly someone is criminally responsible. Nevertheless, this is not a time to exploit your political agenda and/or spread your reactionary shame. You ought to be ashamed of yourself for not being more evolved in your thinking.
Reply to this comment
by huskerarmy March 29, 2007 9:33 AM PDT
"Do all you pro-choicers realize the the initial population control was started by Margaret Sanger..."
Are you suggesting that there were no abortions or "population control" before that? Do you realize that the self righteous always have a villian to blame...
Reply to this comment
by cjhr43 March 29, 2007 9:42 AM PDT
Yes... What was done in dark alleys and filthy rooms has now become a common everyday "medical procedure". Thats good news... at least for the survivor of the medical procedure.
With the availability of prevention (low cost or even free)... abortion should not even be an option now ...except in rare cases. Elimination the "Blessed Event" is now an "eraser" for stupid mistakes.
Reply to this comment
by hlgplfe5 March 29, 2007 9:46 AM PDT
Maybe I should have worded my comment differently. I have no right to judge others. I am pro-life, and I am not ashamed to admit it to the world. My heart does go out to any woman who ends up pregnant and feels she has nowhere to turn. If i could I would help them all. Most of them feel as if they have no one to help. I am not trying to post my political agenda. I am simply trying to say that I do not think that this tragedy is due to the pro-choice movement. I think that it a case of someone who was in some sort of trouble, and didn't know where to go. It is a heart-breaking situation, and it makes me sad. I don't think that the tragedy is because of pro-choice or pro-life. I have personal reasons why I feel the way I do and why I am pro-life. I do not think we should take this sad story and argue, because instead we should wish the two babies that did survive to turn out alright, and hope that the woman, whoever and whereever she is, will somehow get the help she so desperately needs. I did not mean to offend any of you, and I apologize for saying you should be ashamed. Maybe I used the wrong words. We all have our own beliefs and feel strongly.
Reply to this comment
by grumpas March 29, 2007 9:48 AM PDT
hlgplfe5: You say you respect other people's belief's but that doesn't translate into much of anything but so much hot air with people like you! If you respected other people's believes you would not be pro-life! There isn't any way you could respect other people belief's and follow the radical pro-life tenets (they are designed to be intrusive and fascist)! You would be at home minding your own damned business! This is one good example also of why people like you are not pro-life! You could care less that there are three dead infants who were born then abandoned! If you did care you would not be trying to make certain every fetus is born and none are aborted! When they get out of the womb it's immaterial to you what happens to them. If you choose to continue living the lie you have been living be my guest! But, don't try and tell me you are pro-life! You are trying to shove your religious belief's down ever American's throat in the form of laws! Grow up and get a life!!!!! Move on from the sickness these people preach! I for one am Pro-Choice and not the slightest bit ashamed of it! I do not believe God gave us this planet to destroy in the fashion people like you are destroying it!
Reply to this comment
by madisongirl-2009 March 29, 2007 9:48 AM PDT
Concerning abortion

What if the baby that is being killed is also female?? What about her rights to her body, hmmmmm??


Reply to this comment
by cjhr43 March 29, 2007 9:55 AM PDT
grumpas... I had to laugh when reading your post... the ideal thing would be for you to read and follow your own advice...
This is a "free country" (at least for now... if the ACLU is successful it may not be)Keep your own ideas and opinions... no one is trying to change it for you... but please let the rest of us have the same option.
Reply to this comment
by hlgplfe5 March 29, 2007 9:56 AM PDT
Don't you dare insult me like that. I respect beliefs to a point, but abortion is murder. I simply cannot and will not ever say that it is ok to murder a helpless baby. And grumpus, maybe before you post you should read the whole story. Only one of these infants died, not all three. I am Pro-Life, and no idiot like you will ever change my belief. You can say what you want, but I am through.
Reply to this comment
by whoever1234 March 29, 2007 10:00 AM PDT
I'm not surprised to see the typical "this is the fault of the pro-life" arguments here. But consider this - it might be just as much the fault of the pro-choice mindset. After all, the woman was having the babies and obviously thought, "I have a choice to refuse to raise this baby." Sad choice to make, indeed. What if she had lived in a society that proclaimed and practiced the value of life? She may not have permitted herself to make the "choice" that she did.
Reply to this comment
by madisongirl-2009 March 29, 2007 10:01 AM PDT
Concerning abortion

What if the baby that is being killed is also female?? What about her rights to her body, hmmmmm??


PS....

I was adopted, and I am very thankful that my birth mother was pro-life.


Reply to this comment
by cjhr43 March 29, 2007 10:05 AM PDT
Before you choose to speak about what is best for a "prospective child" - talk to a child that "should have been aborted". I did just that. A child who was a drug baby...unwanted by both parents... a badly handicapped child that went on and survived to become an adult. She excelled... won awards in her personal life and in special olympics. She has 3 children of her own now. When she was in her teens I asked her if she thought she would have been better off aborted and she said "no way". She is very Christian and anti abortion.
Reply to this comment
by witwct March 29, 2007 10:06 AM PDT
This is called a terrible, heartbreaking tragedy. The irony is that if this baby had been killed prior to leaving the birth canal it would have been a non-event. Go figure!
Reply to this comment
by hlgplfe5 March 29, 2007 10:08 AM PDT
Madisongirl, I am so glad your birth mom chose life too. You make an excellent point, all of us posting, what if your mom hadn't chose life? You wouldn't be here.
Reply to this comment
by cjhr43 March 29, 2007 10:08 AM PDT
God bless you madisongirl
Reply to this comment
by jetlizhan March 29, 2007 10:12 AM PDT
grumpas-

life begins at conception; therefore, abortion is most definitely murder. that's a fact, jack - not an opinion - no getting around it. and you know one of the 10 commandments is 'thou shalt not kill' - i wouldn't be going against the Master if i were you!
Reply to this comment
by cjhr43 March 29, 2007 10:16 AM PDT
interesting note...
The phrase "thou shalt not give a woman an abortive remedy" has been removed from the Hipocratic Oath.
Reply to this comment
by star2510 March 29, 2007 10:24 AM PDT
If there wasn't pro-choice, just think how over populated we would become with everyone *** like jack rabbits from the age of 14 or younger!! We sould be like China, begging people to come adopt our girl babies! Angelina where in the hell are you when AMERICA needs you??!! We have babies HERE to adopt and need a family, why are you going elsewhere??










mer
Reply to this comment
by rohink-2009 March 29, 2007 10:34 AM PDT
If evr there was a reason for being pro choice this is it. These poor inocents would have been better being aborted than to die born on a bench, or wherever they were found. I will guarantee that this some mixed up person who comes from such a sick Christian Backgroud she did not get an abortion. In addition she needs to be found and helped she is mental!"
Posted by jerryomara

If the woman was Christian she wouldn't have left the babies in abandoned truck beds or benches to possibly die. She would have left them at a hospital or church. A sick Christian isn't really a Christian.
Reply to this comment
by cjhr43 March 29, 2007 10:35 AM PDT
Maybe we should find a clue there... kids are no longer enjoying the joys of youth. They are growing up too quickly. I tried to find cute outfits for my 8 yr old granddaughter and they were too ***.
Reply to this comment
by cjhr43 March 29, 2007 10:40 AM PDT
Amen! rohink
Reply to this comment
by whoever1234 March 29, 2007 10:41 AM PDT
If there wasn't pro-choice, just think how over populated we would become with everyone *** like jack rabbits from the age of 14 or younger!!
Posted by star2510

Or, just perhaps, we would be teaching, stressing, and practicing moral responsibility (even before pregnancy).
Reply to this comment
by madisongirl-2009 March 29, 2007 10:42 AM PDT
Concerning abortion

What if the baby that is being killed is also female?? What about her rights to her body, hmmmmm??


PS....

I was adopted, and I am very thankful that my birth mother was pro-life.



Reply to this comment
by rohink-2009 March 29, 2007 10:44 AM PDT
Maybe we should find a clue there... kids are no longer enjoying the joys of youth. They are growing up too quickly. I tried to find cute outfits for my 8 yr old granddaughter and they were too ***.
Posted by cjhr43

Amen to that. I am a grandma of two grandaughters. It's tough out there.
Reply to this comment
by hlgplfe5 March 29, 2007 10:55 AM PDT
By the way, when I said I respect others beliefs, I think I phrased it wrong. What I meant was that I understand that others don't share my decision to be pro-life, and I acknowledge that, and I know I can't change everyone's mind. So I don't agree with their beliefs, but I accept that there will be those who disagree with me. I do what I can to share my beliefs to those who will listen, and even if I ever changed one person and made them pro-life, I would be so happy. I think you misunderstood me. I am only saying that I agree to disagree, because some will never be on my side no matter what I do. Kudos to all of you who have agreed with me and posted your pro-life comments.
Reply to this comment
by whatithink-2009 March 29, 2007 10:55 AM PDT
This woman was definitely against abortions.
Reply to this comment
by star2510 March 29, 2007 11:03 AM PDT
Whoever1234: I agree wholeheartedly with your comment. I was not raised that way and my boys are not raised that way. I do not know what happened with people who let their daughters wear little bit of nothing clothes and date in the 8th grade. It is ridiculous and it is no wonder this poor unguided woman is leaving her babies around like they were nothing more that gum on her shoe. Her parents obviously taught her the morals of a pig (that is what sows do when they do not want their babies)They should be strung up along side her for allowing this to happen... (who wouldn't know their kid was pregnant 3 TIMES!)
Reply to this comment
by cantshutup March 29, 2007 11:08 AM PDT
must not have been illegal immigrants leaving those babies...otherwise the mom would have been happy to make another U.S. citizen and have us foot all the bills
Reply to this comment
by star2510 March 29, 2007 11:10 AM PDT
hlgpfve5: are you going to raise all the unwanted babies in the U.S. because the mothers 'chose' to have them and give them away? You better start stocking up on pampers, there are lots of them already.........there is nothing wrong with terminating an unwanted pregnancy, better than terminating an unwanted child after birth like this woman obviously chose. KUDOS to all those with half a brain in their head to make the right decison for THEMSELVES and not listen to those with no brain.
Reply to this comment
by cjhr43 March 29, 2007 11:10 AM PDT
Actually the baby was given the respect of a coffin... if it had been killed in the birth canal as a late term abortion it would wind up as medical garbage... treated as discarded "tissue"
Reply to this comment
by star2510 March 29, 2007 11:14 AM PDT
ha ha cantshutup, you are funny!Sounds like a possiblity! ha
Reply to this comment
by cjhr43 March 29, 2007 11:14 AM PDT
Star... if there are so many unwanted babies why is it so difficult to adopt? I know people that have gone to Columbia to adopt because none were available here.
Reply to this comment
by toldyouso21 March 29, 2007 11:16 AM PDT
maybe one of the 'relatives' impregnated her--if daddy did it, that would be a disincentive for him or 'mommy' to tell about the pregnancy or wonder about it. Right to lifers take note--she had them just like you wanted. Now get mad that she did not put them on the market for others to buy them.

here's a clue: look for a girl between the ages of 13 and 19 and look for her to be still living at home--possibly migrants, (and therefore, under the radar. just look for the daddy who seems to be really jealous or protective of anyone who looks at HIS little girl. Sad fact, but often the modus operandi of incest daddies.

Girl probably had no money for abortion or was too young and could never tell the truth or tell/implicate her parents about what happened.
Reply to this comment
by animalfarm2 March 29, 2007 11:20 AM PDT
WHAT THE **** IS WRONG WITH BIRTH CONTROL?!!
The whole argument over pro-life or pro-choice could very simply be avoided with one small pill a day. "She may have been raped" you say. Yeah right, every 11 months for the past three years she has had a child. I'm sure the rapist is watching and waiting for that event to take place so that he can start all over.
Reply to this comment
by star2510 March 29, 2007 11:20 AM PDT
cjhr43: tell me and we will both know. something needs to be done about it. The states obviously enjoy makeing these children grow up with out a home and a family, hence....pro-choice. Women, don't put your children thru that, if you don't want it, take care of it early on!!
Reply to this comment
by toldyouso21 March 29, 2007 11:22 AM PDT
Star... if there are so many unwanted babies why is it so difficult to adopt? I know people that have gone to Columbia to adopt because none were available here.
Posted by cjhr43 at 11:14 AM : Mar 29, 2007


Oh, there are a lot of babies AND children to adopt here. Ever been to an orphanage or seen the roster from foster care.
The fact is, people want new borns not potentially 'damaged goods' and so they go to another country to buy one. They think they will be able to imprint themselves on the child better if no one else influenced them first.

The fact is, the kids here that go unadopted are: biracial or an undesired minority, from a questionable home, come with emotional, physical and sexual baggage--plus in foreign countries, people who could not pass the screening here can adopt if they have enough money.

Several years ago a ring was broken up of children that were being adopted by couples and used in child pornography rings. There have also been cases of single males in the states adopted minority boys and using them for pleasure.

It is not that there are no kids here--it is that some couples feel the bars to adopt are too high in the states, while other people just belong behind bars.
Reply to this comment
See all 133 Comments
  • MOST POPULAR
  • Viewed
  • Commented
Latest News
Featured Blogs