Poll: Giuliani Leads McCain For GOP Nod

CBS News Poll Finds Favorable Ratings For Both, But Rudy Leads

(CBS)  Senator John McCain of Arizona and former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani – two of the front-runners for the Republican Presidential nomination in 2008 – both enjoy favorable views from both Republican primary voters, a new CBS News poll finds, but early on in the race, voters favor Giuliani in a head-to-head match up.

Views of Giuliani are especially positive among both moderates and the conservatives that he and McCain are courting.

Voters planning to take part in a Republican primary next year think both McCain and Giuliani share their values, but would currently prefer Giuliani over McCain if the nomination fight came down to just the two of them.

PREFERENCE IF GOP NOMINATION WERE JUST MCCAIN V. GIULIANI (Among Republican Primary Voters)

Giuliani
50%
McCain
21%
Neither
13%

Both moderate and conservative primary voters say they would prefer Giuliani. Forty-eight percent of conservative voters said they would vote for Giuliani, while 21% of conservatives said they favored McCain.

Both men have been the subject of questions over how their personalities and styles of governance, as well as issue positions, might help or hinder their chances. In the poll, both are seen as having the right kind of temperament and personality to be President.

MCCAIN'S QUALITIES (Among Republican Primary Voters)

Has the right temperament to be president...
Yes
59%
No
21%

Shares your values...
Yes
60%
No
20%


GIULIANI'S QUALITIES (Among Republican Primary Voters)

Has the right temperament to be president...
Yes
76%
No
12%

Shares your values...
Yes
57%
No
23%

America's voters overall hold a mostly favorable view of McCain and have positive views of Giuliani by an even larger margin. Both men, however, remain unknown to many nationwide: half cannot yet form an opinion of McCain, and four in ten say the same of Giuliani.

OPINION OF MCCAIN (Among Registered Voters)

Favorable
31%
Not favorable
20%
Undecided
28%
Don’t know enough yet
21%

OPINION OF GIULIANI (Among Registered Voters)

Favorable
41%
Not favorable
18%
Undecided
25%
Don’t know enough yet
16%

To read the complete poll results, click here.

[beehive21-2009]

Neither is worthy of the Senate ,forget Presidency.(losers)The Rep.will need someone like Britney to have any chance.

[feelfree1]

ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz!!!

The Republican Party is no longer relevant.

[bildooreilly]

Scum always rises to the top whether it be water or politics, just go dig a little bit about your favorite politicians and turn up all the dirt. The ones you see on television are the most corrupt of all... don't vote for people you see on TV.

[scott4261]

Giuliani is way to liberal on the social issues for the right wing nazis to stomach and he will not get the nomination. And McCain has kissed Bush's a s s for so long that he's lost any credibility he may have once had as a "maverick.%u201D

The GOP is dead in the water for 2008.

[hawksprings]

Guiliani would make a great president. As for his social beliefs, all he has to do is say he believes something different now. That's what Hillary does.

[scott4261]

Guiliani would make a great president. As for his social beliefs, all he has to do is say he believes something different now. That's what Hillary does.
Posted by hawksprings at 08:22 PM

-----

Well, I don't like her either (largely FOR that very reason!) Anyway, don't you think we've had enough from politicians who change with the wind?

[mrkim1]

Obama!!!!!!!!!!

[gladys_over]

Here comes Mitt Romney !!

His being a Mormon won't hold him back any more than JFK's Catholicism stopped him.

[gladys_over]

Giuliani's secret campaign strategy was misplaced not long ago.

It's finally turned up now.

It consists of just one sentence: "When in doubt, mention your performance on 9/11."

[cbville72]

The GOP is dead in the water for 2008.

Posted by scott4261 at 08:19 PM : Feb 17, 2007
+ report this comment

You crybabies said the same thing in '00 and '04

[moxford0]

I suppose Rudy Guiliani is a cut above Quick Draw McCain and the neo-idiots in the Republician party. He is perhaps several cuts above if that's saying anything.

[cbville72]

There you have it

The republicans are so discouraged with the current adminstration that even they wiould vote for a liberal rather than a war monger
Posted by liberalameri at 09:46 PM : Feb 17, 2007


And in '08, they will probably win ANOTHER election and we'll have to hear all you pus sees cry about "voter disenfranchisement" and how the voting is "rigged". The tears will be flowing like a river.

[cbville72]

It's amazing to me that you people cry like you do about our "evil" president and your "neocons" remarks. It is such a tired rant.

It is also amazing how you people portray europeans as so much more enlightened that we are...Constantly painting our country in as bad a light as possible on the world stage. I guess it all goes into the idea of creating your ideal society where nobody works for a living because they can sue for any and everything that goes wrong in their lives and kids don't get corrected because it will be too painful for their fragile egos, thus turning them into ADD and hyper sensitive animals. Competition is not allowed either because losing at anything also would harm people too.
Pathetic

[walt1944-2009]

After what we have seen of the Republican agenda over the past 6 years, and after what happened in the Senate this Saturday, why would any sane person vote for ANY Republican. All the Republicans want is war, war, WAR, and money, money, MONEY so they get rich, rich, RICH! Too bad for everyone else because to Republicans, you are just cannon fodder.

[cbville72]

The liberal media......don't leave home without it. Cause its scary out there, just watch the news!
Sorry guys. I believe we are right in what we are doing in Iraq and in the end it will be a country better off than it was under Hussein. The difference with liberals is that once the going gets tough, they run for the hills. They want to pull the troops out and come up with meaningless "non binding legislation"....BTW, that failed today.

[cbville72]

After what we have seen of the Republican agenda over the past 6 years...
Posted by walt1944 at 10:34 PM

Umm yeah...lets refresh: No terrorist attacks in that time since 9/11, the economy is steady, gas prices have fallen and N. Korea has just caved in to the pressure that had been applied to them by our gov't and wants to come to the bargaining table because BUSH said he wasn't negotiating with them until they came to the 6 nation bargaining table. A few months ago, I hear liberal after liberal claim thiswas going to be a failure. It sure is funny to see how little this has been reported on CBS.

[cbville72]

I really hope that the democrats nominate Obama or Clinton.

[johnshaft4]

Would YOU allow your daughter to date anyone of these swine?

[scott4261]

You crybabies said the same thing in '00 and '04
Posted by cbville72 at 10:23 PM

----------------

Obviously, you - just like the incompetent (and now unpopular) president you continue to carry water for - didn't learn a thing from the 2006 elections. We've been in the far right ditch for long enough and the pendulum is now swinging to the LEFT, my friend...

[scott4261]

Amen!

[fascistusa]

wayfedup-

It's time to stop worrying about the Vote. who cares?

Our GOVERNMENT does not represent us. We have no say in our Government. It's that simple. Voting is a joke.

It's time for Fight Club. It's time for V for Vendetta. It's time for another Civil War. It's time for REVOLUTION.

[scott4261]

American politics goes in cycles. The pendulum swung to the left in the 60's, peaking in the '70s (Civil rights, Vietnam, Watergate). It swung to the right in the '80s (Reagan) and then sort of centered in the '90s after peaking to the left in '94 (Clinton/Republican congress). Since 2001, we have been in the far right ditch. Now we are going to take a shift to the left before we settle in the middle again sometime in the next decade.

A Democrat will be elected president in 2008. And then you Republicans will get too greedy again and the pendulum will start its swing back to the right.

And so it goes...

[nivramcireel]

Would YOU allow your daughter to date anyone of these swine?
Posted by JohnShaft4 at 10:56 PM : Feb 17, 2007

If Mitt were available, YES. But Mitt Romney is the one most likely to remain faithful to his one and ONLY wife. The other top three republican contenders might be interested in a 3rd or 4th wife....

[kaliveotin]

Aren't these two men dying of cancer? I know it was the main reason Gulianni didn't take on Hillary in New York? Even if his health is in remission does he really think he'd have a better chance to beat her for president. McCains cancer is and was much less threatenning but again he's too old and sickly to beat Hillary. Sure either of them could beat Baruk Husien Osama, but they won't have that chance. The democrats will nominate Hillary, and only Gingrich has the conversational skills AND CONSERVATIVE credential that would be necessary to give Hillary a serious contest. She is WAY STRONGER than the corporate media would lead one to believe. A Mormon, never. a liberal Republican
would never win the general election. McCain is by far the best Republican candidate but he's not well enough for two national campaigns in the next two years. That leaves Gingrich.

[nivramcireel]

Gingrich lacks character. He presented divorce papers to his first wife while she lay in hospital bed recovering from cancer.

[candojj1]

It's time for a populist like Huey Long to step forward before the walls come tumbling down. Not Huey Long the dictator, but Long the populist. The closest politician to a populist has not reared their head. McCain, Giuliani and Romney are creepy politicians. Clinton, Obama, Edwards and the rest lack the populist passion. They haven't a clue, as Long did, about hardship and wealth distribution. They will not take on the large corporations because the money needed to get elected comes from those companies. The only viable choice is Gore.

[dallison7]

gas prices have fallen

Posted by cbville72




une 27, 1999
Web posted at: 6:28 p.m. EDT (2228 GMT)
The average price of self-service regular gasoline rose .59 cents, up to about $1.19 per gallon.

[grumpas]

Guiliani will never make it! He isn't a big enough nut case to please the right-wingers! So far they rule the party and not likely to ever give up any of their long sought after power to shove religion down this countries throats! So, I wouldn't hold my breath until any of the three makes it to the final's!

[macusweil]

Rudy is the only Republican candidate in the race so far that is not a either a flip-flop or neo-con or both. I remember the a day when standing up for women's rights & equal rights (think gay rights today) was looked on as a positive, that was before the radical right took over this party with their self serving agenda of hate, lies and corruption.

Main Entry: neo.con (ser.va.tive)
Pronunciation: 'nE-O-k&n
Function: noun or adjective
1 a : of or relating to a person or strategy of pretending
to follow traditional conservatism with little or no true interest
in such philosophy simply for personal, political or economic gain.

[bigdadpatrio]

macusweil, it seems like YOU have the agenda of hate. Pretty hateful speech. Typical double standard for libs.

[fredgrad2000]

A lot of posts here about the "right-wing"; and I agree; neither Guiliani nor McCain (who I both like) may be "right-wing" enough to win the GOP nomination...which is too bad, because they both seem actually willing to form their own opinions and hold to them, unlike the entire Democratic field (save Obama)- Hillary has "migrated" her position on the war to fit the Democratic primaries - look at her record; she never once has acted on principle; only on polls!! But for all this discussion of the "right-wing"; let's remember there is a very nutty "left-wing" out there as well; and as far as Republican candidates have to swing right to get their nomination, the Dems have to swing WAY left to win theirs....its too bad the people who control who our 2 real choices for President will be represent the 20% fringes (left AND right) of our society; how about we get 2 candidates who are willing to stand on their own beliefs and who don't have to kow-tow to the fringes? The one thing I KNOW, is that due to Iraq, you will end up with a much more more moderate GOP nominee for 2008, one that the GOP thinks can distance themselves from Bush, than Dem nominee; the Dem nominee will be very left, very liberal, and owned by the surrender left...

and fascistusa - who is this guy!? Go to Venezuela, you and Hugo can have your "revolution" there!!! But thanks for the laugh, you and other loons in the world like Chavez and Ahmadinejad, Chirac - at least you make me laugh!

[candojj1]

to fredgrad2000

you write sooo much c*r*a*p*o*l*a. You can not put your self in the shoes of a poor man. Nor can you see the soon to be poor man squeezed by his poor decisions of his adjustable rate mortgage and the terrible housing market. Nor can you see the plight of those being squeezed by the predatory banker who, at will, bait the average consumer with low rates only to send them some hidden piece of, what looks like junk mail "opt out" statement which the consumer probably does not see and probably does not understand. Furthermore, few consumers know enough about having to write letters to merchants to dispute a charge (in triplicate) BEFORE contacting the credit card company.
So what do these candidates offer to the average Joe? Absolutely nothing. It was Paul Volcker who tried to put some safeguards into place and without his leadership the country would truly be a gangster driven banker's paradise. However, as it stands, these candidates are just stooges of the most evil empire on the face of the Earth. There is no Luke Skywalker in sight.

[archieinsc]

The lead poll NUMBERS ARE WRONG when compared with the complete poll data. It should be Giuliani 50% and McCain 29%, not 21%. I know Bob S. quoted this poll on Face the Nation, but I did not notice if he quoted the right numbers, not having seen the complete poll. Also it is interesting that among all registered voters it was a lot closer: 36% to 28%. Could it be CBS is pushing "America's Mayor"? One wonders.

[scott4261]

Giuliani is way to liberal on the social issues for the right wing nazis to stomach and he will not get the nomination. And McCain has kissed Bush's a s s for so long that he's lost any credibility he may have once had as a "maverick."

But this really is an exercise in futility. The GOP is dead in the water for 2008.

[frb01]

In recent Republican history, this should be McCain's turn, the problems he has are his support for the surge, his age, and his health. I think he and Rudy are the leading candidates for the nomination, but would admit that whoever gets it faces a tough battle with the Democrats. Too many strong contenders over there, Clinton, Obama, Richardson, and Edwards, a candidate with a strength for whichever issue happens to be the defining issue of the moment.

[mefin2000]

How can you compare a hero like John McCain to a cheating, marry my second cousin, connected to a known criminal, arrogant, jerk? John McCain knows what it is like to be in war and with his courage and strenght was able to survive as a POW for over 5 year. What did Rudy do, he cleaned up New York, and cheated on his second wife with his third wife. His arrogance irrates me and his personal life makes me want to puke. I will never vote for someone who can treat the mother of his children the way he did his second wife than he does not deserve to be President. I would rather use my vote for a man who is willing to die for his principles. John McCain is a real hero and if the american people would have voted for him in 2000, than maybe our brave hero's fighting in Iraq and the brave soldiers who have died in Iraq would still be here and alive protecting our country and would still be able to enjoy their families. We need a man who can end this war the right way. A man who will finish the job and a man who will leave the Iraqi people with a better place. The soldier's fighing in Iraq and Afganistan need a leader who knows what it is like to be willing to sacrifice his body for the better of man. Mr. McCain, POW will make a greater leader not only because he is a true leader but also because he is a proven politcal leader. Any man who is willing to cross party lines and work with all parties when he thinks they are right is something our govenment needs.

[norcalruss]

Rudy is the only Republican candidate in the race so far, that I would even consider voting for. I voted for Bush in 2000, and voting for that idiot turned out to be one of the biggest mistakes in my life. If Rudy were to win the nomination he would have strong appeal to the sensible-center swing-voters who decide elections. But that is just the problem. He is not enough of an extremist for the right-wing nut jobs, religious zealots, anti-abortionists, gay haters, and fascists who want global domination by US inc., for him ever to get the nomination. So the nomination will probably go to either John %u2018more war%u2019 McCain, or flip-flopping Mitt the Mormon Romney, whose slogan should be, I used to be tolerant of women/gay rights but now I%u2019ve become a bigot to get the nomination.

[seven-pesos]

any republican can run as long as it's not another southern idiot creep like bush.

the south has no idea what a good president is.

rednecks, white trash, phony christian creeps...

nothing good comes out of the south!

[jdweymouth]

seven-pesos: Nothing good comes out of the south? Texas has the second largest popluation in the country, and Florida has the 3rd largest. The most unciilized, and white trash cities I've seen are, New York, and Los Angeles. The most civilized cities I've seen are, San Antonio, and Jacksonville. I'm a northener, but the north, and south both have their embarassing underbelly. You're not a bigot are you? Oh, I forgot! That title only applies to Anglo-Saxon Christians.

[j0hnwi11iams]

I would have far more respect for the South if the South had more respect for Science. There is a disease called religion that seems to take hold in the ignorant backwaters of the south that seems impervious to fact or reason. The South has been BEHIND on every progressive issue, consistently, beginning with SLAVERY. You should quit trying to defend your ignorance. If only you valued the ideas of science as much as its products. The only thing we get out of religion is more BS and those obedient to shameless con artists.