NEW YORK, Feb. 7, 2007

Bloggers Bash Super Bowl Ads

Amateurs Trump Madison Avenue-Produced Commercials In Blogosphere

  • Play CBS Video Video Ad Challenge Winner On TV Spot

    Katie Crabb, the winner of the Super Bowl Ad Challenge, and Kim Kosak, Chevrolet's general director of advertising, speak with Harry Smith about the commercial courtesy of a college freshman.

  • Video Super Bowl Ad Mania

    Julie Chen gets a sneak preview of this year's ads from ad critic Barbara Lippert and chats with Daisy Fuentes, co-host of the CBS special "Super Bowl's Greatest Commercials."

  • Video A Fan-Made Super Bowl Ad

    A lot of fans watch the Super Bowl as much for the commercials as for the football. One of the ads that will air this Sunday came straight from a fan's concept. Katie Couric has more.

    • This undated photo released by Nationwide Mutual Insurance shows Kevin Federline in the role of a fast-food worker in a clip from the Nationwide Super Bowl Ad

      This undated photo released by Nationwide Mutual Insurance shows Kevin Federline in the role of a fast-food worker in a clip from the Nationwide Super Bowl Ad "Life Comes at You Fast."  (AP Photo/Nationwide Mutual)

    • Sen. Hillary Clinton, D-N.Y., speaks during a town hall meeting, Sunday, Jan. 28, 2007.

      Sen. Hillary Clinton, D-N.Y., speaks during a town hall meeting, Sunday, Jan. 28, 2007.  (AP)

    Previous slide Next slide
  • Super Bowl All The Ads

    CBS SportsLine.com puts all of the commercials from Super Bowl XLI in one place.

  • Interactive Super Sunday

    All you need to know about the Super Bowl: history, matchups, photos, and trivia.

  • Photo Essay Hillary Rodham Clinton

    The Democratic Senator from New York and former first lady sets her sights on the White House.

(CBS)  The Guardian reported that the American Enterprise Institute (AEI) sent letters to scientists in Britain, the United States and elsewhere attacking the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change's report, and asking for essays that "thoughtfully explore the limitations of climate model outputs." The letters were sent by Kenneth Green, a visiting scholar at AEI, who told the newspaper he wrote to scientists, economists and policy analysts asking them for an independent review that would highlight the strengths and weaknesses of the IPCC report.

Many bloggers joke that the most surprising thing about Exxon, with its record profits, is that the company didn't offer scientists more money. "$10,000?! For research that will help Big Oil continue to reap billions of dollars in profits?," Kvatch writes at Blognonymous.

"Honestly, the only thing that surprises me is the insultingly low dollar amount ($10,000), given the many millions that the AEI has rolling around...," Itty Bitty Kitty Committee writes. And Jeremy Korzeniewski at AutoblogGreen adds, "A measly ten seconds of their time (in profit) to each scientist. For shame."

Some bloggers say global warming reports can't be trusted in the hands of profit-driven corporations. "Profit and self interest is what motivates corporations and business leaders, their professed doubts about global warming are not based on real science," a blogger at TheGimpChronicles writes.

But others who fault AEI for trying to sway opinion on global warming also find the culture of blame over our climate troubling. "I personally am still not convinced that we are to blame for climate change. I'm not even sure that we need to find blame," a blogger at Earthpeace writes. "My interest is in behaving responsibly in our home environment - earth, (which is where I differ from the Exxonites). We do not need to adopt a fear or panic culture — merely a responsible culture."


Mad Jump

LisaNova, one of the top YouTubers, is joining the cast of MADtv later this month, and the move has lots of bloggers praising the power of the Web as an open audition. LisaNova, aka Lisa Donovan, auditioned unsuccessfully for MADtv earlier in her career, but her YouTube fame caught a director's eye and she won another audition, and her spot on the show.

Some suggest that one day in the near future, perhaps YouTube will be the pinnacle of stardom, rather than a starting off point. "The question is: will TV always be the pinnacle of fame? We know YouTube will eventually roll out revenue sharing ala Metacafe or Revver, and with the audiences these users command, they may be able to go full time with their YouTube stardom," a blogger at Mashable writes.

Gordon at Multi-Platform Media agrees this is a question worth asking. "The real question here is whether the web is a farm club for TV or a end in and of itself. I would argue that, at least for now, it's a training ground," he blogs. "What's quite cool is the opportunity that forums like YouTube allow for training and truly open auditions."

"Well, it appears YouTube's posturing toward paying its creators is coming a little too late for some of the site's stars, who are already making the leap to television," Liz Gannes writes at NewTeeVee.

Many praise Donovan’s success. "Good luck and more power to LisaNova as she join the list of podcasters and video podcasters who made it all the way to the big screen," Podcast Fresh blogs.

Others claim they spotted LisaNova's talent on YouTube early on. "We quickly recognized Lisa as a budding star whose gift for comedic timing and withering impersonations is reminiscent of Julia Louis-Dreyfus...," The Daily Reel writes.

Blogophile RSS Feed


By Melissa McNamara
© MMVII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Share:
  • Share
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Mixx
Add a Comment
by lpcgraham06 February 7, 2007 2:02 PM EST
??????????????????????????????
Reply to this comment
by KOOLSTUF February 7, 2007 1:58 PM EST
If that WASHINGTON POST columnist said women are
"less interested in politics than men" -- did
she mean: "women are more interested in men than they are interested in politics"; or: "women are more interested in politics than men are interested in politics" ???

I sure hope the former is true! (I'm a h--l of a lot more interested in women -- but absent any,
I do follow politics.)

On average, I'd guess too few of both genders care about politics -- which is why Big Money and Special Interests now own/control most of our politicians !!!
Reply to this comment
by anopinion1 February 7, 2007 1:41 PM EST
question

would leaders of other countries really sit down and talk out things with a woman president from the U.S.??????

they is my fear if she was to win
Reply to this comment
by anopinion1 February 7, 2007 1:37 PM EST
what is youtube?
Reply to this comment
  • MOST POPULAR
Latest News
News in Pictures
Scroll Left Scroll Right
Connect with CBS News

Stay connected with the CBS News using your favorite social networks and online news applications: