February 11, 2009 5:32 PM
- Text
Where Are The Medals For Troops In Iraq?
(CBS)
The war in Iraq is lumbering toward its fourth year, and the American body count has passed 3,000. But, as CBS News correspondent Thalia Assuras reports, questions are being raised about why so few medals for valor have been awarded to the men and women who have sacrificed so much in this conflict compared to wars of the past.
Some of the fiercest fighting of the war was in Fallujah in November 2004 –a month that saw 136 U.S. soldiers killed.
Staff-Sergeant David Bellavia remembers. He was there. "The embers were flying everywhere, tracer fire like a hornets nest, just exploding in a room," he says. "There was no safe spot."
Bellavia – who was videotaped by CBS caring for a wounded soldier during the battle – took on a house full of insurgents – alone.
"I used my weapon and I used my helmet and my plate and a knife and everything I had in my power because I was literally fighting for my life," he says.
Bellavia lost his entire chain of command in Fallujah, but that day in that house he fought and won, killing at least four insurgents. Bellavia's unit recommended him for the military's highest award - the Medal of Honor.
He was awarded a Silver Star.
"It's the most humbling thing in the world, but it's embarrassing," he says now.
Embarrassing, says Bellavia, because so many others are not being recognized with valor medals.
"I think we would be in a better state right now as a military and a nation if we honored those young men and women who are doing their jobs," he says.
Past wars seem to have produced more heroes. In World War Two, the military awarded 464 Medals of Honor; in Vietnam 245. But in Iraq, there have only been two.
As for service crosses, which are the second highest honor that the Army, Navy and Air Force award: 8,716 were given out in World War Two. So far in Iraq and Afghanistan, which have now lasted longer than WWII, just 26 have been given.
Military analysts say part of the reason fewer medals have been awarded in this conflict is that it's a different kind of war.
Some of the reasons why:
Iraq is not a traditional battlefield.
Fighting is often done with high-tech weapons rather than hand to hand combat.
IEDs are often the enemy, rather than human beings.
"There are simply different opportunities, I think, in a conflict to demonstrate heroism and this particular conflict may present opportunities that are different from the past," says Bill Carr, the acting Deputy Undersecretary of Defense who is the head of a multi-branch commission reviewing the pentagon's award policy.
The commission is expected to recommend some changes this summer, but Carr says they will only be minor revisions. He sees no reason to change the policy for the highest valor awards.
"Each Medal of Honor that I've seen has met the standards precisely," Carr says. "It's been carefully reviewed by commanders asking questions of each other, checking back with witnesses, so the process is a comprehensive one."
That explanation doesn't really satisfy Bellavia. He says there needs to be a complete overhaul.
"We need every branch of service on the same page," he says. "And obviously, we need someone from the Unites States Congress to supervise."
Bellavia is on a crusade to make that happen.
"It's extremely personal and only because of the fact that my best friends have bled and died," he says. "I lost 36 brothers in one year."
Some of the fiercest fighting of the war was in Fallujah in November 2004 –a month that saw 136 U.S. soldiers killed.
Staff-Sergeant David Bellavia remembers. He was there. "The embers were flying everywhere, tracer fire like a hornets nest, just exploding in a room," he says. "There was no safe spot."
Bellavia – who was videotaped by CBS caring for a wounded soldier during the battle – took on a house full of insurgents – alone.
"I used my weapon and I used my helmet and my plate and a knife and everything I had in my power because I was literally fighting for my life," he says.
Bellavia lost his entire chain of command in Fallujah, but that day in that house he fought and won, killing at least four insurgents. Bellavia's unit recommended him for the military's highest award - the Medal of Honor.
He was awarded a Silver Star.
"It's the most humbling thing in the world, but it's embarrassing," he says now.
Embarrassing, says Bellavia, because so many others are not being recognized with valor medals.
"I think we would be in a better state right now as a military and a nation if we honored those young men and women who are doing their jobs," he says.
Past wars seem to have produced more heroes. In World War Two, the military awarded 464 Medals of Honor; in Vietnam 245. But in Iraq, there have only been two.
As for service crosses, which are the second highest honor that the Army, Navy and Air Force award: 8,716 were given out in World War Two. So far in Iraq and Afghanistan, which have now lasted longer than WWII, just 26 have been given.
Military analysts say part of the reason fewer medals have been awarded in this conflict is that it's a different kind of war.
Some of the reasons why:
"There are simply different opportunities, I think, in a conflict to demonstrate heroism and this particular conflict may present opportunities that are different from the past," says Bill Carr, the acting Deputy Undersecretary of Defense who is the head of a multi-branch commission reviewing the pentagon's award policy.
The commission is expected to recommend some changes this summer, but Carr says they will only be minor revisions. He sees no reason to change the policy for the highest valor awards.
"Each Medal of Honor that I've seen has met the standards precisely," Carr says. "It's been carefully reviewed by commanders asking questions of each other, checking back with witnesses, so the process is a comprehensive one."
That explanation doesn't really satisfy Bellavia. He says there needs to be a complete overhaul.
"We need every branch of service on the same page," he says. "And obviously, we need someone from the Unites States Congress to supervise."
Bellavia is on a crusade to make that happen.
"It's extremely personal and only because of the fact that my best friends have bled and died," he says. "I lost 36 brothers in one year."
Latest Now in CBS Evening News
- Avalanche survivor owes life to safety backpack
- Evening News Online, 02.20.12
- U.S. remains optimistic on Iran sanctions
- Parents seek to take over failing school
- McCain: Syria is a "world's community problem"
- John Glenn on first Earth orbit, 50 years later
- Survivor recounts Wa. avalanche
- UN inspectors return to Iran's nuclear facilities
- Santorum's risky message
- SoCal parents may succeed in school takeover
- Santorum's popularity puts his views in the spotlight
- Super PAC funding helping Romney
- Sen. McCain: It's time to arm Syria's rebels
- Avalanche survivor: Friend died 3 feet away
- McCain: U.S. should "provide support" to Syrian rebels
- McCain: Iran "supplying arms" to Syrian government
- Evening News Online, 02.19.12
Latest CBS News Headlines
on Facebook
on CBS News
- High court health care argument extended to 6 hrs
- Iowa lawmakers say they've reached prison deal
- Comptroller: NY sales tax collections on the rise
- Steven Madden 4Q net income rises
on Facebook
- Santorum: Democrats are "anti-science," not me
- Carnival/Mardi Gras 2012
- Whitney Houston memorial
- Mozart of Chess: Magnus Carlsen
on CBS News
