Jan. 5, 2007

Contractor Fraud Unchecked In Iraq

CBS News Takes A Closer Look At Allegations Of Contractor Waste And Fraud In Iraq

  • Play CBS Video Video Misuse Of Your Tax Dollars?

    The U.S. has spent billions of your tax dollars on the war in Iraq and plans to spend about $170 billion more this year. Armen Keteyian reports on how some of this money is actually being spent.

  • The Pentagon and Congress are investigating about 80 cases of alleged contractor waste, fraud and abuse by civilian contractors in Iraq.

    The Pentagon and Congress are investigating about 80 cases of alleged contractor waste, fraud and abuse by civilian contractors in Iraq.  (CBS)

  • Interactive Iraq: A Turning Point?

    New Congress, change at the Pentagon, study group report; what does the future hold?

  • Blog Primary Source

    Armen Keteyian and his investigative team keep you informed daily on their blog.

  • E-MAIL US CBS News Investigates

    E-mail Armen Keteyian and the investigation team with your story ideas.

(CBS)  The U.S. has currently spent at least $437 billion on the Iraq war, according to the Congressional Research Service. An estimated $100 billion will be spent in 2007. Much of that money is going to 60,000 civilian contractors involved in reconstruction and providing services to the troops.

But recently, the Pentagon admitted it has a hard time accounting for how billions of your tax dollars are being spent — and the billions that may be lost to contractor waste, fraud and abuse, CBS News investigative correspondent Armen Keteyian reports.

A document — part of a whistleblower lawsuit obtained by CBS News — alleges a blueprint of contractor abuse in Iraq, detailing how the government was billed 10 times more than it should have been when U.S. troops used a recreation facility in Iraq.

That's because they were not billed once per visit, but rather billed repeatedly, every time a soldier used:
  • a computer
  • a phone
  • ping pong equipment or pool equipment
  • a towel
  • a bottle of water.

    The contractor in question, Kellogg Brown and Root, denies any wrongdoing.

    "Eventually we're going to have a bill for about $1 trillion, and people are not going to be able to account for a very, very large part of it," says Sen. Patrick Leahy, D-Vt.

    The Pentagon and Congress are investigating about 80 cases of alleged contractor waste, fraud and abuse in Iraq. To date, 26 have been referred to the Justice Department for possible prosecution.

    So far a few individuals have been charged, most from a single case, and a few million dollars has been paid back. After 3 1/2 years of war, not a single criminal case has been filed against any large corporation doing work in Iraq.

    "The Bush administration doesn't give a damn about contractor fraud in Iraq," attorney Alan Grayson says.

    Grayson has filed dozens of civil "whistleblower" lawsuits against contractors, and he says with no help from the government because of what describes as the administration's ties to major military contractors.

    "After 3 1/2 years, shouldn't they actually have brought some of these people to justice? What is the big problem?" Grayson said.

    A Justice Department spokesperson says contractor fraud and corruption allegations are taken "seriously" and it's "aggressively" pursuing "a number ... of investigations."

    In addition, a senior Justice Department official tells CBS News that it takes two to three years to investigate civil fraud cases and, even then, only about one in five meet the standards necessary for prosecution.

    As the incoming chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, Leahy just isn't buying it. He plans to get to the bottom line ... of just how hundreds of billions of U.S. dollars have been spent in Iraq.

    "This is not going to be a game of 'gotcha,'" Leahy said. "This is going to be a game of being responsible if we are going to spend taxpayer dollars, the taxpayers have a right to know where the money is going."

    Just yesterday, Leahy introduced a bill mandating criminal penalties for those who exploit the war effort.


    If you have information you'd like to contribute to this story we want to hear from you. Email us at investigates@cbsnews.com.

    © MMVII, CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
    Add a Comment See all 21 Comments
    by kosgunnin January 7, 2007 6:54 AM EST
    I believe the biggest issue is that the government allows these companies to charge exaggerated amounts of money. I see first hand what these contractors do over here. Not to say that there not working, but for what they get paid and what a soldier gets paid are just so drastically different it's sickens me. The funny part about it all is that these companies are making so much money for these little things that they do. the big nail biter is that for as many soldiers that we have in Iraq. We have the man power to do the same work they do our selves. We have jobs in the military for every job that these civilians do. We just prefer not doing it. What it really comes down to is that those making the decisions to pay the contractors is getting a piece of that money some way or another. To end this long rant of my opinion. I wish we the soldiers would get paid what we should, not what is budgeted. That the civilians should be on the volunteer plan that we get paid, and have to save 3/4 of there pay from the year being deployed to even try and get half of what they get in real life for a year. But what do I know, im just a poor soldier doing what I'm told to, and watching curruption and greed make decisions that effect our lives.
    Reply to this comment
    by long_rider January 7, 2007 12:05 AM EST
    There is temporary solution to this contractor problem, "STOP PAYMENT". I have worked for many years as a contractor, and if we could not account for our time or expenses we faced having our payments stgopped, but we would have to continue to work.

    The oversight of the Iraq contracts has been non-existant, and the lack of overdight has had the Whitehouse support.

    This administration has contracted out every military function it could, except for dying. The days of KP are over, contractors are feeding the troops over in Iraq, lord only knows what this costing us on a per meal basis.

    After all of the investigations are complete no one will be found responsible, because of the Whitehouse connection.

    The first thing I would want to know is how Halliburton was awarded these contracts with out having to bid on them, that would make the co-president squirm a little.
    Reply to this comment
    by kwqt69 January 6, 2007 10:52 PM EST
    Why do Americans allow Bush and his pals rip them off time and time again and then don't do anything but whine? Well at least it gives the rest of the world something to laugh at.
    Bend over and spread 'em for the good old USA!
    Reply to this comment
    by melcarnahan January 6, 2007 10:19 PM EST
    Speaking of Bush obstructing justice by trying to cover up the White House visitors records while Bush's JackoffGate scandal was being exposed on May 17, 2006, it might be interesting to see the Florida and Texas Iraq profiteering contracts by people connected to Bush's pawn Abramoff.
    Reply to this comment
    by skyk-2009 January 6, 2007 11:16 AM EST
    This has to be the biggest rip off of the American People EVER! We are giving BILLIONS to Contractors to perform functions once performed by Privates in our Armed Forces. Those Billions can not be accounted for in a War that has NOTHING to do with any Attack on this Nation or anything what so ever to do with any Weapons that could be used against us. We are giving away the future of this nation trying to "Give" our system of Government to people who have shown NO DESIRE to have such. We are handing our Kids a debt beyond belief so some Corporation can exploit yet another part of the world and feel safe while doing it. That's the bottom line here. That is beyond a doubt the worst rip off of America EVER!!
    Reply to this comment
    by besscannon-2009 January 6, 2007 8:41 AM EST
    What happened to accountability? How is it our government can pay out billions and not insisted on a decent accounting for where it goes? Good Lord, it looks as if it was "arranged" for Bush to become president so he and his neocon buddies could loot the federal government. Maybe that is why the war was started...for cover for looting the treasury. He has proved rotten enough to be that crooked. Has anyone besides me notice how sneaky Bush's eyes are looking? You know, your eyes show what you are and your mouth shows what you have become. Has anyone noticed the set to his lips and how his chin is receding? Those kind of things can tell you a lot about a person I have found. You learn to observe these things after 82 years on this planet. The tilt of the head denotes a problem, also. Watch the man, you will see what I am seeing. There is something seriously wrong there and we have put ourselves at his mercy and it is all our own fault!
    Reply to this comment
    by mh4cbs1 January 6, 2007 3:33 AM EST
    Dear CBS,

    Are you kidding or what with your idiotic: "Is U.S. Wasting Money On Iraq Contracts?" What's with the question mark?!

    Like, come out from under your rock, you so called news organization. DUH! The Haliburtons and so many other well-connnected corporations have sucked in BILLIONS of our taxpayer $$ in no bid, cost plus contracts. Are you STILL trying to act as Bush's War Cheerleaders? Thought you'd given it up.

    Did you forget to report that over 600 "contractors" have been killed in Iraq? These are folks working for the sleazy War Profiteering corporations, trying to get some quick pay for their kids college tuition.

    You corporate media cheerleaders are as much of the problem as our fascist leaders. Why to 1/2 of the Amercans still believe Cheney LIES that Saddam and Al Quaeda connections? CBS.
    Reply to this comment
    by j-whitman January 6, 2007 3:29 AM EST
    I hope everyone's waiting for Iraq War Profiteering Phase 2 on the abuses of the new contracts.
    Reply to this comment
    by j-whitman January 6, 2007 3:15 AM EST
    Just another reason for "Pay As You Go",,,, ACCOUNTABILITY
    Reply to this comment
    by defirststate January 6, 2007 2:55 AM EST
    It takes years to investigate and prosecute 20% of the offenders. Instead of building a 3 year case which will be reduced to a few counts, if any, why not just file charges on the criminal activity in an individual week or month. Build the case, file charges and go to the next period's crimes, and they are crimes. The billing error excuse doesn%u2019t cut it when the errors are continuous and always in their favor. These investigations would constitute a legitimate use of government resources. Protecting citizens from pickpocketing companies, instead of opening our mail because the font used for the address is threatening or the stamp affixed at the angle a terrorist would use makes too much sense.

    Could they just want to get all they can while no one is looking because of their real fear. Their real fear is that enough people will become sufficiently fed up with violations of our rights and officially condoned theft that we may unreasonably demand governmental responsibility. The administration thinks the idea that the old "constitution" thing is supposed to mean something after all this time is absurd, it wasn%u2019t even initialedsigned by K or W.
    Reply to this comment
    by spammenot995 January 6, 2007 1:54 AM EST
    Is U.S. Wasting Money On
    Iraq Contracts?

    Does a bear sh*t in the woods?
    Reply to this comment
    by grazinggoat January 6, 2007 1:03 AM EST
    Just can't believe it...
    What a SHAME. What a shame...

    Just to say it's never enough to remind people of the rightly earned money tax paid to the government is abusively spent like this. What about the billions (not to say trillions) of dollars abusively spent on armement, without any control at all, pretexting National Security reasons.

    This is the political Lynching of President Bush he was waiting for. There we go. It's just the beginning.
    Reply to this comment
    by bildooreilly January 6, 2007 12:52 AM EST
    These kinds of stories only come out on friday evenings, just like Bush closing the secret service visitors logs to hide their ties to Abramoff and probably more male prostitutes as well.. They only release these kinds of stories on Friday evenings, when people are less likely to see them.
    Reply to this comment
    by bildooreilly January 6, 2007 12:50 AM EST
    Hey but if you're a day late on your taxes it's your ***... in this free and democratic country of ours...
    Reply to this comment
    by bildooreilly January 6, 2007 12:48 AM EST
    sorry rafterman that was directed at arthur
    Reply to this comment
    by bildooreilly January 6, 2007 12:46 AM EST
    Rafterman, it would be great if the dems would actually do such a thing but why do you think they keep voting to fund this scheme? It's because they're most likely making $$$ off of it too.. simple as that.... Same with the illegal aliens, what companies do you think these politicians are invested in??? Pretty obvious.... I can bet they're holding some Tyson stock..
    Reply to this comment
    by bildooreilly January 6, 2007 12:44 AM EST
    Gee, I'm going to go set up some ping pong tables in iraq and charge the troops to play them by the game, then I'm going to put tv commercials all over the USA telling just how much I support the troops...
    Reply to this comment
    by arthurcl1 January 6, 2007 12:30 AM EST
    Why do you think the Republicans love War? The War Machine pays them Billions! Like V.P. Cheney and his company in Irag! The Dem's should have Full Investigations about this Republican Fiasco about Bush's Iraq Empire Megalamania!But recently, the Pentagon admitted it has a hard time accounting for how billions of your tax dollars is being spent %u2014 and the billions that may be lost to contractor waste, fraud and abuse,
    Reply to this comment
    by rafterman1 January 6, 2007 12:22 AM EST
    "Is U.S. Wasting Money On Iraq Contracts?"

    Remember when Norm MacDonald used to do WeekEnd Update on Saturday Night Live and he would follow up a story that was totally obvious with "...from the pages of "Duh" magazine"?

    Nice going CBS. What a "scoop".
    Reply to this comment
    by nothappyatall January 6, 2007 12:16 AM EST
    "Grayson has filed dozens of civil "whistleblower" lawsuits against contractors, and he says with no help from the government because of what describes as the administration's ties to major military contractors. "

    Gee no surprise there why BUSH wants to stay over there huh?
    Reply to this comment
    See all 21 Comments
  • Exclusive Webshow

    Michelle Obama tells how her role as the First Lady has changed her perspective. Watch Now

    Latest News
    News in Pictures
    Scroll Left Scroll Right
    • The Fall Of The Berlin Wall The Fall Of The Berlin Wall

      Looking Back at the Wall that Once Divided Germany On the 20th Anniversary of Its Collapse

    • Patricia Clarkson Patricia Clarkson

      Television and Film Actress, Yale School of Drama Graduate and Academy Award Nominee

    • Day in Pictures Day in Pictures

      A Glimpse at the Day's News as Seen Through a Camera Lens

    • Andre Agassi Andre Agassi

      Former Top-Seeded Tennis Star, Gossip Column Favorite and Philanthropist

    • Yankees Victory Parade Yankees Victory Parade

      The Yankees Celebrate Their 27th World Series Championship with a Ticker-Tape Parade Up Broadway

    • Orlando Office Shooting Orlando Office Shooting

      A Gunman Opens Fire at the Offices of an Engineering Firm Where He Once Worked

    Connect with CBS News

    Stay connected with the CBS News using your favorite social networks and online news applications: