Don't Fall Victim To Return Fraud

Thieves Know How To Return Stolen Items Or Use Counterfeit Receipts

(CBS)  Returning gifts after the holidays may be getting more difficult. Many stores have tightened their policies to combat growing rates of return fraud.

Return fraud will cost retailers more than $3 billion this holiday season, and they're not the only ones paying for this crime. Theresa Kiskiel saved for months to buy a brand-new iPod, but when she got home and opened the box she saw a box full of Uno cards.

"I got the most expensive Uno cards I've ever bought," she told The Early Show consumer correspondent Susan Koeppen.

Someone had switched the iPod with a deck of cards. Retail experts say Kiskiel may have been the victim of return fraud. In cases like Kiskiel's, crooks steal an expensive product, replace it with something cheap, and then return it for a full refund.

"In some cases they are petty thieves, but this has turned into an organized retail criminal enterprise," National Retail Federation Vice President of Loss Prevention, Joe LaRocca, said.

When Kiskiel tried to get her money back for the bogus iPod, the store said no because there was no way to prove that she didn't switch it.

LaRocca sees thousands of return fraud cases every year, and many are caught on tape. In one example, a woman tried to return an area rug at a department store. The clerk didn't realize that minutes earlier, security cameras caught her stealing the same rug right off the shelf. The woman disappeared as soon as she got her refund.

"These people are going from store to store, mall to mall, stealing merchandise thousands of dollars at a time, and then coming back and returning it to the store," LaRocca said. "They can make millions if they're very good at it."

To make the returns easier, some crooks are even using counterfeit receipts. Koeppen found they're readily available online for many high-end retailers and boutiques. Just pay a fee, and the site will send you a custom store receipt printed with your name and any item and price you want.

"Unfortunately, in some cases, those counterfeit receipts do work," LaRocca said. "We know that they're being used to return stolen merchandise to stores, which costs retailers billions of dollars every year."

Retailers aren't the only ones paying for this crime. Consumers now face tougher return policies and higher prices.

"You and I as consumers are paying a little extra at the register, almost a hidden crime tax, to cover those losses committed by people stealing merchandise and taking advantage of retail return policies," LaRocca said.

Kiskiel hopes her case can help others avoid becoming a victim.

"Open it up before you leave the store," she said. "Don't wait till you get home; open it, 'cause you never know what you're gonna get."

[dmorg4]

You know amost the same thing happened to me i bought a sony mp3 player took it home when i opened the box there was no player just software
and the case for the player i was in shock
i went right back to the store with it
and they gave me another they said they had
a problem with the security gaurds taking things
I made them open it before i left too
i advise any body if the pakaging looks damaged
make them open it before you leave i noticed when i bought the player i had the box had one corner that was damaged so they had disconted it because its hard to sell an item with a damaged box but the straps they had on the box were still intact so i didnt think anything of it but the thieves had pulled the player out though the corner that was damaged the open box buys are really suseptable to those tricks
buyer beware its really terrible that poor girl cant get her player i wish i knew which retailer it was so i could send them a bunch of mail about it and maybe she could get her player

[nothappyatall]

"When Kiskiel tried to get her money back for the bogus iPod, the store said no because there was no way to prove that she didn't switch it."

Yeah right, I'd say how do *I* know one of your employees didn't switch it- perfect opportunity, I'd file a lawsuit if I was this woman and force them to prove their claim that *I* might have switched the item, I'd supoena their security cam and all the rest.

[aislingc-2009]

It's about time this was brought to the public's attention. Ever since 1919, when Harry Gordon Selfridge coined the phrase "The customer is always right," customsers have been coming up with ways to cheat businesses.

Part of the problem is that they insist returned packages be "unopened." Maybe they should be open, so the employees can inspect them. Then they can re-seal them before returning them to the shelves.

[mitch0927]

I can understand totally that this is a major problem. But why would you make it worse by giving details on how these frauds are accomplished CBS? Some people out there would probably never do something like that, but since you have given instructions on how it is done, people are going to give it a try. Please think before submitting a story.