February 11, 2009 5:36 PM

Two Missing Climbers May Have Fallen

(CBS/AP)  Two climbers still missing on Mount Hood may have been swept to their deaths over a treacherous cliff by howling winds of more than 100 mph after they left their possibly injured companion behind in a snow cave to get help.

Sheriff Joe Wampler offered that scenario as rescuers went back up the mountain in helicopters Monday to retrieve the body of Kelly James from the snow cave and try again to find his two companions, who have been missing for a week.

But the sheriff spoke grimly about the chances the pair were still alive: "We failed them. We literally failed them. But we tried our best, I know that."

Wampler said climbing equipment found on the mountain — including two slings and two aluminum anchors driven into the snow — led rescuers to believe that James' companions, Brian Hall and Jerry "Nikko" Cooke, had tried to secure themselves to the steep slope. That was the last sign of the two.

Because of that, authorities were "narrowing the likelihood that there may have been an accident," the sheriff said.

The spot on the 11,239-foot mountain where the two men vanished is commonly known as "the gullies," with a 60-degree slope and a treacherous 2,500-foot drop-off. There have been 13 deaths recorded in the same area during the past 40 years.

James, a 48-year-old landscape architect from Dallas, made a cell phone call from the cave on Dec. 10, telling his family the party was in trouble.

Wampler said it appears the three climbers succeeded in reaching the summit from the difficult north side and started go down the easier south side. They apparently tried to pass through a rock-and-ice formation known as the Pearly Gates but did not find it.

They built a snow cave, possibly because of bad weather, the sheriff said. He said all three probably spent the night of Dec. 8 there. The next day, he said, two of the men probably left the cave to go in search of help for James, who may have been injured. Then the weather deteriorated even more.

The two had to dig another snow cave on a steep slope for themselves, not far from the first one, and apparently used snow anchors to secure themselves to the mountain as bad weather raged around them, the sheriff said.

"At some point they were standing there clipped into something, probably because it was so windy there. I mean this is a really steep, dangerous place on the mountain," Wampler said.

Two ice axes, a glove, some rope and a piece of sleeping mat were found along with the slings and snow anchors.

Now the search is focused on two adjacent glaciers — the Eliot and Newton — below the caves where the men last sought shelter and where they may have fallen, CBS News correspondent Jerry Bowen reports.

The climbers may have suffered through weather similar to conditions on Mount Everest, the world's highest peak, said Jim Whittaker, who in 1963 became the first American climber to reach the top of Everest.

"It can turn into an Everest when you get those high winds and snow," said Whittaker, speaking from his home in Port Townsend, Wash. "You get knocked over by the wind. Your goggles fog up. You can't even travel."

Most climbers attempt Mount Hood in May and June, when the weather is calmer. But Whittaker said he did not think it was reckless for the three men to climb Mount Hood during the winter.

"They were climbers that knew what they were doing. They were just pushing themselves to their farthest frontiers. That's when people are at their best," he said.

Frank James, brother of Kelly James, choked back tears when he said a ring found on his brother's body inside the snow cave had confirmed his identity.

"This is a difficult day for all three families," James said. "I feel that I have two other brothers still on the mountain," he said.

© 2009 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.
Add a Comment See all 90 Comments
by benulie December 19, 2006 5:12 AM EST
I have an idea. Require each climber to carry a GPS locator and radios or walkie-talkies. Whatever department is in charge could rent them or require a deposit. If someone gets injured, the climbers could call for help and rescuers would be able to locate them using the GPS. This isn't my original idea. It was brought up a few years back when some skiers or snowboarders were missing on Mt. Hood.

I feel this plan would increase the likelihood of the climbers being rescued and decrease the danger to the rescuers.

If James had a cell phone and was able to call his family last Saturday, why didn't he call 911? Or did he and I just don't know it?
Reply to this comment
by trueprogress December 19, 2006 4:43 AM EST

People are people.
Reply to this comment
by katherineale December 19, 2006 3:06 AM EST
TO; KELLY JAMES FAMILY; YOU ARE ALL IN OUR THOUGHTS AND PRAYERS; REMEMBER HE LOVED HIS FAMILY, HE LOVED LIFE, AND HE LOVED GOD, THAT IS WHY HE FELT SO CLOSE TO GOD, UP ON A MOUNTAIN; WE ARE ALL GRIEVEING ALONG WITH YOU, AND WE ARE PRAYING FOR ALL OF YOU; WE ARE PRAYING FOR THE SAFE RETURN OF; JERRY COOKE AND BRIAN HALL; GOD'S MIRACLES HAPPEN EVERYDAY, SO WE HAVE TO KEEP THE FAITH AND BE STRONG, AND PRAY, FOR THEM AND PRAY FOR THE FAMILIES IN THIS MOST HEARTBREAKING AND DIFFICULT TIME; TO THE HONORABLE HOOD RIVER COUNTY SHERIFF JOE WAMPLER; YOU DID EVERYTHING YOU COULD, ALONG WITH ALL THE RESCUERS, YOU DID NOT FAIL THEM, I KNOW IT IS DIFFICULT WITH THE OUTCOME IS TRAGIC, BUT YOU SIR, ALONG WITH ALL THE BRAVE PEOPLE WHO WENT UP THERE ON THAT MOUNTAIN, OR HELPED IN ANYWAY YOU COULD, AND THE PRAYERS, AND SLEEPLESS NIGHTS THAT SO MANY OF YOU WENT THROUGH, I DO NOT KNOW WHY, ONLY GOD HAS THOSE ANSWERS, BUT YOU ARE A WONDERFUL SHERIFF, AND ALL THE CREW WHO WENT UP, AND IS STILL WORKING TOO GET BRIAN HALL, AND JERRY COOKE HOME SAFELY WE THANK YOU, AMERICA IS PRAYING, AND OUR HEARTS ARE BREAKING TOO, OUR THOUGHTS AND PRAYERS ARE WITH ALL OF THE FAMILIES, AND WITH YOU, AND THE PEOPLE WHO ARE ALL WORKING SO HARD; GOD BLESS; KELLY JAMES, AND HIS FAMILY AND FRIENDS, YOU ARE ALL IN OUR THOUGHTS AND PRAYERS; GOD BLESS THE FAMILIES OF; BRIAN HALL, AND JERRY COOKE, AND GOD BLESS BRIAN HALL AND JERRY COOKE; OUR THOUGHTS AND PRAYERS ARE WITH ALL OF YOU; TODAY, AND ALWAYS; KATHERINE- LOUISIANA
Reply to this comment
by rosegrey1 December 19, 2006 2:45 AM EST
It is so sad that three lives were lost doing what they loved to do. They made it to the top and how good that must have felt to them. Let's not loose that fact in the sad ending. And I do not agree with the Sheriff, you did not fail them, you gave your all, you all are HEROES and I applaud all of you. My thoughts and sympathies go to the families in this most difficult of times.
Reply to this comment
by lifeprecious December 19, 2006 12:34 AM EST
Life is precious.........sometimes its not what we have done......but what we do about it....other lives are saved, lessons learned by those that live their life with the passion of what they love, just as our Australia crocodile friend....we may not understand why people choose to be around danger, however if that brings their life satisfaction, freedom and fulfillment, I applaud their courage to seek and live their DREAMS.......What in our lives have we NOT done because of fear?....

Thoughts and Prayers...........

Life is precious
Reply to this comment
by lifeprecious December 19, 2006 12:28 AM EST
Life is precious.........sometimes its not what we have done......but what we do about it....other lives are saved, lessons learned by those that live their life with the passion of what they love, just as our Austraila crocidile friend....we may not understand why people choose to be around danger, however if that brings their life satisfaction, freedom and fullfillment, I applaude their courage to seek and live their DREAMS.......What in our lives have we NOT done because of fear?....

Thoughts and Prayers...........

Life is precious
Reply to this comment
by falconidae December 19, 2006 12:22 AM EST

There is nothing bitter, critical or negative in simply making a judgment about the climbers' responsibility for this disaster. Judgment is simply the exercise of good sense.

No one on this forum suspends judgment when her doctor makes a bad diagnosis or when Bush invades Iraq. When I hear about three men in mortal danger after attempting to climb an 11,000 ft peak in December I don't check my brains at the door. It would be not only disingenuous but irresponsible to do so.

I see this incident as representative of larger problems, which other posters have mentioned. First, it seems now that we live in a culture devoted to recreation, in which personal fulfillment is the highest value: a form of narcissism. We value experience and above all sensation more than personal relationships. Secondly, we don't demand accountability for people's actions.

In many cases the community has a responsibility to step in when disaster strikes an individual. Individuals are ALSO accountable to the community. That means exercising discretion and not taking wanton risks that could burden families and the larger community unnecessarily.

The situation is very sad, and I'm sure everone hopes the best for the men and their families. At the same time, it is important that we learn from their experience, so that we can avoid similar disasters in our own lives and protect the interests of the community.
Reply to this comment
by kwlambi December 19, 2006 12:19 AM EST
I cannot find anything thrilling about walking up a mountain. So on any story to get us off the immediate goings on outside the green zone, we get caught up in 3 idiots trek up a mountain. terrific
Reply to this comment
by mikys-2009 December 19, 2006 12:14 AM EST
May I kindly ask where good will toward our brothers have gone?

Why do we believe that everybody has to share our own opinions? And why are those opinions so over the top? There are those of you out there who write/speak like you were in some Hollywood Uber Movie.

Can we just take this all down a notch?

There are families out there in deep pain and all some of you can do is describe them in terrible terms. Did you actually know these men? Do you actually think that they wanted this to happen?

Even if you do think they go what they deserved, don't you think that you could express your opinions with some compassion?

I hope you remember that the reasons that this country is so great is because people are not afraid to follow their passions, whatever they may be.
Reply to this comment
by ronmendel December 18, 2006 11:58 PM EST
? It should be illegal to conduct a search for these "thrill seekers". Their fun is climbing mountains in December and they alone must suffer the consequences. Forgetting the immense expense of conducting the rescue, imagine how their wives will feel if and when any rescuers are killed or injured in attempting to locate their "thoughtful, loving" husbands. Winter climbers should be required to sign disclaimer statements at the trailheads, waving any expectation of rescue.

Certainly, no one else should risk their lives or property attempting to rescue those whose very sport is tempting death.

It is interesting to see how many bloggers are too ignorant to understand the difference between rescuing a stranded family and these sportsmen...
Reply to this comment
See all 90 Comments
.
Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook