NYC Marchers Protest Police Shooting

Fifth Avenue Shopping District Is Site Of Demonstratrion Against Murder Of Unarmed Man Three Weeks Ago

(AP)  Thousands of protesters, counting in unison from one to 50 to mark the number of shots fired by police in the death of an unarmed Queens man last month, clogged Fifth Avenue on Saturday in a "Shopping for Justice" protest three weeks after the slaying and one week before the Christmas weekend.

Trent Benefield, 23, one of the survivors of the Nov. 25 shooting that killed Sean Bell, led the marchers from his wheelchair as they headed south through midtown Manhattan. He was encircled by bodyguards, and followed by a group of clergy and elected officials on one of the busiest shopping days of the year just nine days before Christmas.

"This is not just a New York City problem," said U.S. Rep. Charles Rangel, who was near the front of the march. "This march gives people a chance to speak out."

Bell's fiancee, Nicole Paultre, was also among the marchers, as were U.S. Rep. Anthony Weiner, city transit union president Roger Toussaint and human rights activist Bianca Jagger. The marchers started at 59th Street and finished their protest more than an hour later outside Macy's on 34th Street.

The demonstration expressed the protesters' outrage at the slaying of Bell, killed in Queens just hours before his scheduled wedding. Five officers fired 50 shots at the 23-year-old Bell's car, killing him and wounding Benefield and another companion outside a strip club.

"It's important that the police understand that they're here to protect the people," said Larry Dais, a Columbia University administrator and father of a 21-year-old son.

Among those marching was James Canley, whose 25-year-old son Adrian was shot and killed last month by a sheriff's department detective in Thousand Oaks, Calif. He compared his son's death with the Bell shooting.

"11-14-06, Ventura County," read a sign held by Canley — the date of his son's slaying.

Other demonstrators waved signs and chanted as they marched. "Stop NYPD Racist Terror," read one sign. "Jail the Cops," said another.

The victims of the shooting were all black; the officers were white, Hispanic and black.

The march was organized by the Rev. Al Sharpton and other community leaders, and was intended to contrast the slaying of Bell with the holiday spending spree along Manhattan's most famous shopping district. It was the latest in a series of demonstrations since the Bell shooting.

But not everyone was behind Sharpton's cause. Steven Pagones, a former prosecutor who won a $345,000 defamation case against Sharpton and two other men in 1998, showed up at the march to remind people of the civil rights activist's inaccurate charges against him in the Tawana Brawley case.

Sharpton made the unsubstantiated allegation that Pagones was one of a group of white men who abducted and raped Brawley.

"Al Sharpton is capable of making outrageous and reckless charges," Pagones said. "I know, because I was on the receiving end in the Tawana Brawley case, which we know is a hoax. Al Sharpton is an opportunist. My primary purpose is to remind people to be careful when they listen to Al Sharpton."

Police have said that undercover officers were conducting a vice operation at the strip club before the shooting, and they believed the victims were going to retrieve a gun — although no weapons were found. Police have also said Bell's car struck an officer and crashed into an unmarked police van.

But Sharpton and others say police used excessive force.

[ceres5]

It is good to see that many people in NY will not remain silent in demanding justice for the brutal shooting of the three unarmed men. Why after 20 days, the NYPD has not provided any additional information about this incident? Does it have a cover up in mind? Are the four poor Rambo detectives involved in the shooting still suffering from hypertension? Please do not allow Machine Gun Joe, the guy that fired 31 times, to get close to any automatic weapon, or all the people in New York will be in serious danger during this Christmas holiday.

[feelfree1]

Abusive police officers pose a far greater threat to society than any other criminals do. At least we have the right to defend ourselves against other types of criminals.

It is not surprising that our police officers kill so many innocent people. They are mired in overreaction, with many officers thinking that it is OK to attack even unarmed peaceful demonstrators.

I feel sorry for the honest and professional police officers that have to work with these clowns.

I've said this once before and I will say it again:

Al Sharpton is EVIL

First: I am a black woman
Second: Al Sharpton only shows up when there's a martyr
Third: Please read Juan Williams Book: Enough

This book will help you understand that black leaders are making money off of the black poor.

Yes: those cops were wrong. They should not have done what they did. Also: Black on black crime in inner-city black communities is rampant and black leaders should be focusing on the this: many more black people die every year as a result of black on black crime than to white racist police

[cantshutup]

I think those cops should be tested for drugs...what they did seems like something someone high on crack or meth might do...

[olgreyghost]

FeelFree1:

We do have the right to defend ourselves from abusive law enforcement officials. It's just harder to prove self-defense in court when dealing with police. So do what the police do to cover their collective posteriors - carry a camera. It has saved lives, careers, and liberties. Just check your local penal code for the specifics of what constitutes force one can use to protect oneself and what is force to resist a police officer when he is performing his lawful duty.

[feelfree1]

OlGreyGhost,

Good advice!

Thanks for your comment.

[olgreyghost]

"(M)any more black people die every year as a result of black on black crime than to white racist police." - amerigirl28

True courage, indeed...

olgrayghost,


Thank you. It's not something I say to gloat about. We (blacks and whites) need to solve this problem. I just think black leaders can do more than any white person but instead they wait for someone to die and blame racist whites. I know racism has not been abated. The point is however that black people are causing much of their own suffering and we must stop. we need Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson and all the other black leaders to lead.

Much love everyone and good night!!

[olgreyghost]

amerigirl28:

If I, a retired White police officer, had said what you did, regardless of the source of such information being as objective as the NIJ/FBI, I would have been declared a racist. Thank YOU for pointing it out. I have always considered it incumbent upon any people - the different races, recovering substance abusers, former convicts, etc. - to improve themselves from within as outside help can sometimes become more "chains" of oppression. Hopefully, one day we can all reach a solution to our problems without turning the dry land into a sea of glass.

Because of my training and experience, I can see this incident as a terrible "tragedy of errors" with mistakes made by both parties and one party certainly suffering the worst of it. The best hope is that the investigation will discover what went wrong where and what procedures and policies that can be implemented in the future to prevent it from ever happening again.

[vancouverboo]

Had this happened in LA there would have been street riots, arson, looting and random killings of europeana. How nice that the negroes in NYC are so much more civilized that they resort to legal protests, marches and pickets. Bravo, NYC.

[sparkeee35]

I agree with Amerigirl28....Al Sharpton IS evil...he's an oppurtunist...as well as Jessie Jackson. The ONLY time you ever see these 2 in the news...is when something like this happens. BOTH of these 2 guys are full-blown RACISTS. According to these 2 guys...everything that is wrong with the "black" community...is because of the "white folks". But...there are more killings among the "black" communities...amongest themselves...than blacks & whites combined. They are killing their own people...but let something like this happen...and it all falls back to racism...and blamed for everything they CAN'T overcome. People like Al Sharpton...& Jessie Jackson...are the BIGGEST racist & always trying to point fingers at "white folks". They are the ones who live & breathe racism...they are the ones who keeps the differences of races alive..by talkin...and I"m not gonna say "preachin"...cause they aren't ministers...they are public menances to their own society. Neither one of them can say they live a "christian" life...yet they call themselves "Reverand"....let them stay in NY...but know...they don't give a *** about those people...just the publicity they get from this.

[sparkeee35]

You know...I'm really surprized that Al Sharpton & Jessie Jackson have lived as long as they have. They are the BIGGEST racist alive. I notice that they don't come to the South and talk that ***...or at least not without all their paid bodyguards. Keeping the racism issue alive...is what they do best. They aren't out to help "their people"...they are out to help themselves...ONLY!! But let "white folks" say some of the racial remarks these 2 guys make...and the NAACP will be all over it. Why aren't they in New Orleans helping "their people"? They don't want to be associated with that kind of publicity...because they really don't care about those people. Reckon why that is? These guys thrive on Turmoil...strife...dissension...not peace...not understanding. They don't want the MANY different races to get along. Cause then...what else would they spout off about? Yet they are the first one to say something about "white folks" and wonder why the "Klan" is still alive. They sicken me with their ability to draw attention to themselves...yet we have guys fightin a war for their sorry butts...how come they aren't over there? O I forgot...their fighting their own war in NYC. WHATEVER !!!!

[kailumego1]

Just like their white counterparts, who viciously beat and murdered Yosef Hawkins, drugged a black man to his death decapitating him, and firing hundreds of rounds of ammunition into Emmett Till, and the countless other vicious acts of brutally, these individuals have become a %u201Cmirror%u201D image of those who sought to annihilate Native Americans, enslave Africans, and brutally murder post-Emancipation blacks.


Because, although, Al Sharpton and Jessie Jackson may be opportunist riding on the heels of black misery, its individuals like yourself, with your bigotry and denial that has enabled them to %u201Cjump on the racist bandwagon%u201D, in which individuals like yourselves are no better than them.

You are just as much of the problem as they are, in which individuals like yourselves, including those blacks that continue to darken black communities with their degradationious filth, the drug dealing, random drive-by shootings, murderous rampage, social apathy, and self-abasement, need repent and cleanse your own moral decadence, before pointing the finger at on another.

[kailumego1]

They continue to %u201Charp%u201D on the despicableness of whites, while purposefully overlooking the contemptibleness within black communities, such as random and wanton acts of violence committed by blacks on blacks. However, blacks, like whites, are equally in denial, and have conveniently chosen circumventing this degradation placing it on white Americans shoulders.

Certainly, %u201Cblack on black%u201D crime has become a major epidemic, in which most prominent black leaders like Sharpton and Jackson have failed to adequately address. As I don%u2019t agree with what the police officers did, I can fully understand their plight, their fear, you have young black thugs, whom pride themselves on wantonly shooting and killing unarm citizens and police officers, in which they have no remorse. They would just as sure shoot a black person as a white, and it doesn%u2019t matter, they have become so redden with apathy and self-hatred, like those of their white counterparts, until it becomes a %u201Cright of passive%u201D to murder.

[kailumego1]

The trouble here, with most whites and blacks, %u201Cconvenient denial%u201D and %u201Clet%u2019s shift the blame%u201D, all blacks and whites should watch the movie %u201CIn My Country%u201D, an excellent true story about post-apartheid South Africa, during the crimes against humanities trial of former Afrikaans governmental officials, police officers, and ordinary citizens, this inhumanity touched the lives of all South African citizens, not just blacks but whites. It was a testimony how greed, self-hatred, and social apathy can transmogrify human compassion into the most grotesquely, vile degradation imaginable.

It spewed the excrements of bigotry and racism in its most hideous detriment, the mutilation of men [castration and burning of their genitals], women and young girls viciously and savagely violated with wooden and metal objects inserted into their womanhood. It demonstrated how narrow-minded despicable individuals, like yourselves can allow such irreprehensible wickedness to continue, through omission, and then spew sinister wickedness from your mouths.


I agree with Amerigirl28, which both of you have failed miserably to comprehend, blacks, like Al Sharpton and Jessie Jackson, etc. have misdirected themselves by continuingly attacking white America, which doesn%u2019t negate the fact, racism is alive and thriving in White America, by which you are both a testament of that.

[kailumego1]

Humancitizen: %u201CBlacks - YOU want to improve relations?? OK, quit looting and burning and raping and killing everything and everyone in sight any time a black person is touched, arrested, or shot%u201D

Sparkeee35: %u201CYou know...I'm really surprised that Al Sharpton & Jessie Jackson have lived as long as they have. They are the BIGGEST racists alive. I notice that they don't come to the South and talk that ***...or at least not without all their paid bodyguards%u201D.

[sparkeee35]

For the gentleman who has called me a racist...let me get this straight...I am NOT a racist or a bigot...or living in self denial.I treat people the same...I have grown up in the South...watchin & hearin the "racism bandwagon"...all my life...whether it be the KKK or the Black Panthers...they are BOTH wrong. God created us all equal...and there are a lot of people who vehenemtly deny that fact. I'm not responsible for all the many hateful things that white & black people have done...IN THE PAST. That is history...that can never be changed. I don't point fingers at people who TRY to make a better life for themselves...whatever nationality OR race they are. More power to them. There are white people who are just as wrong...raisin their kids to be racist...I'm not one of them. I grew up in a town where racism was very much alive. My father taught us to NOT look at people that way. Most people are judged by the color of their skin...no matter where you live. White or black. You have voiced YOUR opinion...being just like the rest of us...but you decided to point fingers...my answer to your "opinion" is...everyone has one..glad you were able to get all of that off your chest. You are just as bad as you say I am.

[kailumego1]

Sparkeee35, you are as RACIST as they come, " They are the BIGGEST racists alive. I notice that they don't come to the South and talk that ***...or at least not without all their paid bodyguards%u201D. And you think this isn't a RACIST statement, what planet have you come from. Some of the biggest racists are those that flagrantly deny on the one hand, while making insidious remarks about those whom they profess not to be prejudical.

Individuals like you are so typical, you scream the loudest when the shoe is on the other foot, blacks killing blacks, but speak silently in the mist of your own degradation, whites killing, raping, and lynching blacks.

And you being on the defensive is a dead give away, unfortunately, I wish I had been wrong, because maybe it would demonstrate a ray of hope.

But, individuals like you, with your closet undercover racism, is the most deadly and lethal from of inhumanity.

And since you so vehemently protest, then the next time the KKK marches through your neighborhood, I'll be looking for you to protest them.

[kailumego1]

And comparing the "Black Panthers" to the KKK how ludicrous or ridiculous, this is also a demonstration of RACISM. The KKK a murderous vigilante group that viciously attacked unsuspecting blacks for no apparent reason, other than, they%u2019re black, lynching, burning, castrating, etc., with the full support of law enforcement on their side, in contrast to the Black Panthers a vigilante group spawn out of Marxist Revolutionary ideology whose aim was to combat the wanton gratuitous violence against blacks.

So, pray tell, how in the world can the KKK be compared to the Black Panthers, to polar opposites, the KKK murderous thugs and the Black Panthers, revolutionaries combating a greater EVIL of violence perpetrated against blacks.
That%u2019s how I know you%u2019re in denial, you can%u2019t even reason or differentiate between the two groups without imposing your own subjective racism.

Kailumego1

I"m not so sure about the black panthers, but there are many black organizations that teach racial intolerance. They teach that white people are the devil and we are the rightful, righteous owners of the earth, once we take white people off of their pedestal: sounds like the black version of the KKK to me.

Anytime you look at a person's skin color to determine their worth, your organization is racist.

[sparkeee35]

kailumego...you know what? You're absolutely right...every bit of trash you just spouted off to me...without even knowing me...is so far off of the truth radar. But since you THINK you know me & my type...you just go ahead & keep spouting YOUR "intelligent" opinios to everyone. I have heard Blacks & whites BOTH talk their racial b.s. all my life...I have seen both men come to the South...spoutin off their racial b.s. Sure racism is alive today...just as well as it was alive YEARS ago...but the difference today is...kids are being taught...by racist parents...BOTH black & white...that its ok to be a racist. But anyway...whatever...you think you have all the answers...you're just as bad as you say I am...judging & pointing fingers...but if it makes you feel better to call me a racist...knock yourself out...your opinion doesn't matter to me.

[maikkun]

I was there by the library on Saturday along 5th. and I got to watch the march in it's entirety. what struck me as being not too good was that Al had intended for the march to be silent, and it was for a good deal of time. then the crowd got louder and more vociferous and radical. they started shouting "NYPD go to hell," and they had signs that read "Ku Klux Kops," not only are they protesting stereotyping, but they themselves were doing it to the police. if the march had remained silent then the message would have gone through loud and clear, but since the radicals had to muck up the silence with chanting then that downplayed the message. and that is sad. cuz they had a good message to start out with.

[sparkeee35]

Hey everybody on here giving your opinion...kailumego is the ONLY one who is right...no matter what you may say. Notice all the posts he's had lamblasting anyone who dares to have a opinion. Even if you were there or not...he's right...everyone else is wrong. We're all racist except for him. We're all living in denial...and all the other b.s. he spouted off about. This issue is a old issue...it didn't just start today...we have way more important things in our country to worry about...and so do I...so adious to all this SELF RIGHTEOUS B.S.

[olgreyghost]

Let me throw in an interesting twist to inter-racial crime if I may. Most crime is intra-racial (within a race; i.e. White-on-White, Black-on-Black), but there has been an alarming increase in a particular inter-racial crime. White-on-Black is on the decrease but Black-on-White is on the rise and has surpassed White-on-Black (out of ratio to their respective proportions of the U.S. population) and is quickly approaching the amount of Black-on-Black crime. Could this possibly be the result of the blame-game against the White race or is there some other factor influencing this aspect of crime?

Hispanics cannot, due to government definition, commit inter-racial crimes. If they are the perpetrator, they are defined White. If they are the victim, they are defined Hispanic. Hopefully government statisticians will one day correct this error.

Olgreyghost

I like your style! that whole hispanic thing is so true.

sparkeee35 said " Hey everybody on here giving your opinion...kailumego is the ONLY one who is right...no matter what you may say. Notice all the posts he's had lamblasting anyone who dares to have a opinion."

I would like to think he's just exposing cracks in your opinion. But, it is very easy on these boards to become grounded in your argurment, not see the other person's side, abate apologies and genereally become indignant.

I don't know if Kail is really doing that or not, he has not attacked me for the comments I have said. attacking isn't conversing.

[olgreyghost]

Amerigirl28:

Thank you ma'am and I like your style, too. Keep up the good work, we just might win this thing. God bless and keep y'all safe...