February 11, 2009 5:42 PM

Charity As An Investment Goes A Long Way

By
Melissa McNamara
(CBS)  Rex and Deborah Amini are getting advice about making a charitable gift. Deborah, a San Antonio real estate agent and Rex, the CEO of an oil production company, have the heart and means to help, CBS News correspondent Anthony Mason reports.

But they didn't want to just write a check.

"I want to see the numbers. I want things to make sense. I want them to be sustainable," Rex says.

They are part of a growing trend in philanthropy — people who view their donations not only as gifts, but as investments.

In Rwanda, an impoverished African country where most people make less than $2 a day, the Aminis helped a group of women expand a soap-making factory. But first, they made sure the money would be put to good use.

"We had no earthly idea how much things should cost," Rex says. "How are we going to demand accountability? And Geneva Global provides all that."

Geneva Global is a for-profit company that offers independent philanthropy advice.

"Investment advisors for international philanthropy is not our tagline, but it's actually a good description of what we are," says Steve Beck, CEO of Geneva Global.

Their average donor gives hundreds of thousands of dollars. For about a 15 percent fee on top of that, Geneva Global helps find worthy charities and then provides clients like the Aminis detailed analysis of them.

"And then we track the results along the way, much the way people track their investments," Beck says.

That includes telling them when their investment is a bust, which happens in nearly 20 percent of the cases. It's called "performance-based" philanthropy.

"I think these women are very invested in growing this project," Deborah says of the women at the Rwandan soap factory. She adds that she's "absolutely" willing to be invested.

Because of the Aminis' contribution, the women at the Rwandan soap factory have been able to increase their production 50 percent in the past year and hire more workers.

And seeing those results have made the Aminis even more generous. Their latest gift: a new school. Their charitable investments may not have brought them a financial profit, but the Aminis are seeing much deeper rewards.

Copyright 2009 CBS. All rights reserved.
Add a Comment
by auhna November 25, 2006 1:55 PM EST
What a wonderful story. Katie, Theater Concepts, Inc. in Mexia, Texas is struggling to bring sultural activities to a small community. We provide opportunities to interested individuals to live a dream of performing on stage. We last presented a play re: unplanned pregnancies and STD's.More than two hundred people showed up. We do this with very little and no money. We are looking for an angel. Please visit our site: www.theaterconceptsinc.homestead.net and see out trace record. All plays presented by us are original. We have a musical we desperately need help to present. From choreographers to musicians.
Reply to this comment
by mamc4 November 23, 2006 2:25 PM EST
Thanks so much for the great story on what individuals are doing to make a difference in the world. It is so uplifting to see people recognized for their contribution to help others.

My organization, Children of Grace, works with 500 AIDS orphans in Uganda. We provide school fees, medical care and HIV/AIDS education as well as work on projects to enhance the school learning environment.

On this Thanksgiving day I am very thankful for all the wonderful, faithful donors that provide support for our orphaned children. Together, we are changing the world, one child at a time. .

Mary Ann McCoy
Children of Grace
www.children-of-grace.org
mamccy@yahoo.com
Reply to this comment
by snowbrd7 November 23, 2006 1:57 AM EST
Great story, CBS. Very uplifting and informative. A great idea for charitable giving.
Reply to this comment
by jmooibroek November 23, 2006 12:37 AM EST
Your report is very good, and I note a different "slant" over against NBC, that is "more" uplifting and focus on the positive, not "how bad george Bush and the war might be portrayed". Your segment tonight was very short but sufficient on Baghdad.

My comment is specific toward "hands on' giving and demanding results. When I graduated from seminary in 2002, I was led to the same direction by God, and so established Shiloah Ministries Inc. Our website will tell a lot more http://mooibroek.home.mindspring.com

Katie in just a short four years, we have been funded to build a church, a home for a widow, and now a Christian Day School for children who on the average can only give 25% of the cost of education - and we have 400 of them with a quarter being orphans. Please contact me and I would love to have you come. I am leaving for Uganda on Friday for three weeks to bring gifts equipment for the school and install a new President (Ugandan)

God bless you and have a great Thanksgiving with the CBS staff.

Rev Dr Joseph Mooibroek
Shiloah Ministries INC
509 Riviera Drive
McKinney, Texas 75070
501 (C)(3) corporation
469-952-2332
Reply to this comment
by god010 November 23, 2006 12:27 AM EST
You stated that Americans are very generous when it comes to charity...on average they only give 2.3% of their income to charity. This country is only 5% of the total world population but uses 28% of the world resources each year. Considering the pandemic of fat/obese people in this country versus the fact that 50% of the worlds population lives on less than $2.00 per day, do you think Americans are really very generous when it comes to charity? On average, the top 1% of people in America make 200X what the average wage earner makes; since you are in the top 1% you are far divorced from the reality of this country and the world. It must be nice to be insulated and live in a priviledged ivory tower like a fairy princess and not have to live in the reality of this world that most humans have to contend with daily in order to just exist.
Reply to this comment
by daeron7 November 22, 2006 11:16 PM EST
The most effective help often costs the least. For example the US government could STOP funding the TNI military who in turn fund and train Laskar Jihad, Barisan Merah Putih, Jemaah Islamiah; and other al Qaeda related networks.

It would cost nothing to stop the genocide of West Papua and the US funded racial cleansing of our WW-ii Melanesian Allies.

West Papua Information Kit http://fandom.net
Reply to this comment
.
Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
CBS News on Facebook