Nov. 26, 2006

'Bluejay' Spreads His Wings

How A Young Musical Genius Scored A Major Recording Deal

  • Play CBS Video Video Musical Prodigy, Bluejay

    Scott Pelly revisits Jay Greenberg, a symphony writing teen musical prodigy, who some say is the greatest musical genius to come along in 200 years.

    • Jay Greenberg, watching as the London Symphony Orchestra is recording his fifth symphony.

      Jay Greenberg, watching as the London Symphony Orchestra is recording his fifth symphony.  (CBS)

    • Jay Greenberg, then age 12, received an ovation after the New Haven Symphony in Connecticut performed his piece,

      Jay Greenberg, then age 12, received an ovation after the New Haven Symphony in Connecticut performed his piece, "The Storm."  (CBS)

    Previous slide Next slide
(CBS) 
When Pelley caught up with Jay nearly two years later at the Abbey Road Studios in London, his fifth symphony was in the hands of the London Symphony Orchestra, recording for Sony BMG.

In the studio where the Beatles recorded and the "Star Wars" films were scored, Jay heard his symphony for the first time.

Asked where he was when he first started writing his fifth symphony, Jay says, "I was in room 301 of my school staring absently at a map across — on the opposite wall — bored to distraction."

The class was history. "But don’t tell my teacher, OK,” Jay says, laughing.

"That first day, I wrote about 23 bars of the first movement during that class and then, probably about 60 or 70 bars altogether," he recalls.

The finished work runs 190 pages and 1,328 bars. Jay's role at the studio is to make sure all the notes play just as he's imagined.

Every year or two, a brilliant child pianist or genius violin player emerges. Asked where Jay ranks, Zyman says "To be a prodigy composer is far rarer. You have to conquer these issues. How do you notate this rhythm? What's the range of the oboe? Can this be played on the piano? How do you compose for the harp? There are hundreds of thousands of bits of information that you need to master to be able to write a piece of music."

Music is not the only sound Jay is listening to inside his head. He's interested in just about everything — and, for now, he sees music almost as a hobby not necessarily his destiny.

"For example, one thing — I might study physics or psychology or as I mentioned, the computer science or cartography or a lot of other things," Jay explains.

Pelley says Jay's mind makes him the most mystifying interview he has ever done. As he talks, you can see in his eyes that he's thinking about or listening to a dozen other channels.

Asked what would make him happy, Jay says, "That's a good question. Who can really define happiness?"

For Jay, happiness seems to flow from keeping his mind challenged.

Many accomplished composers spend a lifetime writing no more than five symphonies. Jay wrote his fifth at age 13. It’s impossible to know where his mind will take him — and us — but, the 60 Minutes team noticed that at the end of the recording session he was getting bored. As the orchestra played the last bars of this work, Jay pulled out his paper and started writing another.

Produced By Catherine Herrick
©MMVI, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Recent Segments
Scroll Left Scroll Right
Add a Comment See all 29 Comments
by passagesboy November 30, 2006 6:19 PM EST
[regarding my previous post] Okay, I found some soundbytes on Amazon.com and already can hear one outstanding influence, Bartok. Or maybe just an outstanding coincidence, since Bartok really has influenced a great deal of modern orchestral and chamber music which is exposed to the mainstream through movie soundtracks etc.
Reply to this comment
by passagesboy November 30, 2006 5:25 PM EST
One thing was not covered here which really surprised me, it's pretty elementary. What music does, or did, he like to listen to? Part of the whole picture of this story is definitely ehat he likes. For instance, is his music all tonal or mixed with atonality, etc? I was hoping to find an archive of the first piece 60 minutes did on him to possibly get the answer but can't locate it.
Reply to this comment
by patrickde2 November 28, 2006 8:48 AM EST
I was curious as to why in your report about the young composer, you failed to mention that Mozart had the same ability to compose in his head, write down the music, and never make any changes. I feel that you should have pointed this out to highlight this young man's talent. Thank you.
Reply to this comment
by hudson4me November 28, 2006 8:16 AM EST
I too heard whole symphonies in my head when I was young. BlueJay's compositions sound hauntingly familiar. Each instruments' range is aurally displayed by listening to recorded music. When I announced my intention to write a symphony, I received no support from family and teachers. I was told that it was presumptuous to think that I could. All blessings on Jay! I joyfully await his take on Physics.
Reply to this comment
by hudson4me November 28, 2006 8:16 AM EST
I too heard whole symphonies in my head when I was young. BlueJay's compositions sound hauntingly familiar. Each instruments' range is aurally displayed by listening to recorded music. When I announced my intention to write a symphony, I received no support from family and teachers. I was told that it was presumptuous to think that I could. All blessings on Jay! I joyfully await his take on Physics.
Reply to this comment
by derelictable November 28, 2006 3:38 AM EST
I found it obnoxious that, according to this story, musical genius of this sort is only of the classical kind. Somebody, for the love of God, introduce this kid to Jimi Hendrix, Miles Davis and Kurt Cobain... please! I'm seriously tired of 60 minutes, which of I've been watching since I was a kid, doing segments on this "wunderkids" that play classical music. Ever heard of an electric guitar?

p.s. Get rid of Andy Rooney, he's an embarrasment to your show.
Reply to this comment
by jazzguy4 November 28, 2006 12:11 AM EST
What a pleasure this story was. Blue Jay reminds me of the character Matt Damen played in the movie "Good Will Hunting" where "Will" was the janitor but was so naturally gifted in math that he could solve problems that neither the students or professors could solve. Sam Alder reminds me of the math professor in the movie who had great stature in academia but lacked the natural gift that "Will" had. In the movie, the professor was so jealous of "Will's" talent that he tried to hold him back to the same limitations the professor was born with. Sam Alder should not deal his own lack of genius by trying to place restraints on Blue Jay who is a true timeless musical genius.
Reply to this comment
by harmaton November 27, 2006 11:59 PM EST
As much of a smart person he is... give him time. Mozart wasn't claimed to be a genius until way after he died. I have a really hard time believing him in his interview. He may be a musical genius but he has a TON of growing up to do.

see you in ten years... and I bet he isn't doing music.
Reply to this comment
by buzzfrum November 27, 2006 11:22 PM EST
Jay's only CD was released this August by Sony Music #81804. It features his Symphony #5 and his Quintet for Strings played by the Julliard String Quartet. I found it available at Arkivmusic.com Search his name under Composers.
Reply to this comment
by aralion November 27, 2006 9:19 PM EST
Thank God the meds we have today were not available during Mozart's time or we might never have heard the beautiful music which he created. To try to stifle the genuis of someone like Blue Jay is a misguided attempt by some "knowlegeable" people to control that which they don't understand. How many other "geniuses" do we have in our world right now who are in a drug induced haze because they are misunderstood. We will probably never know.

I, too, would like to know where I can purchase Blue Jay's compositions. The small sample I heard on television last night brought tears to my eyes. It was simply beautiful. I imagine that is the type of music that is played in Heaven.
Reply to this comment
by namedujour November 27, 2006 7:50 PM EST
Actually, in rereading my earlier posting, it came off as disrespectful of Jay, or seemed to trivialize his talent. It isn't at all. It's more of a thoughtful analysis of what he does, and a theory about what is happening to him during the creative process. It's merely pointing out what he said himself, that he does not consciously select the notes he writes: He HEARS them and relays them to us. He changes nothing. He simply gives us what he receives, and can write entire symphonies in 25 minutes because his mind is on broadband.

He's a really extreme case of superior "mental stream," which I experience myself to a comparatively inferior degree. Do we define this mental stream as creativity? Or do we create a new category for people who are singularly talented at tapping into the Source?

My personal feeling is that we recognize this as an actual event that is separate from creativity, just as the musician is separate from the composer of the music. The talent is equal but different.
Reply to this comment
by gailmatt November 27, 2006 7:47 PM EST
How can I get a recording of Jay Greenburg's sympphony, The Storm. How exciting to have a musical prodigy of this stature in our own time.

I would like to follow his career and hear more of his music.
Reply to this comment
by namedujour November 27, 2006 7:20 PM EST
Anyone who is creative will tell you that you often get inspiration in a kind of mental stream. I'm a writer, and with my first novel I "received" entire pre-written passages I only had to type. I named my muse Harriet, and often said, "Thank you, Harriet" out loud as I furiously typed pre-written pages of prose.

The book won an award, which I accepted, knowing it wasn't all me.

With my second novel, Harriet took more of a back seat, presumably because I could now write on my own.

Muses are real, and creative people tap into something outside of themselves. If you don't believe this, it's because you aren't a creative individual, NOT because it doesn't happen. (It just doesn't happen TO YOU.) Creative types don't even blink. They all go, "Yeah. I know what you mean." And writers mention this all the time.

So this kid is a marvelous conduit. He isn't creative in his own right - he's a radio transmitting a signal. He doesn't even participate in the process by correcting or changing anything. This alone should tip off scientists that creative people are worth examining to find out how we tick, and how we all describe that stream of prose, or music, or visual images we offer up in our creations. It would be interesting to find out how much of it we all admit is not coming from us.
Reply to this comment
by moshe10_613 November 27, 2006 4:36 PM EST
Shalom to Blue jay,
i might call it Gregori's music...before, there were angels who guards human beings, each had specific talents and specialization...but failed to follow instruction from G-d by making human women their wives, their children became Nephilims and were cast out but some survive and later became the Canaanites...the genetic transfer from them to jay is possible by this time it is the Angel of Music's genes he inherited...Blue Jay is the son of the Angel of Music.
Just me and my mind...shalom aleichem !!!
Reply to this comment
by celticqwn November 27, 2006 4:27 PM EST
Just like Mozart, he hears beyond the simple physical scale of the mind. He is hearing on a higher plane.

I can't believe he has a teacher that wants to teach him to doubt and question that gift. Bluejay needs a teacher that can help him work this ability, not limit it. He doesn't need a Antonio Salieri.

Bluejay hears beyond the ears, and beyond the mind. He sees and hears music to perfection. If he were writing scientific notation, he would be a genius, but since it is music, he is called abnormal. So, they give him drugs, and limit his ability.

I hope he tells those teachers who fear his ablity to get lost and start to work with those who encourage and assist him.

How many other children have been lost because of a teacher who just couldn't understand what ability that child had and called it "abnormal" - that would make an interesting report.
Reply to this comment
by desertrat200 November 27, 2006 4:12 PM EST
FINALLY!!
Rappers be damned!
REAL talent has arrived.
Reply to this comment
by desertrat200 November 27, 2006 4:12 PM EST
FINALLY!!
Rappers be damned!
Reply to this comment
by desertrat200 November 27, 2006 4:11 PM EST
FINALLY!
Rappers be damned.
Real talent has arrived!
Reply to this comment
by lilamath November 27, 2006 3:58 PM EST
I loved the piece about Blue Jay. I'd like to know where I could find any CD recordings of his symphonies that I can purchase. He's truly amazing. He can count me in a a midwest fan.
Reply to this comment
by random_radar November 27, 2006 2:00 PM EST
ecuadoriana,

Amen!

Drugging children into submission is a tragedy.
Reply to this comment
See all 29 Comments
60 Minutes RSS Feed