HAZLETON, Pa., Nov. 19, 2006

Welcome To Hazleton

One Mayor's Controversial Plan To Deal With Illegal Immigration

  • Video freeSpeech: Lou Barletta

    Hazleton, Pa., Mayor Lou Barletta got tired of waiting for the federal government to act on illegal immigration, so, as he says in tonight's freeSpeech, he took his own action.

  • Video Hazelton's Immigration Battle

    Steve Kroft reports on one Pennsylvania mayor's controversial plan to deal with illegal immigration.

  • Mayor Lou Barletta Photo

    Mayor Lou Barletta  (CBS)

(CBS) 
Among them is one woman who 60 Minutes will call "Alicia." She came to Hazleton from Mexico a dozen years ago with her daughter to serve the town’s need for cheap labor. She worked in small factories for $6 to $8 an hour, which with overtime allowed her to live right on the poverty line, until she packed up in September and moved to another town.

"I came to work. I don't do nothing to somebody else. I'm not criminal. I am not – not going to welfare for – how you say stamp?" Alicia tells Kroft.

"Food stamp," Kroft says.

"Food stamps," she replies.

Alicia went on to tell that she worked 10 to 12 hours a day, six days a week. She also said that most people in the plant where she worked were illegal immigrants.

She says it was a good job, "much better" than in Mexico. Asked why she moved, Alicia tells Kroft, "Why? Well, because I don't feel safe. I feel now different. I feel like a people know I'm illegal."

"Do you think the ordinance changed the way people looked at you?" Kroft asks.

"Yeah," she replies.

The larger employers in Hazleton say their labor force has not been affected. But there is a reported shortage of construction workers, landscapers and agricultural workers.
Also leaving town are the Hispanic restaurants, bodegas and shops that catered to Hazleton’s Hispanic community and helped revitalize the city’s downtown area, drawing praise from Mayor Baretta. With their customers gone, many of them are closing their doors.

Isabel Rubio, who is now a U.S. citizen, and runs a gift shop in downtown says her business is off more than 50 percent. But worse than that, she believes the ordinance has changed the town, stirring up ethnic tensions, and making illegal immigrants and the entire Hispanic community scapegoats for all of Hazleton’s problems.

"You notice people treating you different or reacting differently to you?" Kroft asks Rubio.

"Oh, yeah we feel," she replies. "My customers they complain. They say they say to people what you’re waiting for when you’re gonna leave town, soon? Like they want the people to leave town."

Rubio vows to stay put and is not leaving town. "This is my home. We are here 24 years. Half of my life," she says.

"There are some people in town that think that this has much less to do with illegal immigrants than it does with the Hispanic community in general," Kroft tells Barletta.

"Well I disagree with that. I have said over and over again, legal immigrants are welcome in Hazleton. Illegal aliens are not. I'm very clear about that. I've been very supportive of the Hispanic community in the seven years that I've been the mayor here," the mayor says.

"You’ve been called a bigot. You’ve been called a political opportunist," Kroft remarks.

"I’ve been called the grand wizard of the KKK," Barletta replies. "I took an oath of office to protect and defend the people of my community. And they can call me all the names they want. But this is worth fighting for."

Produced By Janet Klein
©MMVI, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Recent Segments
Scroll Left Scroll Right
Add a Comment See all 443 Comments
by jeans-w November 19, 2006 8:03 PM PST
Go Hazelton! I wish more cities would do what you are doing. Wish you and your city all well! Good Luck!
Reply to this comment
by bswack62 November 19, 2006 8:08 PM PST
I totally agree with what Mayor Barletta from Hazelton, PA. is doing. Good Job, Mayor!! We need more people like him to stand up and do what's right. If you are here illegal, you are breaking the law. If you want to stay in the US, then become legal, for example: "Alicia" who was on the 60 minutes show, she has been here for 12 years or more, why is she still illegal?? 12 years is a long time. If she likes our country's money so well, then she should become legal. We welcome you to stay here "Alicia", but you must become legal or it is...Goodbye...so long!!

As for the ACLU, Mind your own business not ours!! Stay out of things that you have no business interferring with!! A city should have the right to govern its territory, You didn't build the city, it dosen't belong to you, or the illegal immigrants.
Reply to this comment
by roxyboxie November 19, 2006 8:08 PM PST
A poor story. stop calling them illegal imigrants
Call them Criminal Aliens!
Or Illegal Aliens.
You seem to be on the side of Criminals instead of citizens of the United States of America.
they don't speak english nor Watch your show unless you put in all languages here in the USA!We do however. Hummmm?
Roxy
USA, USA,
Reply to this comment
by roxyboxie November 19, 2006 8:10 PM PST
Yes Farmers Branch, Texas Go FBT!
Reply to this comment
by armymom-2009 November 19, 2006 8:10 PM PST
i commend the mayor for what he is doing. after all the key word is illeagl. i work at a facility that houses illeagl immagrents, and i do not have a problem with them wanting to be here, only with them being here illeagly.
Reply to this comment
by queenjonny November 19, 2006 8:17 PM PST
Hell yeah! This mayor has is awesome and has the balls to stand up for what is right! Please, please, please come to Beardstown, IL and help their mayor. Beardstown is going through the same thing now, and it won't get any better until immigration laws are enforced!
Reply to this comment
by mbputnam123 November 19, 2006 8:18 PM PST
Hats off to Mayor Barletta for standing firm on this important issue.

I also find it funny that the ACLU says this issue shouldn't be handled at the local level but at the federal level; and yet issues like abortion they say should be handled at the local level. What hypocrites! I think we should deport those who work for the ACLU too!
Reply to this comment
by cinemanetwork20 November 19, 2006 8:24 PM PST
I think its about time 60 minutes does a story on how legal imigrants and natural citizens have to pay for the free ride by illegals an example of this is when an out of state collsge student has to pay more in utahl to go to collage there but an illegal gets a free ride[when will the supreme court address this]
Reply to this comment
by gretchen1234-2009 November 19, 2006 8:25 PM PST
Absolutely unbelievable what is going on here. This country was built on immigration. This is unconstitutional and unethical. Who's going to do the jobs that the immigrants do? some for less than min. wage. This country would fold without immigrants. What is the problem America? What happened to "bring me your tired, worn..." what happened to the land of opporunity for all? They pay taxes everytime they shop, buy gas. Have any of you tried to take that citzenship test? The average American wouldnt be able to pass it. Funny the Native Americans didnt impose such ordiances as this! This mayor comes from a generation of immigrants..what would have happened to his family if an ordiance such as this was imposed when his ancestors immigrated here? UNBELIEVABLE AND UN-AMERICAN!!!!!
Reply to this comment
by bootling November 19, 2006 8:26 PM PST
steve kroft made mayor barletta look like he is the criminal... i thought journalists were supposed to be unbiased. he didn't ask that illegal alien who he interviewed if she or everyone in the company she worked for knew they were breaking our laws by being here, posessing fake documents, etc. or what would happen to americans who did that in mexico! just another one-sided fluff piece... i am so tired of people saying that illegals are doing the jobs "americans do not want to do". I know plenty of landscapers and construction companies who have been put out of business because they can't compete with companies who use illegal labor. it's the small guys who are sole proprietors just trying to get started who are suffering... our middle class. i work for a construction company myself and i know firsthand that we are underbid all the time by companies who use illegals, don't have employees and don't pay benefits like my company who only employs hard working americans who want to keep their jobs! get the facts and tell both sides steve. barletta is a hero, not a racist.
Reply to this comment
by aaaaaepoh November 19, 2006 8:28 PM PST
ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS ARE NOT JUST MEXICANS OR SPANISH SPEAKING PEOPLE, THERE FROM ALL OVER THE WORLD. I FEEL THAT ANYONE WHO CAME HERE ILLEGAL SHOULD GO BACK TO THEIR COUNTRY WITHOUT QUESTION. THERE TOO MANY USA CITIZENS WITHOUT A JOBS. LOOK AT TARGET THEY HAVE A SIGN UP EVERYDAY "HIRING NOW" AND THEY NOT HIRING USA CITIZEN. NOW TELL ME WHAT'S GOING ON THERE SO MANY USA WITHOUT JOBS. YOU MAY SAY NO ONE WANTS THE JOBS THEY HAVE,BUT IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A JOB YOU WILL TAKE ANYTHING. HEALTH BENEFITS THEY TAKING FOR FAMILIES WHO NEED HELP WITH THE ELDER FAMILY MEMBERS SOCIAL SERVICES ARE GIVEN TO ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS, AND ITS NOT FAIR AT ALL. YOU MAY SAY THEY HELP THE PEOPLE OF THIS COUNTRY, BUT THEY ONLY HELP THE RICH, WHAT'S THAT OLD SAYING "RICH GET RICHER & THE POOR GET POORER". THERE IS A SILENT MAJORITY WHO DO NOT LIKE WHAT'S GOING ON IN THIS COUNTRY AND I THINK THE HIGHER UPS IN GOVERMENT NEED TO DO SOMETHING ABOUT THIS. ITS A SERIOUS ISSUE AND I ALSO THINK WE SHOULD ALL SPEAK ONE LANGUAGE AN ITS ENGLISH. AN USA CITIZEN SHOULD NOT HAVE TO FEEL UNCOMFORTABLE IN THEIR OWN COUNTRY, WHAT ONE SPEAKS IN THEIR OWN HOME IS A ANOTHER STORY.
Reply to this comment
by crazzyre November 19, 2006 8:28 PM PST
Yeah for Mayor Barletta! Illegal means not legal, right?! I have donwloaded a copy of the ordinance and am going to give it to our mayor. The illegals say they do jobs no one else wants bullcrap I say. We live in a small town and I no some guys that were working at a lumber yard and they got fired so the owner could hire, yea you guesed it, illegals from Mexico. the guys wee only getting $6.00 and hour so why not get rid of them and hire two illegals to take his place for the price of one.
As far as the A.C.L.U Well I thought it stood for American Civil Liberties Union. If they are illegal they should have no rights in that respect because they are not American. I am part Irish but mostly American Indian. Remember when you said Indian and it meant American Indian. Now it means some one from India. All these nationalities that put it before American, well that's just wrong. Why not say American Irish, American Japanese, American African because we are Americans first and foremost. Heck if you are born and raised here then it should just be American. Also the language thing. If we moved to another country we would have to speak their language. They would not change it for us. When someone comes to this country speak the language. I guess I will get off the soap box but will reserve the right to step back on it.
To the Mayor of Hazelton. Thank You for trying to protect us all. Our borders are way too lax.
Reply to this comment
by gretchen1234-2009 November 19, 2006 8:28 PM PST
How can you be illegal when you are a human being? How can you be an alien when you are born to parents? Undocumented, maybe but its not a criminal offense only a civil one.
Reply to this comment
by tatine-2009 November 19, 2006 8:30 PM PST
What consitutional rights does an illegal have? Illegal is illegal!!!! Apparently the Hispanic communities are the ones who think they can do whatever they want becasue you do not hear the Vietnamese, Asians, Romanians etc., etc. complaining. That's becasue they are here for a better life and respect the land they came to and became citizens the way it should be!! If you are so offended by all of this, either become a citizen or leave. You made a choice to come here now do what's right!!
Reply to this comment
by magnettravel November 19, 2006 8:30 PM PST
I FIND IT EXTREMELY INTERESTING THAT THE DISGUISED LADY MADE THE COMMENT, "I'M NOT A CRIMINAL." EXCUSE ME, BUT AREN'T ILLEGAL ALIENS BREAKING THE LAW? ALSO, IF THE ACLU WAS AS WORRIED ABOUT THE RIGHTS OF CITIZENS AS IT IS THE ISSUES THAT ARE SLOWLY DESTROYING OUR SOCIETY, IT WOULD HAVE MANY MORE MEMBERS.
Reply to this comment
by gretchen1234-2009 November 19, 2006 8:32 PM PST
Oh one last comment..."go back to their country??"" this was THEIR country at one time..remember that? remember California and Texas once belonged to Mexico...i see them only coming back to reclaim what was once theirs...I see nothing wrong with a different language being spoken. Why the fear of the unknown? I dont get it?
Reply to this comment
by texas2step5 November 19, 2006 8:34 PM PST
Ok, so Alicia has been working for 12 years in the same factory. Only one question " just where did she get the "STOLEN" social security number????
Reply to this comment
by here2vent November 19, 2006 8:34 PM PST
this is without a doubt the poorest excuse of journalism i have ever seen. first, i noticed how you were quick to say the mayor is a descendant of immigrants but forgot to say how they came through Ellis Island LEGALLY! oh and how you forgot to mention "Alicia" is an illegal alien. how dare you as an American citizen sit 5 feet from a criminal and not report her to police. AND you sit there and give her sympathy. if she wants to be here, fill out the papers and pay taxes! the REAL criminals in this whole issue are the people who are employing these people. they should be the first to go to jail and/or be fined for all this. these (the employers) are the people who WANT to pay the lower wages and take more profit for themselves. pay your workers a wage they can live on and you'll have American's working in these jobs. and for all you "rich folk" who have an illegal to come in and clean your house, GET OFF YOUR *** AND CLEAN YOUR OWN *** HOUSE...... YOU MADE THE MESS! OH, AND HOW ABOUT RAISING YOUR OWN KIDS,TOO. sad reporting 60 minutes, very sad.
Reply to this comment
by bootling November 19, 2006 8:46 PM PST
gretchen, do you notice that you are the only voice of opposition here? maybe you should take a step back and look around.

p.s. "alien" has 2 meanings in the english language. just because someone is an alien doesn't mean they are from outter space. wow.
Reply to this comment
by gretchen1234-2009 November 19, 2006 8:48 PM PST
Opposition gives you an opportunity to think and reconsider your position. I will not step back because I dont agree. When you read the "other" definition of alien please share it with me.
Reply to this comment
by etoo1 November 19, 2006 8:50 PM PST
The teachers in Hazleton are cute!
Reply to this comment
by prousa-2009 November 19, 2006 8:51 PM PST
Go, Mayor Lou! Thank you for having the courage to stand up for what is right. Illegal is just that, illegal! I can't just go live in my neighbor's house because it's nicer than mine; so what makes the illegal immigrants think they can just come to the USA and live. I don't care what country you're from, if you aren't here legally, go home.....very simple. The United States contributes more money to countries around the world than any other nation, we care; but, we have laws that must be enforced to protect our people. And if we are going to talk about people who deserve to jump to the front of the line, let's start in Darfur....now there's a group of people who need a free pass to America. I recently cancelled my membership to the ACLU, as a union member and Democrat, that was hard to do. The ACLU has lost its perspective. I hope my town adopts the same approach as Hazleton, PA. Good luck, Hazleton!
Reply to this comment
by bootling November 19, 2006 8:51 PM PST


Dictionary definition of alien
1alien adj
1a: belonging or relating to another person, place, or thing: STRANGE
b: relating, belonging, or owing allegiance to another country or government: FOREIGN
2: differing in nature or character typically to the point of incompatibility
syn see EXTRINSIC
-- alienly adv -- alien.ness -y e n-n e s n

2alien n
1: a person of another family, race, or nation
2: a foreign-born resident who has not been naturalized and is still a subject or citizen of a foreign country; broadly :a foreign-born citizen
3: EXTRATERRESTRIAL

3alien vt
1: ALIENATE, ESTRANGE
2: to make over (as property)

Reply to this comment
by fixmyhouse November 19, 2006 8:53 PM PST
I also agree with the mayor in PA. I happen to work in and around what is becoming or is the most populated Indian community around, Edison and Iselin NJ. I guess my biggest complaint would be when I see 5-to up to 11 children coming from one house going to our schools and yes we are overcrowded!!! and need to build more classrooms. In my position at my company I go into these homes to check some construction related installations.(Not for the city or government) and when you see 15 mattresses in a house, 3 bathrooms built into a cellar. I question why I have to share? no really shoulder a tax burden to build new schools when these people are getting away with this. Where are the city officals or (FEDS if we want to get technical)checking these situatiions or the attendence department of the schools monitoring this. Nothing is being done, but sooner or later there will be a tragedy, a family/house will burn then maybe our mayor Choi will do something. Or maybe Mayor Barletta could help Mr.Choi with this problem. I have no issues with any immigrants coming to this country,LEGALLY paying there city county, State and Federal Taxes! (not just gas as someone stated eariler.) Yes God Bless America and all that live to support it!
Reply to this comment
by gretchen1234-2009 November 19, 2006 8:54 PM PST
wow bootling, thanks I guess I cant read or write well. My point being as "humans" living in a country alledgely founded on Christian principles I find it disheartening that PEOPLE are referred to as "aliens" again I think it is absolutely ridiculous that PEOPLE are not simply referred to as people. Thanks.
Reply to this comment
by crazzyre November 19, 2006 8:57 PM PST
those of you that are so compassionate to the illegals just take a couple in and support them. Or better yet try to go to the hospital for a real emergency. they tax the system and we all pay, shall we not ever forget that illegals crossed the border and flew planes into the two trade towers. just Honor this country,if you can't get out
Reply to this comment
by gretchen1234-2009 November 19, 2006 9:02 PM PST
crazyre, I do not get mad at ignorance and if you are truly 2/3 or 3/4 Native American then you know your ancestors history, I wont go into that. No I am not rich I work everyday as hopefully you do. And I will not even validate your statement about "sleeping" with an immigrant because obviously your statements are not supported with intelligence. Again I will restate my point this country is supported by their "illegal" dollars in different industries. Gas, housing, clothing etc. Look at the humanity behind why people risk their lives for a piece of the American pie. Thats all I am saying.
Reply to this comment
by gary1118 November 19, 2006 9:04 PM PST
Right On Mayor Lou. It is great to see someone finally standing up for what's right in this country and not be conserned about his or her own reputation.
Reply to this comment
by ccj6242 November 19, 2006 9:07 PM PST
I agree that this was a one-sided story. Why wasn't "Alicia" asked how many times she brought her daughter to the emergency room for FREE health care?? Or if she works with her kids at home on their English so the schools don't have to put $850,000/per year into English as a Second Language? Who is protecting the legal kids in schools who are having programs like music, P.E., & science taken away because of budget issues since so much money is going to illegals? I fully support this mayor's fight and any other city who follow.
I live in Houston where there is a huge illegal population. Our schools are suffering, our health care system is suffering -- the bleeding must stop!!
Reply to this comment
by marauderman November 19, 2006 9:09 PM PST
Mayor Barletta and the community of Hazleton are right on track. The only reason for the ALCU to fight this is to justify their existence. Are there not enough %u201Clegal%u201D causes for them to fight? The ACLU talks about the unconstitutionality of what the city of Hazleton has done, are we as tax paying citizens supposed to overlook the illegality of their entry into this country and continue to pay the exorbitant cost of the illegal%u2019s education and health care? We all know from past experience, there will be a judge who will determine what Hazleton has done to be unconstitutional. The question is how long will the legal citizens of this country put up with these kinds of actions without demanding change to the system.
Reply to this comment
by lunachick71 November 19, 2006 9:11 PM PST
I was born and raised in Hazleton - Like most of my friends and neighbors, my family immigrated to the US, in the early 1900's (My father's family from Italy, My Mother's from Ireland & Scotland) This city was built by immigrants, but the key issue is that they came to this country LEGALLY.

I have no problem with immigration, but I do have a problem with people who break the law, by coming into the US, using fake documents, and working illegally.

I also have a problem with the crime-rate increase that IS due to the illegal population. I can remember when there was a murder ever few years or so and it was a shock to the entire community. Now, you hear of a shooting, murder, drug bust, every few weeks. Granted, not all of these crimes are directly related to illegal immigration, but a large number of them are, including a man who was murdered, just 3 blocks from where I live.

When I was in High School (in the late 80's) there were no gangs, not one. Now there are dozens of gamgs, including MS-13, which National Geographic's Explorer referred to as the "world's most dangerous gang."

Like Mayor Barletta, I hate seeing my hometown being destroyed. If you want to live here, is it so bad to ask that you follow the same rules everyone else had to?

Reply to this comment
by roberto2225 November 19, 2006 9:12 PM PST
I THINK WE ARE A IMMIGRANT NATION.
NOW IMIGRANT BECOME HEAD LINE NEWS, MAKE SOME POLITICIAN FAMOUS.
BUT DONT WE NEED THEM TO WORK?
ALSO JUST LOOKING ON SOME STATES WHO DID KICK THEM OUT, FACTURES, HOUSES, JOBS......ETC
SOME AMERICAN FAMILIES WAS HURT, DIVORCES, BANKRUPT.....ETC...ETC
OF COURSE SOME IMMIGRANT ARE CRIMINAL, BUT SHOUD WE JUDI THEM ALL THE SAME?
LOOK AHEAD WITH LEGALIZATION OF THE GOOD ONES ..........BYING PAWER OF TEN MILHION MORE ...........HOUSES,CARS,TAX COLECTION LEGALY....ETC....ETC
Reply to this comment
by gretchen1234-2009 November 19, 2006 9:15 PM PST
my point, roberto, dont judge them all the same...treat each PERSON as separate and equal, not bunch them all together and make predjudicial statements such as, "all or most"
Reply to this comment
by jamesw62 November 19, 2006 9:20 PM PST
this is for anyone who thinks its okay to let people come from other countries into the US illegally and then try to hide or in some cases kill people and commit crimes against american citizens..
Remember this... the US does have laws for those crossing into this country without going through the proper border check points. That is what the problem is not a days. too many people are doing this, then using the federal services and getting welfare, health care, free education for the kids, food stamps and who knows what else... Face it. if you are an american citizen and are caught using a fake federal document, you are thrown into jail. but apparently if your illegal, you arent. kinda two sided isnt it???

and by the way before you say anything this isnt about a race of people, this is about ILLEGALLY entering the US. thus they are technically criminals for doing this.

Reply to this comment
by jamesw62 November 19, 2006 9:23 PM PST
I watched the Steve Kroft interview and thought it to be a slap in the face to me as an American citizen. the lady who was questioned should hae been asked how long you have been in the country illegally. should have been asked if she knew that by coming in illegally that she broke a US law? she should have been asked if she has been here for so long how come she didnt make her self legal. and how come she wants to stay here. and if she would ever considered returning to mexico and come back legally.
The wimpy questions where she only had to answer yes or no was a joke. The fact that the ACLU is doing anything against americans and supporting mexican is a joke in itself
Reply to this comment
by roberto2225 November 19, 2006 9:27 PM PST
IM NOT OK WITH UNDOCMENT WORKS, BUT I LIKE TO SEE THE LAW LEGALIZE THEM, SO THEY CAN PAY THERE TAXES LEGALY.
Reply to this comment
by bswack62 November 19, 2006 9:30 PM PST
This is for Gretchen1234, I'm a born american senior citizen, a high school graduate, who worked for a living, paid all my taxes, now living on Social Security, I cannot afford to buy health insurance, so God forbid (yes, I'm also a born-again Christian), I should ever need to go to the hospital, I would never be able to pay the bill, but the illegals since they are american citizens would not have to pay that hospital bill, because they do not have a Social Security number, and have no way of proving their income. Why?? Why should they get all the benifits that I cannot afford?? I've lived here all my life, I'm so sick of these people who get it for free, and whine that we call them illegals. I paid the taxes during my lifetime, and I'm left out. If they become citizens, then they too would have to pay for their medical care, that's why they choose to stay illegal. They don't pay for that medical care, and free schooling by paying taxes at the grocers, or by buying gas. Let them become American citizens, or go back to their own country, since they do not want to speak our lanquage, and stop stealing from us what our taxes have paid for. Remember, Jesus said, to pay your taxes to Ceasar, and render to God what is His. Jesus also said, Thou shalt not steal from thy neighbor.
Reply to this comment
by marowe-2009 November 19, 2006 9:31 PM PST
I am Black. There is nothing racist about wanting immigration laws enforced.

When my people break the law we go to jail. We don't get jobs, education and medical care for doing so.

If children can sneak into the country, why not terrorists?

This country is based on equal treatment for people. That would include punishing all who break our laws.

Illegal is illegal and there is no way to spin it to make it acceptable.

As for Americans not wanting the jobs illegals do, put the welfare mothers to work.

No one asks for the opinion of the average black citizen on this matter, so here it is.
Reply to this comment
by here2vent November 19, 2006 9:34 PM PST
isn't it a pre-requisite to belong to the ACLU that you be communist? i'm sure you, at the very least, have to be anti-american. they are another "plague" we as americans need to somehow get rid of. they're only purpose seems to be to somehow circumvent every law we have, ESPECIALLY if you mention GOD! every member of the ACLU should be sent to their own little island somewhere because they certainly aren't happy living here. it seems there must be a lot of open space in mexico they could inhabit.
Reply to this comment
by cal2bama November 19, 2006 9:36 PM PST
My son is married to woman who is a naturalized citizen from Honduras. This woman makes makes up to 16,000.00 a year cleaning houses and pays $0.00 a year in income taxes and no social security or medicare payments.My son condones this and perjures himself every time they file an income tax return. This same illegal practice is done by many many more illegals. I have not spoken to my son in almost 3 years because he fully supports her. This country has no place for those who do not pay their fair share for living and working here. Kick my son out too!
Reply to this comment
by cal2bama November 19, 2006 9:36 PM PST
My son is married to woman who is a naturalized citizen from Honduras. This woman makes makes up to 16,000.00 a year cleaning houses and pays $0.00 a year in income taxes and no social security or medicare payments.My son condones this and perjures himself every time they file an income tax return. This same illegal practice is done by many many more illegals. I have not spoken to my son in almost 3 years because he fully supports her. This country has no place for those who do not pay their fair share for living and working here. Kick my son out too!
Reply to this comment
by cal2bama November 19, 2006 9:37 PM PST
My son is married to woman who is a naturalized citizen from Honduras. This woman makes makes up to 16,000.00 a year cleaning houses and pays $0.00 a year in income taxes and no social security or medicare payments.My son condones this and perjures himself every time they file an income tax return. This same illegal practice is done by many many more illegals. I have not spoken to my son in almost 3 years because he fully supports her. This country has no place for those who do not pay their fair share for living and working here. Kick my son out too!
Reply to this comment
by fnelpaso November 19, 2006 9:37 PM PST
Thank God for Mayor Barletta and the citizens of Hazleton. This should be done across the U.S. The fed. govt. does not want to do anything permanent to stop illegals. Dems want voters, illegal or not, Repubs want cheap labor. Pres Bush is following his elite globalist thinking father by setting up the 'North Amer. Union' with Mexico and Canada. This is run by the Dept of Commerce and will do away with our borders, Constitution, courts, laws, and the middle class. It is in process right now - US citizens better wake up!!
Reply to this comment
by roberto2225 November 19, 2006 9:37 PM PST
I ALSO WATCHED STEVE KROFT INTERVIEW AND HE DID WWHAT HE DOES BEST REPORT THE NEWS.
WHTCH HIM BACH IN COUPLE MONTHS ON THIS ISSUE....
Reply to this comment
by gretchen1234-2009 November 19, 2006 9:38 PM PST
BSwack62, Jesus (God) also said "love thy neighbor as thyself" please let me state that I too pay taxes, work, am educated etc. My arguement is simply this; why cant we invest in education illegal or legal. These children have the potential to contribute to society as lawyers, doctors, teachers etc. Why not invest tax dollars in this manner, we support sensless other tax drawn programs. I dont know the perfect solution to the current situation in this country all I am asking is to look at the humanity behind the situation and lets look for a better fix, then a knee-jerk reaction.

P.s. the sales industry is the largest one in this country, if a million undocumented workers shop in one day,,look at the return
Reply to this comment
by gretchen1234-2009 November 19, 2006 9:41 PM PST
BSwack62, oh i forgot to mention the situation with Social Security i too am going through that with my grandmother. She worked as a presser at a dry cleaner for 50 years, trying to make it now on Medicare...we are frustated too but I dont think attacking immigrants would fix the situation. Lower the salaries of persons in Congress would be a start.....
Reply to this comment
by gretchen1234-2009 November 19, 2006 9:45 PM PST
marowe, want to point out to you this country felt the same way about black people less than thirty years ago...deportation would have been well supported if possible. I know alot of black people and you do not speak for the average Black American. Minorities are minorities are the same in the eye of the majority...
Reply to this comment
by ponti5 November 19, 2006 9:45 PM PST
I don't know if people understand, but it is ILLEGAL to hire someone and not take deduct the proper amounts for State and Federal income taxes, unemployment compensation, workman's compensation, local and stae taxes. The employers that are hiring ILLEGAL aliens are breaking a multitude of State, Federal and Local laws. Let an American taxpaying citizen ignore the regulations of the IRS and see what happens.

Thank god for someone like Mayor Barletta who finally has the courage to stand up and defend the rights of the working and tax paying americans whose rights have been snubbed by our Federal Bureaucrats.

Mayor, you have my complete support and appreciation.

Mr. President,

Plese take note, we are being invaded at our borders and we are losing. Get out of Iraq and defend America. Also, we are inundated by sympathetic supporters of grossly illegal activity by groups masquarading as someone defending our rights and liberties. Please let the ACLU know that ILLEGAL aliens do not have any rights under our constitution except they have right to go back to where they came from or the right to go to prison.

JP

Reply to this comment
by cal2bama November 19, 2006 9:46 PM PST
My step daughter is married to an illegal from Mexico. This man has fathered a child for whom we must all pay; that is all except his father.We pay for this child's food and medical care and his father pays nothing!How many other children fall into this same mold? His mother knows where his father works and lives in another state but does not tell this to the human resources department of the the county in which we live. She tells them she doesn't know where he is and receives food stamps and free medical care for this child. We must pay for this deadbeat dad!!!
Reply to this comment
by cal2bama November 19, 2006 9:46 PM PST
My step daughter is married to an illegal from Mexico. This man has fathered a child for whom we must all pay; that is all except his father.We pay for this child's food and medical care and his father pays nothing!How many other children fall into this same mold? His mother knows where his father works and lives in another state but does not tell this to the human resources department of the the county in which we live. She tells them she doesn't know where he is and receives food stamps and free medical care for this child. We must pay for this deadbeat dad!!!
Reply to this comment
See all 443 Comments
  • MOST POPULAR
  • Viewed
  • Commented
60 Minutes RSS Feed