Complete Coverage

Nov. 8, 2006

Democrats Do Well In Statehouses, Too

Party Wins 20 Of 36 Governor Races, Including Key 2008 Battleground States

  • Play CBS Video Video Campaign 2008 Preview

    It's time to start thinking about the presidential election of 2008, which could be one of the most wide-open in years. CBS News correspondent Cynthia Bowers offers a preview.

  • Video The Buckeye Bounce

    Ohio's incumbent Republic senator lost big in an election that was watched very carefully, all thanks to the Buckeye state's critical role in the 2004 election. Lee Cowan reports.

  • Video Wallace, Lockhart On 2008

    CBS News political consultant Nicole Wallace and former Press Secretary to Bill Clinton Joe Lockhart discuss the 2008 race for the White House.

    • California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger celebrates with his wife Maria Shriver at the Beverly Hills Hilton hotel, Nov. 7, 2006.

      California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger celebrates with his wife Maria Shriver at the Beverly Hills Hilton hotel, Nov. 7, 2006.  (Getty Images/Gabriel Bouys)

    • Ohio Governor-elect Ted Strickland, along with his wife, Frances, waves to supporters before giving his victory speech, Nov. 7, 2006 in Columbus.

      Ohio Governor-elect Ted Strickland, along with his wife, Frances, waves to supporters before giving his victory speech, Nov. 7, 2006 in Columbus.  (AP Photo/Tony Dejak)

    Previous slide Next slide
  • Interactive Election Briefing Book

    Info on the races, voting statistics, and more from the CBS News Election & Survey Unit.

  • Photo Essay To The Polls

    Across the U.S., voters exercise their right to choose.

  • News Tools Senate Showdowns

    An analysis of all the U.S. Senate races, from Maine to Hawaii.

(CBS/AP)  Democrats picked up six statehouses in this year's elections, and for the first time in a dozen years, Democrats hold a majority of the nation's governorships. The party won 20 of 36 races, including contests in battleground states such as Ohio, Pennsylvania and Colorado that will be crucial to the 2008 presidential race.

Though governors never enact national policy, they can organize state parties to rally around a White House race. They can also strengthen a party's grass roots, turn out votes for presidential contests, and cultivate future national leaders. Their decisions shape policy on health care, taxes and other domestic issues, and often touch citizens more directly than Washington.

The person who sits in the governor's office also can have an impact on elections, says CBS News political analyst David Jones. Control of state governments is important for redistricting and, he adds, citing Ohio and Florida, "We’ve seen instances in which it can be important who's in charge of supervising elections."

Democratic Rep. Ted Strickland became Ohio's first Democratic governor since 1986, routing Republican challenger Ken Blackwell, whom Democrats criticized for his role in overseeing the 2004 presidential election as secretary of state. The state was critical to President Bush's victory.

Only 39 percent of Ohio voters polled said they were very confident in the voting process. "People who were not very confident that their votes would count overwhelmingly went for Strickland," says CBS News political analyst Sam Best.

"It's time for a change. That's the buzzword," said Cindy Mushrush, 54, a stay-at-home mom from suburban Columbus.

"I feel like the Republican Party is not my party anymore," Joan Domek, 75, said after voting in Parma Heights, near Cleveland.

Democrats now possess 28 of the top state jobs, the same majority enjoyed by Republicans going into Tuesday's elections. The mood behind the reversal was no better expressed than in Ohio. No Republican president has ever taken office without winning that state.

Ten states had open seats because of retirements, term limits and, in the case of Alaska, a failure by the incumbent to win the primary. Democrats won six of those, and held onto vulnerable seats in Iowa, Michigan, Oregon and Wisconsin.

The trend followed a national wave of dominance — Democrats wrested control of the House and were in a strong position to capture the Senate. They also made gains in state legislatures around the country — largely fueled by President Bush's fading popularity, resentment over the war in Iraq and various scandals involving the GOP.

Highlighting other gubernatorial races Tuesday:
  • In Massachusetts, former civil rights prosecutor and Democrat Deval Patrick became the state's first black governor and the nation's second to be elected. He also ended a 20-year Republican grip on the governor's office.

  • In New York, Eliot Spitzer, the crusading attorney general who led a crackdown on Wall Street practices, captured a state-record 69 percent of the vote on his way to becoming the first Democratic governor since 1990. Spitzer's margin beat former Gov. Mario Cuomo's mark of 64.6 percent in 1986.

  • In Colorado, which has voted Republican in the last three presidential elections, former Denver district attorney Bill Ritter won perhaps one of the most bitter races — complete with an FBI investigation into one of many attack ads. The Democrat's campaign said the information in that ad, which accused him of being soft on illegal immigrants, came from a restricted federal database.

  • In Maryland, Baltimore Mayor Martin O'Malley unseated Republican Gov. Robert Ehrlich in a very close race. Just as Ehrlich benefited four years ago from his association with Bush, he suffered for it Tuesday.
The geographical reach of the victories will be critical for the next White House race and for redistricting of congressional seats, which is typically controlled by the governor and the legislature. Governors don't enact national policy, but they can strengthen a party's grass roots, turn out votes for presidential contests, and cultivate future national leaders.

"In the past, the Democratic party was strong in the Northeast and California, and that was about it," said New Mexico Gov. Bill Richardson, who won re-election — and is also exploring a presidential run. "Now we're a more centrist, national party who can show victories across the country."

Patrick, 50, defeated Lt. Gov. Kerry Healey in Massachusetts despite an endorsement from outgoing Gov. Mitt Romney, a possible presidential candidate in 2008 who opted not to run for a second term.

"Today, Nov. 7, 2006, the people of Massachusetts chose, by a decisive margin, to take their government back," Patrick told thousands who gathered at the Hynes Convention Center.

"You know change won't come in a flash," the governor-elect said. "You know that it will take focus and commitment and patience. But you also know that government by gimmick and photo-op and sound-bite has failed us. Do not expect more of that from me."

Eleven Republican incumbents held onto their jobs; Maryland's Ehrlich was the only loser. Twelve Democratic incumbents also won, including Wisconsin Gov. Jim Doyle, who made his support of stem-cell research a big part of his campaign en route to becoming the first re-elected Democrat in 32 years.

Michigan Gov. Jennifer Granholm won despite her state's failing economy, battered by the loss of thousands of manufacturing jobs during her term. She defeated millionaire Dick DeVos, even though he put more than $35 million of his own money toward his campaign.

Arkansas Attorney General Mike Beebe broke a 10-year drought for the Democrats, defeating his Republican opponent Asa Hutchinson, former head of the Drug Enforcement Administration and high-ranking official in the Department of Homeland Security.

Republicans prevailed in the country's biggest states. Former movie star and incumbent Arnold Schwarzenegger easily won the California race, beating Democratic state treasurer Phil Angelides.

"Let's seize the golden moment to make this Golden State shine even much brighter, and let's protect the California Dream for all Californians," Schwarzenegger declared.

Another Republican incumbent, Texas Gov. Rick Perry, successfully fended off several challengers, including eccentric mystery writer and musician Kinky Friedman.

Republican Charlie Crist, the state attorney general of Florida, defeated Democratic Rep. Jim Davis in the contest to replace outgoing GOP Gov. Jeb Bush, who served the maximum two terms.

Republican Sarah Palin, the former mayor of Wasilla, won the Alaska race after defeating Gov. Frank Murkowski in the primary, helping tie the record for number of female governors at nine.

In Pennsylvania, former NFL star Lynn Swann was swamped by Democratic Gov. Ed Rendell.

Republican Gov. Tim Pawlenty overcame a nailbiter in Minnesota, narrowly pulling ahead of Democrat Mike Hatch, attorney general.

In Illinois, Democratic Gov. Rod Blagojevich won re-election in a contest that Republicans had at one time hoped would go their way. In Iowa, Democrat Chet Culver, the secretary of state, held the seat left open by retiring Democratic Gov. Tom Vilsack.

GOP Rep. Jim Gibbons was elected governor of Nevada over state senator Dina Titus, despite accusations he assaulted and propositioned a cocktail waitress. And in Idaho, GOP Rep. C.L. "Butch" Otter won a close race against Democrat Jerry Brady, former publisher of the Idaho Falls Post Register.

Elsewhere, Republican incumbents won in Alabama, Connecticut, Hawaii, South Carolina, Nebraska, Georgia and South Dakota as did Democratic governors in Arizona, Kansas, Tennessee, New Hampshire, Oklahoma and Wyoming.


©MMVI, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.
Add a Comment
by missingamerica November 9, 2006 4:40 AM EST
I hope (although just saying this will probably make lights dim all over Washington, D.C. as shredders kick on) the first thing the Democrats do is make public what went on in *** Cheney's secret meeting with the oil company executives prior to Iraq.
Reply to this comment
by boston1954 November 8, 2006 8:29 PM EST
Well don't look at me...........I voted Independent!!!! AND we are stuck with Teddy for a bit more. Yuck.
Reply to this comment
by redtaz6100 November 8, 2006 4:06 PM EST
why is it in the senate race in Virginia the vote count is going down at 11 am today the vote count was 1,170,708 for Webb and 1,162,576 for Allen and at 1pm today the vote count is 1,169,280 for Webb and 1,169,576 for Allen????????????

does anyone else see something wrong with this????????
Reply to this comment
by redtaz6100 November 8, 2006 4:01 PM EST
why is it in the senate race in Virgina the vote count is going down at 11 am today the vote count was 1,170,708 for Webb and 1,162,576 for Allen and at 1pm today the vote count is 1,169,280 for Webb and 1,169,576 for Allen????????????

does anyone else see something wrong with this????????
Reply to this comment
by gunnerv1 November 8, 2006 3:22 PM EST
See you in two years, thats about how long it'll take the Dems to p*** off everybody.
Reply to this comment
by son54c November 8, 2006 3:11 PM EST
TO Talkingham - - - Great discussions on both political parties and their deeds can be openly talked about on many web sites, especially "e-thepeople.org/a-national/". We seriously need to educate ourselves as too what is actually going on in Washington. Both parties are involved in corruption, fraud, wasteful spending of our tax dollars, and foreign policies. Neither party can brag, both are corrupt. As American citizens, we're obligated to educate ourselves in order to correct the many wrongs against this country by our elected representatives. Just look at foreign trade and it's negative effect on our economy. Which party can blame the other, when most of our woes started after WWII? Think about the past administrations that have set the tone for our decline as an industrial nation. We're not in better hands after yesterday's elections.
Reply to this comment
by marcelde November 8, 2006 2:56 PM EST
"MISSION ACCOMPLISHED" by Democrats

"SHOCK AND AWE" from Republicans

Changes? "BRING 'EM ON!"


CHANGE IS IN THE AIR FOR A CHANGE.

THANK YOU, VOTERS OF THE UNITED STATES.
Reply to this comment
by son54c November 8, 2006 2:54 PM EST
TO Talkingham - - - Hey, I wasn't defeated, I didn't have a horse in the race. And, the big story is the number of people that Re-elected those office holders that have done absolutely nothing for the citizens of this nation. And, it's people that voted for those presently serving that need to leave this country, and, yes, Iraq would be a good place for them. Besides, please tell me what either party has done for the citizens of this nation in the past fifty years, if you can, which I doubt. I always get amused when people defend one party or the other, especially when I look at the actual "State of the Union". This country is in big trouble, and has been for at least a half century. No one can brag on Republicans or Democrats, both have had a hand in our present situation. I always ask people to tell me exactly what each party has done for this country that's "Good", and I get no response with any "backbone". We're in deep trouble, and we'll continue to be in deep trouble as long as people are taken in by smooth talking, silver tongued politicians. Please read a little from "Transparency International" when you have time. It's on the web.
Reply to this comment
by talkingham November 8, 2006 2:28 PM EST
Janem and son54 you are so gracious in defeat. Hey you're free to leave the country anytime you wish if it's so bad. Hey, there are plenty of jobs open in Iraq if its so bad here. So you think the big story is that Liberman won, that's your choice. But the big story is that the Dems now have the house and perhaps we will now have some investigations of what in the world the repub scam artists have been up to. I doubt we'll see any investigations. The Dems are no where near as vindictive as the repubs who had to investigate every aspect of the Clintons as soon as they won the House- they spent more investigating Clinton's love life than they did on the 911 commission. From the travel office to the Clinton's ralestate and law practice billings 20 years ago. I wish the Dems were that vindictive but they aren't - they aren't the sleeze merchants who have wasted hundreds of billions of dollars and killed untold innocents with the shock and awe failure of Iraq.
Reply to this comment
by son54c November 8, 2006 1:31 PM EST
Whether it be Democrats or Republicans, the American people WILL NOT be served. The past fifty years bear witness to that statement. Politics is politics, and politicians are politicians. This country has gone downhill under both political parties, for years and years. Corruption, fraud, lies, and self-interest rules the political scene. Anyone that believes politicians are for the citizens of this nation need only look at the economy, the war, foreign trade, foreign policies, the increase in the number living in poverty, illegal immigration, low wages, personal and corporate bankruptcies, the REAL value of the dollar, education, the lack of healthcare for ALL citizens, job out-sourcing, plant closings, mass lay-offs, and the vanishing middle class of society. The biggest mistake we make on election days is Re-electing office holders. When the United States of America hits rock bottom, then, and only then, will the people finally wake up and smell the coffee.
Reply to this comment

Exclusive Webshow

Best-selling author Mitch Albom on his first nonfiction work since "Tuesdays with Morrie." Watch Now

Latest News
News in Pictures
Scroll Left Scroll Right
Connect with CBS News

Stay connected with the CBS News using your favorite social networks and online news applications: