White House Denies Cheney Endorsed Torture
VP Called Dunking Suspects In Water During Interrogations 'A No-Brainer'
-
Play CBS Video
Video
Reporters Hound Snow On Cheney
CBS News RAW: During a White House press briefing, reporters pressured spokesman Tony Snow to clarify a statement Vice President Dick Cheney made during a radio interview.
-
Photo
Vice President Dick Cheney speaks at a business luncheon, Wednesday, Oct. 25, 2006, in Cincinnati. (AP)
-
Interactive
Gitmo Tribunals
Detainees on trial, photos and a history of the naval base.
-
Special Report
War On Terror
Complete coverage of the military's battle against terrorism.
-
Interactive
Second In Command
A closer look at Vice President Dick Cheney's career and his much-publicized health problems.
Cheney's comments sparked an outcry from human rights groups, which claimed his statement amounted to an endorsement of water boarding, an age-old technique in which a prisoner's head is kept under water to simulate drowning.
"This country doesn't torture. We will interrogate people we pick up on the battlefield," President Bush said Friday. He declined, however, to directly respond to reporters' questions about Cheney's remarks.
White House press secretary Tony Snow insisted the vice president was not referring to water boarding.
"You know as a matter of common sense that the vice president of the United States is not going to be talking about water boarding. Never would. Never does. Never will," Snow said.
Asked if the vice president slipped up, an exasperated Snow responded, "No. Are you kidding? You think Dick Cheney's going to slip up on something like this. Come on!"
The controversy stems from an interview Cheney had with Scott Hennen, a conservative radio host in Fargo, N.D., on Tuesday, during which Cheney was asked if he agreed that "a dunk in water is a no-brainer" if it can provide information that can save lives.
"Well, it's a no-brainer for me," Cheney said, according to a transcript of the interview posted on the White House Web site.
He added, "We don't torture. That's not what we're involved in. We live up to our obligations in international treaties that we're party to and so forth. But the fact is, you can have a fairly robust interrogation program without torture, and we need to be able to do that."
Cheney said important information had been gleaned from interrogations of terror suspects like Khalid Sheik Mohammed, the reputed mastermind of the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks, who is being held at the U.S. base in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.
"Our ability to interrogate high-value detainees like Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, that's been a very important tool that we've had to be able to secure the nation," Cheney said.
He added that Mohammad provided "enormously valuable information about how many (al-Qaeda members) there are, about how they plan, what their training processes are and so forth. We've learned a lot. We need to be able to continue that."
A Cheney spokeswoman denied the vice president was confirming the use of any specific interrogation technique.
"He was talking about the interrogation program without torture," spokeswoman Lee Anne McBride said. "The vice president does not discuss any techniques or methods that may or may not have been used in questioning."
Human rights groups condemned the vice president's remarks.
"What's really a no-brainer is that no U.S. official, much less a vice president, should champion torture," said Amnesty International USA executive director Larry Cox.
"This administration aims at a radical break with our country's proud human rights tradition," Cox said. "The America we believe in does not torture people."
Mr. Bush signed legislation earlier this month authorizing tough interrogation of terror suspects and smoothing the way for trials before military commissions.
The president said the United States will abide by its international obligations and will not engage in torture.
The U.S. Army's recently revised Field Manual explicitly prohibits the use of water boarding as part of its wider ban or torture and degrading treatment of prisoners.
The manual applies to all the armed services — but does not cover the CIA, which has come under criticism for mistreatment of prisoners in Iraq and Afghanistan and for keeping suspects in secret prisons around the world.
©MMVI, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.



- 1
- 2
- 3
- next
See all 147 CommentsThis guy, like his boss, ducked military service; yet they eagerly and greedily send young unthinking men to go commit atrocities that will only earn them a place in hell, but not before those sick soldiers have been disrespect by the more decent Americans.
Every American who has a brain knew that torturing of people and the creation of nude pyramids by homosexual soldiers was given clearance from the highest level of our government.
Those soldiers were following orders.
As sane humans, they should have known better than to follow bad orders; and so they are the ones imprisoned for torture.
But who is going to bring the soldiers' ringleaders continue to give the orders for torture to book?
He speaks with this self-righteous attitude; at least Bush is readable. I think if the Democrats take over the House or Senate or both, that they will do what the whole Congress has fail to do, CHECK THIS ADDMINASTRATION. We are going to see how much Chenney and his coo-coo friends did to press their neo-con agenda and we are going to see whom those friends are. If there is evil in our government, Chenny is part of it.
We need to let the Democrats have some power.
STAY FOCUSED AMERICA IT IS ABOUT TO GET TOUGH. WE HAVE A FEW MORE DAYS OF INTENSE ATTACK ADS, SMOKE SCREENS, DIVISION OF ELECTORATE, DECEPTION, MISREPRESENTATION, AND LIES, TO ENDURE BEFORE WE CAN UNCOVER THE ELECTION FRAUD, RECOUNT THE VOTE, AND THROW THESE CRIMINALS OUT OF OFFICE. THEN WE CAN START HEALING AMERICA.
These guys were of no help during the Vietnam war. The only enemy soldier they have ever taken down is Ho Chi Whittington!
Okay, let%u2019s look at THIS.
Hmmmm. Darth 5 deferment Cheney, says waterboarding is not torture but part of a %u201Cfairly robust interrogation program%u201D.
Let%u2019s give *** a few dunks and then see what he says about the direct experience of waterboarding.
I%u2019ll bet he%u2019s so tough that he%u2019ll ask for more since he is far more robust than a little dunking. While he%u2019s on that board, let%u2019s ask him why we really went to Iraq. Let%u2019s ask if he and Fearless Leader got so high on the smell of oil that they began throwing our sons and daughters into a meat grinder just to fatten up the bottom line of Haliburton & the rest of his rich cronies.
VOTE these criminals out!
Cheney, Bush & Rumsfeld are as guilty of cold-blooded murder as any terrorist. To me, they are the real terrorists. I'm still proud to be an American. Bush/Cheney in no way represent the true America. However, it's disgraceful that what this adm. represents to the world is an America of hypocrisy, lies & greed.
To observantX:
While Cheney is on that waterboard, let's ask him a few questions about 911.
We did not interrogate to elicit a confession. We interrogated to gain information that might prevent further murders of Citizens of the US and our Allies.
It is an odd country that cares more for the rights of Terrorists and convicted mass murderers than it does for the rights of unborn children.
You go ahead and be ashamed to be an American, but perhaps you and your children are alive today because we have taken the fight to the MiddleEast, rather than on American soil.
Really! I can't believe it! What kind of felonious, moronic draft dodging, freakin old codger chickenhawk would say waterboarding is a no brainer when we got MIA on the freakin ground! MIA in enemy hands as we speak! If waterboarding is a no brainer for us then i wonder what is a no brainer for the bad guys holding our kid. Someone needs to tell this pasty old coward to shut up!
F Bush --let's impeach Cheney!
God Help our Troops
God forgive Bush and Cheney
We must kill those who don't respect life.
Really! I can't believe it! What kind of felonious, moronic draft dodging, freakin old codger chickenhawk would say waterboarding is a no brainer when we got MIA ON THE FREAKIN GROUND! MIA in ENEMY hands as we speak! If waterboarding is a no brainer for us then i wonder what is a no brainer for the bad guys holding our kid.
Someone needs to tell this pasty old coward to SHUT THE F UP!
F Bush --let's impeach Cheney!
God Help our Troops
God forgive Bush and Cheney
The rip-off war-mongers and greedy pigs need to be tar and feathered and run out of Washington DC and run out of the country, Haliburton needs to be taxed 99% to get back the (our) money that they stole with the help of Bush and Haliburtons former CEO *** Cheney! go figure
The Republican party needs to Die for the sake of our country. They are the true Benedict Arnolds of today. The republican party is the problem within our country and we need to eliminate the cancer once and for all.
TRANSLATION DO YOU THINK *** CHENEY WOULD MAKE THE MISTAKE OF ACCIDENTALLY ADMITTING THAT THE CIA USES TORTURE?
ASIDE FROM THE FACT THAT TORTURE BY ANY OTHER NAME(S), e.g. %u201CWATERBOARDING%u201D or %u201CDUNKING%u201D IS INHUMANE AND AGAINST OUR SIGNATURE TO THE %u201CGENEVA ACCORDS%u201D, OUR USE OF TORTURE PUTS OUR TROOPS AT EVEN GREATER RISKS!
THE %u201CENEMY%u201D (those who unreasonably object to having their families, and nation destroyed and then occupied by us) WILL HAVE NO COMPUNCTION ABOUT USING OUR SAME TORTURE METHODS ON OUR SOLDIERS!
CHENEY%u2019S COMMENTS, EVEN IF PHRASED AS AN INNOCENT DUNKING, WILL BE CORRECTLY VIEWED AS AN APPROVAL BY THIS ADMINISTRATION TO PERMIT TORTURE BUT LIE ABOUT IT WITH EUPHEMISMS.
SINCE THE C.I.A. IS NOT UNDER ANY MILITARY RESTRICTIONS, YOU CAN BE SURE THAT THE CIA HAS HIRED PSYCHOPATHS IN SECRET FOREIGN PRISONS TO ADMINISTER TORTURE TO ANYONE, IRRESPECTIVE OF REAL EVIDENCE AND TO TORTURE AT WILL. MOST OF HITLER%u2019S %u201CS.S.%u201D TROOPS WERE PSYCHOPATHS RELEASED FROM JAILS FOR JUST SUCH A PURPOSE.
Just want to make sure that "credit" is given where it's due....
I just finally figured it out!
When we become a nation of fanatical headchoppers and torturers who follow no laws but the jungle law with no regard for human rights then we will have WON the WAR ON TERROR!
Ingenious!
Victory is at hand!
Vote for Republicans!
God Bless our Troops
God forgive Bush and Cheney
Has the US tortured suspected terrorists? Yes. Are we still torturing suspected terrorists? Probably. If I was a betting man, I wouldn't bet against it. Is it needed for our safety? Maybe. But, most would say, probably not.
But for the VP of the USA to even entertain an interview that would even touch on the subject, just goes to show what an piece of ***, out-of-touch psychopath the guy is.
Especially a few days before such a critical election! What was he thinking??
Dumb@#$.
FIGHT for WE THE PEOPLE..!
THE (TYRANT) GOVERNMENT HAS SHOWN THEIR COLORS
and NOW Cheney CONFIRMS with he thinks torturing US CITIZENS is a " NO BRAINER "
UNITED STATES SUPREME COURT
James B. Veasaw v. Cari M. Domingues,et al.
No: 05-1467
Apparently the US SUPREME COURT AGREES
Now POLITICIANS and BUREAUCRATS are IMMUNE to
COMMIT CRIMES against the People without the fear of RETRIBUTION in the COURTS,
and that FEDERALLY FUNDED PROGRAMS are WORK PROGRAMS designed
to give CRONIES and BUREAUCRATS high paying Jobs, and
their own back door access to the TREASURY.
Just in case you were not aware Citizens of this country must Now
PASS LITERARY TESTS in order to receive PROTECTION in the COURTS
(i.e. say the "MAGIC WORDS" for justice)
(i.e. put the "MAGIC WORDS" on " MAGIC PAPER ")
So much for looking out for the people...
apparently the courts are just a FORMALITY in the path of INSTALLING TYRANT GOVERNMENT.
the FEDERAL GOVERNMENT think they are EXEMPT from ALL (Civil rights and Constitutional) LAWS That is right you give them a little
bit of power these people, and they become TYRANTS and the US SUPREME COURT openly admits IT IS a CORRUPT INSTITUTION.
he didnt truly "call" water boarding a "no-brainer".
Those appear to be the questioner's words. He agreed with the notion, because he is a paranoid slime bag, but your healdline is a little misleading.
I will never be ashamed to be an American.. I am totally ashamed of this "government".
It is said that people in a democracy get the government they deserve, it has become obvious that scared people get very poor government. They will keep scaring you, if you will keep voting for them.
I'll bet Bin Laden thanks his lucky stars everyday for Bush and his rightwing keystone kops! Don't you think he knows that the war in Iraq is costing us $1600.00 A SECOND? We are borrowing that money from China and our grandchildren will have to repay it!
Then we have some cowardly old chickenhawk saying torture is OK while we have MIA on the ground in Iraq! Unbelievable!
God Bless our Troops
God forgive George Bush
You use Christ to act like the DEVIL that you are.
I leave you only with these words.
"The spirit of democracy cannot be imposed from without. It has to come from within."
"God has no religion"
"I like your Christ. I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ."
"Just as a man would not cherish living in a body other than his own, so do nations not like to live under other nations, however noble and great the latter may be."
"I consider western Christianity in its practical working a negation of Christ%u2019s Christianity."
Words from Mohandas Gandhi
You use Christ to act like the DEVIL that you are.
I leave you only with these words.
"The spirit of democracy cannot be imposed from without. It has to come from within."
"God has no religion"
"I like your Christ. I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ."
"Just as a man would not cherish living in a body other than his own, so do nations not like to live under other nations, however noble and great the latter may be."
"I consider western Christianity in its practical working a negation of Christ%u2019s Christianity."
Words from Mohandas Gandhi
You use Christ to act like the DEVIL that you are.
I leave you only with these words.
"The spirit of democracy cannot be imposed from without. It has to come from within."
"God has no religion"
"I like your Christ. I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ."
"Just as a man would not cherish living in a body other than his own, so do nations not like to live under other nations, however noble and great the latter may be."
"I consider western Christianity in its practical working a negation of Christ%u2019s Christianity."
Words from Mohandas Gandhi
You use Christ to act like the DEVIL that you are.
I leave you only with these words.
"The spirit of democracy cannot be imposed from without. It has to come from within."
"God has no religion"
"I like your Christ. I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ."
"Just as a man would not cherish living in a body other than his own, so do nations not like to live under other nations, however noble and great the latter may be."
"I consider western Christianity in its practical working a negation of Christ%u2019s Christianity."
Words from Mohandas Gandhi
Is everybody in US custody (a number that is in the tens of thousands - when you add detainees in Iraq, Afghanistan and Guantanamo together) as a result of the GWOT guilty of decapitating people? Are ALL these people even guilty of being terrorists?
I ask this in light of the fact that 160+ (or more than a quarter) of those who were at Guantanamo (or "the worst of the worst") turned out in fact not to be "the worst of the worst" but were determined instead by the US Government to be innocent and were thus set free.
Because unless you can prove that the US doesn't make mistakes and that they're ALL guilty we're torturing an awful lot of innocent people.
You use Christ to act like the DEVIL that you are.
I leave you only with these words.
"The spirit of democracy cannot be imposed from without. It has to come from within."
"God has no religion"
"I like your Christ. I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ."
"Just as a man would not cherish living in a body other than his own, so do nations not like to live under other nations, however noble and great the latter may be."
"I consider western Christianity in its practical working a negation of Christ%u2019s Christianity."
Words from Mohandas Gandhi
I am now VOTING for INDEPENDENTS (INDEPENDENCE)
NOT LEFT
NOT RIGHT
IF they are IN they are going to be OUT !
I AM FOR WE THE PEOPLE !
They couldn%u2019t get away with that now because everyone is aware of what they can and will do.-- They are winning because we are lowering ourselves down to their level, We allow our precious civil rights to be crushed, sanction torture, allow ruinous tax cuts while waging war, running the national debt to un-sustainable heights, I%u2019m sure the American people would have gladly paid higher taxes to go after the terrorists.
We allow this administration, through scare tactics and lies, to divert the DEFENSIVE effort of going after al qaeda and taliban in Afghanistan to an unjustified OFFENSIVE invasion of Iraq, then, in the process of %u201Cstaying the course%u201D bogging down and depleting Our military capability to the point nations like N Korea and Iran feels free to do anything they want.
If this is what America wants then we are no better than those we condemn.
Saudi born Osama bin Laden was recruited during the Soviet-Afghan war "ironically under the auspices of the CIA, to fight Soviet invaders". 1
In 1979 "the largest covert operation in the history of the CIA" was launched in response to the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in support of the pro-Communist government of Babrak Kamal.2:
With the active encouragement of the CIA and Pakistan's ISI [Inter Services Intelligence], who wanted to turn the Afghan jihad into a global war waged by all Muslim states against the Soviet Union, some 35,000 Muslim radicals from 40 Islamic countries joined Afghanistan's fight between 1982 and 1992. Tens of thousands more came to study in Pakistani madrasahs. Eventually more than 100,000 foreign Muslim radicals were directly influenced by the Afghan jihad.3
The Islamic "jihad" was supported by the United States and Saudi Arabia with a significant part of the funding generated from the Golden Crescent drug trade:
In March 1985, President Reagan signed National Security Decision Directive 166,...[which] authorize[d] stepped-up covert military aid to the mujahideen, and it made clear that the secret Afghan war had a new goal: to defeat Soviet troops in Afghanistan
To all Conservative Christians=GOP=Republicans
- 1
- 2
- 3
- next
See all 147 Comments