Fox: I Was Over-Medicated In Stem Cell Ad

CBS News Exclusive: Parkinson's-Afflicted Actor Tells Katie Couric He Wasn't Acting In Ad

(CBS/AP)  Responding to criticism by conservative pundit Rush Limbaugh, actor Michael J. Fox defended his appearance in a political campaign ad, saying he wasn't acting or off his medication.

In fact, at the time he was over-medicated for his Parkinson's disease, Fox said Thursday in an exclusive interview with CBS Evening News anchor Katie Couric.

"The irony is that I was too medicated. I was dyskinesic," Fox told Couric. "Because the thing about … being symptomatic is that it's not comfortable. No one wants to be symptomatic; it's like being hit with a hammer."

His body visibly wracked by tremors, Fox appears in a political ad touting Missouri Democratic Senate candidate Claire McCaskill's stance in favor of embryonic stem cell research. That prompted Limbaugh to speculate that Fox was "either off his medication or acting."

Fox told Couric, "At this point now, if I didn't take medication I wouldn't be able to speak."

He said he appeared in the ad only to advance his cause, and that "disease is a non-partisan problem that requires a bipartisan solution."

"I don't really care about politics," Fox added. "We want to appeal to voters to elect the people that are going to give us a margin, so we can't be vetoed again."

---

Watch The Entire Interview
Complete Transcript
Watch Fox's Political Ad
Stem Cell Crusader
Why Fox Is 'Grateful'
Couric & Co. Blog: My Interview With Michael J. Fox

---

Though Fox, a native of Canada who became an American citizen in 2000, has been politically active for Democratic causes, he said he has voted for and would vote for a Republican. "Arlen Specter is my guy," he said of the Republican senator from Pennsylvania. "I've campaigned for Arlen Specter. He's been a fantastic champion of stem cell research. I've spoken alongside Mike Castle, who's a Republican congressman. Absolutely."

"This is not about red states and blue states," added Fox, who has also lobbied Congress to lift President Bush's restrictions on funding for stem cell research. "This is not about Democrats and Republicans. This is about claiming our place as the scientific leader in scientific research and moving forward and helping our citizens. That’s all it is. It’s that simple."

On his Web site Tuesday, Limbaugh appeared to back away from his accusation.

"All I'm saying is I've never seen him the way he appears in this commercial for Claire McCaskill," says Limbaugh. "So I will bigly, hugely admit that I was wrong, and I will apologize to Michael J. Fox, if I am wrong in characterizing his behavior on this commercial as an act, especially since people are telling me they have seen him this way on other interviews and in other television appearances."

Fox told Couric that even though it's tough for him to sit for interviews as his symptoms worsen, he feel privileged to be able to do so.

"Honestly, I mean, I really feel this: That you get in your life very few chances to make a difference. And I really feel privileged to do this that I get a chance to do this. But having said that, it's not pretty. It's not pretty when it gets bad," Fox said. "I've learned to throw vanity out the window. I've had enough years of people thinking I was pretty and teenage girls hanging my picture on walls. I'm over that now."

In the Missouri ad, Fox says, "As you might know I care deeply about stem cell research. In Missouri you can elect Claire McCaskill, who shares my hope for cures."

McCaskill has made support for embryonic stem cell research a key part of her campaign to unseat Sen. Jim Talent. The Republican incumbent opposes the research as unethical, saying it destroys human embryos.

The ad debuted prominently Saturday night during Game 1 of the World Series between the St. Louis Cardinals and the Detroit Tigers and will continue airing statewide this week, a campaign spokeswoman said.

Debate over stem cell research looms large in Missouri, where voters are considering a ballot measure that would amend the state constitution to protect all federally allowed forms of the research, including embryonic stem cell research. The scientific study holds promise in the search to cure diseases like Parkinson's and Alzheimer's.

"Unfortunately, Sen. Jim Talent opposes expanding stem cell research," Fox says in the 30-second spot. "Sen. Talent even wanted to criminalize the science that gives us a chance for hope."

Continued

• 1
• 2
• Next

©MMVI, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Share:

Digg

Facebook

Yahoo! Buzz

Twitter

Video and Galleries from CBS Evening News

• Video Evening News Online, 07.03.09
• Video Independence Day Travel Slows
• Video A Fitting Find For The Fourth

Latest in CBS Evening News

Historic Discovery

Recession Puts Brakes on Holiday Travel

Most Dangerous Job In The World?

Add a Comment

• 1
• 2
• 3
• 4
...
• 8
• next

See all 396 Comments

by stephanie801 October 26, 2006 5:46 PM PDT

Does this sound like an apology to anyone else? I don't think so. Try again Rush!

""All I'm saying is I've never seen him the way he appears in this commercial for Claire McCaskill," says Limbaugh. "So I will bigly, hugely admit that I was wrong, and I will apologize to Michael J. Fox, if I am wrong in characterizing his behavior on this commercial as an act, especially since people are telling me they have seen him this way on other interviews and in other television appearances." "

Reply to this comment

by ronniehm October 26, 2006 6:00 PM PDT

Aside from admitting he was wrong and apologizing, what would you include in an apology?

Reply to this comment

by jsilver2th October 26, 2006 6:02 PM PDT

Thanks Rush for helping put the Democrats over the top! Thanks Michael J. Fox for being a classy guy, heads above poor Rush. These campaign ads are now national news- Out here in the desert it looks like the Republicans are pretty hard up. We only have vote by mail in Oregon now so the election is almost over. The GOP candidate for Governor was going pretty good for a while but now he's going down in flames with the rest of the GOP ticket. Looks like this gives the big boost to McCaskill- who needs Talent anyway- another Bush clone.

Reply to this comment

by fredegrar October 26, 2006 6:34 PM PDT

Ronnie,
I think it's the 'if' in Rush's apology that makes it sound like something less than an apology. The 'bigly, hugely' part doesn't help either. It comes out sounding to me like he means it would be big of him to apologize if he turns out to be wrong, rather than an admission of being wrong and feeling remorse it. As Rush often states, he believes he's correct all of the time (or very nearly so), so he probably still believes what he originally said.

Reply to this comment

by baia1 October 26, 2006 6:36 PM PDT

You guys are something else! None of you realize that everything Fox said in the ad was a lie.

Reply to this comment

by coker8721 October 26, 2006 6:44 PM PDT

My father has had to deal with the effects of PD for the past 15 years and I know what the deep brain stimulator that Fox has had implanted in his brain can do. My father can not find the money for such a procedure but if he did then the shaking would not occur enough to notice. I think that Mr. Fox was shifting around more like a person with Cerebral Palsy and not a guy suffering from PD. If he is exploiting the disease then that%u2019s a shame... if not... I think he needs to be re-diagnosed or sue the doctors that put the stimulator in his brain because it%u2019s not working (maybe it needs new batteries?)

P.S. If you do not share my feelings please leave a comment and lets hear what you think!

GOD BLESS AMERICA!!!

Reply to this comment

by berrysxx October 26, 2006 6:52 PM PDT

Guess I should expect anyone watching NBC to be biased towards a liberal. Michael J. Fox should be telling anyone with parkinson's disease that there is hope, not from embronic stem cell research, which has never proven of any value, but with a probe inserted into the brain made by Medtronics. Michael, unfortunately opted for a surgery that was non-reversible and it didn't work for him. That's sad, but for others there is a remedy that is reversible! Check it out if you have the disease, it's awesome!

Reply to this comment

by berrysxx October 26, 2006 6:56 PM PDT

Michael did not have the stimulator according to my source, he had some type of lazer or searing of the brain. The stimulator works for most people! Rush didn't say Michael was faking, he just indicated he doesn't act like on the other shows he's been on.

Reply to this comment

by docjay8406 October 26, 2006 7:04 PM PDT

baia1,

Fox said, "Unfortunately, Senator Jim Talent opposes expanding stem cell research." If you'll notice that is not a lie. Rich Chrismer, Talent's spokesman did not refute this. Chrismer said Talent supports "medical research including stem cell research that doesn't involve cloning or destroying a human embryo." This is already in place and does NOT expand stem cell research.

Fox also said "Senator Talent even wanted to criminalize the science that gives us a chance for hope." The article says Talent "supported a Senate bill that would ban all embryonic stem cell research and impose a million-dollar fine and jail sentence on violators." This means Talent WANTED to make stem cell research a criminal act.

I'm apalled I have to actually repeat something that is as clear as day. There is no need to lie. You don't need to join Rush Limbaugh in his smear campaign against others.

Berrysxx,

Thanks for the comment. It's the IF that Rush included in his statement that irks me. First Rush says he was wrong then he followed it up with an IF, that is very insincere if you ask me. You don't say IF when you truly believe you were wrong. IF is a qualifier that dilutes his statement and sincerity.

coker,

I think you need to check your i facts /i .

Reply to this comment

by jasper369 October 26, 2006 7:10 PM PDT

Rush said if Michael J. Fox really was shaking so bad then he wasn't taking his medication. Well, maybe he is trying to show us what this disease is really about. Thanks Rush, maybe you can stay off your meds and show us what your really like.

Reply to this comment

by oharras October 26, 2006 7:12 PM PDT

Thank you Ms. Couric for the class you and Mr. Fox showed in the interview. Mr. Fox has always been a decent man, and it is a shame to see the toll PD has taken on this fine man. Rush Limbaugh just cannot stand up as tall as you, Ms. Couric and Mr. Fox. Thank you very much!

Reply to this comment

by up4chalng October 26, 2006 7:14 PM PDT

My response is to Berrysxx. I'm not sure what your history is regarding a "probe inserted into the brain" but it's not what it appears to be. My father had this surgery and was fine for about six months. He's now in a wheelchair because he has major balance problems and can not speak so people can understand him. He's still has to take Parkinson's medication to prevent the tremors and dyskinesia just like before. So if you believe in stem cell research or not your probe in the brain is not the cure-all for this disease.

Reply to this comment

by csmith3539 October 26, 2006 7:16 PM PDT

I have nothing but admiration for Michael J. Fox. The way he has handled his disease has been inspiring. To have to defend his actions to the overrated right wing intolerant small minded fear monger that is Rush Limbaugh is a sad commentary on the media and anyone who would listen to that madman's ranting. I hope Michael knows that those of us with independent thought believe in his cause and his being able to further it anyway he can.

Reply to this comment

by navygirl58 October 26, 2006 7:16 PM PDT

Michael J. Fox said in the interview he supported Arlen Spector. I guess it takes a Republican like Spector to have such a serious illness for one to fully understand the importance of stem cell research. Perhaps more Republicans and or their family members need to fall victim to serious illnesses such as Parkinson's, paralysis, cancer, Alzheimers, etc. before they see the light on this moral/political issue. These IVF stem cells will otherwise be useless. Why not allow science labs put them to some use? My heart breaks for anyone who must suffer through anything such as Parkinsons. I was one of those teenage girls who did and still does have a crush on MJF. You are making a difference, Michael and I hope something comes from all of this in your lifetime.

Reply to this comment

by paswword-2009 October 26, 2006 7:17 PM PDT

I want news when I get home, not hollywood either raido or tv, playing the heats of the working people. stick to the facts and report not try to entertain me like hollywood.

Reply to this comment

by ucscorp-2009 October 26, 2006 7:19 PM PDT

Dear Katie,
Earlier this year i was told i might have parkinson's..thank god it turned out to be vertigo..bad, but no where near parkinson's...
When i thought that i had Parkinsons's i turned to Michaels web site! It gave me hope and helped me to understan how devastating it was. Well god spared me but i will never forget or let Michael down...Thanks for dedicating time to my most important issue! As far as Rush is concerned I think he's just looking for another 15 minutes f fame...more like shame.

Again Thanks

Bob Reilly NYS

Reply to this comment

by dw73745 October 26, 2006 7:19 PM PDT

Michael J. Fox shows his zeal , with no apologies to the world, concerning stem cell research. I think that Rush Limbaugh has finally crossed over the line with his comments about Michael. Before using his public postition to make such assumptions concerning Michael's state of mind or medications and turning Michael's zeal into yet another POLITICAL issue, he should have spent a little time verifying his information.
Rush has always been appaulling and now he is unsurpassed in repugnant behavior.

Reply to this comment

by mh4cbs1 October 26, 2006 7:23 PM PDT

Fine, we learned again that Rush is a bombastic insensitive lying fool. But this is NOT News!

If CBS would just report the news that matters, not these "interest" stories for supposed ratings, the American people would have been informed enough not to have let Bush LIE us into Iraq.

Reply to this comment

by processor2 October 26, 2006 7:24 PM PDT

Let's see, Democrats have been running dirty ads most of my life......and now the Neo-Commies get upset when Republicans run a dirty ad ???

IT JUST PROVES MY BELIEF THAT:

LIBERALS DEFINE A DIRTY FIGHT AS ONE IN WHICH THEIR OPPONENT FIGHTS BACK.

...then liberals get outraged that conservatives would dare defend themselves against liberal attacks.



THE MAIN POINT:

The ad against Harold Ford is tame in comparison with manipulating a person sick with Parkinsons Disease

Reply to this comment

by snipitoff October 26, 2006 7:29 PM PDT

MICHAEL J. FOX
I think you are one of the most courageous wonderful people in this world. It breaks my heart to see such a vibrent person suffer such a crippling disease and you do it with the utmost grace and dignity. You are truly one of my super heros who stands firm on everything you believe in. You have been charmed since birth with a great focus on life and you have grabbed life by the twins(lol). I have admired you ever since you first stepped into the public's eye. RUSH has nothing on you! Please be well, you are in the conscience of America. I promis to vote for stem cell and all medical research for the betterment of life.
ps I never do this sort of chat but you bring me to my knees because of your heroism.

Reply to this comment

by replanted October 26, 2006 7:30 PM PDT

It was just Rush. No one in their right mind pays attention when someone arrested with addictive drugs on him speaks.

How many people listen when Michael J. Fox talks? Everyone.

Reply to this comment

by ronniehm October 26, 2006 7:32 PM PDT

This sudden passion for embryonic stem cells is touching. It's not like most most people even knew what a stem cell was before they heard it in a political ad.

Reply to this comment

by one_american October 26, 2006 7:35 PM PDT

Michael J. Fox needs to talk to George Soros; he's the guy with endless sums of money to throw at Parkinson's Disease research.

People need to stop looking to the Government for all their cash needs to fund their pet projects.

That's not what the Government is for.

Reply to this comment

by jumkey October 26, 2006 7:36 PM PDT

Democrats have been running dirty ads? Please, can we have more Republican projection? What nonsense.

Republicans can sense defeat and they're showing their true colors: nothing but loathsome opportunists, willing to sell the country to maintain their grip on power.

Are the Dems the answer? I don't know. But I do know the Republicans are disloyal and anti-American. Ashheap of history for the lot of them, starting with Bush.

Reply to this comment

by gator387 October 26, 2006 7:36 PM PDT

I'm a union ironworker and a man with guts but what Michael J. Fox did tonight on the news broadcast took real guts. I support his fight and think he's on the write track.

Reply to this comment

by jseilkop October 26, 2006 7:37 PM PDT

I applaud Katie for admitting her father has Parkinson's - and that she has also contributed to Mike J Fox's organization following her interview with Mike J. Fox. It was noble of her to admit her bias regarding this issue and ultimately that the CBS news is no longer unbiased news casting - but political commentary.

If you are going to spend as much as a third of a prime time news case supporting a clear political position - the opposing side should have an equal segment of time to share their views. I will no doubt be looking for my news from an unbiased source elsewhere.

For the record - I watched as my Grandfather Died of Parkinson's disease. The ends to not always justify the means.

Respectfully submitted,

Jon

Reply to this comment

by cbclistener October 26, 2006 7:39 PM PDT

This was a fabulous, wonderful interview. The best part of all of it is the signs, personified in Ms Couric, that the news media is getting back to be willing to take know-nothing pundits like Limbaugh and hold them accountable for the things they say. This is *not* the same thing as editorialising, as the Fox piece was *just the facts*...something jokers like Limbaugh aren't obliged to do.

Their time has come, if the new anchor of CBS News is any indication, as this may be the beginning of a new golden era in broadcast news...when the likes of CBS Evening News had a positive effect on the state of the world.

Reply to this comment

by rgbonnet October 26, 2006 7:41 PM PDT

Thank you Michael and Katie for putting a human face on the national tragedy of the politicizing and polarizing of personal challenges. Limbaugh has been exposed for the mean spirited radical that he is. You are to be honored forever, both of you for standing up for the simple respect that all us humans deserve. The evening news is now in a whole new category that I will watch and appreciate on a new level. Thank you again both of you for your courage.

Reply to this comment

by dpeet October 26, 2006 7:45 PM PDT

To Michael J. Fox
Thank You, Thnak You! Thank You!

Reply to this comment

by kjgal October 26, 2006 7:49 PM PDT

I have always considered myself as conservative. I don't know much about stem cell research, but shouldn't the responsibility of destroying an embryo lie in the hands of the mother who had it aborted in the first place???

Reply to this comment

by agnim October 26, 2006 7:52 PM PDT

Here's an idea; why doesn't Fox go to Canada and lean on the Canadians to do the stem cell research there?

Anyway, maybe Linbaugh was himself over medicated with Oxycontin pills and was having a Rush when he made his not so unusual outrageous comment. LOL

Reply to this comment

by iddi1-2009 October 26, 2006 7:57 PM PDT

See, the thing that's wrong here is that 3 of the 4 types of stem cells are medically productive and moral. The one type that has had no medical success and is amoral is fetal stem cells and this is the one that Mr. Fox chooses. All human life is precious, and innocence must be protected. It's a shame that mr. Fox chose to politicize this. It does leave him open for attack. I cannot believe that Mr. Fox couldn't have waited for a better moment to tape his commercial as he has done many other times. This does not in anyway detract from the unfortunate condition he is suffering from.

Reply to this comment

by aa36042 October 26, 2006 7:59 PM PDT

I appreciate all of these comments unfortunatly this fuzzy romanticism has nothing to do with the fact that it is inaprporate for the government to fund medical research such as this. We havea market economy in this country and all of the money that you spend on RX fund research that we use to create better medicine (which other countries then steal and use in thir "free" system (along w medical research tech).
On a separate note, are we to believe that no constraints what so ever are necessary when considering different types of stem cell research? This issue reminds me of the abortion issue in which any law or regulation that helps define abortion is viewed as an attack on abortion by liberals (for instance, can a woman get an abortion at 5 or 6 months?, should a child have to get permission from a parent and etc). What I am trying to communicate is that regulating a procedure or research teqhnique that effects human life does not necessariy autmoaticly mean that it is an "attack". Please take into consideration that these are very real issues with very large consequences for society. Yes,benefits from stem ell research would be great, but do you also understand the drawbacks or are you simply picking the side that doesn%u2019t include a political figure you despise? Please search out all sides of an issue..

Reply to this comment

by anotherlisa October 26, 2006 8:02 PM PDT

When will the people who actually suffer from chronic diseases be listened to? Once you have struggled to keep a microphone on and/or not been able to recall your own name; then come back and say you don't support government funded stem cell research! If we, as a country, pay attention to being empathetic towards lives that already exist, then and only then will we move beyond polarizing fighting that helps nobody.

Reply to this comment

by janlest October 26, 2006 8:07 PM PDT

I have never responded to a forum such as this before. I was so shocked by Limbaugh's behavior & deeply moved by the interview, however, that I had to voice my feelings.

Michael J. Fox is a true gentleman. Who could blame him if he had struck back with revenge & bitterness? Instead he spoke about the cause he believes in with respect for those whose opinion differs from his own.

I've enjoyed Katie since she took over the anchor spot, but I'm even more convinced after this interview that she's got what it takes. She asked the "tough" questions with porfessionalism & compassion.

As for Limbaugh - How much lower can he sink? I for one will never know since I vow from this moment forward to never listen to him again.

Reply to this comment

by iddi1-2009 October 26, 2006 8:08 PM PDT

another lisa sees only a part of the whole picture. We can't live in a Do-whats-best-for-me-and-***-the-rest society, akin to my life is more important than yours.

Reply to this comment

by c_martin81 October 26, 2006 8:08 PM PDT

I think that Rush Limbaugh is the true definition of white trash. If he any knowledge of what people who have Parkinson's disease have to endured, but like my grandma uses to tell me the empty wagon make the most noise. Rush your and empyt wagon.

Think you Mr.Fox for what you are try to do.

Reply to this comment

by energyecon October 26, 2006 8:11 PM PDT

This kind of research is EXACTLY the type that government should be involved in - in fact, basic scientific research that all can benefit from will be undersupplied if market mechanisms are relied on exclusively - due to the non-rival consumption of information (aka free rider problem).

Reply to this comment

by dwightmlee October 26, 2006 8:17 PM PDT

My open letter to Rush:

The %u201Cmost dangerous man in America%u201D just doesn%u2019t get it. Do ya Rush!?

I think David Montgomery of the Washington Post said it well when he said on Wednesday, October 25, %u201CPossibly worse than making fun of someone's disability is saying that it's imaginary. That is not to mock someone's body, but to challenge a person's guts, integrity, sanity.%u201D

I%u2019ve always liked you, Rush. But I like Michael J. Fox a whole lot more %u2013 especially now. While you go out and embarrass yourself for the sake of arrogant preconception and supercilious folly %u2013 he goes out and embarrasses himself and the obvious visible effects of his malady for the sake of A CAUSE!

You may still consider YOURSELF the %u201Cmost dangerous man in America%u201D, Rush but I just now started considering you %u201Cthe most irresponsible mouth in America%u201D. You have finally lost me. Nice going Rush!

Dwight Lee
Natick, MA.

Reply to this comment

by bellal-2009 October 26, 2006 8:39 PM PDT

I really don't get what all the breuhauhau is about. MJF made a powerful political ad and an opposing political pundit challenged it. Big deal.

The only good thing to come of it is we can now have a big, giant, hairsplitting debate on empbryonic stem cell research. A scientist made a comment last night on this site that it was in fact "cloning".

All I want is a cure for chronic diseases. It seems reasonable that if fertilized eggs from fertility clinics are going to be destroyed they might as well be donated to reasearch. Kind of like organ donation. If you're not creating them what's the big deal?

Reply to this comment

by bellal-2009 October 26, 2006 8:43 PM PDT

There is PLENTY of private money out there. It's not like we don't have more than our fair share of rich people in this country. And they are quite generous.

I hear the problem comes down to scientists not being able to use reasearch facilities that have ANY federal funding so they have to go build their new facilities with private funds.

Reply to this comment

by mwitten2 October 26, 2006 8:53 PM PDT

I have just watched Michael J. Fox's interview with Katie. What class and dignity. Rush Limbaugh is a big, fat drug dealer! What scum to represent the Republican Party. The messenger, Limbaugh, is as screwed up as the political party that he represents.

Reply to this comment

by zen-fishing October 26, 2006 8:53 PM PDT

To our little friend agnim:
You need to remember that we listen to Canadians because people like you are not smart enough to interest most of us. Okay I am wrong there, you probably do interest most of the Republican party. Your attack on Michael Fox's former country (our ally with troops dying in Iraq) is just unacceptable. You should be ashamed of yourself for being an idiot but then again I suppose that being and idiot you think things are fine.
I now apoligize for calling an idiot and idiot. I did not mean to be so uncaring to someone with such limited mental capability.

zen fishing

Reply to this comment

by rpaulstu October 26, 2006 8:54 PM PDT

Years ago Edward R. Murrow, under attack by Sen. Joseph McCarthy, said history would ultimately judge who had better served his country. Murrow said he'd like to be remembered by the answer.

Who's a better American, Rush Limbaugh or Michael J. Fox? We don't have to wait for history's judgement. Michael Fox, one-time entertainer, is a far better man than Limbaugh--a full-time entertainer and demogogue.

Reply to this comment

by berrysxx October 26, 2006 8:55 PM PDT

If the dems get in control with Michael J. Fox's help, we won't need stem-cell research. We'll need info on how to fight the enemy here on our own soil. Maybe some of you do gooders need to understand war and battles that are far greater than someones political biased ads. Why don't you go see Flags Of Our Fathers and see the sacrafice someone else was willing to make for your freedom.

Reply to this comment

by jyoung204 October 26, 2006 8:57 PM PDT

All I want to say is that Michael J Fox is the better man than Rush Lumbaugh ever will be. Why isn't Mr. Lumbaugh not fired for his insensitive remarks. To say that Michael was "acting" & not on his medication is totally assinine. Since Mr. Limbaugh has a past history of drug abuse, maybe he ought to take medication for his insensitivity oh wait there is no RX for that. It is time for Mr. Limbaugh to be fired for such crude ignorant remarks.

Reply to this comment

by oink1 October 26, 2006 8:59 PM PDT

"See, the thing that's wrong here is that 3 of the 4 types of stem cells are medically productive and moral. The one type that has had no medical success and is amoral is fetal stem cells and this is the one that Mr. Fox chooses. "

Please, sir. Do not lie. It does your position no good.

The reason that there is no medical success for stem cells is that research has been stymied on them.

Arguing against stem cell research by saying it has shown no success is circular.

Reply to this comment

by berrysxx October 26, 2006 9:05 PM PDT

We have men and women dying and left in much worse shape than Michael J. Fox. I wonder how you would feel if the Rep. started making ads using our military, whether true or not, to help rep. get elected.

Reply to this comment

by rrose56 October 26, 2006 9:08 PM PDT

I just watched the MJ Fox interview. I am moved at the courage and conviction of Mr. Fox and his stem cell concerns. Honestly, I have never considered stem cell issues, I have never even known what it was. I am a republician but when it comes to helping folks with health issues why not do what we can? I have Lupus and would do anything to find a cure. Thanks to Mr. Fox I will check out more about this. I do vote and I would like to see who is behind this type of health concerns. Thanks for opening my eyes and God bless you Mr. Fox.

Reply to this comment

by bellal-2009 October 26, 2006 9:11 PM PDT

berrysxx, right on both posts.

Reply to this comment

• 1
• 2
• 3
• 4
...
• 8
• next

See all 396 Comments

Add a comment

Comment SUBMIT

Click here to add another comment.

The posting of advertisements, profanity, or personal attacks is prohibited. By using this Web site you agree to accept our Terms of Service. Click here to read the Rules of Engagement.

Comment reply

Submit Cancel

The posting of advertisements, profanity, or personal attacks is prohibited. By using this Web site you agree to accept our Terms of Service. Click here to read the Rules of Engagement.

Report offensive content:

If you believe this comment is offensive or violates the CBSNews.com Terms of Use, you can report it below (this will not automatically remove the comment). Once reported, our staff will be notified and the comment will be reviewed.

Select type of offense:

Offensive: Sexually explicit or offensive language

Spam: Advertisements or commercial links

Disruptive posting: Flaming or offending other users

Illegal activities: Promote cracked software, or other illegal content

Comments (optional):

Report Cancel

E-mail this comment to a friend.

E-mail this to: (Separate multiple e-mail addresses with commas. Limited to 10 addresses.)

Your e-mail address:

Send me a copy of this message

Note: Your e-mail address is used only to let the recipient know who sent the e-mail and in case of transmission error. Neither your address nor the recipients's address will be used for any other purpose.

Add your own personal message: (Optional)

Hi, I found this user's comment on CBSNews.com and thought you might be interested in reading it. Send e-mail Cancel

[stephanie801]

Does this sound like an apology to anyone else? I don't think so. Try again Rush!

""All I'm saying is I've never seen him the way he appears in this commercial for Claire McCaskill," says Limbaugh. "So I will bigly, hugely admit that I was wrong, and I will apologize to Michael J. Fox, if I am wrong in characterizing his behavior on this commercial as an act, especially since people are telling me they have seen him this way on other interviews and in other television appearances." "

[ronniehm]

Aside from admitting he was wrong and apologizing, what would you include in an apology?

[jsilver2th]

Thanks Rush for helping put the Democrats over the top! Thanks Michael J. Fox for being a classy guy, heads above poor Rush. These campaign ads are now national news- Out here in the desert it looks like the Republicans are pretty hard up. We only have vote by mail in Oregon now so the election is almost over. The GOP candidate for Governor was going pretty good for a while but now he's going down in flames with the rest of the GOP ticket. Looks like this gives the big boost to McCaskill- who needs Talent anyway- another Bush clone.

[fredegrar]

Ronnie,
I think it's the 'if' in Rush's apology that makes it sound like something less than an apology. The 'bigly, hugely' part doesn't help either. It comes out sounding to me like he means it would be big of him to apologize if he turns out to be wrong, rather than an admission of being wrong and feeling remorse it. As Rush often states, he believes he's correct all of the time (or very nearly so), so he probably still believes what he originally said.

[baia1]

You guys are something else! None of you realize that everything Fox said in the ad was a lie.

[coker8721]

My father has had to deal with the effects of PD for the past 15 years and I know what the deep brain stimulator that Fox has had implanted in his brain can do. My father can not find the money for such a procedure but if he did then the shaking would not occur enough to notice. I think that Mr. Fox was shifting around more like a person with Cerebral Palsy and not a guy suffering from PD. If he is exploiting the disease then that%u2019s a shame... if not... I think he needs to be re-diagnosed or sue the doctors that put the stimulator in his brain because it%u2019s not working (maybe it needs new batteries?)

P.S. If you do not share my feelings please leave a comment and lets hear what you think!

GOD BLESS AMERICA!!!

[berrysxx]

Guess I should expect anyone watching NBC to be biased towards a liberal. Michael J. Fox should be telling anyone with parkinson's disease that there is hope, not from embronic stem cell research, which has never proven of any value, but with a probe inserted into the brain made by Medtronics. Michael, unfortunately opted for a surgery that was non-reversible and it didn't work for him. That's sad, but for others there is a remedy that is reversible! Check it out if you have the disease, it's awesome!

[berrysxx]

Michael did not have the stimulator according to my source, he had some type of lazer or searing of the brain. The stimulator works for most people! Rush didn't say Michael was faking, he just indicated he doesn't act like on the other shows he's been on.

[docjay8406]

baia1,

Fox said, "Unfortunately, Senator Jim Talent opposes expanding stem cell research." If you'll notice that is not a lie. Rich Chrismer, Talent's spokesman did not refute this. Chrismer said Talent supports "medical research including stem cell research that doesn't involve cloning or destroying a human embryo." This is already in place and does NOT expand stem cell research.

Fox also said "Senator Talent even wanted to criminalize the science that gives us a chance for hope." The article says Talent "supported a Senate bill that would ban all embryonic stem cell research and impose a million-dollar fine and jail sentence on violators." This means Talent WANTED to make stem cell research a criminal act.

I'm apalled I have to actually repeat something that is as clear as day. There is no need to lie. You don't need to join Rush Limbaugh in his smear campaign against others.

Berrysxx,

Thanks for the comment. It's the IF that Rush included in his statement that irks me. First Rush says he was wrong then he followed it up with an IF, that is very insincere if you ask me. You don't say IF when you truly believe you were wrong. IF is a qualifier that dilutes his statement and sincerity.

coker,

I think you need to check your i facts /i .

[jasper369]

Rush said if Michael J. Fox really was shaking so bad then he wasn't taking his medication. Well, maybe he is trying to show us what this disease is really about. Thanks Rush, maybe you can stay off your meds and show us what your really like.

[oharras]

Thank you Ms. Couric for the class you and Mr. Fox showed in the interview. Mr. Fox has always been a decent man, and it is a shame to see the toll PD has taken on this fine man. Rush Limbaugh just cannot stand up as tall as you, Ms. Couric and Mr. Fox. Thank you very much!

[up4chalng]

My response is to Berrysxx. I'm not sure what your history is regarding a "probe inserted into the brain" but it's not what it appears to be. My father had this surgery and was fine for about six months. He's now in a wheelchair because he has major balance problems and can not speak so people can understand him. He's still has to take Parkinson's medication to prevent the tremors and dyskinesia just like before. So if you believe in stem cell research or not your probe in the brain is not the cure-all for this disease.

[csmith3539]

I have nothing but admiration for Michael J. Fox. The way he has handled his disease has been inspiring. To have to defend his actions to the overrated right wing intolerant small minded fear monger that is Rush Limbaugh is a sad commentary on the media and anyone who would listen to that madman's ranting. I hope Michael knows that those of us with independent thought believe in his cause and his being able to further it anyway he can.

[navygirl58]

Michael J. Fox said in the interview he supported Arlen Spector. I guess it takes a Republican like Spector to have such a serious illness for one to fully understand the importance of stem cell research. Perhaps more Republicans and or their family members need to fall victim to serious illnesses such as Parkinson's, paralysis, cancer, Alzheimers, etc. before they see the light on this moral/political issue. These IVF stem cells will otherwise be useless. Why not allow science labs put them to some use? My heart breaks for anyone who must suffer through anything such as Parkinsons. I was one of those teenage girls who did and still does have a crush on MJF. You are making a difference, Michael and I hope something comes from all of this in your lifetime.

[paswword-2009]

I want news when I get home, not hollywood either raido or tv, playing the heats of the working people. stick to the facts and report not try to entertain me like hollywood.

[ucscorp-2009]

Dear Katie,
Earlier this year i was told i might have parkinson's..thank god it turned out to be vertigo..bad, but no where near parkinson's...
When i thought that i had Parkinsons's i turned to Michaels web site! It gave me hope and helped me to understan how devastating it was. Well god spared me but i will never forget or let Michael down...Thanks for dedicating time to my most important issue! As far as Rush is concerned I think he's just looking for another 15 minutes f fame...more like shame.

Again Thanks

Bob Reilly NYS

[dw73745]

Michael J. Fox shows his zeal , with no apologies to the world, concerning stem cell research. I think that Rush Limbaugh has finally crossed over the line with his comments about Michael. Before using his public postition to make such assumptions concerning Michael's state of mind or medications and turning Michael's zeal into yet another POLITICAL issue, he should have spent a little time verifying his information.
Rush has always been appaulling and now he is unsurpassed in repugnant behavior.

[mh4cbs1]

Fine, we learned again that Rush is a bombastic insensitive lying fool. But this is NOT News!

If CBS would just report the news that matters, not these "interest" stories for supposed ratings, the American people would have been informed enough not to have let Bush LIE us into Iraq.

[processor2]

Let's see, Democrats have been running dirty ads most of my life......and now the Neo-Commies get upset when Republicans run a dirty ad ???

IT JUST PROVES MY BELIEF THAT:

LIBERALS DEFINE A DIRTY FIGHT AS ONE IN WHICH THEIR OPPONENT FIGHTS BACK.

...then liberals get outraged that conservatives would dare defend themselves against liberal attacks.



THE MAIN POINT:

The ad against Harold Ford is tame in comparison with manipulating a person sick with Parkinsons Disease

[snipitoff]

MICHAEL J. FOX
I think you are one of the most courageous wonderful people in this world. It breaks my heart to see such a vibrent person suffer such a crippling disease and you do it with the utmost grace and dignity. You are truly one of my super heros who stands firm on everything you believe in. You have been charmed since birth with a great focus on life and you have grabbed life by the twins(lol). I have admired you ever since you first stepped into the public's eye. RUSH has nothing on you! Please be well, you are in the conscience of America. I promis to vote for stem cell and all medical research for the betterment of life.
ps I never do this sort of chat but you bring me to my knees because of your heroism.

[replanted]

It was just Rush. No one in their right mind pays attention when someone arrested with addictive drugs on him speaks.

How many people listen when Michael J. Fox talks? Everyone.

[ronniehm]

This sudden passion for embryonic stem cells is touching. It's not like most most people even knew what a stem cell was before they heard it in a political ad.

[one_american]

Michael J. Fox needs to talk to George Soros; he's the guy with endless sums of money to throw at Parkinson's Disease research.

People need to stop looking to the Government for all their cash needs to fund their pet projects.

That's not what the Government is for.

[jumkey]

Democrats have been running dirty ads? Please, can we have more Republican projection? What nonsense.

Republicans can sense defeat and they're showing their true colors: nothing but loathsome opportunists, willing to sell the country to maintain their grip on power.

Are the Dems the answer? I don't know. But I do know the Republicans are disloyal and anti-American. Ashheap of history for the lot of them, starting with Bush.

[gator387]

I'm a union ironworker and a man with guts but what Michael J. Fox did tonight on the news broadcast took real guts. I support his fight and think he's on the write track.

[jseilkop]

I applaud Katie for admitting her father has Parkinson's - and that she has also contributed to Mike J Fox's organization following her interview with Mike J. Fox. It was noble of her to admit her bias regarding this issue and ultimately that the CBS news is no longer unbiased news casting - but political commentary.

If you are going to spend as much as a third of a prime time news case supporting a clear political position - the opposing side should have an equal segment of time to share their views. I will no doubt be looking for my news from an unbiased source elsewhere.

For the record - I watched as my Grandfather Died of Parkinson's disease. The ends to not always justify the means.

Respectfully submitted,

Jon

[cbclistener]

This was a fabulous, wonderful interview. The best part of all of it is the signs, personified in Ms Couric, that the news media is getting back to be willing to take know-nothing pundits like Limbaugh and hold them accountable for the things they say. This is *not* the same thing as editorialising, as the Fox piece was *just the facts*...something jokers like Limbaugh aren't obliged to do.

Their time has come, if the new anchor of CBS News is any indication, as this may be the beginning of a new golden era in broadcast news...when the likes of CBS Evening News had a positive effect on the state of the world.

[rgbonnet]

Thank you Michael and Katie for putting a human face on the national tragedy of the politicizing and polarizing of personal challenges. Limbaugh has been exposed for the mean spirited radical that he is. You are to be honored forever, both of you for standing up for the simple respect that all us humans deserve. The evening news is now in a whole new category that I will watch and appreciate on a new level. Thank you again both of you for your courage.

[dpeet]

To Michael J. Fox
Thank You, Thnak You! Thank You!

[kjgal]

I have always considered myself as conservative. I don't know much about stem cell research, but shouldn't the responsibility of destroying an embryo lie in the hands of the mother who had it aborted in the first place???

[agnim]

Here's an idea; why doesn't Fox go to Canada and lean on the Canadians to do the stem cell research there?

Anyway, maybe Linbaugh was himself over medicated with Oxycontin pills and was having a Rush when he made his not so unusual outrageous comment. LOL

[iddi1-2009]

See, the thing that's wrong here is that 3 of the 4 types of stem cells are medically productive and moral. The one type that has had no medical success and is amoral is fetal stem cells and this is the one that Mr. Fox chooses. All human life is precious, and innocence must be protected. It's a shame that mr. Fox chose to politicize this. It does leave him open for attack. I cannot believe that Mr. Fox couldn't have waited for a better moment to tape his commercial as he has done many other times. This does not in anyway detract from the unfortunate condition he is suffering from.

[aa36042]

I appreciate all of these comments unfortunatly this fuzzy romanticism has nothing to do with the fact that it is inaprporate for the government to fund medical research such as this. We havea market economy in this country and all of the money that you spend on RX fund research that we use to create better medicine (which other countries then steal and use in thir "free" system (along w medical research tech).
On a separate note, are we to believe that no constraints what so ever are necessary when considering different types of stem cell research? This issue reminds me of the abortion issue in which any law or regulation that helps define abortion is viewed as an attack on abortion by liberals (for instance, can a woman get an abortion at 5 or 6 months?, should a child have to get permission from a parent and etc). What I am trying to communicate is that regulating a procedure or research teqhnique that effects human life does not necessariy autmoaticly mean that it is an "attack". Please take into consideration that these are very real issues with very large consequences for society. Yes,benefits from stem ell research would be great, but do you also understand the drawbacks or are you simply picking the side that doesn%u2019t include a political figure you despise? Please search out all sides of an issue..

[anotherlisa]

When will the people who actually suffer from chronic diseases be listened to? Once you have struggled to keep a microphone on and/or not been able to recall your own name; then come back and say you don't support government funded stem cell research! If we, as a country, pay attention to being empathetic towards lives that already exist, then and only then will we move beyond polarizing fighting that helps nobody.

[janlest]

I have never responded to a forum such as this before. I was so shocked by Limbaugh's behavior & deeply moved by the interview, however, that I had to voice my feelings.

Michael J. Fox is a true gentleman. Who could blame him if he had struck back with revenge & bitterness? Instead he spoke about the cause he believes in with respect for those whose opinion differs from his own.

I've enjoyed Katie since she took over the anchor spot, but I'm even more convinced after this interview that she's got what it takes. She asked the "tough" questions with porfessionalism & compassion.

As for Limbaugh - How much lower can he sink? I for one will never know since I vow from this moment forward to never listen to him again.

[iddi1-2009]

another lisa sees only a part of the whole picture. We can't live in a Do-whats-best-for-me-and-***-the-rest society, akin to my life is more important than yours.

[c_martin81]

I think that Rush Limbaugh is the true definition of white trash. If he any knowledge of what people who have Parkinson's disease have to endured, but like my grandma uses to tell me the empty wagon make the most noise. Rush your and empyt wagon.

Think you Mr.Fox for what you are try to do.

[energyecon]

This kind of research is EXACTLY the type that government should be involved in - in fact, basic scientific research that all can benefit from will be undersupplied if market mechanisms are relied on exclusively - due to the non-rival consumption of information (aka free rider problem).

[dwightmlee]

My open letter to Rush:

The %u201Cmost dangerous man in America%u201D just doesn%u2019t get it. Do ya Rush!?

I think David Montgomery of the Washington Post said it well when he said on Wednesday, October 25, %u201CPossibly worse than making fun of someone's disability is saying that it's imaginary. That is not to mock someone's body, but to challenge a person's guts, integrity, sanity.%u201D

I%u2019ve always liked you, Rush. But I like Michael J. Fox a whole lot more %u2013 especially now. While you go out and embarrass yourself for the sake of arrogant preconception and supercilious folly %u2013 he goes out and embarrasses himself and the obvious visible effects of his malady for the sake of A CAUSE!

You may still consider YOURSELF the %u201Cmost dangerous man in America%u201D, Rush but I just now started considering you %u201Cthe most irresponsible mouth in America%u201D. You have finally lost me. Nice going Rush!

Dwight Lee
Natick, MA.

[bellal-2009]

I really don't get what all the breuhauhau is about. MJF made a powerful political ad and an opposing political pundit challenged it. Big deal.

The only good thing to come of it is we can now have a big, giant, hairsplitting debate on empbryonic stem cell research. A scientist made a comment last night on this site that it was in fact "cloning".

All I want is a cure for chronic diseases. It seems reasonable that if fertilized eggs from fertility clinics are going to be destroyed they might as well be donated to reasearch. Kind of like organ donation. If you're not creating them what's the big deal?

[bellal-2009]

There is PLENTY of private money out there. It's not like we don't have more than our fair share of rich people in this country. And they are quite generous.

I hear the problem comes down to scientists not being able to use reasearch facilities that have ANY federal funding so they have to go build their new facilities with private funds.

[mwitten2]

I have just watched Michael J. Fox's interview with Katie. What class and dignity. Rush Limbaugh is a big, fat drug dealer! What scum to represent the Republican Party. The messenger, Limbaugh, is as screwed up as the political party that he represents.

[zen-fishing]

To our little friend agnim:
You need to remember that we listen to Canadians because people like you are not smart enough to interest most of us. Okay I am wrong there, you probably do interest most of the Republican party. Your attack on Michael Fox's former country (our ally with troops dying in Iraq) is just unacceptable. You should be ashamed of yourself for being an idiot but then again I suppose that being and idiot you think things are fine.
I now apoligize for calling an idiot and idiot. I did not mean to be so uncaring to someone with such limited mental capability.

zen fishing

[rpaulstu]

Years ago Edward R. Murrow, under attack by Sen. Joseph McCarthy, said history would ultimately judge who had better served his country. Murrow said he'd like to be remembered by the answer.

Who's a better American, Rush Limbaugh or Michael J. Fox? We don't have to wait for history's judgement. Michael Fox, one-time entertainer, is a far better man than Limbaugh--a full-time entertainer and demogogue.

[berrysxx]

If the dems get in control with Michael J. Fox's help, we won't need stem-cell research. We'll need info on how to fight the enemy here on our own soil. Maybe some of you do gooders need to understand war and battles that are far greater than someones political biased ads. Why don't you go see Flags Of Our Fathers and see the sacrafice someone else was willing to make for your freedom.

[jyoung204]

All I want to say is that Michael J Fox is the better man than Rush Lumbaugh ever will be. Why isn't Mr. Lumbaugh not fired for his insensitive remarks. To say that Michael was "acting" & not on his medication is totally assinine. Since Mr. Limbaugh has a past history of drug abuse, maybe he ought to take medication for his insensitivity oh wait there is no RX for that. It is time for Mr. Limbaugh to be fired for such crude ignorant remarks.

[oink1]

"See, the thing that's wrong here is that 3 of the 4 types of stem cells are medically productive and moral. The one type that has had no medical success and is amoral is fetal stem cells and this is the one that Mr. Fox chooses. "

Please, sir. Do not lie. It does your position no good.

The reason that there is no medical success for stem cells is that research has been stymied on them.

Arguing against stem cell research by saying it has shown no success is circular.

[berrysxx]

We have men and women dying and left in much worse shape than Michael J. Fox. I wonder how you would feel if the Rep. started making ads using our military, whether true or not, to help rep. get elected.

[rrose56]

I just watched the MJ Fox interview. I am moved at the courage and conviction of Mr. Fox and his stem cell concerns. Honestly, I have never considered stem cell issues, I have never even known what it was. I am a republician but when it comes to helping folks with health issues why not do what we can? I have Lupus and would do anything to find a cure. Thanks to Mr. Fox I will check out more about this. I do vote and I would like to see who is behind this type of health concerns. Thanks for opening my eyes and God bless you Mr. Fox.

[bellal-2009]

berrysxx, right on both posts.